The Prophecies of William Blake, Seer: Bootstrap Edition (Patreon)
Downloads
Missing 1 file, as this post has not yet been imported.
Content
After deciding i wanted to do an edition of Blake, I quickly realized that I would have a much better time working on the project if I had the typeset poems in the format the project would end up doing. The result of that is attached—an absolutely monstrous 3 GB pdf containing nearly all of Blake's works. What I'll say of it is that it's absolutely as well-formatted an edition of William Blake as it's possible to bodge together in a month using a Microsoft Word template designed for typesetting nothing more complex than Last War in Albion, which is to say that it's a hot mess that I've already found at least one major error in.
You'll also note this PDF is more than 700 pages. Which means that the finished edition is also going to be two volumes, probably split before The Four Zoas, although honestly even that's pushing length on the second volume and I wouldn't rule out three volumes with The Four Zoas getting its own volume in which we really get into the mess of that thing.
"We?" you say? Well yes. The published edition of this is going to rope Penn in to give it the sort of typesetting job it deserves. We're printing in full color, so we may as well use it and give these poems a presentation that feels commensurate with what's going to be a pretty fearsome price tag. Because if we're not going to publish the best edition of William Blake ever compiled, why the fuck bother?
Until then, I have an edition of Blake I can get writing with. I've got a ton of printer ink on its way to me, and I'm going to spend Tuesday printing all 741 pages of this motherfucking thing and taking it to get comb bound. And then I'll, um, get back to finishing that Sandman chapter and working on this as a side project, because this so wasn't supposed to be how I spent my week. Whoops.
Anyway, I also finished another bit of commentary, on All Religions are One and There is No Natural Religion so here's that too:
----
Blake would not complete his first work of illuminated printing until some four years after the initial composition An Island in the Moon. The possible reasons for this gap are considerable. Most obviously, it may have simply taken a while to turn theory into practice, especially while fitting the process around his paying work as an engraver. A larger problem comes in the form of Blake’s account the method being revealed to him by his brother Robert in a vision. This would put his initial conception of the method no earlier than February of 1787. But the method clearly exists in An Island in the Moon, and the dating of that to 1784 is well supported by a variety of topical references in the text.
The circle can be squared. For one thing, there’s the hypothesis that An Island in the Moon was recopied closer to 1788, and that the final section was added then. This confounds the theory that the drawings on the final page are Robert’s, but the support for that theory is considerably thinner than the other relevant claims. There are, however, other problems—most obviously, the final section of the manuscrupt does not show markedly more revision than the earlier portions, which is inconsistent with the idea that it is a first draft added after the transcription of an earlier manuscript.
Other possibilities exist, however. Perhaps the missing account in An Island in the Moon was lacking some key technical detail that was posthumously imparted by Robert. Peter Ackroyd offers the hypothesis that Robert’s association with the technique originates in Blake’s use of an image originally drawn by Robert, called “The Approach of Doom,” as a test image in fine tuning the method. Perhaps there’s not even anything to resolve; Blake was never above sexing up an account of his visions, and may have simply decided that ascribing the method to his beloved late brother was more appealing than trying to explain his dream journal.
What is unambiguous is that Blake completed his first works in the medium in 1788—a pair of pamphlets entitled All Religions are One and There is No Natural Religion. Before looking to the contents of these works, however, it is worth understanding precisely what it is Blake had created. Blake was an engraver; as the word suggests, this meant that Blake’s printmaking was done by cutting lines into a surface—typically a copper plate. This could be accomplished by engraving—essentially chiseling lines directly into the copper—or by etching, in which the copper is covered with a ground which is selectively scraped away before bathing the plate in acid, which eats away at the bare parts. In both techniques, ink was then filled into the resulting crevices, and the plate pressed onto the paper in order to produce the finished image. This form of printmaking is called intaglio, and had obvious limitations. A skilled engraver—which Blake undoubtedly was—could execute works of considerable subtlety, but at the end of the day there are still hard limits to what can be done working with needles and chisels.
Blake’s great invention was to work in relief—that is, to create a raised surface on the copper onto which ink would be applied. He accomplished this by drawing on the copper plate in an acid-resistant varnish, then bathing the plate in acid so that the untreated areas were eaten away, leaving the image in relief. This allowed Blake to work on his plates with pens, brushes, and other tools designed for nuance and precision. Where other forms of printmaking took drawings and reproduced them, Blake could draw directly onto his plates, and execute calligraphic writing. This approach also allowed him to bring all parts of bookmaking under a single roof, and thus to control every aspect of production. This was in marked contrast to the usual bookmaking process of the time, in which text and images were printed in different shops by different artisans, the former using a letterpress and the latter intaglio plates. More to the point, Blake could create unified designs that integrated text and image. Blake would then execute these designs on watercolor paper so that he could paint over them, allowing each copy to be a unique object direct from the hand of the artist.
All Religions are One and There is No Natural Religion are both plainly Blake testing his new medium. After first working on a straight image in the form of “The Approach of Doom,” here Blake introduces text and commences entwining it with images. At this stage he is working in miniature—the individual plates are scarcely more than two inches in their longest dimension. This decision was likely made in part to save money on copper, which was the most expensive element of the process; better to fuck up and lose a small piece of copper than an entire large plate.
All Religions are One is the earlier work, and most visibly shows Blake working out the process. His penmanship improves as he goes, and he begins attempting more ambitious page designs. Only one copy survives, and it has the sense of being prepared with an eye towards legacy. It was printed in 1795 on oversized pieces of paper, and Blake went back to the copy some time around 1818 and added a series of framing lines around each image so as to fill in some of the vast expanses of white. There is No Natural Religion has more copies and, perhaps more interestingly, more versions—Blake prepared two iterations of the text, and at different times combined plates from both versions to create the finished work. (Get used to this.)
The pages are at once simple and tauntingly complex, with Blake crashing giddily against the limits of his frame. The text is similarly fervid, with Blake offering religious polemics in the form of a series of short aphorisms. A plate early on is All Religions are One, just as he’s getting the backward handwriting thing under control, sees him proclaim that “As all men are alike in outward form, So (and with the same infinite variety) all are alike in the Poetic Genius,” which he labels in larger text as Principle 2, then draws a nude couple reclining atop the title, a spindly tree along the left edge whose branches wrap around the title and couple, and then a flock of sheep and some smaller trees along the bottom of the, recall, two inch square page.
This Poetic Genius serves as the main subject of All Religions are One. By it, Blake means something akin to the soul, although he does not use that term. (He does, however, note that the Genius “by the Ancients was call’d an Angel and Spirit and Demon.”) That Blake would equate the soul with imagination can scarcely be called a surprise—it is, after all, the faculty through which his most spiritually profound moments are experienced. More surprising, perhaps, is his contention that “the Body or Outward Form of Man is derived from the Poetic Genius. Likewise that the forms of all things are derived from their Genius”—a claim that tantalizingly suggests the material world itself is simply imagined into being. The titular omnism, meanwhile, is derived from the belief that there is but one Poetic Genius (as, per Principle 2, all men derive the same basic form) and all religions and philosophies are simply limited expressions of it.
There is No Natural Religion, exiting as it does in two distinct texts, is a stranger document. The traditional way of anthologizing it is to treat it as two series of numbered aphorisms. The first series, consisting of a plate labeled “The Argument” and six proclamations, appears only in copies printed in 1794, of which there are six extant. These copies conclude with the first two aphorisms of the second series, along with a plate from that series labeled “Therefore.” These three plates also appear in the lone 1795 copy (a large paper one akin to the sole copy of All Religions are One) along with the remainder of the second series, save for the third aphorism, which, if it ever existed, is lost. I have departed from convention and reproduced the text in the two versions that Blake printed.
The 1794 version is, however, deeply puzzling. Its first six aphorisms advance a materialist viewpoint that, man’s perception is constrained by “his natural or bodily organs,” that he cannot reason beyond these perceptions, and that his desires are similarly constrained. This is, obviously, an extremely uncharacteristic thing for Blake to argue, and the remaining three plates directly contradict it, opening with the declaration that “Man's perceptions are not bounded by organs of perception. he perceives more than sense (tho' ever so acute) can discover.”
The second version, consisting of the entirety of the second series, makes altogether more sense, opening as it does with the claim that man’s perception exceeds mere sensory input. It continues in this vein, drawing distinction between this visionary capacity and the “ratio”—the product of reason as applied to existent knowledge, coming to the conclusion that “If it were not for the Poetic or Prophetic character, the Philosophic & Experimental would soon be at the ratio of all things, & stand still, unable to do other than repeat the same dull round over again,” or, as he puts it more pithily, “He who sees the Infinite in all things sees God. He who sees the Ratio only sees himself only.”
What is perhaps most curious about this is that Blake has taken the argument “imagination is good actually” and dressed it up in the iconoclastic bombast of titles like All Religions are One and There is No Natural Religion. Sure, the lack of natural religion is a logical consequence of Blake’s materialist view of the natural world, but it seems at first blush like something of a side point to his argument about poetic vision. And while it would be a brilliant tactic in the modern age of clickbait, it’s a curious tactic in an era where blasphemy laws still existed. Indeed, it’s far from clear that Blake even sold these pamphlets.
The truth, however, is that Blake largely obscures the most significant aspect of his argument—perhaps even from himself. Both versions of There is No Natural Religion conclude with the slogan “God becomes as we are, that we may be as he is.” Likewise, All Religions are One takes pains to insist that the Platonic form of the Poetic Genius—the “True Man”—is the source of all religions. And yet for all Blake’s protestations that there is such a thing as a unifying core of singular creativity, his every action plainly undermines the claim. We are speaking of a man who has just invented a bespoke medium for himself in which he can control every aspect of the design—whose vision is practically bursting out of the frames of his tiny two inch plates, and whose career is only going to get stranger from here. The idea that anyone is quite like him in Poetic Genius is plainly absurd. There are artists who are plainly of their times—whose work, however brilliant, was simply going to happen in some form or another. But William Blake is not one of them. Had he not created this body of work than nothing like it would have ever existed.
But if we take this fact in tandem with his notion of Poetic Genius and the Prophetic character the conclusion is inescapable. If the divine is the product of human imagination, and Blake’s imagination is truly singular, then William Blake was calling wholly new gods into being.