Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Chapter 37

Failure

The dungeon’s stones were slick with water and dressed in mold. Things had been done here, leaving their smells in the air— rot and waste and the twang of old blood. The cells were mostly empty. None stayed full long, save for one. 

Harry did not feel well. His body ached from his last transformation, barely two days passed. But he hid every sign of that as he stared at the girl held aloft by her chained arms, her toes narrowly touching the ground, head hanging and robes ripped many places over.

“She is alive?” he asked.

“I would not have called for you over a mudblood’s corpse.”

Voldemort’s voice was misleadingly high and deceptively calm. He rarely screamed and never cursed, which only made him more frightening. Harry learned long ago to hide flinches when his master spoke. 

Instead of answering, he walked past the Dark Lord, stepping into the cell. “You. Look at me.”

The prisoner lifted her head.

Not only did it prove to him she wasn’t dead, it proved she was alive. Her eyes were real eyes. Human eyes, packed with emotions and so sharp he worried he might be cut standing in their path.

Harry looked back. “What do you wish me to do with her?”

“Cut her secrets out of her,” Voldemort said. “She has proved resistant in the face of my other blades, so the task falls to the sharpest one. Learn everything she knows. Use any method you wish, and do as you please with her when you’re done.”

Harry nodded. He faced the girl again, swiping with his wand and cutting the chains that held her up. She collapsed immediately, landing with a thump on her knees. Her legs were not fit to hold her weight.

But her neck was strong enough to raise her head. She looked straight at Harry… and smiled.

“Nice to meet you,” she said.

He could see why the others failed.

O-O-O

Her name was Hermione.

She told it to him herself, right after telling him he had a nice house, and right before asking if he had anything to read.

She showed no fear. She had no need of it, she said, when he asked— she was already captured, had been tortured terribly, and was going to die. Fear, she said, was the anticipation that things could go badly. She knew they would go badly. Therefore, she had nothing to fear.

That was not the only bit of… wisdom that she shared. Voldemort told him she had spoken only two words in her weeks of captivity within a Death Eater dungeon, both said directly to the Dark Lord’s face. “You’ll lose.”

They’d earned her a bout with the Cruciatus. She screamed, to be sure, but divulged nothing that could be used. She was as sullen as prisoners came.

It was a great surprise to Harry, then, when he found that she would not shut up.

“Have you ever tried a beignet?”

Hermione was seated in a chair at Harry’s table. She wasn’t bound or chained. There was no point, given Harry had faced far more dangerous opponents than one wandless girl. Every morning he brought her to this place and interrogated her. That was how it started, anyway. He had become the one faced with questions.

“I have not,” Harry said. He was sitting at the opposite end of the table, its wooden surface separating them lengthwise. 

“I hadn’t either until I came to Hogwarts. They had all kinds of new things there. Desserts, ghosts, magic.” She was smiling, though Harry thought it only accentuated her unnatural thinness. “You never went to Hogwarts. Do you wish you had?”

“Wishes are a waste of time,” Harry said.

“What makes you say that?”

Harry didn’t elaborate, sitting in silence, leading Hermione to tilt her head.

“You’re very strange. You don’t like my questions, yet you don’t make me stop. You’ve even given up on interrogating me.”

“False,” Harry said. “I decided on a more efficient method. The only tool fit to break you is another person. Once I capture someone you care about, their pain will loosen your lips.”

“So you say,” Hermione said. “But while you plot, all you have is me, and you haven’t hurt me once.”

“That would be inefficient. You’ve proven you can withstand simple methods.”

“Bellatrix would have done it anyway.”

Harry smiled. 

“That’s why I’m better than her.”

He had nothing else to say. Draco was gathering information for him about those close to this strange Muggle-born, at which point he would be able to put his theory into practice. 

He didn’t expect Hermione, kicking her legs under the table, to offer that information up freely.

“My parents are dead,” she said. “Killed in a Death Eater raid, if you were curious. I don’t have many friends either. I never quite fit in at Hogwarts, as much as I loved it. If there was someone I’m close to… I look up to Professor Dumbledore a tremendous amount. To save his life, I’d give up any secret without a second thought. But that doesn’t help you much, does it? You can’t exactly capture him. He even frightens your master.”

“You could be bluffing,” Harry said.

“And you should be livid that I called your master scared. But you aren’t.” 

“He’s not present to hear you,” Harry said simply.

Hermione started to laugh. Her throat was still raspy on account of weeks with too little water. 

“Well, until you find someone close to me, we might as well talk!” Hermione said. “It’s not like we have much else to do.”

O-O-O

“You were telling the truth.”

They were at Harry’s table again on another morning, slightly more than a week later.

“I don’t lie to you,” Hermione said. She chewed a bit of toast. Her appetite was returning, and she could keep most things down now. “What were you referring to, though?”

“You said that you didn’t have friends at Hogwarts. Draco confirmed it. An antisocial bookworm. Those were his exact words.”

“I was never antisocial,” Hermione said. “I’ve just never been good at it. Making friends is supposed to come naturally. That makes it hard to learn, if you’re terrible at it. So, what will you do now?” She spread butter across a second slice of toast. “You have no hostages to break me with.”

“I could pick at random,” Harry said. “Your weakness is watching others in pain. I doubt you're cold enough to stay silent while watching an innocent Muggle girl scream in front of you.”

He was right. He knew he was because of how she looked at him. For a second, there was hostility. For a moment, she showed pain.

Harry averted his gaze momentarily, speaking no more on it. He didn’t get up and leave his house, even though it would take no planning to abduct a random Muggle. 

When his eyes returned to her, she was smiling, and the knot that had appeared in his chest started to loosen.

“Can you call your elf?” Hermione asked.

“Why?”

“Because he’s cooked me such a nice meal. I’d like to thank him.”

Instead of questioning it, which would take far too long for every zany thing she did, Harry just listened. “Dobby!”

“Master called for Dobby, sir?”

The elf appeared with a pop. Harry pointed across the table. “She called for you.”

“Hello, Dobby. My name is Hermione. The food was lovely! You’re a very good chef!”

“Dobby is,” said Dobby. “Better than most elves. And all wizards.”

“Won’t your master strike you for saying that?” Hermione asked.

Dobby puffed his chest out. “Master Potter doesn’t hit me. The Malfoys didn’t like Dobby, they hit him lots and got rid of him for being a bad elf. But Dobby can’t be a bad elf, because Master Potter never complains about Dobby!”

“That’s very kind of him.” Hermione was looking at Harry.

“Kindness has nothing to do with it,” Harry said. “Dobby does nothing worthy of punishment. Why would I do it for no reason?”

Dobby leaned toward Hermione, who enthusiastically leaned toward him in return so that they could converse quietly. What they said escaped Harry. He intended to let his attention wander, only to find himself looking at Hermione.

Fat was starting to return to her cheeks. She didn’t look like a corpse the way she had when she arrived. She just looked malnourished. She had been bathing regularly, returning a sprightliness to her curly brown hair. Her eyes had never been dead, not for a single moment of a single day. They glowed as she and Dobby shared a conversation he apparently wasn’t entitled to hear.

Dobby disappeared. He might’ve winked at Hermione before leaving— Harry wasn’t looking at the elf. He was finding it hard to look away from Hermione.

Worst of all, she knew it.

Hermione propped her face on her hands, gazing straight back at him across the table. “How do I look?”

“Too comfortable,” Harry grunted.

“You could make me less comfortable.”

He didn’t reply to that, making Hermione’s smile grow.

He left the room first, but he wasn’t running. He just had business elsewhere.

O-O-O

It started with one bookshelf. Eventually, that led to the second one, and the third after that. Each of them filled up with books fetched by Dobby. After the first ten, Harry no longer checked the items that were brought in.

Hermione’s room started as an empty one with a single boring bed just like all the other rooms in his mansion. Somewhere along the way, it filled with the life that the rest of the house lacked. She got sheets that were red and gold. When she asked for perfume to freshen herself up, it was granted like the rest of her requests.

Maybe because of the life the room had taken on, Harry began spending time in it. Neither of them believed him when he said it was to interrogate her more often.

“You left the door unlocked yesterday,” Hermione said.

She was laying on her stomach, kicking her legs as she read a book on the bed. Harry was sitting in a chair beside the window. “Was it?”

“Yes. The front door was, too. Voldemort’s right hand man can’t be overlooking little details like that! Someone could use oversights like that to hurt you.”

“I’ve been… out of it,” Harry said. He had one arm on the back of the chair, with his cheek resting on his hand. “Why didn’t you run?”

Hermione turned a page. “I couldn’t! That would be anticlimactic. If I’m going to make an escape, I have to use my magical abilities, or at least my sharp intellect. What kind of story would it be if I walked out of an unlocked door?”

Harry blinked slowly. He was usually good at controlling his tongue. Excellent, even. But he was not lying about how he was feeling. A migraine pounded in his head at all hours. Ordinary smells and sounds had become painfully loud. It was harder to keep his tongue leashed than normal. “I would value my life more than some story.”

Hermione looked up. A moment later, she shut her book, rolling to sit up.

“I’m not being serious,” Hermione said. “I’m sorry, Harry. I didn’t mean to mock you. The reason I didn’t run is because I haven’t achieved my mission.”

“What mission?” Harry asked.

Hermione smiled.

“Are you here to kill me? I’m at my weakest now. If you’re waiting for a better time, it won’t come.”

“That’s true,” Hermione said.

“Then what are you here for?”

Harry almost never raised his voice but he did so now. He regretted it a moment later when the sound pounded in his ears, worsening his headache. He shrunk back in his chair, covering both of his eyes for a moment, trying to drown out his senses. It was a good thing he was in this room— his nose was the worst of them all, but Hermione’s perfume calmed it, and her room reeked of that scent.

He took a deep breath and uncovered his eyes, only to find her standing right in front of him.

She leaned down, her face hovering right in front of his. Hermione’s cheeks were full. Her hair looked lustrous. Even her lashes had recovered to a beautiful state, long and curling. How had she been lonely in Hogwarts? Harry wondered. Had no one ever looked at her?

“Harry Potter,” she said. “Why do you fight for Voldemort?”

“He raised me.”

“Tortured you, more like. I’ve seen how you react to things. Any kindness unbalances you like you’ve never met it before.”

“He made me what I am,” Harry said. A similar thing to say, but different in ways that he felt mattered.

“Do you enjoy what you are?” Hermione asked.

“I don’t get to think about things like that.” 

“Are you scared of dying?” Hermione asked.

“No.” He was. “I fear nothing.”

“You fear Voldemort, for one thing. And I think I know another one. You’re scared to be loved.”

“Love never hurt anyone. Why would I fear that?”

Hermione shook her head, smiling wryly at how little he knew. 

The next moment she was leaning in.

Harry hadn’t expected it. He reacted instinctively, throwing himself back. His chair toppled over, his back hit the floor, and he had to roll through the landing in order to scramble back to his feet.

For a second, his hand almost went to his wand. 

Hermione was smirking.

“The reaction of a man who definitely, completely, is not scared of love.”

“You’re playing with me!” Harry accused.

“A bit. I’m sorry. But I’m being serious, too. I don’t lie to you, if you remember.”

Harry’s heart was beating. He wished it would stop. He was having a hard time thinking. His body reacted, returning to instincts built up as a helpless child. When he didn’t feel in control, he ran away.

Harry grabbed the door handle to flee.

“You’re going to have to kill me!” Hermione said.

Suddenly, he wasn’t able to get the door open. His wrist wouldn’t turn.

“I haven’t learned what you know.”

“Voldemort doesn’t care what I know.” Hermione’s voice was gentle. “He wants you to do as he says. He knows you’ll serve him, the thing he doubts is your cruelty. When you don’t gain anything from it, can you kill an enemy at your mercy?”

“Maybe I killed you. Maybe I burned your body. I threw the ashes in the garbage.”

“That won’t be good enough.” He could tell she was smiling, just from her voice. “He’ll want to see. He’ll send someone to check. Bellatrix, or another one who hates you.”

Harry spun toward Hermione. His face was angry, because she was right. “You never stop talking!”

“You could make me,” she said.

Harry’s wrist remembered how to work. He never left a room faster.

O-O-O

They didn’t talk. Harry didn’t go to her room, Hermione didn’t come to him. They ate separately. Harry was running. He knew that, obviously, but if he wasn’t willing to face what was chasing him, why would he stop?

It wasn’t as if he agonized over their conversation. He didn’t have the opportunity to. He spent most of a day in bed, then on the next, he woke up with the pain he’d been feeling much more muted. That was always how it went on the day. He opened his window and sat on the sill for almost an hour, looking at the morning sky.

Hermione ate breakfast with him that morning. It had been two days since they shared a table. She didn’t speak until the end of the meal.

“It’s not your fault,” Hermione said. “You never had a choice. He made you into what you are. That doesn’t mean he has to choose your future, too.”

Harry got up silently, limping toward the door. Hermione turned away and called Dobby, thanking him for the food the way she always did. At one point, she’d even suggested working hours and a wage, for an elf! She was smart in some ways, dumb in others. That was Harry’s verdict.

He said nothing to her and left in silence. That would be his second greatest regret.

In the afternoon, he replied to letters. They always built up around the full moon. 

He ate lunch in his room. He sat on his bed after that, staring at his hands. When his head started to pound, blood throbbing in his veins, he got off of his bed and pushed its wooden frame. It skidded aside, revealing the door underneath.

A moment before he entered the door, Harry stopped.

“Dobby,” he said softly.

The elf was there immediately. “Yes, Potter sirs?”

“Lock that room.”

The elf didn’t say anything for a few seconds.

“Dobby will do it,” he said finally, disappearing.

Harry climbed through the hatch.

He pulled his robes off and hung them on a hook. This room had no windows, just a cage made of sturdy metal. Harry opened the gate, brought it shut, and made sure it was locked.

He sat down with his legs crossed, reduced to his underwear. The cold helped him keep his mind sharp. Wolfsbane was expensive and had always been useless to him. He didn’t want to be aware when the wolf was in control. If he surrendered, let it beat against the bars, and woke up when it was over, then he could pretend it never happened. He could pretend that this wasn’t who he was.

When the chill started to disappear, he knew it was time. Fur was sprouting over his body.

His limbs twitched. Bones changed shape. A tail grew on his back. Eventually, Harry’s neck snapped back, releasing a howl. Claws came out and attacked the metal. They were repelled with an awful noise. Harry’s vision blurred as something else used his eyes.

The next thing he knew, he was seeing red.

He was always groggy the morning after. It took almost five seconds for him to realize something was wrong. It took another twenty five to understand what.

He tasted blood.

It was everywhere. On his clothes. On his face. Most of it was on the floor, forming a puddle. So, so much blood. Harry started crying. The tears were fast— faster than his brain. That took much longer to recognize the face beneath him.

Hermione was still alive. Her chest was moving, slightly, above a horrible bite wound. He was hyperventilating. He put a hand on her side, as if his fingers could stop the bleeding.

“No.” Harry’s voice didn’t sound like his own. It was quiet, weak, vulnerable. “Why? I wasn’t going to—”

He stopped. He had been about to answer his own question.

Hermione touched his cheek. It was incredible that she had the strength with all the blood she’d lost.

“It’s not your fault.” Harry hated that she was smiling. “He’ll trust you now. This way, you have a future.”

“I don’t want a future—”

Hermione surprised him one more time. She lurched up, her face managing to reach him. Her lips pressed into his lips before she fell back. When she landed, her arm flopped to the side, losing strength.

“You didn’t dodge that one.” 

When her chest stopped, for once, Harry’s howl was all his own.

Comments

adorsey

Missed this one

Venastus

Wonderful, as always. Glad this finally got an update.

gigamans

Forgot how depressing this story was