Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hey there everyone! And an extra special welcome to all the new Patrons!

Since many of you are here for Fill In The Jank Season 2, I wanted to start right away with production. It's going to take a few weeks to get everything ready, so it's best to get your input as soon as possible.

I've got several poll questions I plan to ask in the coming week, but before I do, I wanted to have a general survey.

What you all are looking for in a season 2? What do you want to change? What do you want to keep the same? Any ideas for how to improve the show? Let me know all your ideas in the comments to this post, and I'll incorperate all the best ones into the upcoming poll.

Comments

Xaldreca

I think giving a minimum amount of Genesys points to all players, around 10 or so, would be fun. Additionally, I would recommend mixing Extra Deck Types. One week they get Fusions and XYZs, the next they get Synchros and Links. That type of dynamic.

Nicolas Aizpurua

Have viewers vote to award a coin for most creative/interesting deck (either in place of or in addition to the one you award)!

Luke Hayward

I think it would be fun to have 2 half decks each week and have them randomly assigned to each player but don't tell them who has what. This will add an extra element of strategy and deck build variety while still making it easy for inexperienced players to work with it.

Luke Hayward

I second this, but we need to be careful not to let it devolve into just giving the weaker players coins every week

Hamyton

I think actually having an extra deck all the time or the ability to add cards to the extra deck to some extent would be a good addition to the deck building creativity but you said that in the funding video. What I think is that maybe you should have episodes where different formats are played, like maybe one episode you do the N/R special, another could be the Edison week, really show the players other parts of yugioh so they can get the full experience

Markus Manssen

To raise popularity maybe bring in other guest Yugitubers but only to have them come up with the half-deck + introduction (with some cross-checking from you) and perhaps rate the decks for creativity at the end.

Hardleg

The only potential problem with that, is that every coin would be a delivered a week after the fact. Which means the final episode wouldn't have a coin, since the season would be over by the time ya'll see the episode and vote.

Nazgul4

I think it was in Filler in the Jank when someone suggested that we can keep the Extra Deck, but you give them specific cards (or a list of cards they can use) and they just fill in the main deck.

Sultan

I think season 2 should include the extra deck as it's fundamental to a lot of archetypes but it should have heavy restrictions so that it doesn't feel like they are playing modern yugioh like the later half of season 1. I suggest that the extra deck be LOCKED as in they can't add cards to it and can only use the cards provided that way we can still include modern archetypes and extra deck summoning mechanics but it's curated so that they can do what the archetype wants but with controlled power level for more fun games.

Sultan

I feel that fill in the jank was best when they weren't trying to build boards on turn 1 so if you don't feel there is a good enough restriction to stop that type of game play while having an extra deck I would be fine with getting rid of it

PhoenixDarkKnight

I think the extra deck shouldn't be fixed but limit it to like 8-10 cards max, aka give them half the extra deck for the core archetype cards but give them room to add in tech options/ more archetype extra deck cards, maybe go full genesis rules so no links/pendulum unless the preset deck calls for them. I feel the extra deck adds an extra level of deckbuilding that kinda feels bad without it.

PhoenixDarkKnight

I get that build a board turn one is the least fun part of modern yugioh a board should take a couple of turns to establish, removing links and pends to an extent limits the amount of build a board that can occur, one maybe two negates is possible to play through,

Starpe __

I think the limits to the extra deck should be on a per-episode basis, OR, tied to the wheel in some way. Maybe make a second wheel with 16 options to say how much extra deck space everyone has(as in spin once to decide for everyone so things are equal), and don't provide decks with inherent extra deck slots. If you don't want that extra complication though then just default to 5 slots lol

Mark Chang

1. More Bloopers. 2) If the goal is to teach people to play Yu-Gi-Oh, try one episode where they all play the same deck and can focus on their playing skills. Then an episode when they all get cards from 1 set list to try and focus on their deck-building skills. III. If you have time, you can try do your own build of a deck. That way, they can compare how they built it compared to a Yu-Gi-Oh veteran. Fourth More Critter.

Supermetroidfan

I think allow the extra deck when it makes sense to the theme now. But use it to sort of show how much a deck is meant to play into it. Like if you did another episode with zombies, include maybe 4-6 tool box monsters, and don't let contestants add. Then for an episode that is meant to play into an extra deck, give them up to maybe 7, and let them determine what they want. So they'd still follow a concept but have creativity. I'd also like some access to Genesis points for everyone, it might help them play with a more adaptable plan. Maybe like 20 at most as an allowance every episode? And I would really like to see an under dog coin. Where we could vote in some way for who struggles the most at like the half way mark in the series might be fun!

D_D_DAmericaD_D_D_Deutscher

I was hoping Joe would ask us changes to FITJ season 2: Now if we look at this show in terms of any other series/anime then season 1 was our intro to the gang, their intro to Yu-Gi-Oh, and there Training arc. Now like any good anime/series they need a villain/unified goal to overcome with their training, so here are two ways we can make season two different: 1.) We put the gang in groups of two and put them in Master Duel ranked. The first episode they can work together, go nuts with the decks, and see which team reaches master 1 first by the end of the season. (Each week their decks get nerfed by punishment wheels) 2.) we put the gang in groups of 2, they duel against us Legos to see which gets more points by the end of FITJ season 2 team FITJ or team lego (us) , first episode they and we go crazy with our decks, then each week we spin two wheels. 1 wheel for them 1 wheel for us to restrict our decks. I really like FITJ as much as anyone but I feel like for season 2 if we don't add some different aspect to it then we're just re hashing the same thing. I'm 100% open to feedback from Joe the Legos and the FITJ crew. Hope this helps Joe. ✌️

Tengen Toppa Bob Ross

Opening up the Extra Deck to allow folks to dip their toes in. Learn about each one without being overwhelmed.

Spudivo

I think there needs to be some kind of balancing factor for wins, but I'm struggling to think on how to implement one. Maybe some kind of king of the hill where the winner gets an extra perk like some Genesis points, but the other 3 get to restrict them in some way. The restrictions could be in a small pool of options like add 5 cards to the minimum deck limit, reduce extra deck size by 2, or must play 2 normal monsters. I love who you cast and vibes felt great, but multiple times it felt like there was 1 guy who knew the game beating up on the new players.

Aly

Maybe having like 3-5 slots in the extra deck where they can put any type of ED card they want ? This would mean having a mini ED during non-ED focused episodes, and having the possibility to mix ED card types during ED focused episodes. One con of that however would be that it could lead to too much focus on the ED monsters...

CVSama

It was mentioned in the final episode of season 1, but having the wheel give both a restriction and a free card could make for some interesting deck building ideas. Alternatively you could put Genesys points on the wheel with each restriction to allow more overbearing restrictions to have at least a little incentive to keep

Tea

I think the format you landed on for the wheel by the end was good, but it should have been based on overall points rather than the previous episodes outcome. I think your suggestion for what to do with the extra deck and to give them 10 genesys points both sounded good. I think if someone manages to lose consecutive weeks they should accumulate the genesys points until they don't come in last, and lose them as normal. I think the wheel restrictions were good as they did encourage deck variety, but certain restrictions were extremely punitive depending on the week and if the people in 3rd or 4th are struggling and they still manage to end up with a really bad restriction then that would feel a bit unfair, so I think if that happens you should offer them some kind of trade deal where you pick a restriction you think would be more appropriate and see if they want to swap (or some other way of avoiding it, maybe they trade some of their genesys points to swap the restriction). I think Arim was a bit too dominant, but I'm not sure what you could do to avoid that other than giving more comeback mechanics for last place and drawbacks for those ahead. More Jank would also be good, my suggestions would be Ojamas, Arcana Force, Chemicritters, Paleozoics, Dustons, Nemleria, Ghosttricks, Nouvelles. You could also vary the format more between episodes, similar to the filler episode, but like maybe one week they work in teams and both use the same deck, or they all build decks which are then randomly assigned, or they do a tag duel.

GearOverlord

Giving all of the players 10 to 15 Genesis points would be fun and as you said in the episode it would let more of the players experiment with more popular cards. Limiting the extra deck to between 5 and maybe 7 but the last place player can go to 10 cards. Maybe give the option to buy more extra deck slots with their Genesis points. 5 points a slot sounds fair.

brian luyckx

I would go for a raise in the genesys points. Example: everyone gets 10 points in the beginning, Second duel the winner starts with a bonus of 2 extra genesys points on the 10 that he already had. And keeps staking the points for every victory. ( Max 3 ) After 3 consecutive wins al the other player gets a 10 additional point start. (So they are back even , and can maybe create some very interesting deck builds. Wheel stays of course. But in addition of playing under certain harder conditions they can get a boost of a certain amount of points added to the points for that episode. It can end up a pretty hard fight like that 😉

SAMURIADI

limit cards that have the word "negate" that are in the extra to one, that way we dont have a speedroid stomp. as fun as speedroids are getting 2+ negates when the original was fire/warrior/pendulum is a bit off putting

Christopher McGuirk

I like the nature of the contest as friendly competition and the show's focus on learning, and I do also like the banter, so I think keeping time limits off is overall better. Even though there have been some turns where I'd wish a move would be made already, for me overall the scales still tip towards banter. I think the idea of everyone getting a few Genesys points is good; maybe that escalates each season and thematically represents growth. I think it was nice that the finale had the most deckbuilding freedom available; it's upping the intensity for the season finale. I think it could also be fun if Joe needs to make a deck for the season finale and the winner of the season gets to challenge him.

Legacy Crusaders Yugioh

Current ranking can give a set number of genesys points, with a minimum set for the start for tied record, like everyone gets 25, then there record by percentage can split the 100 points where needed, so after 1 episode, one person would be 2-0 another 1-1, and 1-1, and then 0-2, so they can be at 0, 25, 25, 50. in the next episode. You can also include some pointed cards in the half decks that are free, like consistency cards they would not have to use points on like a foolish burial. I thought the filler in the jank was my favorite episode. Something about the boss rush was cool. Maybe it can be a planned thing or can just be filler again. The player names choices for the wheel was really cool and once it broke it was sad, but that seems like something that could've been corrected just using obs with a color source and a text source just covering hard leg with the correct name. They probably should do a proper full pendulum episode, with just pends, maybe given them some really basic links, like traffic ghost or link spider, or lanphorlynkis so they have the chance of pending 2 from extra. I feel like they didn't do too much real pending in the pend episode. If you try really hard you can try to make balanced (none way more powerful) half decks and the wheel could be for the half decks, then they can build decks to counter the decks that were spun, but they can't go to hard on one cause their matchups are random, or they can build to punish the top player. Below is just a bunch of ideas of things that could be done in episodes under the idea of teaching new players things... things such as conjunctions, giving them a bunch of cards that miss timing, and will cause the missing of timing (trap holes) and cards that can special via chain link 2 like e-tele. Activate once per turn/use once per turn cards can be in a deck with a bunch of cards that can negate effects, or activations. Hard once, soft Once. Rest of the turn locks, and During the turn locks. Equipment spells, and how bad they are. Targeting vs non-targeting, not targetable, non destructible, sent vs destroyed, vs tributed. Costs vs effects. Chain blocking. Alternate Win Conditions. Burn, Deck Out, Exodia Side decking, or building for best of one but for the meta, by giving them each different half decks and have them build to beat each others half decks with the rest of their cards. They could also have to use each one once. Maybe one day on what ritual summoning is, and another on the ways we break it, drytron, nekroz, mitsu. Just spitballing ideas.

ViridianRaven

I'm going to split my suggestions into two parts, editing and gameplay: Editing: The duelling needs to be clearer on a lot of things: who's playing, what their restrictions are, and who's talking. My suggested layout would be to have the two duelists have their PNG avatars separate from the spectator's gallery. If you want to get fancy, having a cool graphic slide in (akin to a fighting game intro or Pokemon battle) at the start of the duel could be fun. Either way I'd like to see some kind of reminder, at least at the start of the duel, of what the match up is. Gameplay: - I like the wheel of restrictions idea because it ensures different decks get built rather than everyone showing up with the same stuff, but it definitely needs some tweaks. My personal idea: the person in last gets the "wheel of bonuses" - extra genesys points, a generic link monster or two, or something bonuses. I'd stay from power 1 of cards like Pot of Greed and instead give them tools to build around or ways to boost the power/consistency of the strategy they choose. - Secondarily, you could have a separate wheel of harsher restrictions for the person in first. However I do think some of kind of "restrictions draft" could be interesting - you spin a whole bunch of restrictions, then the person in last place picks first, and so on down the order until the winner gets stuck with the last one. Could be hype if someone picks an interesting restriction because they think they can cook. - Regarding power level - I think the fusion episode was a good power level to shoot for. Had some comboing and creativity without going too far, vs. say the XYZ episode which had some very powerful boards.

Alotaro

My one real concrete suggestion, that i haven't already seen someone note, would be to, now that you have covered the different summoning types and extra deck mechanics, to move more towards in essence exploring common mechanical gimmicks for archetypes. Like, just as off hand examples, graveyard recursion decks, counter(the thing you put on a card) decks, counter trap decks, banish focused decks, so on. I also think, and this is more something I've seen others pitch as well, that i think there needs to be more of a limit of some kind on the Extra deck. Not to remove it entirely, but my suggestion would be to have you pick all or most of the cards that are in the extra, or, to allow some more freedom in variety and focus, to pick cards which they then get to choose the specific ratios for. The second example there basically being to move it away from having a blacklist(banlist) of extra deck cards and instead have a Whitelist, so you can have more certainty in the uniform power level of their extra decks.

Dracodragon

If a deck needs points to be playable give them the exact amount of points for it but make it an option to use them on anything that way they could experiment with ratios and it could be a choice between playing more handtraps, boardbreakers or playing a more consistant engine