Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Holy Hell! What a hard episode to watch! Thanks for being here!!

xx

ames

Files

The Pacific Part 9 Watch Along

😭

Comments

Bubba Fett

Back during Kung Flu I saw a meme that was funny at the time but the sentiment applies to this show and the caption on it was "it gets worse before it gets worse"

Stephen Knueppel

"War makes monsters of us all. But what happens when we no longer wish to be monsters?"- Kameron Hurley.

Stephen Knueppel

Even though Okinawa was part of Japan and it's people Japanese citizens the Japanese soldiers looked with disdain on Okinawans. They were treated much like Native Americans in the 1800's and deemed inferior. Okinawa cost the lives of 7,000 Marines and Army personnel as well as 5,000 sailors from kamakazi attacks. Nearly 40,000 more were wounded and mental casualties were at an all time high. The Japanese suffered nearly 100% KIA. Somewhere between 87,000 and 110,000 depending on the source. Civilians on Okinawa also had around 100,000 killed or nearly a third of the pre invasion population of the island. Although the morality of dropping the Atom bomb on Japan is still debated for men at the time facing an invasion of the Japanese Home Islands there is little debate. Better a few bombs wipe out a city or two than invading, especially when the estimate was 1 million US casualties. Also the Air Force was already wiping out Japanese cities with fire bombing causing 100's of thousands of casualties with regular bombing missions. Okinawa was the only battle where both commanding Generals were killed.

John Courtright

This episode was such a gut punch! I can't believe the realism of how this was shot. The horror and chaos of Okinawa made me sick to my stomach. What a performance by Joseph Mazzello as Eugene Sledge! What a character arc! It was so amazing to see Eugene regain some of his humanity in the midst of such hell. It's been an incredible series but I'll be glad for us to wrap it up with the next episode.

Clay F

Flame throwers are insane. No matter how many times I see them in war movies, I find them striking. Good observation about scent association in that war environment. I hadn't really thought about it. Sledge still has his humanity. He needs to get the hell out of there. I wasn't sure what to think about Eugene at the beginning of the series, but I think he may be my favorite character in the series. My son and I went to Hiroshima. We went to the Hiroshima Peace Memorial Museum.

Robert Livingood

Just a note on the nuclear bombs dropped on Hiroshima and Nagasaki. Reasonable minds can certainly disagree whether there was moral justification for doing it, but the US had realized that as dreadful as the island to island fighting had been on the march toward the Japanese mainland (Peleilu, Iwo Jima, Okinawa etc), actually invading Japan proper would have been far worse than anything that had already occurred. Realistic estimates suggested that at the very least 200,000 US servicemen would have died invading Japan and probably at least 300,000 Japanese would have perished, whereas the 2 nuclear bombs killed an estimated 125,000 and severely injured another 125,000. Unimaginable as it is to contemplate, it’s difficult to argue that the nuclear bombs didn’t actually save lives on both sides. Likely the first and only time such a statement can be made. In fact, the preceding three year bombing campaign of Japanese cities and strategic industrial sites killed, by most estimates several hundred thousand (mostly civilians) with other estimates reach nearly a million. Many believe that Operation Meetinghouse aka The Fire Bombing of Tokyo in March of 1945 using an early form of napalm was if anything even more nightmarish and, by some estimates, killed more than Hiroshima and Nagasaki combined, though officially at least 100,000. In preparation for a ground invasion by Allied troops there likely would have been nonstop aerial bombing campaigns like this, which is partly why President Truman, bless him, made the decision he did to use the nuclear weapons instead and just try to end things imediately. War as they say, is hell, and none was more hellish than the war in the Pacific. It’s been said that in WW2 fighting the Germans was like a terrible heavyweight boxing match, brutal but within the bounds of convention with discernible rules generally adhered to by both sides. Wheres the war in the Pacific was a knife fight in the gutter to the death.

Baron Imhoof

Japan began their war in 1931, and they killed 40+ million soldiers and civilians, while only losing less than 10% of that. And when it was over they were treated very well by us, with billions to rebuild their economy and our military to protect them, especially from China, where they had murdered tens of millions. I do not wish Japan or its people ill now, but I cannot be sorry my dad and uncles didn't have to invade and occupy them in 1945, nor can I feel much sympathy for the price they paid for their 14-year rampage.

Robert Livingood

Amen to that. My Marine grandfather was set to be in the first wave of the ground invasion and he always said that as lucky as he had been to survive 3 years in the jungle up to that point, he knew he would never have come home if Truman hadn't dropped the bombs. On an even more personal note that is of no consequence to anyone but me and and my family, but my mother, my brother, my nieces, my kids and myself exist today only because Gramps did come back.

Clay F

I rewatched this full reaction last night. Such a good reaction. Tough for you in ways.