Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

It's finally here! This one ended up being a huge project. It posed an interesting challenge of illustrating, given there are very few visual records of the actual event. This was greatly assisted by my mate Alexander Jamieson (some of you may know him as Melbournesparks on youtube, with the G scale garden tramway). After just a small suggestion from me, he went to a lot of effort recreating scenes for this video in Open Rails, the open-source version of Train Simulator. The Comeng model already existed but only in Metro era condition, so he back-dated it to approximately 2003 M>train condition for the video. There are also a handful of photos of real M>train Comengs taken by me on my film camera when I was just a kid. There will be a behind the scenes video covering all this, likley next month.Anyway, we had a lot of fun with this one - hope you enjoy it!

Files

Melbourne's Runaway Train // The 2003 Broadmeadows Runaway!

This is the story of the 2003 Broadmeadows runway, where a Melbourne suburban train rolled 16.8km from Broadmeadows to Spencer Street with nobody onboard, ending in a major collision. This video is based on information contained in the official report by the Australian Transport Safety Bureau, which you can download here: https://www.atsb.gov.au/publications/investigation_reports/2003/rair/rair2003001 Want to help support the channel, get early access to new content and exclusive behind the scenes videos? Join me on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/Taitset Script, narration, diagrams, photographs (except where noted) and video are all by Martin Bennet. The gradient diagram is scanned from the 1927 Victorian Railways Grades book. The network map is scanned from an old issue of Melway. This video contains several scenes created in Open Rails - the open source version of Microsoft Train Simulator (MSTS). These scenes, including the train used, were modeled and produced by Alexander Jamieson. Check out his channel here: @melbournesparks3828 My voiceover was recorded with the equipment and expertise of my brother Cian, who is also the voice of Metrol in this video. Check out his music here: https://hyperfollow.com/cianbennetmusic Chapters: 00:00 - Intro 00:49 - A quiet evening at Broadmeadows 03:09 - The fateful bathroom visit / Off we go! 04:40 - A bit more context 06:35 - That's a big hill 09:21 - ..what are we going to do with it? 10:21 - No.1 Box gets a phone call 12:03 - The near miss at North Melbourne 13:58 - It's coming! / The Trolley Problem comes to life 14:42 - The Big Bang 17:35 - It's not supposed to look like that 18:39 - ATSB makes some findings 19:46 - 20 years instead of 11 minutes 21:19 - So, where are they now? 22:20 - The other runaways / Some enormous bouncy buffers 23:05 - A final final note 23:21 - That's it #melbourne #trains #railways #transport

Comments

Iris Donaldson

That was bloody brilliant, had lots of laughs across it but was an absolutely lovely watch as always!! Lost my mind at the trolley problem reference

Taitset

Thank you so much! Not going to lie, I did keep laughing at the trolley problem bit myself. 🤣

Iris Donaldson

It's INCREDIBLY hard to pick a highlight of the video, you got some great humour throughout it (chapter titles especially are a good chuckle), but the trolley problem bit be the tip top!!

Taitset

I'm so glad someone noticed the chapter titles haha

Iris Donaldson

The second I noticed them I knew I had hit gold! I can already see myself rewatching this later tonight and laughing at parts again. "And where am I going to put it?" broke me as well. It sounds weird to say this but you make me wish we had more train disasters because the way you told this story was beautiful haha!!

Taitset

I know what you mean! I do love how funny that phone conversation is given that's what they actually said. Especially how the signaller gets hung up on at the end.

Iris Donaldson

Oh absolutely! I'm trying to figure out what you covered as the inaudible mumbling but cant quite pick it out...

Taitset

Haha yeah, it was just rambling nonsense with some slightly sweary sounding bits.

Hazel

Definitely my favourite video from you so far! Very entertaining and explains it very well. The security camera animations of the train running through the stations were really professionally done, and the diagrams were very helpful.

Alex Pennini

Absolutely excellent video! This might be my favorite video from you by far. It's got all your usual level of quality, but has a great script, uses the excellent track diagrams and uses all sorts of approaches - audio only, recreation in game, pictures, etc. I love all the little details scattered throughout the video like the M-Train billboard at Broadmeadows, the trolley problem guy, the chapter titles but I especially love the recreation of the phone calls, they were my favorite part of the ATSB report. "Oh yeah, where am I going to put that?" "Yeah, righto", just very Australian response to an impending disaster. It's got a definite appeal to non-rail fans! I showed my partner, who's not into trains as much as I am, and she was on the edge of her seat, and was so nervous as it headed towards Spencer Street. Silly question, is the train in the video moving real-time? What I mean is, is the train moving towards Spencer Street even when it's not on screen? There were a couple of moments when I was looking at the train on screen during the security camera animations and wondering if it had taken into account the time it had been off screen while you were showing other stuff or narrating.

Taitset

So glad you enjoyed it! I'm glad it gave the illusion the train was continually moving, I did try to pace it like that! But no, they're all just individual scenes, and the ones at broady, Glenroy and Moonee Ponds aren't actually on a complete route, Alexander just built those three spots specifically to stage the shots.

Matt Austin

Outstanding work, Martin, thank you! Getting some happy flashbacks from the Open Rails shots too.

Charles

Bit late to comment but thank you again for another excellent video. This is a genuinely wild thing to have happened and it's kind of a miracle that no one had boarded it before it started rolling. Also been keeping an eye out on YouTube every now and then to see how the views on this one are going, and to see it tick over 100k is sah exciting! I'm so happy to see your videos getting the flowers they deserve - although still not enough if you ask me!

Taitset

Thankyou, yes it's been doing pretty amazingly! This is definitely my first video to average over 10k a day for a whole week.