Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Poll

3D printer reviews

  • Review anything else sent your way 44
  • Only review printers that are different/interesting in some way 35
  • I hate 3D printer reviews 0
  • I have no preference 8
  • 2019-01-19
  • multiple choice
  • 87 votes
{'title': '3D printer reviews', 'choices': [{'text': 'Review anything else sent your way', 'votes': 44}, {'text': 'Only review printers that are different/interesting in some way', 'votes': 35}, {'text': 'I hate 3D printer reviews', 'votes': 0}, {'text': 'I have no preference', 'votes': 8}], 'closes_at': None, 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2019, 1, 19, 21, 23, 19, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': True, 'total_votes': 87}

Content

Dear Patrons,

I thought I would share my recent experiences with 3D printer reviews and ask for input on future reviews.

Recently, you've seen reviews for the Ender 5 and JG Aurora A5S.

I currently have a CR-10S Pro under review. Well on pause really, as the LCD is defective. It does print extremely well though, perhaps a Prusa MK3 killer. Not quite as refined and probably needing some simple mods but a huge step up from most of the cheaper printers I've reviewed.

I also have an Artillery X1 Sidewinder under review. This will probably be the next review out, because nothing has broken on it. It's something different, with a range of interesting design features. It moves around stupidly fast, the default travel speed is 250 mm/sec. It's almost like a reduced price CR-10S, better in some ways but worse in others. If you are interested I can do a post with some pics and overview of the features.

I'm also currently meant to be reviewing the Alfawise U30, but after a bunch of extrusion problems it blew a stepper motor driver on the mainboard and another mainboard is on the way. As this is largely just a clone, I haven't enjoyed reviewing it at all.

I'd love some feedback on what you would like me to review in future. I'll always try to review printers that are well publicised and of note, such as the CR-10S Pro, but beyond that, feedback is appreciated. Please vote and leave any other comments below.


Files

Previews only

Comments

Fishysan

Tough decisions Micheal! All is appreciated though! Other areas of interest, deeper calibration methods for any of the printers! How to deal with the tougher ones; dimensional accuracy, ringing, ghosting, etc. What about other printer styles? CoreXY or Delta? Not as many on the channel. How about the possibility of 32bit on the typical 8 bit printers? Is there a point? What can we look forward to? MOAR with your A20M or multi-filament systems? PS: I have an Ender 3 v1 (modded lots now!), and an earlier A20M also. Thankfully I learned so much w the Ender 3, else the A20M would be a bin tosser! But I've been banging at it. Getting there. Thanks and be well on the other side!

Teaching Tech

I am in discusssions with a company over reviewing a corexy with lerdge 32 bit board, as well as a giant k280 delta. These opportunities frequently disappear into thin air, which is frustrating. Definitely more coming on dual extrusion. I have some water solution filament now to try with pla.

Fred Novy

Would be interested in upgrading mainboards. How they r different? Keep up the good work.

Geoffrey Pitman

I find the reviews interesting, as I was in the market for a new printer. I settled on the Geeetech A30, as it's an ender 3 clone with two extruders.

James White

I find the best reviews are for things that break new ground, or price barriers in terms of quality vs cost. Really interested in seeing what 32bit boards can do for us, have spent a lot of time and money modding my ender 3 into something else, makes me wonder why there isnt a budget printer out there with better drivers, 32 bit boards etc. Maybe there is, and maybe you will review it - Thats the value in reviews - opening our eyes to the possible!

Teaching Tech

For the MKS Gen L I'm using, the initial advantage is from the included bootloader and double capacity. The real advtantage comes from the future upgrades. Touch LCD is the next video, soon after that should be upgraded and silent stepper motor drivers.

Mark M.

I'm very new to 3D printing. Just got an Ender 3 in December. All the printers are new to me, so I learn from every video you post. I know many of your experienced viewers are champing at the bit for newest and coolest, but don't forget us newbies - everything is new and cool to us.

JAYTEE

Hey Michael, I reckon you should review anything that you feel comfortable with. If it's an obvious piece of cr@p then avoid. We love your vids and trust whatever you put out there will be worth watching. I love learning. Cheers, JAYTEE

Asger Vestbjerg

I would like to see some 3d printers with Linear rails in your review, that is were I Hope to see the printers go, to have more pricition in The movements of the axises. Thanks for our good job, love IT😀

Brandon Wolfe

I’d really like to see your take and opinion on some of the new more affordable sla/dlp printers. Is the tech at the level for entry level printing or is not still pretty complicated (I know it requires a bit different file prep), and are the lower priced units worth the cost over an fdm with a smaller nozzle? I’ve been eyeing a few, just have to convince the wife the printer will pay for itself :)

Teaching Tech

The delay in my peopoly moai review is really ridiculous now, but I will detail the types of issues I've had that caused the delays, not always the printers fault. There were discussions with Creality and Wanhao about reviewing their latest resin models but they too went cold. It's like they just forget they were ever dealing with me. You really have to be setup for the workflow, I keep mine inside a built wardrobe now to reduce the fumes.

Teaching Tech

Great food for thought, thanks Ian. I have been meaning to write a review policy for a while now. In the meantime I have been firm about not rushing things and giving my honest opinion.

Lord Sarix

You know Angus did an interesting take where he got a unit to review and it was DOA and not just DOA but would never have worked. Instead of doing a review he preformed an autopsy. While I could see a video like that taking ALOT of time it was interesting to listen to him explain all of the design failures that lead to where they were. It's nice for two reasons because it helps serve as a buy beware but at the same time should the manufacture see that it gives them some community feedback on why their machine was garbage.

Teaching Tech

I saw that one and I agree it would make an interesting video. If I'm ever in that position I will probably do it too. Thanks for the suggestion.

Mark Needs

Ender 3 2208 upgrade please, I'm not confident enough to have a crack without one of your videos first :D

Rhynier Myburgh

In researching an upgrade to the MKS Gen-L myself, I came across the Einsy Rambo (the board used in the Prusa i3 MK3). It has the TMC2130 driver chips on the board. What I am wondering is, given the cost of motor dampers, TL smoothers and TMC2xxx driver boards for the Melzi or MKS Gen-L, the $120 for the Einsy Rambo doesn't seem so expensive to get the best drivers for quiet operation and amazing safety features, etc. What is the possibility of a video featuring an upgrade to this?

Rhynier Myburgh

Have you considered other automated manufacturing in the maker space, e.g. CNC machines and laser engraving/cutting? It seems there are many opportunities to explore and show how to build and use these or convert a 3D printer to a laser engraver. Just some random thoughts ...

Teaching Tech

I would definitely consider this, just need the right printer where the mainboard is a complete dud to make the video about.

Teaching Tech

I have two laser cutters and a CNC, hoping to use them more on the channel this year. In my opinion converting a 3D printer to CNC is not the best idea because the frame isn't rigid enough and the debris from machining will quickly get in all of the wrong places. The RClifeon video demonstrated this. Adding a laser cutting head is another story, I would definitely consider doing this in future.

Rhynier Myburgh

That sounds great. And I totally agree about converting a 3D printer to CNC - I was more thinking about also exploring CNC. I have the original ShapeOko with a parallel printer board interface and it is not easy to use and has been gathering dust. However, watching your channel has given me new incentive to upgrade to a Grbl control board and get it up and running again.

David Lockwood

I recently purchased Artillery Sidewinder and was very impressed with the burly build. The thing is a tank! Thanks for the review. Unfortunately the motherboard had a lifespan measured in seconds. I contacted the manufacturer who very nicely walked me through the debugging process. In the end they agreed to send a new MKS Gen L board sans drivers. I have an SKR v1.3 board and some TMC2130 drivers with a wiring loom. Since the boards are a direct replacement mount wise I thought I'd try putting it in the Sidewinder while I awaited the package from China. Your video on the TMC2130 install on an MKS Gen L board in SPI mode is excellent, I thought I'd give it a go. Whoa Nellie, not so fast. The 8 and 32 bit boards are mount compatible but way different in pin out. I went to the BigTreeTech.com website but their diagram left me flummoxed. You mention covering the SKR board in your video. Any chance of doing it sooner rather than later?

Teaching Tech

Hi David, today's video should be what you're after. Just open the config files from Marlin 2.0 and Artillery files side by side and copy over your settings.

David Lockwood

Michael- While I am lacking in typing skills, you certainly have your finger of the pulse of your audience. We seem to be on the cusp of a 32-bit rush. All the help you provide makes it possible for this 73 Y.O. wannabe techie to at least pretend to keep up.

Teaching Tech

Third time lucky! I have been a bit hesitant personally because of the change in what I'm used to but now that I've crossed the line I'm sold.