What Can We Learn From: Deiland and Summer In Mara (Patreon)
Content
One of the biggest challenges in game design is communicating intent to the player. If a game designer is doing their job well, the player should understand what behaviors are expected of them to have an enjoyable experience with the game. As discussed in a previous What Can We Learn article, this is mainly achieved by rewards the desired behaviors—and sometimes by punishing undesired behaviors, like breaking weapons that you use too frequently, or upping the difficulty if you spend too long in one place.
However, gameplay is not the only way that a player can be rewarded. Narrative is a crucial part of many games, and even games with barely existent excuse plots still have a plot to provide context for the player’s actions.
Rewarding the player with story content isn’t new—it’s the basic premise behind almost every single story told through video games as a medium, from main plot progression to flavor text and world details provided by item flavor text. However, using narrative as a reward is very different from reward the player through gameplay.
Chibig Studio’s debut title, Deiland—later delisted in favor of its remake, Deiland Pocket Planet—and its prequel Summer In Mara are extremely similar games, perhaps unsurprisingly. They share a near-identical Primary Gameplay Loop. That is, the second-to-second or minute-to-minute gameplay, such as the gunplay in a shooter or each turn in a strategy game. Both of them are cozy farming games about a small child singlehandedly solving everyone’s problems by growing crops and collecting materials to craft into items or cook into food, and deliver to NPCs.
As a matter of fact, several characters appear in both titles.
What this means is that Chibig has effectively created two games that consist almost entirely of fetch quests, and more specifically the kind you usually see as a minor side quest in larger titles. The kind of fetch quests that are generally mocked with stereotypes like ‘Kill 10 Rats’ or ‘Fetch 3 Flowers’. And yet, paradoxically, they made it work.
Context As Motivation
Priming your players for a specific style of play is part of the job of not only game design but marketing. A trailer giving you incorrect impressions of what a game will be like can negatively color your experiences with it, even if the game itself is good, because you came at the game anticipating a different kind of play.
It is also possible to interrupt the flow of expected play through gameplay—the much detested Forced Stealth Sections in action games are frequently cited as this kind of interruption.
However, by leaning into the flow of the game, it’s possible to enhance the experience through player expectation.
For example, both Deiland and Summer In Mara require time to pass for crops to grow—Deiland uses a real-time clock while Summer In Mara tracks the passage of in-game days. This encourages players to take it slow, since they’re already waiting for time to pass anyways. While your crops are growing, why don’t you gather fruit from trees? Or perhaps feed animals to start their own timers towards giving you materials and resources.
Summer In Mara also gives players the ability to sail mostly freely around Mara, for both resource collecting and exploration purposes, giving more incentive to allow time to progress normally instead of deliberately jumping ahead.
Both games have few gameplay rewards for the completion of objectives. Usually a new decorative structure, sometimes a new crop you can grow like any other, and rarely a new functional structure for your farm, like the aforementioned animal pens. Tool upgrades to expand your progress are only given out as part of story progress, limiting what you can do until then.
The main reward that comes with completing objectives in these games is the opportunity to speak with the characters and learn more about their lives.
While main story progress will, naturally, reward the player by progressing the game’s plot, each major character has their own chain of side objectives that you can use to learn more about who they are, and their relationships with the other characters. Not only does this make the shared setting of these games feel more alive, but it makes it easier for the player to grow attached to characters and their own journeys.
Furthermore, these characters can interact with one another, showing further depth to their personalities and relationships, both pre-existing and how they change over the course of the game.
Each character’s personal quest chain progresses as it’s own, smaller story, more personal to the character involved. From watching Brram’s early career as a chef in Summer In Mara knowing that he’ll own his own restaurant by the time of Deiland, to Caleb and Noho’s relationship to Aquilla’s mysterious past to Akaji’s personal project that you can personally find sailing around Mara, the island of Qalis feels bustling even though the characters rarely move from their spot.
These character-focused side stories flesh out not only the major cast, but also the setting of Chibig’s shared universe, tightly playing to the studio’s strengths in character writing.
Failing To Plan
While the use of narrative as a reward for player progress can be a powerful force to encourage player behavior, even in optional side activities, it also comes with its own drawbacks if not properly thought through. One of the biggest ways this can be seen is in the structural differences between Deiland and Summer In Mara. The most notable drawback is the risk of a lack of agency.
Deiland is heavily inspired by Antonie de Saint-Exupery’s The Little Prince. The titular planet is an incredibly tiny one home to only the game’s protagonist. Other characters visit Deiland via their spaceships, allowing you to meet them. However, because you remain largely stuck to your own planet, progress is largely out of your hands while you wait for the necessary characters to appear. With no means of progressing the game beyond completing quests for NPCs, you have nothing to do until the plot literally comes to you.
Chibig seemed aware of this problem, as Summer In Mara gives you access to your own boat very early on, with your only restriction on where you travel being a certain radius around the game’s beginning that widens as you progress.
Of course, this is not a perfect solution, or at least, on its own, does not fix a lack of agency in the narrative. Many RPGs have been criticized for having the important story moments occur offscreen, in cutscene, or performed by NPCs as opposed to the player character—especially when these are then attributed to the player despite their lack of involvement. Inversely, an entirely linear game can maintain player agency by making the player character have an active role in the storyline even without giving the player any form of branching narrative choice.
Summer In Mara handles this by making the player character the driving force of the main plot. At no point is she actually forced to do something that she doesn’t want to, although she may not be happy about the hoops she’s forced to jump through to get certain other characters to act. While other characters advice and help her thanks to their experience and wisdom, the player is rarely asked to carry out the plan of someone else. Rather, they assist you so that you can move on yourself.
Narrative in games serves as both a framework to contextualize gameplay and player action, a means of parsing the images and sounds on the screen—and as a means of progression. It can be used as a reward for player behavior, and to encourage that behavior. But like all forms of design, it has to be thought through and executed for the benefit of the player.
Special thanks to my Tier 3 Patrons, Haelerin and Christos Kempf!