Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hello everyone, remember how I predicted this video would be about 40 minutes? (I guessed that just based on word count)As promised, this is my extended thoughts on the metro tunnel, taking a more critical eye than in previous videos, but also pointing out a bunch of things I really like. This was filmed in one day (except for a handful of additional shots, you can tell because it's cloudy in those), written over two days and edited over 5 days. Definitely a record for a video of this length, but also not a pace I can normally maintain. Here's to a rare patch of hyper-focus.There's also a solid 2 minutes talking about pigeons.Hope you enjoy it!

Files

Metro Tunnel: My Hottest Takes!

All my thoughts, observations and criticisms on the Melbourne Metro tunnel! You can find the rest of my Metro Tunnel videos here: https://tinyurl.com/ycy2wwmb My G&MR video: https://youtu.be/AJolzsLFMEc My unofficial guide to 'Tracks:' https://tinyurl.com/269fft36 If you enjoyed this video, please consider joining me on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/c/Taitset My voiceover in this video was recorded with the assistance of my brother Cian Bennet, who also composed the credit music. Check out his stuff here: https://hyperfollow.com/cianbennetmusic All footage, photographs and graphics used to create this video are my own, unless otherwise credited on screen. Chapters: 00:00 - I have many thoughts 01:40 - Anzac 17:14 - Town Hall 21:40 - State Library 26:34 - Parkville 30:14 - Arden 37:58 - The last chapter #melbourne #transport #trains

Comments

Ford

Something else that's missing from the Tram stop at Anzac is Navilens, which for a brand new stop is a bizarre omission annd i have to imagine this was never added to planning requirements for new stops.

Arthur P

Pretty crazy the amount of advertising that wasn’t even mentioned in any planned or to the press. I understand they have to make back the funds they spent but still degrades the whole look of it

Bryan A.

Excellent work, Martin! I do like "Wronger" and can match it with "More Betterer"! Yes the canopies at the new Montmorency station are a joke too... Just for fun, I tried walking underground from Town Hall the Flinders Street. Interesting but not achievable without entering ticketed areas. The signage as you pointed out is substandard and my journey was quite disorienting. Still wondering what will be offered in the shops in the currently spartan Campbell Arcade... All that potential rent being lost at the moment.

Lucas Azzola

Come for the trains, stay for the pigeons.

Bill Mathews

Thanks Martin. Great video. And as much as I am in awe of these new stations and what they will mean to PT in Melbourne, colours and signage are terrible. Did they take nothing from the loop? Beige - Flagstaff. Orange - Museum (Melbourne Central) and Blue - Parliament. It's not rocket science. My first encounter with State Library Station was amazing and I was so impressed with its striking design elements. But that evaporated immediately once I got to Town Hall to see a virtually identical station at platform level with the same colour combo.

Lynx

as someone who rides frequent old underground trains subways and light rails those stations dont have character. Every video on this tunnel needs to end with an escaltor shot

Lucas Azzola

Question from me, anyone know why the pedestrian tunnel between Town Hall and Flinders St (to Campbell Arcade) is so steep? Being underground (no ventilation) I think I even broke a bit of a sweat walking up the hill. Wondering how accessible it is if you're in a wheelchair...

Chloe Shadowstar

Interesting about the via town hall. At Footscray, the announcement said "via town hall". Then five minutes later said "via the metro tunnel" for the same train. This has happened multiple times

Ashley Abud

Fun fact, the slideshow used in the elevators shown at 10:50 are used at other stations, just not in the regular elevators. The goods lifts and evacuation lifts have the exact same slideshow of Arden (even though 4/5 of those stations are not, in fact, Arden)

Taitset

Yes, it's pretty hopeless that they missed that!

Taitset

Montmorency is the one I always think of first too!

Taitset

It was similar for me, I didn't realise they looked the same until I first went into State Library.. and suddenly found myself in 'another' Town Hall.

Taitset

I guess any steeper and it would have had to have escalators. But yeah, it is quite long and steep.

Taitset

That is an extremely fun fact!

Lucas Azzola

Naively I would have thought they could build the intermediate floor of Town Hall station slightly higher up so it would be roughly at the same level as the arcade and underpass. Maybe there were constraints preventing that.

Bryan A.

The difference in levels is clearly the problem. The exit onto Flinders Street near Young & Jackson's will be interesting. Cross fingers it will have lifts and escalators... But yes, it isn't good.

Anthony A

Really insightful video as always, Martin. My main concern with Town Hall (and the other Metro Tunnel stations) is wayfinding consistency. After trains themselves, the core job of a station is moving large crowds efficiently. The best metro systems achieve this with strict, system-wide uniform signage and design, so commuters don’t hesitate or get confused. This feels like something Victoria should lock in now, with the intent to scale it network-wide (similar to NSW). A specific issue: Town Hall’s exit signage. Some signs reference Degraves Street as Exit 7, but much of the station only highlights three exits. That mismatch is the most confusing part of the Metro Tunnel wayfinding—especially for tourists and non-English speakers. P.S. Now that I think about it, I definitely waited for a Footscray bound train at the screen doors that were not in use at Town Hall Station.

helix28

Don't remind them that there aren't any glaring advertising screens at the main Parkville entrance. Before you know it they'll close the entrance for 2 months only to hang one from one from those concrete support beams.

David Stosser

Re door heights and banana-shaped carriages, that's an engineering thing. The carriages will be designed to flex with weight, so a loaded train will have the centre doors lower than an unloaded train. This is why the old timber carriages, particularly the PLs but also other classes, have that characteristic banana shape except when fully loaded.

David Stosser

Also, suggestion for a followup - go back to the original business case for MM1 and list the other projects associated with it, noting which ones actually happened? For example, the high capacity signalling is West Footscray to Clayton, but was supposed to be Watergardens to Dandenong (IIRC), and there were a range of other network improvements listed e.g. Upfield duplication.

Taitset

A few people have said this, but I'm a bit skeptical about how common that is beyond HCMTs. Just looking at any of my telephoto pictures, I can clearly see it on HCMTs just about every time, but no other Victorian steel car looks like that in the same conditions. Only possible exception is some Siemens cars, but it's extremely subtle, so hard to be sure. Most Comengs show a few battle scars, but I can't find any showing a consistent banana. Even H cars all look pretty much dead level after all these years. I've also never seen an example of a visible sag under load. I checked pictures of some other CRRC built EMUs, and can't find any others where it's so visible either.

Taitset

Yes that would definitely be worth looking into!

David Stosser

Hmm. Maybe put a camera at platform level at some other place that sees multiple classes of EMU, and freeze-frame as each door passes? I suppose another hypothesis is that all the older trains did the same thing when new and they've been stretched/bent to flat since then? Could check that hypothesis with the XT2.0's :P

David Stosser

The rule used to be 1:21, or 1:14 with flat sections every few metres that averaged out to 1:20.7.

Taitset

Yes not a bad idea! Will definitely be interesting to check it on the XT2s.