Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

2022 was a superb year for indie games, with countless contenders for personal favorite, and I didn’t even get through all of the big ones. Vampire Survivors comes to mind. But one of the big ones I did get the chance to play was Cult of the Lamb.

If you’re unfamiliar with the title, Cult of the Lamb is a roguelite hack-and-slash that takes that genre and hybridizes it with colony management.

Combining Genres

Colony management games are slow. They’re strategy games about the steady accumulation of resources and managing those resources to turn a net profit on them compared to the upkeep costs of people and facilities. Knowing what you need, what you will need, and how to get it efficiently is necessary to success. You have to think ahead. If you don’t, it will suddenly become a very fast game, in the sense that a burning house burns fast.

By contrast, hack-and-slash gameplay prioritizes melee combat, which generally means you have to keep on guard and think fast. Planning minutes or hours in advance isn’t going to do much about the sword that’s less than a second away from cleaving your face in.

You might think that combining these two seemingly disparate genres would be hard—and to be fair, it is—but it’s something that has been done for decades at this point. The original ActRaiser came out in 1990, and SoulBlazer (by the same team) in 1992 had similar elements.

The trick to combining genres that seemingly don’t fit together is to encourage the player to use one genre to progress in the other. You want to create a cycle whereby the player wants to engage with one of your systems to improve themselves in another, and then use those improvements to earn more upgrades for the previous system.

For example, in the Persona games, by doing well at the life simulation aspects—upping your social stats, increasing your Social Links, etc. —you gain new powers to use in combat. In ActRaiser, the more you do for your people in the city management, the more they worship you, the stronger you become in combat. On the flipside, there are combat sections you must complete in order to expand your city in certain directions. ActRaiser’s 2021 remake, Actraiser Renaissance, went even further by introducing a tower-defense style attacks on your city, adding more action to the strategy elements.

This method is not limited to action games, either. Firaxis’ recent XCOM titles also do this by having you scavenge materials and weapons during the tactical combat sections for use in the base management sections, which provides benefits for you in tactical combat.

Cult of the Lamb does this as well. Certain resources needed for upgrading your Cult and base and/or completing side quests can only be found in specific dungeon crawls. And since you can only access new areas to explore by clearing the previous area, you are incentivized to make progress to reach them. Additionally, needing resources encourages you to run dungeons repeatedly for more materials. You can even find seeds you can grow back at your base camp.

Your base camp features all of your upgrade trees. Stronger weapons, weapons with new passive bonuses, new and stronger Curses (your ranged attacks), all of that is handled back at your Camp by spending devotion from your followers. This also has the deliberate side benefit of encouraging you to keep them happy so they continue to worship you.

(A fundamental principle of game design: You Encourage The Behavior You Reward)

In other words you need to go on dungeon runs to upgrade your camp, and you need to upgrade your camp to do better on dungeon runs.

However, there is one extremely important thing to consider when designing a feedback loop like this one: balance. And I’m not talking about gameplay balance here, either. What I mean is, if one of your systems is inherently easier, more productive, or provides more benefits, than you will encourage players to exploit that to great effect.

As I said above, you encourage the behavior you reward, and this is all about rewarding.

For example, in Cult of the Lamb, what is stopping you from hanging around in your campsite until you have all the worship you need for the strongest weapons before you’ve even fought the first boss? In Persona, why don’t you max out your Social Links and reach your ultimate Personas as soon as possible? In ActRaiser, what’s stopping you from recreating New York to scale and over-leveling yourself?

Answering that question is one of the most important design decisions you can make, as each has their own pros and cons.

Persona answers this with Time Management. You are always on the clock in Persona. There is only so much time in a day, and interacting with Social Links, upgrading your stats, all of that takes up your precious time. If only ever engage with the life simulation, bad things happen. In Persona 3, the boss fights are all scheduled, so you’re going to be under-leveled. Persona 4 and 5 introduced deadlines to achieve certain goals or you lose. Straight up.

ActRaiser doesn’t allow you to terraform the environment, and as such the designers are able to limit the size of your city, meaning that they have total control over what benefits you get for having a city of the largest possible size with the highest tiered facilities.

In Cult of the Lamb, your followers can age and die. If you aren’t constantly running around picking up more of them, you will eventually run out of them. And while you can resurrect deceased followers, doing so has a real-time cooldown on it, during which more followers could drop dead. You also need to feed them to keep them alive, and I’m sure you’ve already guessed where you get food from. Additionally, as I mentioned before, you need to explore the later dungeons to get certain materials, meaning that even if you stick to the early game for as long as possible, you have a hard limit on how much you can develop.

Like all elements of design, this does not always necessarily provide a positive experience. In Cult of the Lamb, I always felt as if I was moments away from disaster. Timers, even ones that last for in-game weeks, can be extremely stress-inducing, especially if you aren’t intimately familiar with the game—for example, a first-time player. This can be the desired effect for some games, but it is worth keeping in mind.

Procedural Generation

Above all else, there are two things that define the Roguelike(/Roguelite) genre. The dire consequences of character death, and the procedural level generation.

There are many, many ways to handle procedural level generation, and I’m sure there are more out there that haven’t yet been invented. There are some where each room is itself individually generated, which can be done to make areas organically (like caves) or even manmade structures, depending on the method. There are others where each room is built by hand ahead of time by the developers and then randomly stuck together like tiles on a board game.

(As a matter of fact, many board games actually do that, such as Betrayal at House on the Hill)

(Never underestimate the ties between board games and video games.)

And as you might expect, there are pros and cons and considerations to every one of those methods of procedural generation.

You’ll hear me say this a lot in this series, but I cannot say for certain why a developer would choose any one method over another without actually speaking to them. There are things I can infer, and educated guesses I can make, but at the end of the day, I was not on the team who made those games, and I don’t know what was considered or how.

Cult of the Lamb has two methods of procedural generation: The actual dungeon crawls—each  ‘floor’ of the dungeon only being a few rooms long—and the connecting branching paths between them.

Cult of the Lamb takes the Room Tile approach as mentioned above. This is the method where a level is constructed out of premade rooms that are connected with preestablished doors to another random room. This is a particularly common method of procedural generation. Connecting premade rooms means that you don’t need to worry about your Procedural Generation creating areas antithetical to your design goals.

Warframe, for example, uses this method to reflect the different factions’ bases and spaceships, ensuring they feel properly manmade and uniform through the faction while also being filled with wide-open spaces to encourage the high-speed mobility-based gunplay that defines the game.

Cult of the Lamb has a stronger emphasis on melee combat, and as a result the player needs to have room to get close to an enemy and room to dodge away. A randomly-created tight corridor with even a few enemies in it would be brutal to fight through.

Having premade rooms has another benefit over generating rooms individually: loot.

As mentioned in the previous section, Cult of the Lamb heavily emphasizes managing your commune of cultists, building structures for them, gathering and refining resources, acquiring food, etc. By creating the various Room Tiles ahead of time, the developers can be certain that the player will have access to certain things every run, such as tall grass that can be cut for seeds, or rocks that can be broken for stone.

Additionally, as mentioned, there is another kind of Procedural Generation on every run.

The branching paths that connect each floor of the dungeon takes the form of that flowchart which I believe was popularized (if not invented) by Slay the Spire. Much like a board game, there are a number of spaces aligned in rows, and each space connects to some of the spaces in the next row. As you’ve probably guessed by the fact that I’ve put this in the Procedural Generation section, what you get from this board is random every run, but once you’ve started the run, the board is locked in. You can look ahead to see what spaces are coming up, and plan your route accordingly. After all, some spaces do not connect to other spaces. This is important because the spaces aren’t just dungeon floors, but also perks, shops, recruitable followers, resources, etc. If you need several different things available on the board, planning your route is crucial, and many times you’ll have to pick between two things you need.

This system adds a new, strategic element to every run, one that makes you think ahead, but is also simple enough that it doesn’t distract you when you’re actually in combat. After all, it’s only relevant between floors. You don’t need to debate where you’re going next while neck-deep in enemies; only once you’ve cleared the floor and moved on.

Not to mention the variety of benefits there are that you have to choose between. Sometimes you’re forced to pick between healing or perks or other benefits that will only affect your current run and a space that gives you something you need for your base camp in the long run. It’s a reinforcement of the resource management from the other genre that’s been mashed together, and an incentive to do a run in the first place since you might find something you desperately need while on your crusades.

The result of all of this is that every run in Cult of the Lamb is far more strategic than a cursory glance would suggest, all in service of feeding into the game’s Primary Loop. This has an added side-effect as well: by making runs more strategic and tests of endurance, any given run can last for quite a while. This means that when your run ends, you’re incentivized to manage your camp and explore the surrounding areas, where you can find side quests and shops for your base camp, just to have a change of pace before throwing yourself back into a new run.

Upgrades

The difference between Roguelikes and Roguelites is somewhat subjective, but the primarily recognized difference is how permanent death is. To be clear, I’m not suggesting that the game needs to erase itself from your hard drive to be a perfect imitator of Rogue (though I know of at least one that does, in fact, become unplayable after death). I’m referring to how much of your progress is lost.

In a traditional Roguelike, the answer is everything. Literally everything. Goodbye. You get nothing! You lose! Good day, sir! By contrast, Roguelites have some means of permanent upgrading to make future runs easier, such as upgrading your castle in Rogue Legacy, liberated stations remaining persistent in Heat Signature, the upgrade tree from Orbital Bullet, or the mirror from Hades.

Naturally, allowing the player to freely upgrade themselves means that the only obstacle between a player and victory is time. Time to grind for money or EXP or whatever resource goes towards making their character stronger. This lends to a sense of inevitability, and creates an odd difficulty curve in which the game itself becomes easier the longer you play, independent of your skill.

The inevitability problem is one that has been long solved; simply limit what the player can upgrade, or have unlocks that don’t significantly affect game balance at all, such as new weapons that can spawn in future runs, or cosmetic options, or new playable characters, etc.

Cult of the Lamb features multiple upgrades that persist between runs, from your base camp to your sermons. Every form of upgrade in Cult of the Lamb is in some way locked to ensure that you can’t simply sit around managing your cult forever to become incredibly powerful.

For example, your defensive Fleeces are unlocked via sidequests, however rather than being straight upgrades to your default garb, each comes with its own passive benefit and drawback. This can be useful for customizing your playstyle, but not for breaking the game.

Similarly, you can gain powerful abilities that will dramatically improve your odds of success… but each of these powers can only be unlocked by paying a resource collected from defeating a boss for the first time. Which abilities you have is up to you, but the developers know with perfect accuracy how many of these powers you have at any given time.

There is, however, one significant exception. The previously mentioned Sermons. While impractical—especially as followers can and will die after a while—Sermons can be used to permanently increase your health and increase the level of the weapons and spells you can find on a run, meaning they deal more damage. Sermons are instead capped by how many followers you have, which requires materials to maintain their lodgings, food, hygiene, etc. This is, however, manageable if tedious, so a dedicated player could use this to upgrade their offensive ability substantially early into the game.

(This may actually be intentional; it’s possible to do the bosses out of order, which requires you to tackle the stronger enemies in their dungeons.)

It’s a strange dichotomy to have so many unlocks that have no impact on game balance, but to give the weapons levels that impact their damage. For reference, the other unlocks on that same tree give you access to possible variant weapons with passive benefits, like dealing damage over time or recovering your health when you hit an enemy. While these weapons are more powerful than the default weapon, you don’t get to choose what benefit you get, so if you don’t like yours you have to find another one.

Increasing the level of the found equipment is only ever a positive in every situation, regardless of playstyle.

I can’t say for sure why this decision was made, but I think it might be a way to tie into the base camp management, as it means that there can be a massive difficulty spike after each boss so the player is encouraged to do their Sermons.

Choice

Mark Rosewater, head designer of Magic: The Gathering, once defined the difference between Choices and Options when it comes to game design.

Choices are between A or B. Options means you can have A and/or B.

Cult of the Lamb is a game filled with Choices, all in service of the Primary Loop between the Roguelite Hack-and-Slash and the Colony Management. I don’t agree with all of the design decisions of Cult of the Lamb (if you’ve never played it, literally not a single reviewer is exaggerating about the abundance of poop jokes) but there’s a very clear vision behind the game, and that clarity has led to an elegant design. The developers knew exactly the kind of game they were making and how they could encourage player behavior for that goal.

Special thanks to my Tier 3 Patron Haelerin!

Comments

No comments found for this post.