Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

As I have noted previously, games are a unique artistic medium thanks to their interactive nature. Being present within the world of the game, able to examine, explore, and interact at your own time poses a number of difficulties with maintaining a consistent pacing or tone. It can be hard to take a game’s narrative about a lack of control seriously when you can simply run around in circles being silly and the game is helpless to stop you.

However, interactivity also brings with it countless tools to bring new kinds of narratives to life, and to convey crucial story and character information in ways that other mediums cannot.

Originally released in 1994 before receiving a 2022 rerelease, classic JRPG Live A Live makes excellent work of many common and expected forms of gameplay to expand upon its narrative and themes. Live A Live is an anthology game, showcasing heroes from across space and time facing off against great evils. Each chapter presents a self-contained story and minor tweaks in gameplay that make each scenario feel unique without dramatically changing what the player is familiar with.

While this article is mostly dedicated to the means of conveying the narrative, as opposed to the narrative itself, we will be covering major spoilers for several chapters in the game, including the eighth chapter—notable for the fact that the chapter’s existence alone was a spoiler for the original release, and even in the remake the marketing remained extremely coy about what happens. If you care about spoilers, this is your chance to back out.

Story From Gameplay: RPG Elements

Like most games, the story of Live A Live is conveyed primarily through character dialogue and cutscenes. Live A Live takes this a step further than many similar 2D RPGs by having different sprites for several important characters to help convey their emotions, even for a silent protagonist. However, Live A Live is not content to stick within conventional narrative structures for games of its ilk when it could incorporate player interaction or game mechanics.

Even when Live A Live is an arcade fighting game or a survival horror game, it is an RPG. And it is through many RPG elements that even in 1994 were ubiquitous to the point of being genre standards that Live A Live expands upon its own narrative in clever ways.

The Shifu from the Imperial China chapter cannot gain experience or level up, thanks to his aging body beginning to fail him. Similarly, robots such as Taroiro from the Near Future chapter cannot gain experience because their bodies cannot be trained. Instead, robots are improved through the use of stat-increasing items specific to them, known as Robotic Enhancements, and learn new moves through equipment.

In The Middle Ages, when Streibough gains levels, his stat improvements are uniformly terrible, frequently getting a single improvement to most stats, and only if he’s very lucky getting a +3 or +4. While he has no need for his Physical Attack stat, it has a chance of not improving at all on a Level Up to further drive home his lack of improvement. His voiced barks generally have him comment that he’s not growing as much as he thought, or declaring that he will surpass protagonist Oerstead eventually. By contrast, Oerstead routinely has multiple stats increase by 3 or 4, including his stats that generally lend towards Magical Attacks despite being a physical attacker. Thus, Streibough’s hidden envy of Oerstead’s successes and inevitable betrayal are not only supported through dialogue, but gameplay. Especially as the third party member of the chapter, Uranus, is themselves a support spellcaster, further leaving Streibough behind.

Furthermore, the death of Hasshe and the faked-death of Streibough leaves you with only Oerstead and Uranus on your defeated trek back to Lucrece Castle to further contrast them.

Foreshadowing future events in a narrative can be surprisingly difficult to do well. Ideally, the audience won’t realize what exactly is being foreshadowed until the moment of the twist, at which point it will all become clear in hindsight, or on a second playthrough. Streibough’s horrible stat improvements create foreshadowing through encouraging player behavior. By having Oerstead’s stats consistently leave Stribough behind, and picking up additional party members to supplement Oerstead, the player is disincentivized to use Streibough more than they have to. And thus, when Streibough reveals that he feels himself cheated, sidelined, and abandoned by Oerstead’s successes, it is the player who feels the impact of leaving him behind.

Story From Gameplay: Shifting Scenarios

The chapters of Live A Live each tell their own complete stories within their own scenarios, with gameplay shifting to match. Sometimes this is simple, subtle changes like how the Prehistory chapter has no dialogue because language hasn’t been invented yet. Other chapters have more substantial changes.

The Twilight of Edo Japan chapter changes almost nothing of the gameplay, but recontextualizes its gameplay via story. The entire chapter is a prolonged dungeon crawl as the shinobi Oboromaru infiltrates the palace of the Ode clan to rescue an important prisoner. You are told at the start of the chapter that your approach is up to you: you may sneak through with your blade sheathed or you may paint the walls red in Ode clan blood. Few enemies respawn in this chapter to represent that you are indeed slaying your foes, and certain characters will react to you making your way through the castle without taking a life.

The meat of the Wild West chapter is a timed mission to scrounge supplies from a rundown settlement so that the locals can use them to set up traps for the approaching gang of outlaws out for your blood. The gunslinging protagonist of this chapter has been a loner for some time before the start of the chapter, and even when the gang first appears takes quite a bit of provocation before he involves himself. Tying the gameplay into relying on the people of the town enhances the themes of human connection.

The Present Day chapter is one of two radical departures from normal gameplay, being based on an arcade fighting game, letting you pick between six different opponents to battle against in a boss rush before a final opponent appears after the other six are bested. While the combat is identical to any other chapter—other than Masaru’s ability to learn certain moves that he’s hit with—this is the only chapter without any overworld or exploration.

The other major departure from traditional RPG gameplay is the Distant Future, which is a full-on horror game as the crew of the spaceship the Cogito Ergo Sum are slowly picked off, and you have to run from the large alien creature aboard the ship and the obstacles thrown at you by the ship’s malevolent AI. As the chapter progresses, attempting to use any terminal will have the ship’s AI taunt you that it has total control and you may as well surrender now. The remake added an additional touch, having this same taunting message replace the loading screen lore and hints, so that you the player are being mocked.

This is not the only time the game pulls the loading screen stunt, either. The final chapter has no loading screen text. Whether this is because your party isn’t familiar with the strange land they find themselves in, or because Lucrece is now devoid of human life is ambiguous. However, defeating a certain optional boss who has great knowledge of local events causes the loading screens to suddenly gain new hints and lore specifically from said boss. Now, the actions taken by the player have had a real impact on the flow of narrative information; by tying this to player successes, this makes the narrative change feel like a prize for the player.

None of these interactions are unique to Live A Live, but few games make any more than the basic use of them expected by most players. Live A Live’s narrative trickery is not done through clever programming, but by recognizing opportunities to add story to places that other games never think to. It’s true that many games use loading screens to provide lore or gameplay hints, but expanding on the present narrative using a loading screen is practically unheard of.

By recognizing interactions and gameplay systems as means of providing information to the player, Live A Live finds new ways to convey narrative themes, foreshadowing, character details, and plot elements.

Special thanks to my Tier 3 Patrons, Haelerin and Christos Kempf!

Comments

No comments found for this post.