What We Can Learn From: Legend of Zelda Tears of the Kingdom (Patreon)
Content
In a previous What We Can Learn essay, I described an important fundamental of game design, arguably the single most important. You Encourage the Behavior You Reward. I have chosen to word it this way for a reason. This principle is not only a way to guide player behavior in the ways that you want, but a warning. If you reward behavior that you don’t want players to engage with, then that’s what they will do regardless of your own desires.
During the 2016 Game Developers Conference, Mark Rosewater, lead designer of Magic: the Gathering, discussed various things he’s learned about game design over the twenty years he had worked on designing that game. Quote:
“It's not the players' job to find the fun. It is your job as the game designer to put the fun where the players can't help but find it. When the players sit down to play a game, there's an implied promise from the game designer that if they do what the game tells them to do, it will be fun. So most players will do whatever the game tells them to do to achieve the desired goal (usually win), even if that thing isn't fun. When the game is done, if the players didn't enjoy themselves, they will blame the game—and rightfully so!”
During his speech, he gave a humorous exaggeration of a game where players win by banging their heads against the table until they pass out which is not all that dissimilar to the stories of hand injuries related to spinning the control stick in the original Mario Party.
Breath of the Wild and its follow-up, Tears of the Kingdom, are based around this principle in many key ways, but in others, it inexplicably does the opposite. Punishing the player and forcing specific behaviors
Rewarding Exploration
Properly guiding player behavior requires designers to be constantly aware of where and how the game rewards the player. Many open world games are decried as being ‘empty’ or otherwise sparsely populated, but it would perhaps be more accurate to say that many of these games instead fail to properly reward exploration.
As documented by Mark Brown of Game Maker’s Toolkit, Nintendo wanted Breath of the Wild to encourage a more freeform experience of exploration while still guiding players towards important landmarks. This was achieved by spreading landmarks through the game’s wilderness, with the terrain designed to specifically limit visibility, so that there would only be a handful of landmarks on screen at once. From shrines to campfires to enemy encampments to stables, Breath of the Wild was designed to provide the player with reasons to stray from the physical roads of Hyrule while staying on a breadcrumb trail of details from tower to tower and plot beat to plot beat.
Tears of the Kingdom hasn’t changed this structure at all for the very simple reason that it works. However, the deep underground caverns known as The Depths present a problem with this system: visibility. The Depths are incredibly dark, making it difficult to spot the various landmarks dotting it until you locate a nearby Lightroot to illuminate the area. While the Lightroot can be found by using your map once you realize they correspond to the location of a Shrine on the surface (as helpfully mentioned by an NPC), the end result is that there is very little reason to do anything except beeline the next Lightroot so that you can actually get your bearings.
Mood, too, is important. The Depths are meant to invoke dread and fear. The use of Gloom as a status effect that lowers your maximum health until you reach a Lightroot or leave The Depths works for this purpose, but dread and fear and antithetical to exploration. On the surface, not knowing what’s behind the next hill could lead to all kinds of goodies or items or upgrades. In The Depths, you’re liable to accidentally run into an enemy camp or a field boss you weren’t prepared for and had no way of detecting ahead of time.
Sadly, there is very little incentive to explore The Depths. They become the barren, empty space I alluded to several paragraphs ago. Once you have enough health and decent weapons and armor, the dread and fear once imposed by the oppressive atmosphere gives way to boredom. Even illuminated, it’s hard to see in The Depths, leaving it feeling dull and uninteresting, which is even worse in the unilluminated areas where you may find yourself spending several minutes doing nothing but holding forward on the control stick and watching Link’s climbing animation.
While there are ways to provide temporary illumination to navigate The Depths, rather than creating a series of interesting landmarks and points of interest, Nintendo created something of a wasteland. The Depths serve as a mirror counterpart to the surface, and these parallels are often interesting, such as lavafalls underneath hotsprings, or how rivers and chasms are tall mountains. However, the lack of visibility means that actually seeing these interesting reinterpretations can be challenging, and any body of water on the surface is impassible in The Depths, forcing the player to find ways around, and to pay constant attention to the map of The Surface. After all, unless you can get a bow strong enough to illuminate the entire rockface in Brightbloom flowers, it’s almost impossible to know when a mountain goes all the way up to the ceiling of The Depths or is merely very tall.
Worse, the actual points of interest—the Abandoned Mines and Yiga Clan Bases—were often positioned so that you already knew where they were. Abandoned Mines are located directly below towns, for example. These locations granted new schematics for Autobuilding vehicles or charges to upgrade the player’s Zonai battery, but were sparsely scattered, and repetitive.
The ruins in the depths are somewhat more varied and usually infested with monsters. Avoiding these encounters is much easier than the other enemy camps in the Depths simply because it’s harder to accidentally obscure the only light source by approaching from the wrong angle, and these ruins each contain a special armor set—usually one that had been DLC in Breath of the Wild or a similar reference to a previous game—making them at least worth the trouble. However, several of these ruins have corresponding maps found in the Sky Islands telling you exactly where they are. Furthermore, while enemy camps in Breath of the Wild could be raided for useful weaponry, weapons in Tears of the Kingdom have all been decayed, so you won’t even get much loot from the monsters, either. More about combat, weapons, and fusing later.
The most useful thing that can be found in the Depths are the scattered stone mounds where a ghost of a Hylian soldier provides you with a Pristine Weapon, undecayed by Ganondorf’s malevolent magic. However, this system is obtuse, and easily overlooked if you aren’t aware that these weapons persist until collected. It’s possible to assume that the given weapons remain low-tier and weak throughout the entire game without realizing that the ghosts will provide stronger weapons after the weaker ones are collected, based on what weapons Link has used already.
The ultimate failure of The Depths, however, is the reward for acquiring every Lightroot. Completing every Shrine in Tears of the Kingdom grants you a special armor set that can be upgraded beyond any other, and comes with a unique appearance and flavor text. Activating every Lightroot grants you a medal in your inventory. Functionally, a gold star sticker. Congratulations for all the tedious work of navigating the darkness and dealing with Gloom.
There’s an odd beauty to The Depths, once you’ve grown accustomed to the dark plains and mountains, but there is ultimately little to do there over a long-term.
Rewarding Combat
Breath of the Wild is a great game released to universal praise, but it is not without flaw, and many of these flaws returned in Tears of the Kingdom.
One of them returned with a vengeance.
Allegedly, the point of weapon durability in Breath of the Wild and Tears of the Kingdom is to encourage experimentation with different weapons, equipment, cooking effects, or tactical approaches to encounters. In practice, results are decidedly more mixed.
Breaking the player’s weapon does not encourage them to find a new way to fight the enemy, it is forcing it. In fact, it’s closer to punishing the player for using weapons at all. However, while the fragile weapons of Breath of the Wild could be used to actually fight monsters, Tears of the Kingdom added the Weapon Fusion system. And you are going to use it whether you like it or not.
Fusing materials to weapons increases their damage and possibly their durability—not that the game tells you the latter. Your only indication of a weapon’s durability is when it’s at full, when it’s been used, and when it’s about to break. Anything more specific than that is asking too much. Certain materials also add additional effects to weapons, especially arrows.
But to ensure that players would use this system, Nintendo made the decision to take away all of the weapons. While an in-universe reason is given for the sudden decay of all weapons in Hyrule, it’s blatantly the developer holding you at metaphorical gunpoint until you get in line, made all the more obvious by how much stronger enemies are in Tears of the Kingdom from its predecessor.
There are times when field bosses will deal less damage to you than the highest tier of the most basic goblin with a stick.
Worse, every enemy now has far more health to encourage the use of stronger weapon fusions. However, weapon durability actively discourages such tactics. After all, you only get about twenty hits or so with any given weapon, and then the rare, valuable, powerful material is gone forever.
The most effective strategy for fighting enemies in Tears of the Kingdom is to not do it at all, to let the new Sage Spirits handle all of the fighting for you, since they will never have their weapons break.
Let me repeat that. The most effective strategy to fight enemies in Tears of the Kingdom is to not fight enemies.
Making weapon fusions mandatory through weapon durability has other problems as well. In Breath of the Wild, switching to a new weapon after one breaks barely affects the pacing of combat. But in Tears of the Kingdom, if you don’t have any other fused weapons, you need to go through the arduous process of pulling up the inventory menu, finding what you want to use, dropping it on the floor, and then activating the Fusion Power—which works in real time, meaning that you will have to run around defenseless for the two seconds or so this part takes while the enemy you broke your weapon against is free to attack you—and fuse the material to the new weapon.
The quick-access menu for materials only slightly alleviates this problem, as it contains every single possible material and unlike the inventory screen keeps everything in a single line instead of a wider grid. The sorting options exist and help, but are also limited.
Environmental solutions are rarely worth finding, either. The physics options in Tears of the Kingdom, such as pushing boulders down slopes to run over unsuspecting enemies, are oftentimes simply not present. At best you’ll find a way to reach the enemy so that you can sneak attack them undetected. And when such environmental weapons are available, they’re oftentimes exactly as ineffective as your weapons, but much harder to successfully use.
Tears of the Kingdom attempts to compensate for this by giving the player monster parts from defeated foes to fuse to their weapons. In theory this allows the player to upgrade themselves by fighting stronger and strong monsters, but in practice, the weapon durability means that even if a weapon can be used effectively against a powerful monster, it likely won’t last long enough to feel worth it.
The ultimate casualty of weapon durability continues to be The Master Sword.
Much like in Breath of the Wild, the Master Sword, the Sword of Evil’s Bane, the Sword that Seals the Darkness, the greatest sword ever forged… runs out of energy after a few brief encounters and needs ten real-time minutes to recharge. And while in Breath of the Wild, the Master Sword did considerable damage for being a longsword as you would expect, in Tears of the Kingdom, it remains useless until you fuse something to it.
This is especially egregious considering the role the Master Sword has in the narrative, resulting in its lack of gameplay functionality feeling like even more of a letdown. A form of ludonarrative dissonance where the story has emphasized it far beyond its gameplay capabilities.
Nintendo even seems to be aware of the problem, as the Master Sword will be instantly restored at the start of the final boss battle and never run out during that fight—a fact the player is unlikely to miss, considering that before you are allowed to fight the final boss, you must cut down several waves of enemies, guaranteeing that you’ll lose at least two weapons.
This approach to player behavior, of favoring the stick over the carrot, actively disincentivize much of the exploration and experimentation that Nintendo wanted to promote.
Special thanks to my Tier 3 Patrons, Haelerin and Christos Kempf!