What We Can Learn From: Sundered (Patreon)
Content
I discussed last month how multiple genres can be combined mechanically by creating a cyclical structure that encourages the player to engage with elements of one genre to earn benefits in another. This tried-and-true formula has been employed for many years to great success. But not all combinations are created equal.
Sundered is a Roguelite Metroidvania created by Thunder Lotus Games, who also created Jotun and Spiritfarer. The game takes heavy influences from the Cthulhu Mythos, set in an ever-changing series of caverns deep below a desolate wasteland.
To be clear, Sundered is an excellent game that I highly recommend, but it also contains a significant flaw in the central design, which I feel is worth discussing, especially in the context of combining multiple disparate genres.
Player Motivations
In 1996, Richard Bartle proposed a taxonomy of game player psychology. Psychology in the game industry is nothing new, and in fact a core part of much design. However, Bartle’s Taxonomy provided a useful way to think about players—and more specifically, their motivations for play. While the taxonomy is intended for multiplayer analysis it can still be applied to singleplayer games, especially in the modern age of constant online socialization.
Bartle’s proposal divides players into four categories set on two axes. The X Axis representing a scale from Acting On to Interacting With, and the Y Axis representing a scale from other players to the world of the game.
The influence of analyzing multiplayer behavior is obvious but still useful even in a singleplayer context.
Bartle categorized the four quadrants of the graph as playing card suits, but they are today known as Killers, Achievers, Socializers, and Explorers. For the most part these names are self-explanatory. Killers are part of the Acting On graph, and they enjoy Acting On other players. On the other end, Explorers prefer to Interact With the game world. This doesn’t necessarily mean physical exploration, as it can also include fiddling with game mechanics and unorthodox strategies.
Killers are the group least relevant to singleplayer discussion. Not completely irrelevant, but for the purposes of this analysis they will not be important.
Roguelikes/Rougelites are generally popular with Explorers and Achievers. Achievers can demonstrate mastery over a game by doing well even when starting from scratch each run. Explorers have game systems to interact with and experiment with. After all, Roguelikes are especially designed around forcing players into unique or unconventional builds from the roll of the die.
Metroidvanias also encourage both Achieving and Exploring. As such, it would seem reasonable that these two genres can be combined to appeal to audiences of both. However, Exploration in a Metroidvania is largely based around discovering the layout of the game world.
While many Metroidvanias feature mechanical exploration, such as the various spells in Bloodstained: Ritual of the Night or the hidden synergies between Charms in Hollow Knight, the primary draw of the genre is the world itself. Metroidvanias are a genre predicated on a large, interconnected game world filled with shortcuts and pathways the link them together, which the player gets access to by acquiring new abilities.
This is where the greatest flaw in Sundered’s design rears its ugly head. The world of Sundered is procedurally generated.
Clashing Styles
If you’ve ever played a Metroidvania, it won’t take long for you to understand the problem. The ruined kingdom of Hallownest from Hollow Knight contains countless secrets and pathways and sequence breaks that players are still talking about years later, from the hidden bosses like the Nosk to the unexplained giant corpse in The Queen’s Garden. Bloodstained: Ritual of the Night features a piano in a courtyard that protagonist Miriam will play at and if the Fairy companion is equipped, they will sing along. Castlevania: Symphony of the Night has a confession booth that will stab you if you sit in it for too long.
All of these are well remembered by fans of those games, and but a small sample of the Exploration that the Metroidvania genre is built upon. There are also other secrets, such as the Health and Weapon upgrades hidden behind destructible walls or behind platforming challenges that may not even be obviously a path at first glance, or in many recent Metroidvanias, sidequests and NPCs.
Sundered, by its structure, cannot have that. There are no secrets in the world of Sundered, and it does not take long to see repetition in the specific tiles that comprise the world, especially when some of those tiles are reused in a different hue in another part of the game. There are no landmarks with which to orient yourself.
You can see the flaws in Sundered’s procedural generation by looking at the map. Many of the rooms by nature cannot be procedurally generated, even if the room only contains a ledge that’s slightly too high to climb without a double jump. The paths that are procedurally generated still have to be fixed in space to ensure that you can’t get yourself stuck or break into areas early.
Every setpiece is marked on your map by the fact that it can’t be generated.
As a 2D action-platformer Roguelite, Sundered excels, but as a Metroidvania, it falls apart.
Simply put there is no world to explore in Sundered. The sprawling caverns are literally interchangeable by their very nature. There are no hidden upgrades, no perks, and no items to find. Important rooms are marked by having a different color on the map to represent how they aren’t being procedurally generated, so once you have the map for the area, you know exactly what’s important to you.
Exploration in Sundered has no reward.
(Clarification: there are perks and similar systems in Sundered, but they’re not hidden; they’re locked behind optional combat encounters.)
Why It’s a Problem
This may seem like an obvious answer if you’ve read the article up until this point, but it’s important to address nonetheless because, as stated previously, Sundered is an excellent game.
This major design flaw does not impact play. It does not interfere with combat, nor does it interfere with your mobility options. The various traversal tools in Sundered are fantastic, and some of the most interesting uses of 2D space, like the ability to run up any flat wall.
The problem here is one of audience.
This design flaw in the handling of mashing Metroidvania and Roguelite genres is a problem because it means that players expecting those genres will be disappointed. The Procedural Generation means there is nothing worth exploring, and the Metroidvania map layout means the paths aren’t truly random or diverse on subsequent runs.
While Sundered has succeeded in blending the gameplay of these genres, the means by which it has done so could easily alienate fans of both. Reading the reviews on Steam makes this abundantly clear. If Sundered wasn’t an excellent action-platformer, it could easily have collapsed under its own weight.
I discussed at length the combining of genres in last month’s What We Can Learn article. Sundered has combined two genres, and in some ways its done it well. However, by failing to support player motivations, both of the genres feel flatter, hollower, and less complete.
What Could They Have Done?
There is no one-size-fits all solution for any problem, and that is especially true for creative media such as games and game design. These alternative options I am presenting each come with their own significant design challenges, and as always, without personally interviewing Thunder Lotus Games, I can’t say for certain what specific goals they had for the project that could have made their chosen solution the optimal one.
The procedural generation of a roguelike/lite does not map well to the idea of exploring a world and discovering all of the ways that world is interconnected. Until a game developer invents a means of procedural generation that can actually create an entire Metroidvania on its own, there is no solution that will not in some way water down one or both styles of gameplay.
If you wanted to lean heavily on the Metroidvania, then creating a large, interconnected map standard of that genre, but then randomizing the movement upgrades given to the player would force the player to find new ways to navigate the map, changing up each playthrough considerably. However, doing this would require a wide array of movement tools and places to use these abilities to ensure that the randomization actually results in different paths through the world as the player progresses. The player would need to be able to reach at least one upgrade from anywhere on the map with any combination of upgrades to ensure that it’s impossible to get stuck.
In a similar vein, the player could be placed in a static world, such as the meticulously interconnected world of a Metroidvania, and given random objectives to complete at various places along the map. This would allow for map exploration while still maintaining randomized Roguelike/lite runs, but risks large parts of the map serving no purpose on any given run.
Sundered, and I feel the need to stress this because of how much I have derided it, is a good game. However, failing to properly accommodate player motivations and genre expectations can result in a shallower or less fulfilling gameplay experience.
Special thanks to my Tier 3 Patrons, Haelerin and Christos Kempf!