Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Turns out to be the sort of month where I post very little, but all of it is quite long. The epilogue to LWIA v2 currently stands at 38,000 words. On the one hand, the end now feels in sight; on the other, there's probably an entire Draugr Castle's worth of words between me and it.

At least the next section shouldn't be too long.

----

Another triptych of short stories followed A Game of You, this one under the banner “Convergence” and linked by the motif of storytelling, with all of them featuring a story within a story. By and large these mark a diminishing return for the format, which Gaiman would not straightforwardly repeat again in the back half of the comic. The first of these was “The Hunt,” a charming but deeply inconsequential story about werewolves narrated by an old man to his granddaughter with a cute but obvious reveal that the grandfather is the protagonist of his story. The other two, however would have interesting ramifications in spite of their relative slenderness. First was “Soft Places” in Sandman #39, which saw Marco Polo lost in the desert and straying into the borderlands of Dream—a concept that would be picked up thirty-five issues later in the comic’s penultimate issue. 

The final story, “The Parliament of Rooks” returned to Lyta Hall and her son Daniel, who the story follows into the Dreaming where he’s told stories by Cain, Abel, and Eve. This constitutes a sly joke about DC Comics history, as the trio had all hosted horror anthologies in the 1970s. (Eve, in fact, hosted two, beginning with Secrets of Sinister House, and then taking over Weird Mystery Tales from Destiny.) The actual stories told are largely trifles, as you’d expect from being three or four pagers in the midst of another story—the main point of the exercise is plainly to refresh the reader’s memory of Daniel. But Jill Thompson, on pencils in another iteration of having the incoming artist do the last of the one-offs, ended up dramatically elevating one. 

This was the final tale, offered by Abel, about how he and Cain came to be in Morpheus’s employ. Gaiman’s concept for this story was to be a riff on Sheldon Mayer’s humor series Sugar and Spike, which ran from 1956 to 1971 and featured the eponymous pair of toddlers, with Dream and Death being reimagined in this style (much to Cain’s outrage). Thompson, looking at Gaiman’s instruction to make them “really cute,” meditated upon her Hello Kitty alarm clock on the grounds that “it’s the cutest thing on the planet,” and concluded that “it has a huge head with big eyes, but its face is all the way down in the lower third of its head. I then realized that kittens and puppies, and human babies, all have their faces smashed don towards the bottom of their heads; and their faces grow up into their heads as they get older. So I made Dream and Death look like little Japanese manga figures, with enormous heads and large eyes, but tiny noses and mouths.” The result was, in fact, alarmingly cute, and immediately became a favorite request for convention sketches from Thompson. Indeed, she would go on to write and illustrate The Little Endless Storybook in 2001 and Delerium’s Party in 2011, a pair of picture book-style stories of the little scamps, as well as Death: At Death’s Door in 2003, which leaned into the manga influences more fully to do a suitably zany retelling of Season of Mists from Death’s perspective. 

The nature of these spinoff books, however, is a more complex issue than it might seem. For all that Gaiman had successfully positioned himself as the auteur star of Sandman, the fact of the matter was that it was a DC Universe book written under a work for hire contract. Gaiman was in no danger of being sacked from the book, but if DC had wanted to fire him and replace him with a new writer he’d have had no actual recourse either. Similarly, he had no control over future use of the characters—DC could choose to exploit them any way they wanted. If they’d wanted to continue Sandman ad infinitum and flank it with a host of secondary titles they could have. In practice, however, this was not what happened. 

Gaiman started pushing on the subject of what would happen when he left all the way back during Season of Mists, telling Karen Berger “‘I think I’m going to want Sandman to stop when I stop.’ And she said, ‘You know that will never happen,’ and so on.” A similar conversation followed a few months later with Jeanette Kahn. Gaiman shrugged it off and, as he tells it, “I just carry on with my grand plan, and everything keeps going.” In practice this meant that, when asked in interviews, he would give an answer to the effect of “DC will stop Sandman when I’m done, which I would really like, or they’ll carry on, and I don’t really have any control of it. Although, obviously, if they did carry it on, I would not do any further work ever for DC. If they stop it when I stop it, I will maintain a very cheerful business relationship with DC.” And in 1994, as Gaiman entered the home stretch of his run, Berger finally conceded the point and agreed to bring the series to an end.

The exact mechanics of this negotiation remain private, but several factors can be inferred. For one, this was around the same time that Alan Moore, after splitting from DC over, in part, creators’ rights, had landed at Image Comics, where Gaiman had already done some work. Avoiding an outcome where Gaiman gave his next big series to a competitor was an obvious priority. For another, Gaiman made sure that the carrot part of his carrot and stick act was actually substantive. He did not, for instance, attempt to insist that DC leave all of the Sandman characters alone forevermore—he simply demanded that Sandman itself be retired as a title, ensuring that he remained the sole auteur on it. In fact, just three weeks after the end of Sandman DC would launch The Dreaming, a continuation of the story that plainly served as what DC would otherwise have published as Sandman #76, complete with Dave McKean covers. Gaiman was credited on the comic as a “consultant”—a credit he also took on The Little Endless Storybook—and while it was obviously a sinecure, it also served to emphasize Gaiman’s consent for the arrangement. 

Crucially, Gaiman began modeling this approach well before he departed the book. In January 1993 DC launched a new imprint, headed by Karen Berger, called Vertigo. The point of this line, as explained by Berger in the promotional Vertigo Preview, was an act of self-definition. “Most of you already know,” she writes in the introduction, “that DC currently publishes six monthly titles that aren’t quite like any others in the industry: Sandman, Hellblazer, Doom Patrol, Animal Man, Swamp Thing, and Shade the Changing Man. But, despite producing comics that are challenging, disturbing, and creatively singular, we’ve been an ill-defined lot. We’ve been called horror, mature, sophisticated, dark fantasy, cutting-edge and just plain weird. Tired of tired misnomers, and not even having a collective name, we decided to define ourselves.” The common elements in these six titles were clear enough. For all that they’d been nicknamed the “Berger books,” Berger in fact had nothing to do with Doom Patrol and had by 1993 departed from Hellblazer, Animal Man, and Swamp Thing as well. What united the books was instead the fact that they were all primarily associated with, and in most cases currently written by writers hired out of the British market. 

But a glance at Vertigo Preview makes it clear that the line was centered on Gaiman, with Sandman as its flagship. Sure, three of the books were ones that Morrison was heavily associated with—Animal Man, Kid Eternity, and Doom Patrol. But they were in the midst of a sabbatical from the industry, and their only new contribution was a miniseries called Sebastian O, which was an existing project acquired from a failed Disney imprint. And so the cover of Vertigo Preview, in addition to a piece of Duncan Fegredo’s art from Enigma, focused almost entirely on Gaiman, with images of both Dream and Death alongside one of the old Wesley Dodds gas mask version of Sandman, who would be anchoring a new book titled Sandman Mystery Theatre. Gaiman was uninvolved in this, as well as with the new Black Orchid series that Dick Foreman was writing, with Jill Thompson strategically placed on art for the first six issues, but both were clearly in his orbit. 

The bulk of Vertigo Preview constituted two page previews of the various launch titles. But its headlining attraction was a seven page Sandman story entitled “Fear of Falling” with art from Kent Williams. This was wholly disposable—a depressed theater director dreams of climbing a mountain, meeting Dream and Matthew, where they discourse about his fear of heights before he wakes up, newly resolved not to abandon the play he was working on. But it speaks volumes that Gaiman was willing to pen a short piece purely to allude to the brand name, just as it speaks volumes that Gaiman spent the end of February doing a bicoastal signing tour to promote the launch. As an advertisement for what keeping Gaiman on board and happy to be a good corporate citizen could bring, it was a compelling one.

Gaiman’s most substantial contribution to helping DC and Berger get Vertigo off the ground, however, could be found at the other end of Vertigo Previews, where he kicked off festivities with a two page excerpt of Death: The High Cost of Living, which released on January 12th as the first Vertigo book to hit shelves. This was, obviously, a marquee title, and had been a long time coming, dating back to the summer of 1991 when DC ran a fan poll for the convention season about what supporting character should get their own miniseries. Gaiman had been discussing the possibility of doing a Death one, and with the poll imminent Karen Berger called him about the possibility of including her in the poll, noting that “The thing is, if we put Death on, she’ll win. So basically, do you want to do the series now?” Gaiman decided that this would be “a nice excuse to actually get me to turn the story froma  nice idea and something I wanted to do one day, into something I was definitely going to do.” As predicted, she won.

In many ways, the comic takes full advantage of that level of demand. The series concerns the idea, first raised back in Sandman #21, that Death spends a day of each century being mortal, charting the course of her day living as an ordinary person in New York named Didi. But the actual plot is astonishingly threadbare. The villain—an immortal who calls himself the Eremite and seeks to force Death to kill him—doesn’t even appear until the second issue, and never really gets an explanation, though Gaiman has suggested in interviews that he’s “somebody I first wrote about in Books of Magic,” suggesting he’s probably Mr. E after returning from the end of time. More to the point, there’s not really a proper resolution to him; he just sort of fails and the story ends. There are some other threads that run through the entire arc, most obviously Mad Hettie, an immortal homeless woman who first cropped up back in issue #3, who implores Death to find her missing heart. But it’s emphatically not a comic that is primarily concerned with plot. In an interview while the book was in progress he was asked what Death does in her day as a mortal, and answered “Well, so far she’s eaten an apple, she’s eaten a hot dog, she’s gone for a ride in a taxi, she’s gone off to listen to music…” and the truth is that this is an entirely accurate summary of the first half of the comic.

But Death largely lends herself to this. She is, at baseline, the manic pixie dream girl, with her primary character trait being that she’s relentlessly, comprehensively charming. Much of how her debut worked so well was simply because she provided a startlingly fun contrast to the endlessly brooding Morpheus. And The High Cost of Living largely repeats that trick by pairing Death with Sexton Furnival, a teenager who’s introduced via two pages spent writing the world’s most pathetically unsympathetic suicide note, in which he declares that life is, in his estimation, pointless, and he should know because “I’m mature. I know my own mind. I’m sixteen—almost sixteen and a half,” and besides, “I don’t have anyone I’m in love with. To be honest, I think love is complete bullshit. I don’t think anybody ever loves anyone. I think the best people ever get is horny: horny and scared, so when they find someone who makes them horny, and they get too scared of the world outside, they stay together and call it love.” Gaiman suggests that this gives the comic a “Catcher in the Rye-ish kind of feel,” which is true both in its kind of meandering plot and in his comparison of Sexton to Holden Caulfield, where he notes that “in some ways he’s the hero, and in other ways you just want to slap him round the face and stand him in a corner until he cheers up.”

Obviously spending a day with Death proves enough to accomplish this, but even that’s not really the point of the comic. There’s no big, moving speech about wanting to live; he just ends the comic musing that “It would be really neat if Death was somebody, and not just nothing, or pain, or blackness. And it would be really good if Death could be somebody like Didi. Somebody funny, and friendly, and nice. And maybe just a tiny bit cray. And I wish I could see her again. I wish she wasn’t dead. But if it means dying first… well… I suppose I can wait. For a while.” The point is by and large the journey—the time spent bantering about Disney movies (Sexton thinks that “Beauty and the Beast was a better movie, but I like the songs in Little Mermaid more,” while Death “liked The Little Mermaid more. I mean, even though they’d given it a happy ending”) or eating bagels (“I love food. Food is so great. I mean, it’s so much more fun than photosynthesis or having a power pack in your back or bathing in liquid crystals, or any of those things”) or having Death mend his jeans (“I left the holes in at the knees. I figured you wanted them”). It’s not that the comic is devoid of substance—a sequence after the Eremite captures Death and Sexton and they care for his grievously injured henchman until he dies is satisfyingly chilling. (“Hey,” Sexton muses, “if you were like, really the spirit fo death shouldn’t you have been here for him when he died?” “I was here,” Death cooly replies. “Oh yeah. I’ve… never seen a dead body before,” a chastened Sexton admits. “I have.”) But it is by and large a slice of life comic, or perhaps a slice of Death one.

That it works is a testament to just how good a creation Death is. But what’s perhaps most remarkable about it is simply that it shows Gaiman flipping into the overtly populist mode he had previously resisted. It’s worth comparing to A Game of You, not least as a sizeable chunk of the second issue concerns Death and Sexton attending Foxglove’s first attempt at playing a concert (she sings songs about both Judy and Wanda, noting that both are dead. “Maybe it’s contagious.”). There Gaiman pointedly, aggressively withheld audience pleasures, forcing the reader to spend time with characters they didn’t know and were likely to find offputting. And this sort of confrontational approach with readers had been a fairly routine element of his style up to this point, starting from “24 Hours” and continuing with his decision to use The Doll’s House to train readers away from standard expectations for the comic. Up to this point Gaiman has been ambitious, in the way that conquering the world requires. But The High Cost of Living sees him cashing the check, so to speak—writing a work that rests on that reputation instead of building it. 

And yet for all that it’s a somewhat lightweight bit of fanservice, it’s also clear that The High Cost of Living was a project Gaiman cared deeply about. He spent the whole of the 00s trying to get a film version made, working on a first draft of the script in 2001. This isn’t entirely surprising, especially given the degree to which Gaiman’s late career focused almost exclusively on film adaptations of his older work, but what’s striking about The High Cost of Living is that not only did Gaiman write the script, he intended to direct it himself, going so far as to shadow Guillermo del Toro on the set of Hellboy 2 and to make A Short Film About John Bolton in 2003 as preparation for the task. The film languished in development hell, and seems to have had a final nail go into its coffin somewhere around 2010, but the fact that Gaiman was inclined to go to such lengths speaks volumes.

Of course, there is another interpretation of Gaiman’s desire to direct the film himself. When asked about his desire to do so, his typical explanation is something like “for me, the tone of voice was the most important thing about the movie. I didn’t want someone to make a bad Death movie anymore than I want anybody to make a bad Sandman movie.” There’s a savvy respect for quality control there—and Gaiman did, in point of fact, work to block several Sandman movies over the years. But there’s also a clear continuation of his policy of not overusing Death. Gaiman always understood the importance of not killing the golden goose, and it’s unsurprising to see him being extra protective of his signature character. 

Gaiman’s populism was also on display in Sandman, which was in the latter portions of a ten issue arc entitled Brief Lives when the Vertigo switch happened. This arc had, in fact, been a key aspect of his thinking around Game of You. Part of why he’d been willing to test the readers’ patience there was because he “expected everyone to like the next major storyline, Brief Lives; and everyone did.” Indeed, it’s the only arc to in any way trouble Season of Mists’ claim to be the iconic and definitive arc. Some of this is down to the fact that it offers similar pleasures. Once again the larger lore of Sandman is being explored in depth. All seven of the Endless appear, including Destruction, with the arc’s main plot concerning an effort to find him. And loads of other side characters make reappearances—Bast, the Corinthian, and Orpheus all make appearances, with the latter’s arc reaching its conclusion. It’s also an arc that is absolutely crucial to setting up the series’ eventual ending—Gaiman flags Brief Lives as the point past which “the course of the rest of the series is set in stone.” 

None of these, however, are the core engine of why Brief Lives succeeds. That comes down almost entirely to Gaiman employing the same basic trick that animates The High Cost of Living, namely having a scene-stealing audience favorite of a character marauding around the story. This, of course, requires him to get lightning to strike twice, creating a second character on the same order of magnitude as Death. Or, rather, to elevate an existing one as Delirium, the youngest of the Endless, finally takes center stage. This is one of Gaiman’s most successful executions of the long game. By the time Brief Lives starts in Sandman #41 it had been twenty issues and nearly two years since her debut in the prelude to Season of Mists. In that time she made only two brief appearances—a three page scene in “Three Septembers and a January,” and a single line in the Sandman Special. She was not an ostentatious mystery akin to Destruction, although she had the intriguing detail that she used to be Delight, but she was certainly a compelling one—Gaiman uses her as a sort of cracked mirror Greek chorus for the scene in which the Endless meet, letting her insert oddball comments about how “I lost some time once. It’s always in the last place you look for it.” 

Aiding her memorability were her dialogue balloons, which, like virtually all of the lettering in the series, was the work of Todd Klein. Klein is one of the more remarkable figures in Sandman. Plenty of people made their reputations working on Sandman,  but Klein leveraged his work on the book to become comics’ first and perhaps only superstar letterer. When the Eisner Awards established an award for Best Lettering in 1993 it was immediately won by Klein. And then, in 1994, it was also won by Klein, and again in 1995. 1996 saw Stan Sakai take one, but then in 1997 Klein began a run of twelve consecutive victories in the category. All told, out of the thirty-one times the award has been given fully eighteen of them were to Todd Klein—an absolutely astonishing level of dominance. And while that haul includes plenty of work beyond Sandman or even his many other collaborations with Neil Gaiman (he quickly became Alan Moore’s preferred letterer as well), it is hard to imagine that Klein would have such a titanic reputation if not for his work on the title.

The central reason that Klein was able to build such an improbable reputation is simply that he was a visible presence throughout the book. Gaiman made heavy use of the technique of giving characters bespoke lettering design, with Klein, by his own estimate, creating around fifty unique lettering styles over the course of the book. Ironically the book’s most famous bespoke lettering style—the white-on-black balloons used for Dream—were not really his work. Klein lettered those balloons traditionally, with DC’s production department making negative image reproductions on a photostat machine and pasting them over the original lettering. Klein, in fact, opposed this, on the grounds that “I’d worked in DC’s production department for 10 years previous to this, and I knew that the reverse stats would vary greatly in quality, sometimes being too dark and hard to read, sometimes being too light, with the letters running together, also hard to read,” although he admits that he was wrong, and has besides long since digitally cleaned up all the issues. But the precedent was set, and so, when Gaiman got in touch asking if he minded designing another bespoke style for Lucifer in issue 4, Klein was game, and from there the requests kept coming. 

Delerium, however, was one of the more complicated ones. Gaiman called for it to “represent a sort of mad variety, getting louder and softer, like something going in and out of focus,” which Klein approached by having her lines run in undulating wave-shaped patterns instead of straight lines, with the patterns shifting around the points where the text got bigger or smaller. The balloons were then colored by Daniel Vozzo, with shifting colors—initially relatively simple gradients in her first appearance, but by the time of Brief Lives evolving into concentric rings of colors that pulse outwards from the center of the balloons. It’s a complicated effect—one Klein admits was “fun to do in small amounts, but tedious in large ones,” and one of the only effects Klein still had to do by hand instead of  on a computer when lettering subsequent projects like Endless Nights. But it further cemented Delerium’s status as a compelling and memorable character.

Brief Lives, however, requires her to be a star, not merely an intriguing background figure, and so Gaiman spends the first issue reintroducing her. Indeed, Dream is entirely absent from it, in what undoubtedly tested some readers’ patience given that by this point the previous year of the book had been six issues A Game of You flanked on either side by a triptych of short stories. Instead the issue follows Delirium as its protagonist as she has a small emotional breakdown in a BDSM club, then visits Desire and Despair, over the course of it drifting towards deciding to seek out her missing brother. Delirium cuts a vulnerable and pitiable figure across this issue, her non-sequitur train of thought repeatedly hanging on ideas and clinging to them after their context has expired so that she’s out of step with whatever’s going on around her—a panhandler asks her for some change, and she gets hung up on the word, repeating it seven times before musing that “when you say words a lot they don’t mean anything. Or maybe they don’t mean anything anyway and we just think they do,” before concluding that she needs a change—all of this, of course, tacitly feeding into her desire to find Destruction.

But crucially, she’s also just very funny throughout. There’s a fantastic visual gag in the sex club where she approaches a goth girl she’s mistaken for Death, and a recurring bit across the issue in which, after relating to the panhandler how “There was a big flood once and I got really wet in that, only it wasn’t rain, it was the gunky stuff inside people’s eyes,” she attempts to remember what the name of said gunky stuff is, with Despair finally answering the question late in the issue. And she’s got loads of great bits like describing Despair’s “voice that sounds like people with wet and bubbly stuff in their lungs buried under the ground being crushed to death by giant worms talking,” or her meandering appeal upon borrowing Desire’s gallery—the collection of sigils with which the Endless call upon each other—because she’s lost hers somewhere in her own realm, “Sister? I’m standing in my gallery, only I’m not because this is Desire’s but can I come and see you? Please? Please? I’m holding your sigil. Your ring thingie. Really I am.” She’s even capable of quality deadpan, such as when Despair describes the man she’s watching, a midwestern supermarket manager whose collection of child pornography was found by his wife who’s now “sitting in their family room, realizing that his life is over, wondering if he has the courage physically to end it. He doesn’t. Isn’t it beautiful,” Despair asks, to which Delirium offers the magnificently nonchalant “It’s okay. I suppose. If you’re into that kind of thing.”

An interesting detail of the first issue comes when Delirium arrives at the sex club, in a half-page panel where, unusually, Gaiman has bothered to specify what music is playing. More than that, the panel is designed to draw conspicuous attention to the choice—its foreground features a man in fetishwear and restraints kissing his partner. Their heads and postures curve slightly to the left, pulling the reader’s eye to the space above their heads where, instead of a dialogue bubble, are the lyrics: “All the world just stopped now, so you say you don’t wanna stay together anymore, let me take a deep breath babe.” It’s a strange amount of attention to bring to the opening bars of an album cut from a record that peaked at fifty-three on the Billboard charts. But for those who recognize the song in question it was a significant moment. The song in question is “Tear in Your Hand,” by Tori Amos; the lyric immediately after the portion quoted is “If you need me, me and Neil’ll be hangin’ out with the dream king,” and Gaiman’s invocation of the line served to cement one of the most significant aesthetic alliances of his career.

Tori Amos was born just a few years after Gaiman to a Maryland-based minister. A piano prodigy from a young age, she set out in her early twenties to make it as a pop star, where she immediately crashed and burned with a mediocre and directionless bit of new wave called Y Kant Tori Read. Regrouping from this setback she started work on a solo album, eventually titled Little Earthquakes. While working on it, in late 1990, she briefly host to a friend, Rantz Hoseley, for a few months. Hoseley was a comics fan, and left a copy of the recently released Doll’s House trade lying around. Amos was charmed, and while home in Maryland for the holidays that year penned “Tear in Your Hand,” including the Gaiman reference. 

The next summer, Hoseley was at San Diego Comic-Con, where he stopped by Gaiman’s table and dropped off a tape of Amos’s music with the comment “She sings about you on one of the songs—don’t sue her.” Hoseley had included Amos’s number, and Gaiman phoned her. Amos recalls him asking if she was “thinking of doing this as something other than a hobby, because it’s pretty good,” to which she replied “that’s a relief, because Little Earthquakes is being released in a couple of weeks.” Her label had relocated her to London in the leadup to the album’s release on the rough logic that it would be easier to launch her there, and she and Gaiman quickly struck up a friendship, with Gaiman working in his reference to the album only a few months after it came out. 

There is little doubt that Gaiman and Amos’s friendship is genuine. As Gaiman puts it, “we were old friends immediately. Whether you want to view that as fact or metaphor, that is very much true.” Amos, meanwhile, notes that “we held a spiritual brother and sister archetype, he would pop in and see me in the oddest places. I would get sent stories to read even in the down under of Down Under. He would find me somewhere in Australia—I can’t even pronounce its name. My spiritual brother would send me stories. I would pop in and see him just to have coffee and wave to Odin or Freya before jumping on a plane to make a concert.” More prosaically, Amos notes that the pair “met at a time when celebrity hadn’t made us guarded about people. Also, there was never any confusion that it was going to be a romance,” while Gaiman recalls waiting at Notting Hill Gate station after a gig as Amos “stood on the platform acting out the entire video for ‘Silent All These Years.’ I was thinking, ‘This is one of the coolest people I’ve ever met.” 

But for all the genuine warmth, their friendship also doubled as an aesthetic alliance, with both of them peppering references to the other across their career. Amos’s second album, Under the Pink in 1994, featured a line in which Amos bemoans that it “seems I keep getting this story twisted, so where’s Neil when you need him?” Boys for Pele, in 1996, features a song in which she asks “will you find me if Neil makes me a tree,” while one of the b-sides for the album was entitled “Sister Named Desire.” In 1998’s From the Choirgirl Hotel she off-handedly mentions the Velvets, a reference to Gaiman’s Neverwhere, while her 2002 album Scarlet’s Walk features a several line sequence in which she calls Gaiman for advice, demanding “get me Neil on the line, no I can’t hold. Have him read ‘Snow, Glass, Apples’ to me, where nothing is where it seems,” subsequently recounting Gaiman’s counsel, “Little sis, you must crack this… you must go in again. Carbon made only wants to be unmade.”

Gaiman, for his part, penned a series of brief pieces for Amos’s concert programs, beginning with the cheekily titled “Hi, by the way” for her Under the Pink tour. He established Rose Walker as a Tori fan, having her describe herself as “more of a cornflakes girl,” and had Amos pen the intro to the Death: The High Cost of Living trade paperback. He also based a talking tree in Stardust on Amos (hence her line on Boys for Pele), and wrote a picture book, Blueberry Girl, adapting a poem he wrote for Amos’s daughter. The most often cited Amos reference in Gaiman’s career, however, is the persistent claim that he based Delirium on her.

It’s easy to see why people think this. For one thing, by the end of Brief Lives Jill Thompson is drawing Delirium as a woman with long, curly red hair just like Amos’s. For another, Amos has an extremely distinctive rhetorical style. Explaining how she wrote the title track to Little Earthquakes, for instance, she offered, “My eye twitches sometimes. I was surrounded by the thoughts I smash. They decided I would be a good dinner. I decided I wanted 3 bridges in this song.” For “Mr. Zebra,” off of Boys for Pele—a song whose lyrics would also serve as solid evidence here—she explains that “we pick up Ratatouille Strychnine, who we love because she's our little double agent who can poison people and get us out of trouble when they're hurting us! But she's tired, she's tired of the poisoning." Or, when clarifying what she meant when she said that her song “Mother” was not just about a mother-daughter relationship, she offered the lengthy account that it’s about “how it was in the past, aeons ago, when we weren't made of flesh and blood yet and our free spirits were floating around. There was no good or bad expression, just free expression. I have a certain idea about the deluge/flood that differs from the accepted interpretation. My vision has to do with the disagreement in yourself. The way you can split up yourself, which means the way you judge a certain part of yourself. Why is Caroline's green so much better than mine? Instead of this you can also see the expression of others just as a message and stay true to yourself. The deluge/flood had to do with judgements. Some kind of energy is taking power over you when you start blaming yourself and condemn yourself. 'Mother the car is here' means: arriving on a place like earth, where that energy is very dark and attractive and sensual. That's also a part of us. If you try to separate those things strictly, like light and dark, like those New-Age people do, then you are acting superior. Then your hands are so clean, no filth under your nails, no wisdom. You have to unify those two things, that's what I tried to do in ‘Mother.’ The idea of: If I like it, I hope I can remember. Maybe it happened a billion years ago…” And, of course, it’s in an issue about Delirium that Gaiman first references Amos.

Nevertheless, the timeline simply does not work out. Gaiman introduced Delirium in November of 1990, back when Rantz Hoseley was staying with Amos and first introducing her to Sandman, and around a year before he and Amos first connected. And while it’s true that Delirium resembles Amos in the later issues of Brief Lives, this is best explained by the fact that Jill Thompson also resembles Tori Amos, an admits that she “used myself as a model for a lot of [Delirium’s] body language, the way she sits or stands.” Equally, Gaiman does not deny the resemblance, noting that Amos “seemed like a fairy to me. She was this little red-headed imp who reminded me of Delirium,” and admitting that “Delirium was created before I met Tori, but they steal shamelessly from each other.”

It is ultimately the bidirectional nature of this theft that is most revealing. Gaiman notes of Amos that “One of the misconceptions about her is that she's barking mad. She's funny, and she tends to concretise metaphors very colourfully, but if she's talking about being wet like a mango it's worth understanding that this is a figure of speech. She's one of the most level-headed people I know.” This undoubtedly extends to her public persona, and her bonkers statements are surely at least partly character work on her part. Indeed, it is Amos who offers the most revealing account of her friendship with Gaiman, when she notes that “our whole relationship is about reading between the lines and pushing each other to be great. Good is not good enough.” Which is to say that at the end of the day, both Gaiman and Amos are profoundly ambitious and at times ruthlessly career-savvy people. Amos, for instance, adopted a shrewd career-long policy of not commenting on what contemporary artists she’s listening to, so that she could, for instance, incorporate massive amounts of trip-hop influences into her 1998 From the Choirgirl Hotel while still having her own creative vision centered in its reception. And when she does nod to her contemporaries, it’s strategic and provocative.  She made an astonishingly swift and attention-getting move to cut a cover of Nirvana’s hit “Smell’s Like Teen Spirit,” ripping out its grunged out guitars and famously unintelligible vocals in favour of a smolderingly sexual piano cover and dropping it only eight months after the original as a b-side to her lead single for Little Earthquakes. She repeated the trick some years later, cutting an equally headline-grabbing Eminem cover for her album Strange Little Girls, itself a brutally sharp move to burn off the end of a record deal she wanted out of with a throwaway covers album before releasing Scarlet’s Walk, a proper major work of an album, barely a year later on a new label. And when it came to her late career, once her hit-making potential was exhausted, she took a similar approach to Gaiman, learning to effectively monetize her core audience with an approach to touring in which she massively rotates her set list night to night, bringing out an endless parade of deep cuts and obscurities, and thus providing tacit encouragement to the legion of obsessive fans who will follow her from show to show. 

The resulting alliance, unsurprisingly, paid off for both of them. Amos’s quirky persona and intimately confessional lyrics were tailor made to appeal to the exact same people that Gaiman was targeting with Death or, for that matter, Delirium. But as they were in completely different media and industries they were at no point in competition with one another for that audience. More to the point, both of them cultivated attentive readers who would pay attention to details like who, exactly, this Neil fellow or the Dream King are, or what that song playing in the background of two pages is. The result was that each served as a tremendously effective gateway to the other’s work.

Following the cementing of this alliance, Gaiman briefly flirted with continuing the pattern of audience frustration that he’d been working in since Season of Mists. On the one hand, the second issue of Brief Lives finally reintroduces Dream, moving the story to the rough present of its main character for the first time in fourteen issues. But as befits that kind of absence the story has lurched to a new and uncertain place. The first pace shows a despondent Dream walking despondently to stand on a balcony as he narrates “She… She has decided she no longer loves me.” The identity of Dream’s new ex is left unrevealed—a decision Gaiman insists was not him trolling the reader, but simply that “a few panels later, I found the Sandman saying, ‘I would appreciate it if the palace staff would be so kind as to refraim from mentioning her in future, when in my presence.’ And I thought, ‘Oh dear. We’re not going to know who she is for a long time now.’” (It was, in fact, Thessaly from A Game of You, a fact that would finally be revealed some twenty-three issues later.) After half an issue of Dream moping (and the castle staff, most especially the wisecracking janitor Merv Pumpkinhead, grousing about how “he’s gotta be the tragic figure standing out in the rain, mournin’ the loss of his beloved. So down comes the rain, right on cue. In the mean time everybody gets dreams fulla existential angst and wakes up feeling like hell. And we all get wet”), however, the story changes gears and never looks back.

The transition is, unsurprisingly, the arrival of Delirium in the Dreaming to appeal to Morpheus for help finding their brother. What becomes immediately apparent once she does is that Delirium and Dream form an absolutely untouchable double act. Dream’s straight-laced mopiness is perfectly suited to serve as the straight man to Delirium’s excesses. He plainly loves his sister, but is also understandably frustrated by her. He invites her for a meal, for instance, at which she asks for “little milk chocolate people? About three inches high? Men and women? I’d like some of them filled with raspberry cream,” along with mango juice to drink—a setup that manages to make Dream’s subsequent request for “an omelette, a light salad, and a glass of white wine” one of the series’ more unexpected laugh lines. This, however, is simply setup for a nine panel grid page in which Delirium tells an increasingly dismayed Dream that two of the chocolates are “making lo-ove. K. I. S. S. I. N. G.” (This last bit is lettered by Klein with a distinct bubble for each letter, each colored differently by Vozzo) Chastised by Dream, she apologizes and meekly says “they weren’t really kissing. They were um. Squidging.” When this fails to improve matters she tries again, venturing that “It’s okay. I’ve finished mostly. They’ve gone all sticky anyway. And I don’t like mango juice. It’s yecchy,” although to this she appends, quietly, one more “kissing.” Dream suggests that they perhaps talk in his gallery, and they depart, allowing Gaiman what he proclaims his “favorite caption in all of Sandman” as he describes how “Touched by her fingers, the two surviving chocolate people copulate desperately, losing themselves in a melting frenzy of lust, spending the last of their brief borrowed lives in a spasm of raspberry cream and fear.”

And there are seven more issues of this. Gaiman literally takes the act on the road, which is to say that the bulk of the storyline is simply Dream and Delirium’s road trip to find Destruction and getting into a variety of misadventures along the way. It’s repeatedly fun—pretty much every issue has multiple astonishingly quotable lines. But it’s also a pretty significant tonal shift from the horror comic that Sandman had debuted as some three and a half years earlier. It is not that the book has abandoned seriousness; this is the arc where it turns into a tragedy, after all. And even if it weren’t, there’s plenty of substantive and even quite dark beats—an entire subplot about the goddess Ishtar in which she blows up a strip club by unleashing the full capacity of her power during a dance, for instance. But the arc is focused on humor in a way that simply wasn’t the case in the comic’s early days—there’s scarcely a joke across the entirety of Preludes and Nocturnes, for instance.

Gaiman is hardly the first to tell a fundamentally dramatic story that’s laced through with comedy bits. It’s a time-honored strategy for popular success—a best of both worlds literary style that can have big, weighty concepts and dramatic climaxes while maintaining a moment-to-moment flow that’s focused on straightforward entertainment. That Gaiman should be adept at the style is hardly a surprise—he had after all collaborated with Terry Pratchett and written the book on Douglas Adams, and his aptitude at the mythic/dramatic end has already been well established. But what’s notable is simply that Gaiman is being so adamantly and extendedly accessible. Like Death: The High Cost of Living, Brief Lives is positively decadent in its appeal to its audience, merrily stretching out over nine issues—the longest arc to date in the series—all of them just tremendously fun. It was a clear and conscious effort to play to the crowd—to lean into the reputation Gaiman had built.

It’s notable, if only for context, that Brief Lives was also the period during which Gaiman emigrated to the United States. This was not done for career reasons—his wife had been an American who was studying Scientology in the UK, and so this was simply her returning home. They settled in western Wisconsin, about an hour outside of Minneapolis—not exactly a buzzing literary hub (although Gaiman would forge a long-term relationship with Dreamhaven Books and their associated press, which issued a number of small run projects for him including Angels and Visitations, his first short story collection, shortly after he moved; for years one could send things to Dreamhaven Books for Gaiman to sign the next time he was in). Gaiman has suggested there was some measure of culture shock, noting that “I thought I understood America. The Midwest, and by inference America, was weirder than I could have imagined,” although before long he was finding inspiration in the landscape, his experience as an immigrant, and the books on American history and folklore he was reading.

This move did not mean that he was wholly out from under the thumb of Scientology—his wife remained active in the Church—but it still marked a clear milestone in Gaiman’s escape from his family’s control. If Brief Lives and The High Cost of Living read as a victory lap, that’s only appopriate for a writer who had very clearly won. Whatever goals he’d had when he walked into that meeting with Berger and Giordano five years earlier had more than been accomplished; he was already more successful than he could have imagined. He’d made it. 

It is helpful to think back to “24 Hours,” and Gaiman’s comments about how happy endings require stopping the story at a certain point. Or perhaps back to “A Midsummer Night’s Dream,” and Gaiman’s line about the price of getting what you want being having what you once wanted. It would be nice, in many ways, if this is where Gaiman’s story ended. It would be a story about Moore’s most successful protege, who used what he learned from his mentor to escape a lifetime of abuse and write a hit comic. It would be a happy ending—the story of what is, perhaps, the most noble and worthwhile use of Moore’s magic there is. 

The point in which the ending of Sandman becomes inevitable comes in the sixth issue of Brief Lives. Dream and Delirium’s initial efforts to find Destruction have faltered as they run up against the magic Destruction has worked to cover his tracks, resulting in a trail of, well, destruction in their wake. Dream calls off the search, returning to the Dreaming, leaving Delirium despondent. After being memorably scolded by Death, Dream voyages to Delirium’s realm and agrees to resume the search. The consequences of this are hinted at earlier in the issue, when Dream visits Bast and she alludes to the existence of an oracle Dream could consult, and are made more explicit in the next issue, when Destiny bluntly informs Dream that he will need an oracle, and that there is precisely one who is capable of perceiving the Endless as he is “of the family.” This, of course, is Dream’s own son, Orpheus, whose price is simple: that Dream finally grant him death. This, however, makes him a kin-killer, exactly as Desire had long been trying to trick him into doing, and thus bringing the wrath of the Kindly Ones. (Desire, ironically, finds themself ambivalent about this development.) 

Interestingly, there is relatively little thought given in the book to why Dream takes this decision. As soon as he returns to the Dreaming he is already giving thought to taking up the quest in earnest (having, initially, just been playing along with Delirium in the hopes of bumping into Thessaly on Earth), consulting Bast, when she asks why he wants to find his brother, answering that “I do not want to. But… I am much afraid I need to.” His conversation with Death tips the scales, but it’s not entirely clear why. He gives one sort of answer when informing Delirium that he’ll try again, when she asks if he likes her, to which he says “I suppose I must do, Delirium. You entertain me. And it distresses me to see you troubled.” Later, when Destruction asks why he came looking for him, he suggests that it’s because of one of the people who died along the way, and a sense of justice. Neither answer quite satisfies, however, and the decision, for all its implications, remains opaque.

Dream’s fatal decision only takes the book to its two-thirds mark (the equivalent “Act I” break being, roughly, the end of Season of Mists), and Gaiman still had much to do before the end. Nevertheless, he had set the book on the path to its conclusion. More to the point, he had set his comics career on the path to its conclusion. He would not abandon the medium entirely, but in the nearly three decades since Sandman’s completion he’s written just over two dozen issues, the bulk of them written for Marvel Comics as part of a complicated deal to get them to clean up the copyright situation around Miracleman. He was, by and large, done with the industry.

Unlike his character, it is not hard to see why Gaiman made this decision. The same critiques he’d made at the beginning of his career about writing Future Shocks applied just as well to DC. While Sandman was technically in the DC Universe, Gaiman had for all practical purposes created a bespoke fictional universe featuring the single most iconic character he’d ever create in his career. And he owned none of it. The temptation to ensure that he actually had all of the rights to his next creation was obvious. Equally, the case he’d made about writing for Fleetway—that it represented a failure to invest in himself—plainly did not apply here. Writing Sandman had been an excellent investment in himself; it had gotten him everything he wanted, after all. But now he wanted more.

Comments

Scott Martin

Nice. Since as you note the official Tori-to-Delirium pipeline does not work out, I wonder whether the historical Tanaqui Weaver could be contacted to weigh in on The Allegations and how many levels of screen memory drove the early Dreamhaven era . . . how the Tori bond shifts to the manic baby sister in the uh wake of a squelched romance.

Tim Hardy

The Hunt also sets up / reinforces the danger or risk of getting what you dream of, with the grandfather ultimately deciding against it.

Doctor Memory

"Of course, there is another interpretation of Gaiman’s desire to direct the film himself." Sadly in retrospect one might see another motivation here: a desire to hold a position of authority over whoever was cast in the part.

Richard Lyth

I distinctly remember an SFX interview about the Death movie where Gaiman was salivating over the prospect of getting to meet all the hot young actresses of the day. Sounded great at the time, but in retrospect definitely a red flag.

HARNAIK KAHLON

“But now he wanted more.” Doom approaches … Have you thought about making your Warren Ellis chapters a companion piece to this? There’s a through line there, the use of Moore’s magic for dark ends.