Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

ummm. is this heartbreaking only to me? or everyone?

Let me know your thoughts below! What an episode! So many laughs! + Daddy Picard! Lfg!

xx

ames

Files

Star Trek: TNG S4xE25 "In Theory"

Comments

TechJJ

I love any storyline that explores the "human" side of Data. And many times these can produce good amount of laughs! But this one brings me back to probably the most emotional and heartbreaking episode of Data that I still claim to this date - The Offspring (S3E16).

pickupthepieces

A love story for Data makes total sense in his journey. Glad the writers found a way to explore it in a good way. With humor, realism and bittersweet heartbreak (for us). I think you would be a very good friend to Data Ames. You got his back and it would be a barrel of laughs, well not for Data of course. 'The probe room...' Interesting take. 🤣

Joe R

If only Jenna had the One Wish Willow this would be a completely different episode. Spot could end up in a sandwich though.

WastedPo

I have mixed feelings about this one. I think it's very funny, but some of the humor gets kind of goofy towards the end, and it's like they had to make Data dumber and more obtuse than he's been in a while for the jokes to work. Even the ending, if we are to accept that Data can't feel romantic/sexual love -- the Data they've established would've still been more sensitive to Jenna's feelings and wouldn't have been so shrugging towards her obvious pain. Also, I find the "debate" about whether or not Data has emotions to be moot, because the writers have clearly implied over the four seasons thus far that Data does have emotions. (Measure of a Man, The Most Toys, Legacy, Pen Pals, Elementary Dear Data, the Offspring... those are just off the top of my head.) Heck, entire episodes only work if one assumes he has emotions. Data will often vocally state that he doesn't feel anything, but entire plotlines and subtexts, and little private moments are thrown in there specifically to contradict this assumption. So for this episode to repeatedly state that Data essentially doesn't care about anything or anyone goes against the character they've built over the past four years.

Anthony Hernandez

It is heartbreaking when she leaves and he’s alone with spot. It is of course heartbreaking for me, but not for him which adds more heartbreak because he can’t get there with his feelings. I think this is the danger of AI. It will get better and better at emulating having a soul, but it can never have one. It will be confusing for some people. There is an AI program that I have used in the past that helps you talk through mental and emotional issues. It does feel almost human at times. I could easily see how lonely people could crave relationships with AI.

Anthony Hernandez

When the show was airing, there was a group of women who were called Spiner Femmes. They had a crush on Data, and many believed he had emotion no matter what the writers of the show portrayed him as having.

Clay F

Great reaction. The episode seems to suggest that Data cannot feel emotion?

John Courtright

For me, the heartbreak on Data's behalf in this episode was somewhat mitigated by the fact that (like WastedPo observed in these comments), "they had to make Data dumber and more obtuse than he's been in a while". I think by this time (S4xE25) Data is more informed in his understanding of human behavior and more nuanced in his interactions than portrayed here. This seems more like Season 1 Data than Season 4 Data. I also found it interesting that Data uses contractions in this episode like "Honey, I'm home!", "I'll join you.", and "You're not my mother", despite the fact that his inability to use contractions is treated as a major character trait and plot device, such as in "The Offspring", when Data is astonished when his android daughter, Lal, naturally uses a contraction. The above inconsistencies made it difficult for me to take this episode too seriously.