Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

PoP rework ideas

  • Not interested in the simplified version. 14
  • Will very likely prefer the simplified version. 47
  • Interested in the creation of the simplified version, but unsure which to continue yet. 87
  • Just improve/clean up alternate modes like quickruns/standard/simplified. 21
  • Just focus on other projects after PoP in it's current form is finished. 21
  • Only do the time/stamina change. 17
  • Only change stamina (small amount exclusively used for special actions) 3
  • 2025-06-12
  • 210 votes
{'title': 'PoP rework ideas', 'choices': [{'text': 'Not interested in the simplified version.', 'votes': 14}, {'text': 'Will very likely prefer the simplified version.\t', 'votes': 47}, {'text': 'Interested in the creation of the simplified version, but unsure which to continue yet. ', 'votes': 87}, {'text': 'Just improve/clean up alternate modes like quickruns/standard/simplified.', 'votes': 21}, {'text': "Just focus on other projects after PoP in it's current form is finished. ", 'votes': 21}, {'text': 'Only do the time/stamina change.', 'votes': 17}, {'text': 'Only change stamina (small amount exclusively used for special actions)', 'votes': 3}], 'closes_at': None, 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2025, 6, 12, 15, 32, 15, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 210}

Content

Over time, a lot of systems etc. became needlessly complicated, creating a weird state where it's likely too overwhelming for new players and trivial/repetitive for others.I've tried some things with different game modes/modifiers like standard/simplified, but there are more fundamanental issues. Adding further bandaids etc. probably won't solve much, so I'll likely want to do some bigger overhaul eventually to simplify some stuff.

Doing the proposed changes likely won't be too hard/take long, but I don't want to maintain two separate versions with content updates etc.Once done, I'll probably decide which version to continue.

It won't happen yet, but I wanted to gather some opinions on the idea. (Next normal PoP update will likely still take a few weeks)

Temporary plans/differences:

Main gameplay loop:

A big difference is removal of time and stamina.Each day you can quickly arrange your characters in one screen (drag in party/job slots/breeding etc.)Use resources to unlock/improve various slots. Resource aquisition is more important.You then choose an expedition/portal to go on from a smaller selection. Fixed selection for special quests etc.Portals may have step limit until end with some quests or optional objectives to achieve. Can take a few supply items with you with various effects, effectively replacing camping.No revisiting/building in portals? Just explore and find interesting stuff/resources and recruit rare characters.Portals are more mysterious/interesting with less known before you enter.Bring camp supplies to heal, tools to mine, teleporters etc. based on known information.Better rewards/stronger stuff further away from portal.Upon return, the day resolves and a short summary window is shown (jobs/breeding results). Then next day begins. Between expeditions you have a few actions to spend on stuff like arena fights/dates or shows. Skipping expeditions may grant additional town actions next day.

Stats/Characters:

Genes give direct stat increases. (e.g character with 5 base strength and 2 strength genes will have 7)Maybe species/uniques have slightly different gene weights, replacing growth values. 1 strength gene on a centaur may grant +2 str, while it only gives +1 on a plantgirl etc.

Breeding focuses more on gene distribution with cap on total points. (e.g if you want to get max str and hp, you may not be able to increase other stats much) Total gene cap may increase with higher hostility portals.

Level will likely change in some way. It's fixed at maybe max lv 10. Levels won't give stats, but skillpoints to customize them. Each character may have a few small skilltrees you can assign points to. (Linear upgrades with some mutually exclusive choices)Centaurs will only have a centaur skilltree, while pegasus has a centaur and harpy skilltree. Empty slots may contain generic trees of varying rarity like "offensive","fire" etc. Can choose available trees during fusion. With 3 skilltree slots, pure species have space for 2 random ones, hybrids only 1. Uniques have fixed starting skilltrees.Skilltrees affect base stats, unlock passives/skills etc. (Characters can learn more than 4 skills and change between them at home)Or alternatively, levels/exp just don't exist and you purely upgrade through getting better gene caps and traits from later portals.

Likely lower genetic trait count.

Simplify/remove some secondary stats like fertility/virility. Just create one egg/day if paired. Bonuses obtained from traits.

Some small things that are currently based on stamina or time and wouldn't be worth spending a day action will be removed or changed.

Maybe stamina will stay in some form purely for special actions/certain work options. Like just have 3 stamina points that always regenerate 1/day at base. (sex training / summon spirit / crystal production for crystalgirls etc.)

Rework goals:

Less, but more meaningful decisions at a time. less micro-management.Characters should feel more unique with more focus on synergies and special abilities/traits, instead of mainly ending up stacking max stats on everything and giving the best generic skills.Building/customizing existing characters should be more fun.Difficulty more based around adaptability/creativity than knowledge.Shorter runs that feel a lot more varied based on the characters/traits you get.Clearer direction at all points, especially beginning.Easier balancing and difficulty scaling.

Consequences: (when doing the changes)

Lower potential for building overpowered characters.Less micro-managing could also be bad.Portals are likely single use, with some exceptions. Building in portals likely won't be expanded on. (wouldn't be worth it spending an expedition/day to revisit)Base stats will need to be a bit higher to make changes in growth/genes/items more nuanced. (like 50 hp and 10 str for average lv 1 character)

What are your impressions?

Comments

Aarongeddon

I'd like to see stamina kept but reworked, currently it can be really punishing. Personally I really like how indepth and complicated the game can be, but I know that makes it hard to pick up.

King Ducky

Stamina is a quite complicated system that most of the time is not crazy important, except for the main character. Replacing it with a simpler system may be a very good idea.

King Ducky

With regard to the reworking of how genes and levels work, i am not sure. When you do it the way you propose, I expect it will radically alter game balance. I would be glad to give it a try, but expect that you will spend significant time tweaking these new systems afterwards.

Tama

I'm not exactly sure how I'll feel about the proposed changes unless I can put my mitts on it and fiddle around. I don't think there is an inherent problem with a time/stamina system as plenty of other games have it, there are just so few ways to recoup stamina with so many different uses for it in the early game and so few uses for it late game. As for the skilltree changes, I can see your vision and I am prepared to keep an open mind, but I'm also bias towards the current implementation that lets me turn my favorite units into exactly what I want them to be. Personally, a better method to mark and separate specific units special to me (like a bank/box) or some kind of toggle to remove them from the lists for fusion and brothel. Additionally, it would be nice to be able to nurture the uniques in some way to improve their base stats to the same magnitude we can improve bred hybrids. All that being said, perhaps a class/job system to give us class-specific stat growth and skills with racial bonuses and racial specific skill could be an avenue to explore? At the end of the day, I enjoy PoP because it's a passion project of yours, so I'm willing to support anything you're passionate about as I always have for almost a decade now. Good luck Syv!

Ragoz

Been playing the game years, its something I pickup now and then on patches to have a look, but I've never managed to complete the game. I think toning down or removing systems that don't feel impactful might be a good move as a lot of the time I feel like there is too much micro-management. I like the idea of gathering your party a doing a single time portal. Ive never engaged with building in the portals.

Phoenix

I love the complexity of the game and would likely lose interest and stop playing if it gets over-simplified with the proposed changes. I recognize that im in the minority here and will be sad to see the end of the game as I know it :( I'll still try the changes, but none of the proposed changes appeal to me, I crave the micromanagement and persistence the game has now

Xagrall

By the middle of the game I always feel like my attention is being more and more scattered by the overwhelming number of mechanics. It's not that I don't like them, there are just too many of them. And with each turn I realize that I'm missing more and more moments.

PoshOctavia

for me i like that this game is actually indepth enough that i never run out of things to do, every time i pick it up again theres some new system to discover or build i can make, its alot more similar to much larger more indepth rpgs in that sense. i think the fact its a bit scattershot with mechanics is a bit overwhelming, but its also part of what makes it unique, the fact its a game that actually does have so many interesting little nibblets to it. one of my favorite parts is being able to go into portals and potentially build things in them, i would actually love if that was expanded a bit. being able to stabilize and secure portals is one thing that makes this game very unique, it gives them a sense of place that a random dungeon runner just doesnt have. i think it does need changes, but i think simplifying it down isnt the right direction, i think that now that you can see all the systems it has rather than them being added in over time, its a good time for a reworking to make things flow into eachother more.

Brandon Lincoln

I love the idea of making the skill-trees for the individual characters based on species and even the stat changes with genes. Doing both of those alone would make characters feel more unique especially if a little limited on how many skill-points you can get. You can even make some skills that work better in a group or if that were a lone wolf or maybe if they're the only harpy or the only mermaid kind of thing. however I'm not sure with the time/and stamina rework, something does need to be done in that area maybe more ways to recoup or better ways? I Quite like the time mechanic myself i don't think that pulls away a new player i don't think most will realize until they run out of stamina and that's where it slows down. The MC has 200 to start but sleeping only recovers 50 that's only a quarter not counting Mya milk of course, but the change i would suggest is maybe make the starting stamina closer to 100 and adjust stamina cost values for all activities. that or increase how much you can recover by a little bit I think allowing for overpowered characters is what makes a game that has a breeder mechanic or even create your own mechanic so much fun. If anything as an idea portal hostility has a gene level cap with higher having more variety or even multiple high totals but you need a strong team with either equipment or good skills. maybe with the portals instead of time based on the inside it always cost for an example 3 hours to go in (maybe more for balance purposes) and 30 stamina? halved for your first expedition in a day and you have a limited set of steps but other than that its the same allowing you to explore fight and build but not worrying about being in there too long. Maybe with some buildings can help complete exploration goals or fighting goals. As for new player integration maybe a forced but slow introduction to the beginning is needed. Maybe forcing oriel for first launch? I am honestly not sure with this one. But hey if you do read through all my word vomit know this at the end I love the games you made so far and hope you continue to thrive and enjoy making them. All these ideas i gave are just suggestions in mind to help simplify. Don't forget to enjoy the changes yourself, its never a bad thing to lean into your style of game

Syvaron

Thanks. You can change uniques through fusion. They stay unique if the resulting species is the same. The quick manage window let's you drag units into the symbol to mark them and basically use them as boxes (by default it just shows all boxes). You can also drag them from there to fuse/brothel while seeing all marks and having access to filter. The whole quick manage window is a bit unintuitive though and I'll likely improve filters etc. The skilltree thing is probably the least finished idea. I mainly just thought levels don't really add much to the game if all it does is slightly delay some power increase for a unit you'll likely replace soon anyway.

Syvaron

Skilltrees would act as additional customization in a simple way (replacing stat gains on level). Maybe the "Fire" tree has mostly some magic and mana stat increases and you can choose between Fireball skill or burn on attack etc. If a character gets like 10 points to spent and has 2-3 skilltrees with about 7 nodes each, you can choose to max one and take a few points in another.

Syvaron

Current stamina is a bit weird and unintuitive. Increasing recovery amount would actually slow down the game a lot as it reduces the main way time passes. Might just feel weird/like a waste of time clicking sleep multiple times in a row, but in real time it's instant. Passing days faster is probably good as it causes more interesting stuff to happen than lasting longer on one day. Portals used to work similarly (initial stamina cost and time limit before you had to return). Could be interesting to consider an initial time cost as well to get fixed amount of steps/turns and just force teleport once they run out. (get refunded half entry gold cost if you returned naturally) Where it's just 1 step per tile or combat round, 2/3 for difficult terrain. And just have a new type of single use normal portal that is more rewarding.

Brandon Lincoln

That makes a lot of sense actually. I cant wait to see what you do!

Olaroll

Maybe this is a bit of an unorthodox suggestion, but have you ever considered implementing some basic analytics to the game? It'd be a great way to find out what mechanics players actually engage with. Should give a lot insight for making changes like these.

Jacob Wick

First off, feel free to make the game you want to make. I'm interested in streamlining the time/stamina to actions per day, but I would be a little sad to lose the ability to breed a completely overpowered team with maxed stats. I would be willing to except having to work to unlock those maxed stats. The two mechanics I'm least happy with are sex training and the brothel. Sex training seems really time consuming for slow progress and the brothel isn't very rewarding and also not sexy. Have you ever considered combining them, so that characters in the brothel can focus on certain actions to gain skill?

Scathach

I feel that it's important to keep in mind that if you simply things too much it could leave players feeling like they have less freedom to play the ways they want to. I'm someone who likes to take my time with things getting characters as strong as I can get them and just to unlock everything. I play games to relax and I'm not a fan of feeling rushed, so I always play on Freeplay mode. That being said, I do think the days could be streamlined a bit, particularly in the way the town works. I actually like to visit portals multiple times, especially if I find a rare biome. I also like to play as Corruption and one of my favorite things to do is corrupt portals, and I'd like to be able to do more with the corrupted areas. like being able to make more advanced tentacle structures and stuff like that. I also like the exploration aspect of it, and making them single use would remove that to some degree. I don't know how I feel about time/step limits. I do like the idea of having to pay attention to resources in portals. I'm probably weird in this regard, but I kind of like how a portal can mess you up if your not properly prepared for it or if you stay on an expedition longer than you should. It makes me feel like I'm going into uncharted territory and I need to be thoughtful of what whether or not I'm willing to take the risk. That's an aspect of the game I personally feel is really special and unique. I rely like the idea of characters having their own skill trees, and being more customizable. I love making even my starter characters as strong as I can get them, and anything that allows me to do more of that just makes it better in my book. That being said, a part of the fun of these kinds of games is making overpowered characters. i would say do what you can to make the game better, but make sure players are still free to play the way they want to.

RavingMado

I try to do a full run each update to keep up with my soft '100%' file but I think the most interesting changes here for me would be Stamina and Time. I'm definitely on the side of over optimization/limitless potential for the most part just because it's fun to try and find what you can and can't force or different ways to ramp up faster, etc etc. I tend to exclusively play on unlimited with hostility/rival power ramping fast though, so to each their own in that regard.

Anbcdeptrai

As someone who design and manage game / app development for a living my only advice for you is "If it ain't broke don't fix it" Sometimes a feature or function might appear as complicated or unneeded but if it doesn't interfere with the player's experience then its not worth the time and effort to remove / reworked it. You should implement some event tracking into your app to determine 1. What the players ain't bother using and 2. What is broken and not working as intended. After you gather some data from real players, as well as survey some detailed feedback from them - only then decide on what to rework and when to do them.

Tama

never tried fusing uniques actually lol... good to know. I suppose that's entirely viable now too for most/all uniques given we can breed for human impure hybrids now too!

Scott Snelling

Absolutely the #1 thing that has kept me from getting more into PoP is the "too many things to do" going on. First, obviously, you have the fact that there are a TON of different things you can focus on, on a macro scale. Breeding, adventuring, dating, farming, etc. And they all share some/all of the resources you spend to do them with others (mainly energy). So if you do A, you can't do as much of B/C/D/E/F. So if you don't *know* which is best to do, you're hurting yourself. But in addition to that, on a per-day situation in-game, there's often stuff to try to remember. Like checking on eggs, or exploring certain areas for event triggers. And with so many things possible, it's very easy to see something get forgotten. So the idea of a streamlined "main" screen where you assign creatures various roles, but all from the same screen, sounds really good. So you're assigning characters to the brothel, farm, adventuring party, etc all at once. Keep the variety, but present it in a way that's more accessible & understandable to a new player - and importantly, one where the tradeoff is obvious. Other specific parts of the game are also very complicated for the return you get. Farm breeding assignments take a lot of time to look through, assign, and get running, but then you can leave them in place as long as you want (unless you use one of them for something else). And all those depth factors to it make it interesting - but it feels like it is so complex that it takes away from other parts of the game. All suggested changes 100% sound like a game I'd enjoy more than the current one.

Cyrilion

I personally enjoy the game more in it's complex form, there's so many hit it and quit it games, and i like to have a system i can dig my teeth into. I will say however that there is a lot of confusion among new players, and it could be scaring people off, so if you want to reach a broader audience then i suspect simplifying will help here. Personally my favourite things in the game are the storyline, lore, new character events, dating events, the town events, the equipment system, the crafting system, the breeding system, dating system(though i have issues with it), the brothel, and theory crafting runs. The main downside in all this other than confusing new players is that some of the systems are very shallow, i would love if we could build actual settlements inside portals and expand outwards, but that could be a whole game by itself, i don't think it adds much to PoP, so if i was cutting i'd start there. Stamina management is something i don't mind, but changing it to an actions taken per day changes little for me. Removing time definitely would make doing challenge runs less fun imo, we do already have freeplay after all. Im interested to see how resource acquisition upgrading my slots will work. Making all portals single use definitely makes sense outside of Creation, but i'm sure they'll be changed to reflect the lack of hives. All together i'd say im intrigued at the idea but i think i'll prefer the current game. My issue with dating is entirely in the card system, i end up quick saving and quick loading to get a workable deck, so i *never* make more than one deck, mainly my issue is if i toss out an option i lose the entire level gain for nothing, i have rolled 15+ times in a row to get nothing, making decks feels bad and takes forever, i'd rather just buy moves and upgrades, or get a free minor boost to a card if i decline all options. TL:DR i like complex games more, but i'm gonna support you no matter what because i'm down to see what games you're cooking up.

The Overlord

I've always thought the Time / Stamina system in PoP worked in weird ways, especially with how you cold go into a portal at 8 AM, come back at 10PM, set some jobs for everyone and get the results as if they worked the whole day at that. So I'm definitely on par with the Time / Stamina rework. I wasn't too sure about the Character / Stats rework at first, but I'm totally behind the "characters should feel more unique" statement you put in the goals, so if you think reworking the stats will achieve that then I'd say go for it too!

Satrnsnightmare

I am sure at this point I'm echoing sentiments, but I think with a few couple hundred hours into the game I wanted to chime in. I really love the micro managing part of the game, especially in the portals because it's a very entertaining combat sim. Truly I sometimes wish there was a more "appropriate" version to play on the team or something. All that aside, I like the new ideas! I think there is merit here for a new system, though I think allowing one to return to a portal over a few days is a better move, in case of special environment portals like heaven, or situations where a party wipe leaves you in shambles if you can't recover your stuff. I genuinely avoid artifact portals if it's not unique items, because losing my team and/or gear can be a monumental loss

Satrnsnightmare

I think the stamina system is fine if you remove a time system, since it's now a limiting factor for portals that makes resting worth it for more than just healing. The morale system has always confused me, since it just felt like a second, more crippling stamina system.

Satrnsnightmare

All things considered though, you've made a wonderful game that many of us enjoyed, so I'm sure whatever choices you make will be enjoyable!

Olou

Only a few notes : One i did rather like the feel of deciding the stabilize a portal to effectively colonize it, a rather unique thing in any game waiting making sure to clean out corruption on it ect. the only frustration was having to go in and collect the yields manually (And sometimes not even be able to carry it all out) but i will admit it did feel rather silly having my waterworld crystal farm to make what is supposed to be the most valuable resource become pretty mundane. Two I enjoyed that time was important to the game and deciding on trying to explore particularly dangerous portals needed to be met with proper preparation or caution to avoid it becoming a massive time sink. I do think some form of camping would be nice to keep but limit it to an item ala "tent" if you do intend to remove time as a factor. Stamina on this hand is fine IMO to change drastically as it never did much for me other than cause mild frustration on expeditions. Last for now I support some changes to genetics and leveling as it can be a bit obtuse to understand, and changing genes into leveling trees seems like an interesting idea. Worth noting i suppose that I normally play long or unlimited games for my frame of refrence.

Erotica Fanatic

I agree, I'd rather have the stamina system than the time system because they're functionally the same thing; systems that restrict the amount of actions you can take per day, and I for one would prefer to be limited to actions per character than actions per 'day.'

Erotica Fanatic

I agree with basically all of that. Though I will say there are systems I never use and/or didn't even know were there, like camping/camping related skills. I haven't played in a while so that's the only one that springs to mind.

Eebie Abby Obie

Personally, I've rather enjoyed this game specifically for its complexity and different systems and options to explore. Let's face it, there's already a ton of simplified adult games out there with very little depth. Outside of the gorgeous art and world building, the primary reason I took such an interest in this game in the first place was because of it's weird and complex mechanics. While I love your art, I probably wouldn't have given this a second look if it weren't for the fact it reminded me so much of X-Com. It would be a real shame to see some of my favorite things streamlined out of the whole experience in exchange for a "less is more" approach. Please forgive me if this seems blunt, but I feel like honesty is key when gauging interest in things with your audience.

Hichten

As someone who has only recently discovered the game, starting out it is *very* overwhelming, even in tutorial mode - so having a somewhat more streamlined experience might help greatly. On the other hand, the complexity is a lot of the charme of the game too. It's hard to say if boiling the game down will make it better, just different or worse. If you are offering to try it out I'd say go for it.

Sinbath Last

Do adjustments so your work would be easier

Andrew Amell

Honestly there are only a couple of things that id say could use an overhaul. One thing I would really comment on is that a reduction in micromanagement (but maybe not complexity) would be appreciated for the breeding and Jobs Systems. Replacing Stamina with action points or just like a time budget for activities for the day would be nice so you could introduce a better feeling of going from day to day. Portal Expeditons are really cool and tbh the stabilizing and colonizing with building in portals is cool. The biggest downside i would say exists for it is that you have to reenter to collects resources. Maybe keep the colonizing but make it a passive resource or a Job slot like say investing in X portal to be stabilized as a Y resource portal if Z type of Character works it. I don't think a step limit as like a portal life span would be good, but I would say something like requiring camping in portal for day progression would be good. Like introducing a hard day's end time to the system rather than being able to go into the morning. Maybe if an AP system is introduced you could make it so that per day you can expend another AP to gain more explore time for that day. An additional game mode i would appreciate would be a Special mode like free roam but where progression is just entirely focused on Story Quest Portals rather than how it is with Day limits or Free Plays Level up. Just be cool as an option that allow someone to go through ALL the story content on one run, without the potentially massive time sink that Freeplay can become. Maybe just make it a mode limited to the Majors rather than all Minor Chars. Overall I dont think PoP needs much of an overhaul but things that would reduce specifically micromanagement for like Jobs and breeding would be cool just to cut down on the menu time part of management.

Lastear

You know, with the level of change you're considering, I think you should just make Portals of Phereon 2. Most people interested in the first game have already either dropped it or adapted to the diffulty. A PoP 2 release would be fresher and give you more room to play with the new mechanics without breaking anything

monster encyclophedia

I think the simplified version is another challenge because I've almost adapted to the system of this game, thanks to my experience playing this game from the first moment I started in 2022. So it doesn't mean "I don't want you to change" or anything. I accept those challenges every update, so it's just like always having happy concerns. The vast content of this game (which actually includes long, repetitive things like you said) is a fun expression part of this game along with the art style of this game, but I think there are parts that need to be changed and parts that don't. Time and fitness limits were a tricky challenge. Having to properly mix relaxation and challenge because of the constant flow of time in order to do something wasn't really fresh at first, but it was a necessary act, and the process wasn't very enjoyable. Instead, it gave me a sense of immersion. However, time, on the other hand, was the most difficult variable when prepared. Because events are set at a specific time, and if they are not observed, they are often missed, so many times they were careless and blew them away. This is an uncomfortable system in a way, and I think it's a good part if it can be improved further. If you change it to the daily adventure limit or the number of activities, it would be much more pleasant and better to plan ahead. In addition to that, I also like the gene part. In fact, breeding-related genes started to be less needed to concentrate on combat. But what I don't want to change is the part called "challenging potential." The beauty of mating systems is that they end up producing the most powerful characters. The lower the potential, the less reason you have to crossbreed. It's easier to just recruit. In conclusion, I want a change to happen, but I don't want it to be in the direction of lowering the potential. The first thing I want you to think about is that I want your work to be improved so that it doesn't become too difficult.