Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Happy Saturday!

I ended up choosing and watching the Theatrical Cut on YouTube Rentals.

Glad I finally knocked this movie off my list! There's a bunch of cool epic battle scenes in this one, especially Hector vs Achilles, and honestly, I'd say it's more of a love story at its core. I don't know a ton about this time period, as I never studied ancient Greece. It had a lot of peaks and valleys for me. I'm chalking it up as a fun popcorn movie. Sean Bean was the standout for me in this one!

ENJOY! I did!

xx

ames

Files

TROY (2004)

Comments

AJ

Looking forward to all your thoughts on what a great brother Paris is.

Catchermag

Decent flick, with some great actors. I’m not sure why this time period isn’t tackled more, it’s ripe with stories to pick from. No one has really done it justice. Troy was directed by Wolfgang Peterson and he has helmed some great pictures. I just think this one was too large in scale. Not his fault. Look at Oliver Stones Alexander. It’s drivel. Sure, 1000 years between the two but relatively comparable. My favorite film of this nature, I’ll say, is Kingdom of Heaven, Directors Cut (famously the theatrical release sucked). But hey, that was directed by Ridley Scott, the David Lean of our time. He knows how to make a movie like this.

Frankie H

Oh nice it's free on youtube in America. With ads. Wait no it's the edited TV version. Boo youtube. I can't believe youtube has different versions of the same movie between the US and Canada. Actually it sync's well with Ames version until there's a nude scene where the tv version jumps ahead. Which is kind of funny.

Frankie H

Who's your favorite character and why is it Hector? What's funny is the guy who plays Achilles's second-in-command is in 300 as the Spartan second-in-command to King Leonidas. Talk about type casting. Also the actor who plays the Trojan general and the actor playing the Spartan King (Brandan Gleeson) played father and son in Braveheart.

Jacob Brumfield

I read the illiad and the odyssey a very long time ago. I think youre right. They did the best with the time they had. They didnt get everything in the movie but they got a lot of it. Still one of my favorite movies. I really did not like Paris at all. He had no redeeming qualities in my opinion

Brian

I tried again with this one last night. It’s such a great collection of actors, with such a lackluster script, imho. Not horrible, by any stretch, but… given the cast, I always wished for more from this one. And I’m mildly curious to see Nolan’s upcoming Odyssey. I’m not a huge fan of Nolan. I certainly appreciate that he takes these huge swings at big, epic productions, but. I don’t know. He spends so much time trying to be clever, instead of character development, that I often feel like the Tyler Durden character from Fight Club watching Nolan’s works, in that I want to sarcastically analyze afterwards “How’s that going for you? Being clever?” I’m still firmly in the camp that Nolan’s most interesting work is still Memento, which I still love rewatching from time to time. Hit or miss for me from that point on, however. But, 31 flavors, man. Some folks love chocolate. Some folks love rum raisin. There’s a big enough appetite for all comers. 🙂

JM63

Decent, but pretty forgettable, sword & sandals flick. TBH, feels like an attempt to cash in on the success of Gladiator (2000) and the first three LOTR films (2001, 02, 03). I think the actors did as well as they could with the material. For anyone looking to get caught up on the Iliad before watching The Odyssey, I highly recommend this stand-up comedy version of the Iliad by BBC presenter and historian Natalie Haynes. It's really excellent and a lot of fun! https://podbay.fm/p/natalie-haynes-stands-up-for-the-classics/e/1582546980

Bubba Fett

The one time seeing Sean bean in the cast and it not being a spoiler 🤣 How awesome would he have been with the odyssey as a sequal. Robbed of greatness. Side not on COX, I loved him and Bean together in this and the Sharpe's series.

Ken Schneyer

A wonderful reaction, Ames! You gave me some new things to think about. ;) As promised, here is the rather lengthy essay about this film I posted in 2022: ******************************************************* Troy (2004) is a guilty pleasure for me. It's fascinating because there's so much that's done well, right along side some really awful, even laughable choices. It's both a terrible and a wonderful movie, and watching it is like biting into an especially flavorful lemon: it stings, but you can't stop. . THE GOOD: (1) Delightful, scene-chewing performances by Sean Bean (Odysseus), Brian Cox (Agamemnon), Eric Bana (Hector), and Peter O'Toole (Priam), turning the whole thing Shakespearean. It's impossible not to fall in love with Hector, and not to want to strangle Agamemnon. (2) Julie Christie as Thetis. She has one (1) scene, but she manages to make you forget everything else in the film. She's not a demigoddess in this version, but she clearly has the Sight, although she never says so aloud and it's clear that her visions are imposed on her. Like everything else Christie has ever done on film, it's electrifying. (3) The balance between making the audience sympathize with the Trojans and the Greeks. You don't approve of either defending Paris's affair with Helen or of Agamemnon's thuggish greed for control of Troy, but you feel for the soldiers on both sides, and you want the war to end so that they can all go home to their families. War is not glorified; every death hurts. You can't decide whom to cheer for. (4) The (many) lines that actually come from the Iliad. Achilles's and Hector's dialogue before their last battle, including "There are no pacts between lions and men", sent a chill up my spine. (5) The theme of the human desire to be remembered, and its curious connection with glory in battle. The film begins with Sean Bean's beautiful voiceover, "Men are haunted by the vastness of Eternity..." and makes it clear (as does the Iliad) that Achilles is seeking never-ending fame, and why that matters. (6) The cinematography is beautiful, especially the scenes that take advantage of the landscape (or seascape). (7) Much of the fight choreography is fascinating, and while I don't for a moment believe Achilles's signature move (leaping into the air and driving his swordpoint down into his opponent's chest from above with his full weight), it's still fun to watch. . THE AWFUL: (1) No Cassandra, no Hecuba. The female cast is reduced to three (four if you include Thetis), of whom Briseis is the only interesting character. Helen just makes a bunch of stupid choices and regrets them, and Andromache just suffers. (Compare this to the way those two appear in The Trojan Women, and you'll get an idea at the missed opportunities.) (Yes, I also missed Clytemnestra and Iphigenia, not to mention Penelope, but I can understand how you'd think of those stories as too big to include in this one, which is already enormous.) (2) The stupid, cowardly, homophobic decision (a) to make Patroklos into Achilles's younger *cousin* and ward, FFS (can anyone say Dick Grayson?), instead of his lover and comrade-in-arms; and (b) to make Briseis into a love interest instead of a war prize. I call it a single decision, rather than two, because obviously they realized that romantic affection could be a great motivator for Achilles, but they didn't have the guts to give him the affection he actually had. Now, Rose Byrne takes the opportunity to make Briseis into someone genuinely interesting, a critical voice who rejects the entire warrior ethos, and I appreciate that, but there's so much dreck that's piled on top of it that it's almost lost. (3) Brad Pitt, especially his accent. I often like Pitt's work, and I actually understand what he was trying to do with Achilles, but it just doesn't work. You can't turn a pivotal figure in the redefinition of Hellenic "honor" into an existentialist contemporary man brooding on the morality of his life. And that wandering accent, OMFG; I mean, I know that literally everyone else in the cast was British, but this was Kevin Costner all over again. (4) Orlando Bloom's Paris. I mean, it isn't impossible to imagine Paris as a feckless pretty boy, but it's painful to watch. I suppose I should admit that Bloom makes me believe the character is sincere, but he is so selfish, silly, unrealistic, and ultimately cowardly, that I don't care about his sincerity. And he gets Cassandra's best line -- except that it isn't that actual line. (5) Too many unnecessary deviations from the Iliad with no payoff. The early deaths of Ajax and Menelaus are pointless, since it's already been established that Agamemnon would fight anyway and that the Greeks would lose without Achilles. (6) Hector's and Achilles's skepticism about the gods and their influence on war. I grudgingly admit that it functions as good character points, especially in the conflict it creates between Hector and Priam, but it's so post-Enlightenment (to the point where Hector literally speaks one of G. B. Shaw's lines from "Saint Joan") as to make you cringe. (7) No ethnic realism whatsoever, not even a faint attempt at it, in the casting. I mention this last because it's typical of filmmaking of that era (and it was worse in earlier eras), but still, ouch. Anyway, I keep watching it. ******************************************************* I might add things nowadays, but I thought I'd give you what I originally wrote. If you're interested in reading the Iliad and/or Odyssey before the new film comes out, I highly recommend Emily Wilson's recent translations (and especially the lengthy introduction she wrote to the Odyssey, which I keep reading over and over).