Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hi everyone, this was not a video I was planning to make 10 days ago.. then an X'trap hit the dirt and my plans changed. This one was very much a collaboration with Alexander Jamieson, who lent his garden railway for filming again, and made a lot of observations on the incident.I didn't really consider making a video about this when it first happened, and you might notice that I only took still images of the site. But then I started getting a lot of questions from non-rail friends, and realised there was a demand for a better explanation than what the media were providing. Which also led me to some commentary on the media coverage it's self.My voice is a bit croaky in this one - if it had been anything else I would have waited to record it, but breaking news doesn't wait!Hope you enjoy it.~Martin

Files

The Clifton Hill Derailment // My Thoughts

My thoughts on the July 2025 derailment of a Metro Trains Melbourne suburban X'trapolis train on the Mernda line at Clifton Hill. This video was a collaborative effort between myself and Alexander Jamieson of the Eltham South Electric Tramway, check out his channel here: https://www.youtube.com/@melbournesparks3828 A special thanks to Marco Pagliaro for providing additional images for this video. All uncredited images and footage are by Martin Bennet (that's me). Want to help support the channel, get early access to new content and exclusive behind the scenes videos? Join me on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/Taitset My voiceover in this video was recorded with the assistance of my brother Cian, who happens to be a sound recordist and musician - check out his stuff here: https://hyperfollow.com/cianbennetmusic Chapters: 00:00 - It's.. not supposed to look like that 01:02 - Some context 02:40 - FUN FACTS 03:01 - How do derailments happen, anyway? 04:49 - The OTHER one 06:09 - The 22m window 07:31 - ..an overhead fault? 08:41 - Probing the derailment 12:27 - Channel 9 does an ageism 13:33 - A bit that's hard to think of a chapter name for 13:53 - Clearing the line 14:53 - It'll be fine 15:07 - Thanks #melbourne #derailment #trains #transport

Comments

Jed Smith

Is the tracks I see on the ski rails on the frankston line check rails, or are they something else

Jackary!

i think you’re onto something with the end of the bridge and especially with how bouncy x’traps can get on wooden sleepers it definitely could be a stretch to say but it might’ve jumped the rail. also excellent video as always !

Taitset

Those are guard rails, they don't normally contact the flange, they're just to keep a train on the bridge after it derails.

Dom Evans

Brilliant as always!

Bryan A.

Excellent work, Martin & Alexander! I first thought that nasty curve down from Rushall would have been a contributor but reckon you've nailed it. 22 metres from the bridge, eh? Did you happen to stray up there and measure it? 👍👍

Lucas Azzola

Great vid. Loved the recreations 😂. I'm wondering if the trailer car bounced over the rail, possibly due to a compounding jolt from the car in front of it as it exited the bridge? and/or faulty suspension?

Andrew Marszalek

Great video, even from up here in Sydney the bits of media coverage had seemed odd in some of their speculation. Personally I think you will prove to be a lot closer to the final findings than the media were. Amazing what a bit of common sense and clear thinking can come up with…

Taitset

Just me and the ruler tool on google maps haha. It seems to be accurate to less than a metre in most cases.

Taitset

Definitely a possibility!

Thomas Hooper

Hey Taitset new sub to the Patreon, watching your videos from SA and recently got to participate in a mass casualty exercise on an old V/Line carriage in Goolwa, love to share the videos. Look forward to the new content!!

Matt Austin

Outstanding work, thank you Martin and Alexander. My own intimate derailment experience was my first time driving a 48 class locomotive outside Junee Roundhouse when delivering it into Junee Yard. We coasted through points into the yard, all going well until vibration, a rattling noise, and dust encouraged me to pull up quick smart. First time! I copped it from my workmates until the spread rail cleared me. Damned old technology, derailments wouldn’t be a problem with levitating hover-pods!

Taitset

Very cool, I probably would have traveled on that carriage at some point!

Taitset

Time to upgrade the 48s to hover-pod bogies immediately!

Agentanonymous4876

Hey Martin great video on the Clifton hill derailment now speaking of derailments for the Belgrave/Lilydale video why don’t you mention the Croydon Hitachi derailment in the video just a little idea for it

Taitset

It probably will get a little mention, I took a photo of that set in the city earlier the same day it derailed!

Förfäders spår

As if to corroborate your point, there was a rail accident here in Sweden today that _did_ involve a pantograph becoming entangled in the wires. And of course, what happened was the wires got ruined while the actual train stayed put on the track. It did interrupt service for a few hours (as of writing, one of the two tracks is back in service), and I’m sure the passengers had a very bad time, but it looks like it’ll just be remembered as one of many small incidents in the Terrible, Horrible, No Good Summer of 2025.