Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

As the selection of an artist who would maintain an emotional objectivity suggests, Moore was deeply uninterested in writing a whodunit in which the Ripper murders would be solved—a story that would build to some climactic reveal of the suspect. This was consistent with his larger desires in treating a murder, but moreover was a necessary factor in depicting a murder that is, in practice, unsolved. There are, of course, countless theories regarding the identity of Jack the Ripper—Moore would eventually give a history of them in the “Dance of the Gull-Catchers” appendix to From Hell. But none are definitive, and while some are plainly fanciful, there’s not even anything that could be pointed to as a leading contender. Moore, for his part, is firm that “nobody knows and probably nobody will ever know” the Ripper’s identity. And so building the entire story towards an innately unsatisfying reveal was simply an unappealing option. And so Moore instead structured the story, as he explained in the intro to Taboo #2, not as “a ‘Whodunnit?’ so much as a ‘Wha’happen?’” 

Nevertheless, this still required that Moore pick a suspect for the purposes of telling the story. Moore is clear in his intro that this is not intended as any sort of claim of truth, describing the selection as “simply a convenience of fiction.” Nevertheless, contrary to the epigraph of Charles Fort declaring that “one measures a circle, beginning anywhere,” he did in fact have to construct a theory of the case. And so from the morass of Ripperologists with their pet theories Moore selected one—Stephen Knight’s 1976 Jack the Ripper: The Final Solution.

This was not a choice made on the basis of plausibility—indeed, Moore speculates that Knight “wrote it as a hoax,” although he describes it as an “ingenious hoax.” Instead he seems to have made the choice because Knight’s theory was simply more interesting, saying that, “whether true or not, [it] seemed to open up fascinating territories of lore and tradition.” Discussing the theory in “Dance of the Gull-Catchers,” Moore goes into more detail, describing it “a Swiss-watch work of art, ingenious in its incorporation of the Lees and Stowell theories.” Translated out of Ripper geek geneologies, Moore is describing here Thomas Stowell’s 1970 article “Jack the Ripper - A Solution?” in the Criminologist, which implied that the Ripper was Prince Albert Victor, Queen Victoria’s grandson and second in line to the throne. Adding to the theory’s splash was the fact that Stowell died shortly after the article’s publication and his son burnt all of his papers. The Lees theory, meanwhile, refers to a far older strand of thought, first recorded in The Chicago Herald in 1895, which reported a second hand account of the spiritualist Robert James Lees’ telling people how he had led the police to the door of the Ripper—a doctor in a fashionable house in London—and of how the doctor was institutionalized under a false name after a secret trial. Picking up on a detail in Stowell’s theory about the physician Sir William Gull’s peripheral involvement, Knight’s book splits the difference, abandoning the rather farcical notion of an insane and murderous royal in favor of the still scandalous but altogether more modest notion that Gull was the Ripper, with the murders intended as a cover-up of Prince Albert Victor’s illegitimate child.

Knight’s account is framed as a sort of escalating fascination. At the story’s start, Knight finds himself interviewing Joseph Gorman, who styled himself Joseph Sickert, claiming to be the secret son of the painter Walter Sickert. Gorman had appeared a few years earlier in the BBC’s six part Jack the Ripper TV series. This strange series was a hybrid drama/documentary, with popular detectives Charlie Barlow and John Watt from Z-Cars and Softly, Softly reviewing the evidence, interspersed with dramatic reenactments of crucial scenes. Its sixth and final episode meanders through Stowell’s theory and some other details around Prince Albert Victor before offering an interview with Gorman, introduced with triumphant flourish as “someone who is alive and well and living in London,” promising a “story that’s never been told before.” 

Gorman unfurls his story with relish, working his way up over the course of five minutes to his headline claims so as to gradually ramp up the stakes and audacity of his tale. In the TV series the fictional detectives treat it as at once strangely plausible and impossible to nail down. The series ends with the detectives convinced that there’s been some sort of cover-up, but refusing to commit to any specific theory. Still, the fact that Gorman’s theory is presented in the final episode positions it as the show’s de facto last word, allowing it to pool vaguely with an earlier thread involving some graffiti discovered around one of the murders reading “The Juwes are the men that will not be blamed for nothing,” which the show presents as having Masonic connections.

Knight evinces tremendous skepticism in Gorman’s tale. “It all sounded terribly unlikely,” he complains. Nevertheless, he was fascinated, convinced that Gorman “may have been grossly misled, but he believed utterly in every syllable of his tale.” (This claim is, perhaps, undermined by Gorman subsequently recanting his claims, although he later retracted the retraction in a bid to get royalties on Knight’s book.) He begins to pull on the threads, and is repeatedly astonished to discover their plausibility. In practice these chains of association are always slightly overstated—a parade of vague corroborations stitched together with a bunch of “are likely to have been”s and other handwaving conjectures. But the breadth of its implications, including Knight’s decision to take the vague whiffs of Masonic connections and inflate them into a wholesale claim that the Ripper murders were “perpetrated according to Masonic ritual” makes it easy to see why Moore was drawn to the theory. If the Ripper murders were to be Moore’s lens on their times then the most audacious and far-reaching theory of the case had obvious sue, especially when it was so well constructed to remain vaguely plausible, allowing Moore to maintain the structural conceit that, even though it is a work of fiction, “the events detailed in ‘From Hell’ could have unfolded just the way we describe them.” 

Comments

No comments found for this post.