After Show Reacts :)

Bored now. I ranked every Buffy The Vampire Slayer episode (all 144 of them)! (Patreon)

Published:

2026-02-10 18:22:10

Edited:

2026-02-10 18:40:00

Imported:

2026-09

Tags:

Buffy The Vampire Slayer Buffyverse

Content

Into every generation, a reactor is born.

She alone finishes the series years late,

plans a “final thoughts” video five separate times,

deletes the footage,

and then accidentally makes a tier list instead.

This is that video.

---

I finished Buffy the Vampire Slayer years ago and always planned to make a proper “final thoughts” video about the whole series… and I genuinely tried. Like, multiple times. I recorded a bunch of different versions, started editing them, hated how they turned out, and scrapped every single one. (I still have the footage though lol).

At some point I realised that doing a tier list and talking through the episodes as I go is probably the most honest (and easiest) way for me to actually get these thoughts out of my brain and onto YouTube. So this video is basically my long-overdue Buffy thoughts in tier list form — the episodes I love, the Xander's I don’t, and the ones that I’m very ready to argue about.

I’d love to hear where you agree or completely disagree with me. Drop your own rankings or hot takes in the comments because I know this fandom has opinions, lets just keep it civil :).

Spoiler warning: this video talks about the whole series, so yeah… spoilers for all of Buffy.

Timestamps:

0:00 - 4:04 - Intro to the video

4:05 - 9:21 - Description of the tiers

The tier list if you'd like to make your own I'm not sure how to link with the tier names I selected, you'll have to edit those in sorry!!: https://tiermaker.com/create/buffy-the-vampire-slayer---all-the-episodes-1201982?presentationMode=true

Files

I Ranked EVERY Episode Of Buffy The Vampire Slayer! - A Series Review Tier List!

Into every generation, a reactor is born. She alone finishes the series years late, plans a “final thoughts” video five separate times, deletes the footage, and then accidentally makes a tier list instead. This is that video. --- I finished Buffy the Vampire Slayer years ago and always planned to make a proper “final thoughts” video about the whole series… and I genuinely tried. Like, multiple times. I recorded a bunch of different versions, started editing them, hated how they turned out, and scrapped every single one. (I still have the footage though lol). At some point I realised that doing a tier list and talking through the episodes as I go is probably the most honest (and easiest) way for me to actually get these thoughts out of my brain and onto YouTube. So this video is basically my long-overdue Buffy thoughts in tier list form — the episodes I love, the Xander's I don’t, and the ones that I’m very ready to argue about. I’d love to hear where you agree or completely disagree with me. Drop your own rankings or hot takes in the comments because I know this fandom has opinions, lets just keep it civil :). Spoiler warning: this video talks about the whole series, so yeah… spoilers for all of Buffy. -- Timestamps: 0:00 - 4:04 - Intro to the video 4:05 - 9:21 - Description of the tiers --- #BuffyTheVampireSlayer #BuffyTierList #TVTierList #SeriesReview #BuffyRanking --- Follow me on twitter for updates: https://twitter.com/AfterShowReacts EARLY FULL REACTIONS & PILOTS ON PATREON HERE: https://www.patreon.com/AfterShowReactions Join the Discord community: https://discord.gg/W7N4b5f