Professor Potter: Chapter 70 (Patreon)
Content
Chapter 70
Destined Burden
One hour before dinner, when the day inevitably arrived, Neville and his friends were escorted out of Hogwarts.
Minerva McGonagall took them herself. Outside the school, by the front gate, they were met by Sirius Black, Dorcas Meadows, and Emmeline Vance. They were all in different moods. Dorcas was calm, Emmeline was pretending to be calm, and Sirius was grinning.
“Our homebase is going to blow you away,” Sirius told Neville. “Your jaw is going to drop. You’ve never seen anything like it!”
Neville couldn’t help rolling his eyes, which made Sirius snicker. He only quieted when McGonagall gave him a tried and true instructor’s look. She might have been the only person alive who could hush him that way.
“Gather in,” McGonagall said, producing a loose shoestring.
One Portkey journey later, Neville was home.
The sky was dark gray, smeared with thick clouds. He could see his breath as they walked through the garden. The lumpy, misaligned shape of Longbottom Manor didn’t breathe any whimsy into Neville’s heart today. He kept coming back to the same questions.
Why was he here?
Why were Ron and Hermione with him?
If they were being let into the Order, why now?
He’d even wondered if someone else died. Someone close to him. Someone important to the Order. But he ruled that out. If that was the case, they would have just told him in a letter, or left him to learn about it in the Prophet.
That’s how it always went.
“This way,” McGonagall said.
They went past the Order members watching the door. Marlene McKinnon on the left and Daedalus Diggle on the right both bowed to Neville, which made his cheeks turn red. Daedalus actually meant the gesture, while Neville caught Marlene smirking. She was doing it to make him blush.
“Welcome, Neville!” Daedalus said.
“Try not to get lost,” Marelene said, making Sirius laugh.
It was a strange feeling, to be led through his own home. Neville walked behind Headmistress McGonagall. Ron and Hermione walked behind him. In the back, Sirius and Dorcas strolled along. Emmeline had paused at the door to talk with Marlene.
“What’s this about?” Neville asked. “Can’t you tell us what we’re here for?”
“You’re here because it’s where you’re meant to be,” Dorcas said.
“I’d hope so, since it is his house,” Sirius said. “Can I keep milking that joke? I don’t think it’s dead yet.”
“That’s not what I was talking about,” Dorcas said.
“I know what you meant,” Sirius said, his voice suddenly flat.
“There’s a very important meeting being held today,” McGonagall said. “Your presence is necessary, Neville. It will make sense soon.”
Longbottom Manor wasn’t big enough for a long walk. By the time McGonagall spoke, they’d reached the dining room. She put her hands on the door and pushed it wide open.
Compared to the hallway, the dining room was bright. It took Neville’s eyes around half a second to adjust.
When the room came into focus, it was a bit over half-full. Neville saw a lot of familiar faces along with some he didn’t recognize. There were two long tables, both facing each other, while a smaller table sat against the far wall. The arrangement was done so everyone in the room could see those at the small table.
Out of five seats there, only two of them were open. The others were taken by Harry, James, and Neville’s Gran.
Surprisingly, Dorcas was the one to touch Neville’s shoulder.
“Shall we sit down?” she asked.
When they were halfway across the room, Neville gave up convincing himself that one of the seats wasn’t for him.
Sure enough, Dorcas guided him to the most important chair in the whole room— right in the middle of the special table, with Professor Potter on his right and Gran on his left, the Supreme Mugwump just on the other side of Harry. Dorcas sat down on the other side of Augusta.
Facing the room like this, it was impossible not to feel everyone’s attention on him. They were all watching him so closely. Neville rested his hands on the table, moved them to his lap, wrung them, then let them fall to his sides, all in the span of half a minute. Then he put them back on the table. His palms were sweating.
“What is this?” Neville whispered loudly.
“Why, it’s a meeting of the Order of the Phoenix, the brave supporters committed to aiding your battle against Voldemort,” Gran said. “Try to remember their faces, Neville. Nothing would make them happier.”
That’s not what I meant, Neville thought. He always had trouble saying things like that out loud.
“That’s not what he was asking,” Harry said.
Neville actually thought of invoking his Occlumency defenses, because it was like the professor had read his mind. Of course he hadn’t actually. They weren’t even looking each other in the eyes.
Gran touched Neville’s hand, getting him to look at her.
“It will all make sense soon,” she said. “The moment has finally come.”
Neville wasn’t feeling any more relaxed. As soon as Gran took her hand away, Professor Potter tapped Neville’s shoulder. He turned to him and felt a sudden sting as their eyes met.
This time, Neville really did need his defenses. He brought them to bare and, even though he was a bit sloppier than normal, repelled the probe. Harry smiled at him.
Without his saying a word, Neville was suddenly less tense. Harry had given him a reminder. Occlumency had gone from something Neville thought he’d never to know to something he was starting to consider a strength, all through careful work and a bit of belief. A barrier he’d been convinced was insurmountable had been torn through by his best efforts.
Neville wasn’t helpless. He’d learned, he’d grown. In the past, he had fought with his life on the line.
Who cared if the Order bowed to him. What did it matter if they looked at him with stars in their eyes, seating him next to four of the strongest witches and wizards in the country? Neville had been through worse than some embarrassment and nerves. His eyes found Hermione and Ron sitting next to Sirius, Ron pale with excitement and Hermione fidgeting, going spare. He almost laughed. Had he looked that bad?
Gran raised her voice.
“I think that’s everyone we are going to get,” she said. Emmeline and the guards from the door had just slipped in, finding their seats. “Thank you everyone for being here. In times like these, that cannot be taken for granted.”
“Where are the rest?” Elphias Doge asked. “How can they miss such an important meeting?”
There were a lot of empty seats, Neville noticed.
“Those you don’t see among you are busy,” James said. “Without the surveillance they’re offering, some remote villages would be completely without protection. Already, brave work from people in this room has prevented two tragedies. Your missing fellow members are preventing more.”
“Lots of us fought in the last war,” Sirius said. “How many full meetings did we have back then?”
“We lost the man who founded the Order itself,” Elphias insisted, in the grouchy tone reserved for the elderly. “In these circumstances, they can surely take one night off. No mission could be so important!”
“What would they be leaving their missions for? To cry about Dumbledore’s death with us?” Harry asked. “Albus is gone and nothing we do tonight will change that. If we risked innocent people’s lives just to mourn him, he’d have hexed us until we were blue in the face.”
“Quite right,” Augusta said. “The past remains the past, now and forever. What we’ve convened to discuss is the future.”
The future. Neville’s mouth was a bit dry. Me.
He, Ron, and Hermione were the youngest ones in the room. He saw a girl with pink hair who was a few years older than them, and the former Beauxbatons champion Fleur Delacour who graduated from school last year. There were only a handful of others younger than thirty years old. This meeting was about them. Himself, Ron, and Hermione… Or maybe it was all about Neville. They had to be related to the topic. Otherwise, they wouldn’t be here.
Neville remembered the difference in attitude between Dorcas and Sirius on the trip here. Harry’s face gave nothing away. James seemed slightly grim. Gran was smiling. Dorcas seemed a little bit excited. Something was happening.
“We can’t run from the question,” Gran said. “We have lost our leader. We have mourned, forged on as best we could, and now we come to the crossroads. We must decide who will lead in his place.”
Now, everyone was looking at Neville.
“Me?” he asked, unable to keep his voice down.
“You are the chosen one.” Gran spoke to him gently and excitedly, like she was soothing him after a bout of accidental magic. “Facing You-Know-Who is your fate, Neville. You alone have met and defied him time and again.”
“Which is why we’re giving you the choice,” Harry said.
The room didn’t stay quiet. Almost everyone had a comment or question, which they shouted out at the same time. The resultant noise was unintelligible.
Marlene McKinnon stood up near the back of the room. A fairly small girl, she cupped her hands around her mouth.
“SHUT YOUR ARSES UP!”
As far as Neville could tell, she didn’t use a drop of magic, just her deceptively mighty lungs.
Marlene nodded in satisfaction, sitting down. “Carry on.”
“Don’t you think this is too soon?” Molly Weasley asked. “He’s just a boy. You’re suggesting we bring children into a war!”
Her husband touched her arm while Sturgis Podmore cleared his throat.
“I don’t mean to be rude, Molly, but the way I see it, haven’t we already failed to keep them out?” Sturgis said. “How many times has Neville been attacked? More than my nan had freckles. And let me tell you, if you ever laid eyes on her — Merlin rest her soul — you’d know I’m not talking about just a few.”
“So we should just give up?” Mrs. Weasley asked. “Throw the children in headfirst, because they’ve already been in danger before? Perhaps we should send them to assault Lestrange Manor!”
Sturgis shifted. “C’mon, you know that’s not how I meant it…”
“He does have something of a point,” Remus said. The werewolf wasn’t cowed by Molly Weasley’s hearty glare. “At the very least, it’s not fair to keep them out of all Order meetings, when they’ve risked their lives as much as any of our members.”
“We’re getting off-topic,” James said. “Whether we accept Hogwarts students as members is a separate conversation. While I consider it one worth discussing, that’s not what Augusta is proposing. She wants Neville to lead.”
“He was born to,” Augusta said. “Age is only as important as experience. Can anyone in this room say they’ve risked their lives as many times as Neville, facing the Dark Lord’s plots?”
Sirius pointed. He didn’t answer out loud, but his eyes said plenty.
He was directing everyone’s attention to Harry.
“I can’t think of anyone who would do a better job than Harry!” Hestia Jones said.
“He’s been a member of the Order for less than a year,” Elphias Dodge said, crossing his arms.
“On his first mission, he captured the Carrow Twins,” Hestia said. “He’s the one who killed Greyback and stopped Voldemort from winning over the giants—”
“On missions we were never told about!” Elphias said. He looked around the room, disgust on his face. “Does that not strike anyone other than me as strange? We, who have been supporting Dumbledore for decades, were passed over in favor of a stranger who appeared from nowhere? We weren’t told the truth even after the fact. Why would a new member be sent on so many missions?”
“Instead of experienced members like you?” Sirius asked.
“Well, if you put it like that, yes!”
Marlene laughed out loud. “If you’d been in the woods with us that night, Elphias, you’d be dead and we probably would too.”
Neville wondered if meetings usually got so heated or if tonight was a special case. Elphias Dodge looked like he would have jumped out of his chair in anger, if not for his two bad knees.
“Let’s try to keep it civil, Marlene,” Harry said. “If any of you, like Elphias, are wondering why I was given so many missions so soon, I’d ask you to look at the results. Dumbledore was a man who made use of every ally he had, playing to their strengths. He recognized what my strengths were… And now Bellatrix Lestrange and Fenrir Greyback know them as well.”
Harry was different when he talked that way. Neville could see the change in his eyes. It had been the same at Dumbledore’s funeral.
Neville was happy when Harry’s gaze softened again. The professor actually got up, putting his hands on the table, leaning forward.
“I’m grateful that so many of you think highly of me,” Harry said. “I truly am. However, Augusta and I have already come to an agreement. In fact, I was the one who suggested this arrangement. Neville will choose our next leader.”
Neville’s mind raced as he heard that. He’d been sure that this was his Gran’s work. Based on the proud look on her face, she’d clearly had some hand in it. But why had Harry suggested that Neville choose? There was something he was missing.
Gran touched Neville’s shoulder, planting her hand.
“You were special from the moment you were born,” she said, her voice quiet and firm; proud. “This has always been your fate.”
A box, Neville thought reflexively. Those were Professor Potter’s words. That’s what he called words like fate.
Neville looked to his professor, doing it reflexively, the way he would when he had a question about class or Occlumency. He found Harry smiling at him.
Maybe he imagined it, but for a moment, Neville felt like he glimpsed a familiar twinkle. One he hadn’t seen since he had a lemon drop in his mouth.
“The choice is yours,” Harry said.
It was almost redundant, the way he kept repeating that. Choose, choice, chosen— over and over. But Neville couldn’t think about why. There was no time. Everyone was waiting.
When he faced the room, Neville noticed again how there seemed to be two groups. There were those looking at him with expectations, and those who weren’t. The first group included Marlene, Sturgis, Emmeline Vance, Dorcas, and most of all… Gran herself.
Neville could feel their attention like a physical weight, stacking on top of him until he thought he was going to be sent crashing through the floor. It was nothing he wasn’t used to. It was a look he’d seen two rooms over from here when he was nine years old, when an anal French potion master tried to drill a boil-cure into his head.
“Go on,” Gran whispered.
She hadn’t used the word choice a single time. She didn’t think it was one, Neville realized. It was obvious what she was urging him to do.
Step up. Be special. Join the war and face his fate, fighting as the Dark Lord’s equal.
Neville heard Harry’s voice even though the professor hadn’t spoken.
In life, we’re always allowed to make a choice of some kind.
He told that to Neville when they last sat in his office. He knew. The whole time, Harry had been talking about this.
The room was silent. Hermione was visibly shaking, the atmosphere getting to her. Mrs. Weasley looked worried. Sturgis was so excited he looked like he might cry. Everyone was waiting. Gran leaned forward, watching with proud eyes.
But that’s the thing. The grandson she’d always been most proud of wasn’t quite him.
“Harry Potter should lead the Order of the Phoenix.”
With that one line, Neville turned the silence into an explosion of noise.
O-O-O
If you went to the second floor, through the bedroom that once belonged to Neville’s Great-Uncle Jebediah Longbottom, you could pull back the purple curtains and crawl out onto a section of the manor’s uneven roof. It was a very private section of mildly-slanted shingles, their grade shallow enough that you wouldn’t slide off. The view looked over the back lawn and out to the forest beyond. In particular, it had a great view of the sky.
Neville sat with his knees up, his chin resting on them, observing the view. He had his arms around his shins, hugging them to his chest. It would be time to return to Hogwarts soon. The meeting had already ended. Hermione and Ron were with Ron’s parents and his older brother Bill, talking about how school was going. They’d let Neville go off on his own, sensing that he wanted to be alone.
This was Neville’s private place. He’d never been found here, not even by his Gran, so it was his hiding spot when things became too much.
Tonight, even though he’d come here, he was smiling.
Perhaps he’d run away. Certainly, he could see the argument for calling it that. But it didn’t change the fact that he’d done something for himself. It felt good to make a choice.
“Ooh, that’s a tight squeeze!”
Neville’s head whipped back. He soon relaxed. It was just Professor Potter, looking somewhat goofy as he pulled himself through a window that wasn’t much bigger than his body, until he finally managed to get his legs underneath himself.
“How did you find me?” Neville asked.
“I’ve hidden enough times in my life to sniff out a good hiding spot,” Harry said. “How do you feel?”
Even though he’d come here to be alone, Neville didn’t mind this company. “Good,” he said. “Really good.”
Professor Potter looked, if anything, a bit too happy to hear that. He beamed so brightly that Neville might’ve thought his life had somehow been saved.
“I’m glad,” Harry said. “The older I get, the more I find myself agreeing with Mrs. Weasley. Keeping kids out of the war is for the best. It’s not that you can’t help, quite the opposite. It’s just, some things should be left to the adults.”
“What if the adults can’t handle it?” Neville asked.
“Then, of course, it would fall to whoever’s left.”
Harry looked into the distance… nostalgically? That didn’t seem like the right word, Neville just didn’t have a better one. It seemed his teacher was reminiscing on something bittersweet.
“The point is, I don’t plan to fail,” Harry said. “Live your life, Neville. Enjoy the moments you can. Grow up. No prophecy should be able to take that.”
Neville nodded, although inside, he felt a little bit sad. He almost wanted to say out loud, it’s too late for that. He had never just been a kid. It felt like Harry was thinking something similar, but the two of them held back from pointing it out.
“You’re proficient in Occlumency now,” Harry said suddenly. “You’re a bit better than the average Auror. That’s more than enough to say that you’ve learned it.”
Neville was shocked. “So our lessons are done?”
“They’ll change,” Harry said. “Learning is never finished. Especially for a student. Come to my office on Monday.” He put his hand on Neville, looking so deeply into his eyes that Neville almost called on his Occlumency defenses by reflex. “Protecting your mind was only the first step. There’s lots you need to know now.”
“I thought learning Occlumency was to stop my nightmares,” Neville said.
“That’s one benefit,” Harry said. “Learning Occlumency was to keep Voldemort out of your head. Once you’re able to manage that, the goal has always been to share things with you. Things that only I, James, and Dumbledore knew.”
Neville swallowed. “Then… I could really keep You-Know-Who out of my head?”
“Your defenses could give him a challenge,” Harry said. “It’s too much to say that you could keep him out. However, the situation has changed. The things I have to tell you, you need to know. Come Monday, you’ll understand.”
Just as Neville had been feeling unburdened, thanks to the choice he made earlier, his nerves started to make a comeback. Harry saw this and squeezed his shoulder.
“I’m proud of you,” he said. “You did great, Neville. I know making that choice wasn’t easy. I’ll make sure you don’t regret it.”
They heard voices. People in the front garden were shouting Neville’s name. It sounded like Ron and Hermione.
“I’ve got to go,” Neville said.
When he went toward the window, Harry stopped him.
“Want to take a shortcut?” he asked.
A second later, the professor had hurled Neville off the roof with a wave of his wand. A sharp flick arrested Neville’s downward momentum, suspending him in the air so his feet could touch down gently. Harry waved to his slightly stunned student. After about thirty seconds, Neville jogged around the house to get to his friends.
Harry sat on the roof alone for the better part of five minutes. Finally, he came in through the window.
“I see why Neville’s always liked that spot,” he said.
Augusta Longbottom was leaning against the frame of the door. “He thinks I don’t know where he goes,” she said. “Ridiculous. A grandmother always knows.”
To Harry’s eyes, she looked older than usual. Not frail, she was never frail, she just seemed a bit… smaller. Compared to normal, at least.
“I’ve made a bit of a mess of things, haven’t I,” Augusta said.
“It worked out in the end,” Harry said.
“I don’t mean just tonight.”
“Ah,” said Harry.
“I care more about my family than anything in this world, Mr. Potter. There is nothing I would not do for them,” Augusta said. “However, I have at times been forced to reckon with the fact that my judgement is not, always, flawless.”
Harry held back a quip about humility. By Augusta’s gruff standards, she was being vulnerable.
“I struggle to see things from other’s point of view. I can be quite stubborn. At times, when I take the wrong path, that can be troublesome. Albus always managed that side of me.”
“So he did,” Harry said, recalling how the late headmaster sent him into Augusta’s care, to watch over those who’d been moving behind his back.
“I will not promise to be demure, as Augusta Diane Longbottom never has been, and will not be until the day that she finally dies,” Augusta said. “But I will always do my best, for my grandson and for this country, and you can count on that. So manage me, Harry Potter. Follow the path you think is best. I’ll accept no less from a leader.”
Harry patted his chest twice, using an open palm, creating two quick thumps.
“I can give you my word on that,” he said. “I mean to win this war.”
This time, he had no plan to leave it up to kids. It was just like he said to Neville. He trusted them, and at the same time, he had no wish to rely on them.
Some things, after all, were supposed to be the job of adults.