Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hi everyone, I had quite a lot of fun with this one. Hope you enjoy it.

Files

Melbourne's Replacement Bus Problem..!

Melbourne has a problem with rail replacement buses. Let's talk about it. Want to help support the channel, get early access to new content and exclusive behind the scenes videos? Join me on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/Taitset My voiceover in this video was recorded with the assistance of my brother Cian, who also composed the credit music for this video - check out his stuff here: https://hyperfollow.com/cianbennetmusic Additional voices for this video were provided by Astrid MacFarlane and Cian Bennet. Additional research and sandpit construction skills were provided by Alexander Jamieson. All photographs, footage, drawings and diagrams are by Martin Bennet (...me) unless otherwise credited on screen. Historic photographs are by the late Weston Langford: https://www.westonlangford.com/ The historic clipping from The Age is from the Trove archive: https://trove.nla.gov.au/ Chapters: 00:00 - Melbourne, we need to talk. 02:07 - It didn't used to be like this 05:24 - The priority has gone 06:40 - The problems with buses/And PTV 16:22 - You're doing this for us, right...? 18:16 - People build their lives around it 20:45 - Back at Watsonia 21:52 - They even wear clothes now 22:22 - Something positive 23:08 - Alternative transport, has been arranged #melbourne #transit #transport

Comments

Max Wilkie

I ended up becoming a bicycle commuter because of a big rail occupation. Back in the winter of 2023, both the Sunbury and Werribee/Williamstown lines were occupied for two weeks as part of West Gate Tunnel works at the Dynon Road bridge at North Melboune. Vehicle access to the city via Dynon Rd was also closed at the same time, which resulted in a major traffic nightmare on Footscray Rd, which the replacement buses were all caught up in. I ended up using my bike to get from Footscray to the Craigieburn line at Newmarket to try and avoid this, which eventually turned into a full bike commute all the way to the city, which I've kept up ever since. I'm obviously very lucky to live close enough to work to be able to do this, but it does go to show how behaviour-changing even a relatively short occupation can be, even for someone as train-enthused as I am. Banger video by the way, as always.

Øystein Furu Almo

What perfect video for a 50 min bus ride (not the replacement kind, though the bus is trying VERY hard to be a tram)

Chris

Superb work. Thank you. It is mega frustrating -- is it privatisation or govt maladministration at the root of this? I find the PTV app appalling at best. Travel in other major cities and it's hard to disagree... Thanks, again.

India Lucia

Great video as always! The easter eggs were especially funny to find, please never stop hiding them in your videos

Bryan A.

Urggggghhh! GRN is my local station, so I have been a fellow sufferer, Martin. At least the previous "Occupation" gave us a new station, along with Monty but the latest has been to improve stuff for uneconomically viable road users... The hideous and unreliable bus replacements enabled passengers to be thrown from their seats by incompetent bus and car drivers (actually experienced same)! You had to be lucky to get connections because the services weren't interested in cooperating. It would be interesting to compare the body count of PTV commuters being inconvenienced with the number of single occupant vehicles all this is being done for... N.B. Always wondered how they dropped Watsonia into the cutting. Thanks!

Lucy Parkinson

I'd always wondered why the bus replacement timetables were so bad. This feels like something I've just gotten used to, it's interesting to see that it wasn't always like this. Now I'm angry :D

Lucy Parkinson

Also loved seeing the moustache shaved

Ant Wakefield

I found this very apt as I live in Greensborough and drive / ride / train those same routes in the video. I just pretended trains didn’t exist for two months and wore the extra costs of driving into Richmond and paying $12 a day for parking. It’s a literal shitshow that I found easier to avoid. No one yelling at me, feeling like I’d been dropped into a second world country, onto packed, sweaty busses that take forever to get anywhere.

Matt Austin

I really enjoyed this one too, thanks Martin. Watching on the TV meant I caught the Easter eggs, very well done!

Taitset

Haha yes, a lot of people watching on phones would be missing them!

Taitset

Honestly not sure what the origin of a lot of these problems are, but it's certainly a wide systemic thing.

Taitset

That's pretty cool that it ended up having that outcome for you!

Taitset

Yep, will be interesting to see what ends up happening!

Garth

I watch it a second time. If it would have been the worker from the 70’s he may have been kicked off site :). Unless there are other Easter eggs and that makes no sense. PS: although I’m not on a commuter line, I primary work from home and go to Geelong every 2 weeks or so and can work on the train. When the trains are down I don’t go and can feel isolated.