Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

There has been a lot of discussion in the comments of the reveal post, the poll, and in the discord. A few people have been wanting more information on exactly why the art should be replaced, and why koikatsu won't work going forward, so I will deliver that information here for those that wanted more information.

Koikatsu has extreme limitations. Including but not limited to clothing models not working on certain characters, limiting designs, models and textures preventing me form making characters more unique and identifiable, poses not having good angles, and other limitations that prevent me from making intended designs and scenes for each character. Several ideas I have had for fully corrupted supreme goddess and demon queen have not worked in the tests I have made. With koikatsus, those characters will not be able to stand out too much from other models during their routes. I have reached the limits of what I can make unique in koikatsu, and continuing to use it will not allow me to make the content I intend to, and want to make. From this point on, koikatus models, scenes, and poses will look less and less unique and detailed as I approach the absolute limit of what koikatsu can do. Drawn art also allows me to make more complex scenes of characters interacting with each other outside of sex scenes, greatly opening up what I can do with the characters after their corruption routes end.

There is also a massive issue with koikatsu that could severely impact, or end development. The version of koikatsu I use is several years out of date, and has a few issues when it comes to making character designs, and animations in particular. The main reason I use this version, is that it is the only one with working mods the character models rely on. Upgrading this version of koikatsu to a more recent one to get even a little improvement would break several mod, and therefore models, requiring a redo of the art regardless of how the current poll turns out. This also applies to any issues with my computer. My computer is fine at the moment, and I do not expect to have any issues any time soon, but if it breaks, gets stolen, lost, etc., (anything that would require me to get a new one, or have it reset, really) then I will loose access to all models, and the backups I have will not be compatible with available versions and mods of koikatsu, bringing development to a total halt for months until I can rework the art for the new version of koikatsu, and adjusted models, some of which could look worse if the mods the models rely on no longer exist in existing koikatsu versions.

There are too many limitations and issues with koikatsu for me to be comfortable continuing to use it. If something goes wrong with koikatsu in the future, development in its entirety could end. If something goes wrong with drawn art, it can cause a sight delay before I can regain development progress.

If I loose access to the version of koikatsu I use for one unexpected reason or another, I will need to rework the art regardless, or end development. With koikatsu, I will not be able to make the game I want to make. Replacing koikatsu's art is the best way to ensure development can continue in unforeseen situations, and for me to make Rise of Corruption the game I intend it to be.

I do want to honor the results of the poll, but at this point in development, koikatsu is a detriment to the game's continuation. It is entirely possible that unforeseen circumstances would force me to change the art regardless of the poll results, and V0.4.0 would be the best time to replace the art without it causing problems if something forced a change after V0.4.0.

Depending on additional feedback, development concerns, and potential solutions to koikatsu's problems, the current poll might end early, and the V0.4.0 replacement gone through with regardless to ensure long-term continuation of development. I apologize for any confusion or potential poll votes being disregarded as a result of not making this clear in the initial posts.

Comments

Mythloon

Hey I couldn't help but notice you forgot to mention that you can't add foxgirls with Koikatsu. So for there to be Kitsunes it is necessary for Koikatsu to be replaced.

长谷幸

Hi. Your concerns about Koikatsu is totally fair and I fully respect your attitude to make the game better. However, so far as I can tell, the hand drawing art, again, with no offend, is far from good comparing to what is now in the game. Therefore, though I understand that it means extra work and pressure on you, I sincerely hope that you can find a better replacement.

Emilio

I forgot to ask: What do you think of CUSTOM ORDER MAID 3D2? Could it replace Koikatsu?

Umarius

No. That would have similar limitations, if not more than koikatsu when it comes to making designs for RoC.

Petra

Plus you've been working on the drawing over a year now it would suck for you to have to scrap it all that so hopefully you'll be able to put that to use at some point.

DCPains

I think the one thing id say if the hand drawn art style feels like a different game. Its just a touch to cartoony - anime-y for me. If that could be fixed up I reckon it's a winner. Do think commenter are being a bit over-harsh which is reflected in the polls results

RivalFox

Ultimately, it's your project, and you need to do what's needed for its success. I've played/supported it off and on since it came out, and I've mostly liked the koikatsu models I can understand from your POV on the issue. It's just the drawn art isn't great (not bad), but it doesn't beat the 3d models currently. I'm not an artist, but one critique is that many of the arms from the preview you showed are kinda stumpy, but then normalish in other screenshots. Misaki and Reina's left arm in particular? I support you either way! I'm here for the long haul and love your writing for scenes!

RivalFox

Honestly, I prefer well-drawn art than 3d game shit.

ppwanpao

Think the current art quality isn't the right time to replace Koikatsu. Actually, quite a few people can still accept the Koikatsu style, and they're open to changes, but the prerequisite is that the alternative needs to be of sufficient quality.

ZOD

I support replacement of art, but new art doesn't seem to be better than Koikatu. I'm sorry to say this, this new art is hard for me to accept.

Umarius

There is still time between now and V0.4.0's development for the art to noticeably improve with the right feedback. The main point to keep in mind is that at this point in development, continuing to use koikatsu risks ending or severely delaying development in the future. This is just the best time in development to replace the art before any issues with koikatsu would force a messy and rushed change regardless later on.

Umarius

There could be more improvements with the art, and I will be making those improvements as I get the proper feedback. The biggest point to keep in mind is the one made at the end of the main post. Issues with koikatsu could force a messy/rushed art change later on, if not end development. V0.4.0 is just the best time to make that chance before such a thing could become a problem in the future.

nonomii

Maybe you can try Blender?

Greg Silver

I can't put my finger on exactly what it is I'm not a fan of (mostly in terms of the faces) but... it looks cheap and gives me scammy mobile game vibes. I also think the 3D models fit way better

Fire

understandable about the limitations with koikatsu but at the moment between the 2, koikatsu still is far better even with simpler/not as unique looks with simple and re used animations cause it looks more consistent and doesnt give a weird uncanny valley vibe to me like the new art does. if it was more refined and looked better than the simple koikatsu models id be more open to the possible change. biggest thing for me is unrefined it looks, how unproportioned /consistent they are between scenes and the faces are idk how to really describe other than off. in no offense but it also reminds me of old javascript styled art for h games. i do hope the art improves a lot or find a workaround cause i love this game

Aaicm shao

I’m a player from another country, and I’m not very good at English, so I hope you’ll excuse me if my expression isn’t quite accurate. I came across your work on a small website by chance, gave it a try, and was truly impressed. So I made up my mind to support you without hesitation—even though I didn’t know how to use PayPal, I went ahead and applied for an account just to support you. (It was really troublesome to sign up on the foreign site; it took me a whole week.) I really love your work—your character design and storytelling are top-notch, especially the female lead. I noticed that you’re having some concerns about the game’s art resources. Personally, I’m already very satisfied with the current 3D art style—I really like it. But if you, as the creator, still decide to change the current art resources, I’ll support that too. I’ll always be here to support you in making an even better game. Lastly, I hope to appear in the game’s supporter list. My name is (少林阿哥).