Rachel’s Demons 3 (Patreon)
Content
Author’s Note: This is an AU out-of-canon short story I intended as a Halloween special, but didn’t finish in time. So, please enjoy this version of a short Rachel story ahead of the current story. You might recognize some characters, and some details are intentionally vague to avoid spoilers. This story’s canonicity is dubious until we get there in the main one, which will be… soon-ish. Happy belated Halloween!
~~~
Rachel sighed, staring at the empty bed across from hers. Mindy had barely been in the room all week, and Rachel worried for her physical, mental, and spiritual health. The girls she’d been hanging with were bad influences, and she wasn’t just saying that because they didn’t invite her along. They were atheists and pagans who had her dressing and acting differently from how she was during orientation weekend.
Then there was Mindy’s new boyfriend, the incubus from hell with his demonic, lustful ways. He’d recently tried to trick Rachel into discussing things with a therapist at the school, just to dissuade her from thinking of him as what he truly was. She wouldn’t fall for his tricks. The therapist had been fine, but she wasn’t going to ‘open her mind’ or ‘consider other perspectives’ so that Arthur could hypnotize her into becoming his concubine. If he wanted to tempt her away from what was right, he’d have to work a lot harder than that.
In fact, she planned to go on the offensive. She’d stop him from seducing any more young women, even if she had to infiltrate the women he surrounded himself with. Arthur was a demon of pure lust, and she wouldn’t let him get away with corrupting any more women around him.
Rachel slipped out of bed and stepped into the common room. The RA had helped Bella and Sarah decorate for Halloween, but Rachel didn’t participate. Neither had Mindy, but that was because she was never around. Her and Mindy’s door had the same decorations as it did during orientation weekend.
Bella and Sarah were on their way out, both dressed in the skimpiest Halloween outfits Rachel had ever seen. She could barely even call Sarah’s a costume, and Bella was indecent, even for her.
“Bella, what the h-e-c-k are you wearing?” Rachel asked. She spelled out the word heck, but she was sure Bella got her meaning.
Bella stopped and looked at Rachel. “Rachel, why aren’t you in your costume? We’re going to the party, right? You said you were going as a chauffeur?”
Rachel frowned. She didn’t remember that conversation. She looked to Sarah for help.
“We were talking about going to the party.” Sarah gestured to herself and Bella. “You were on the sofa, listening in, and said we needed a chaperone. Bella suggested you come as a chauffeur, and you laughed and said yeah,” Sarah summarized. “Remember?”
Rachel didn’t remember the conversation, but assumed from Sarah’s recounting that she hadn’t been serious. “What would a chauffeur outfit even be?” Rachel asked.
“Suit jacket and booty shorts,” Bella said. “Or something. Knowing you, it’d just be a suit.”
“I don’t have a suit,” Rachel said. “Men wear suits, ladies wear dresses, and I’m not partying! You shouldn’t either. It’s dangerous and evil.”
Bella laughed.
Rachel didn’t.
“Oh, shit, you’re serious,” Bella said.
Rachel flinched at the curse word.
“It’s a party, Rachel. We’re freshmen in college. This is what we do!” Bella said. “Don’t get your panties in a twist.”
“Be nice, Bella,” Sarah said. “The poor girl’s so sheltered she doesn’t know how to have a good time. She thinks if she enjoys herself, she’ll end up in hell.”
“That’s not–” Rachel tried to protest, but the jabs hurt, and she didn’t know what to do. Bella and Sarah were supposed to be her friends. Heck, Mindy was supposed to be her friend, too, but she was never there. Rachel stamped her foot and crossed her arms, but it only made Bella and Sarah laugh more, as if she were the immature one.
“Look, don’t worry about it,” Bella said. “You can stay here, but we’re going to the party. You’re welcome to join us, though! We’ll put together a killer costume for you.”
“What’s wrong with my outfit?” Rachel asked, gesturing to herself. Her floor-length wool skirt, thigh-length sweater, and blouse made a modest outfit in cozy fall colors of brown and orange. It was warm enough to wear outside, and comfortable enough to wear indoors, which made it perfect.
“You can’t go to the party looking like a Sunday school teacher.” Bella pointed at her sweater. “That’s not a costume. That’s a buzzkill.”
“I’m not a buzzkill,” Rachel protested. “I just don’t want anyone to roofie your drinks!”
“That’s why we’re going together and taking precautions,” Sarah said. “Look, just borrow one of Mindy’s outfits, alright? You two have the same bust size under those sweaters. You can keep us safe and make sure we don’t drink too much.”
“We’re still drinking, though,” Bella said. “But that’s not a bad idea. Borrow one of Mindy’s skirts and a top, and bam: sexy secretary or sexy schoolgirl outfit. You’re ready to go.”
“Rachel’s got more butt than Mindy does, though,” Sarah said. “And wider hips. Maybe one of your skirts, Bella, and one of Mindy’s tops?”
“I can spare a skirt,” Bella said. She turned, giving Rachel a side view. Her ridiculous outfit was nothing more than a pink-and-tan tube top, a belt, and a canvas ‘skirt’ made of two fabric panels. Calling it a skirt was a lie. It was a loincloth. Gold earrings and a gold necklace completed the outfit, but Rachel didn’t know what her ‘costume’ was.
“I’m not wearing a skirt like that,” Rachel said, pointing at Bella’s skirt. “What are you even supposed to be?”
Bella laughed. “I’m Chel, from Road to El Dorado!”
Rachel stared at her. She’d heard of the movie, but she hadn’t seen it. It was from the same studio as The Prince of Egypt, but her parents said it was about two men pretending to be gods. They didn’t want her watching it.
“Look, it’s slim pickings for Latina icons, and I’m tired of going as Selma Hayek characters,” Bella said. “It was this or sexy nun, but everyone’s going as sexy nun. Spirit Halloween didn’t even have any. So are you coming? I’ll get you a pleated skirt. Now, hurry.”
“I can’t steal a shirt from Mindy!” Rachel protested.
Sarah sighed. “It’s not stealing. It’s borrowing. Come on.” Sarah pushed her into the room and moved to Mindy’s closet, combing through it until she found a top she liked. “Here we go,” she said. “This is workable.”
The top was a button-down blouse, but cropped so that half of it was missing under the bust.
“Take your sweater off and get out of that garbage bag of a skirt,” Sarah said.
Rachel was halfway to obeying before she stopped herself. “Please, can I just wear my clothes?”
“Your clothes aren’t a costume, and this is a college Halloween party. You’re already way overdressed just wearing this, but I know you won’t wear just your bra,” Sarah said, gesturing to herself. She wore a ripped satin nightie, with blood stains beneath and on it. Rachel could see her panties through the torn holes, but it seemed unintentional as she moved. The hole that exposed her stomach with her budding abs was intentional. The torn hole ended in the middle between her navel and her breasts, and just below the low waistband of her panties when she moved the right way. It didn’t look like she was wearing a bra, though. Her nipples looked like they wanted to poke through the material.
“Maybe you should change and wear something less revealing?” Rachel asked. “You wouldn’t want to stir up lust in anyone.”
Sarah gave her an amused expression. “Uh, yes, I would,” she said, chuckling. “There’s this guy in my chem class, Julian. He’s super cute, a bit of a dork, but I’m hoping he asks me out tonight if I play my cards right. I mean, look at me. How could he resist if I lean forward like this?” She pressed her arms together as she leaned over, showing Rachel how far the nighty fell away from her unrestrained breasts, which were small but lewd.
“Wouldn’t he have to ask your father first?” Rachel asked, looking at Sarah, confused. “And you shouldn’t lean over! I can see straight down your nightie! You need a bra!”
Sarah laughed. “You’re hilarious,” she said, tossing the top to Rachel. “Now, come on.” She clapped her hands. “Strip!”
Rachel turned away, turning her back to Sarah. She set Mindy’s shirt on the desk and pulled one from her closet that was the same, but longer. A long, white, collared button-down shirt she could tuck into her pants. She had to swap out her bra, changing her canvas-colored one for a frilly white one that wouldn’t show through.
She put the bra on, then the shirt, and buttoned it, only for Sarah to undo the top four buttons when she turned around. Rachel re-buttoned them, but Sarah smacked her hands.
“Stop that,” Sarah warned. “You should look sexy. Isn’t there a guy you want to notice you tonight? I saw the way you look at that violin player in the quad.”
Rachel’s cheeks burned hot as coals at the mention of Theodore.
“Ah, see?” Sarah nudged her. “Come on, let’s see what Bella found for you.”
Bella was waiting for them in the common room and tossed a gray pile of cloth at Rachel as soon as they left her room. “There you go!” Bella said, snapping her fingers. “Now, please tell me you have some Mary Janes.”
Rachel looked confused as she held the pleated skirt out in front of her. “Where’s the rest of it?” she asked, looking over it at Bella.
Bella laughed. “Girl, take off that baggy pile of cloth and put on that skirt. Come on! We’re late!”
Rachel went back into her room and emerged a moment later in black Mary Janes, white socks, and Bella’s skirt. She tugged at the hem with every step. At its longest, it reached the middle of her thighs, but the fold was heavy enough to stay against her legs with its many pleats.
“You wear this places?” Rachel asked, looking at Bella in disbelief.
“Of course!” Bella said. “If guys don’t notice you in that, they’re blind! You’re so hot!”
“What?” Rachel asked, confused. “No, I look like a slut. I don’t want guys to notice me. This is ridiculous.” She closed the top buttons on her shirt again. “You can’t expect me to wear this to a party?”
“You can stay here,” Bella said, giving Sarah a look that said something Rachel wasn’t meant to understand. “But we’re going. So if you want to come with us and keep us safe, you’ll have to come wearing that. You don’t have time to change, and it’s a cute costume! It’s just a sexier version of whatever they had you wear at that uptight Catholic school, right?”
“I’m not Catholic,” Rachel said, as though it were an insult. “And I was homeschooled.”
“That tracks,” Sarah said, nodding. “But tonight! We party!”
Rachel twirled her hair in her fingers, playing with the ends. “What should I do with my hair?”
“Braid it on the way! Now, come on!” Bella pointed toward the door. “Party, here we come!”
Sarah laughed and threw her arms around both Rachel and Bella. Rachel was lucky enough to grab her purse on the way out, but Bella and Sarah ignored her protests about her skirt’s length. They swept her along, chanting about the party until they hit the exit in the dorm’s lobby.
The October chill swept over them in a breeze that made Rachel hold her skirt in place, one hand in the back, the other in the front. Her plain white panties covered her more than Sarah’s black underwear or Bella’s loincloth, but they weren’t something that anyone needed to see.
She sighed, but she’d never admit how much gratitude she had that they brought her along for their safety.
“So what’s up with you?” Sarah asked, nudging Rachel. “I know your parents were strict, but is Halloween, like, no fun at your house? You act as if you’ve never worn a costume before.”
Rachel shook her head. “It’s the devil’s holiday.”
“Isn’t it a holy day?” Bella asked. “All Hallows’ Eve. Hallow means holy, right?”
Rachel shook her head. “It’s not about the day, but what people do on it. It’s a time for Satan worship and satanic rituals. I have a tract about it if–” She reached into her purse, but Sarah stopped her.
“Not to stifle your spirit or anything, but please don’t hand out any tracts at this party. Be cool,” Sarah said. “Those guys in the lounge still make fun of you for giving them that tract about Dungeons & Dragons.”
“They should know the dangers!” Rachel protested.
“Honey, no,” Bella said, shaking her head. “Be cool. That tract was ridiculous, by the way. D&D is nothing like that.”
Rachel frowned. She’d rather be secure in her eternal destination than considered ‘cool’ by her peers. And how did Bella know what the tract said, or what D&D was like? Had one of those guys tricked her into playing?
“Halloween is my favorite time of year,” Sarah said. “I’m not as big on it as I used to be, but it’s a lot of fun. My whole family went as the Addams Family last year. I was Wednesday.”
“Really?” Bella asked. “I never pegged you as a goth chick.”
Sarah chuckled. “Oh, I’m sure I have some pictures if you scroll back far enough on my Insta. I tried to make it spooky season all year long my junior year, but the makeup was expensive.”
Bella laughed.
“Halloween’s my least favorite time of year,” Rachel admitted. “My friends always made fun of me for not going trick-or-treating.”
“You’ve never been trick-or-treating?” Bella asked, shocked. “Ever?”
Rachel shook her head. “My church does a harvest festival instead.” The harvest festival was her pastor’s idea of a fun alternative to the satanic holiday. “They had a hayride, booth games in the Fellowship Hall, and we wore Bible-themed costumes. It was fun when I was little, but I outgrew it.”
“That sounds…” Sarah trailed off, unsure what to say, and looked to Bella for help.
“Fun?” Bella asked. She shrugged. “Not as fun as trick-or-treating, but maybe they’ll have bobbing for apples and stuff at the party? Is that what you meant by booth games?”
Rachel raised her eyebrows. Actual party games might be fun so long as they weren’t beer pong or strip poker. She’d seen a movie once where a bunch of college kids had a party. It was a Family Films movie, and it ended up being a warning about drinking and driving. The characters in that movie had gotten up to some pretty sinful things before they died and went to hell. She hoped this party wasn’t like that. So long as no one started a game of Truth or Dare, they should be fine.
“Maybe we should go back,” Rachel said. “I don’t think I can play any games in this outfit; the skirt is too short.”
Bella checked the skirt and shook her head. “Rachel, the skirt is fine. You’re covered! It’s just showing some of the skin above the knee. It looks good on you! And it won’t fly up on its own. Just keep your legs together when you sit, and you’ll be fine.”
Rachel frowned but didn’t protest. She always kept her legs together, anyway.
“Oh, hey!” Sarah said, waving to someone in the distance. “There’s Mindy!”
Mindy ran up to them, laughing, with someone following behind her. She’d been between two girls, holding their hands. Normally, Rachel wouldn’t have thought anything of it, but given the temptations that Mindy faced, she worried that the other women had been trying to seduce her into sin.
“Wow,” Bella said, looking Mindy over. “Girl, you look hot!”
Mindy giggled. “Thanks! I can’t wait to see Arthur’s costume! Rani wouldn’t let me see it before the party. We’re meeting him there.”
Rani waved from behind Mindy, catching up with a stroll after Mindy ran ahead. Another girl walked with them, but Rachel didn’t recognize her. Their ‘costumes’ were indecent.
“Who’s your new friend?” Bella asked.
“This is Yvonne,” Mindy said, gesturing to the new girl. “Rani and I are working on seducing her into our cult.”
Rachel gasped, covering her mouth with her hand.
“Now, you’ve done it,” Bella sighed. “It’s not a cult, Rachel. Mindy was just making a joke because you keep calling it one.”
Mindy nodded and turned toward Rachel, but her smile vanished. A hard, hateful look came into her eyes. “Hi, Rachel.”
Rachel froze, unsure of what to say. Mindy’s hostility wasn’t something she expected. She’d been all smiles before, so it made no sense. Come to think of it, she’d been avoiding Rachel for the last two weeks. Had her boyfriend done something to her with his Incubus ways? Did he turn her against Rachel so that Rachel couldn’t save her from his cult?
“Whoa, what’s up?” Sarah asked, looking between them. “Did something happen between you two?”
“No,” Rachel said. “Mindy, are you okay?”
“No?” Mindy asked. “So you didn’t out me to my mother as a bisexual and show her my private sketchbooks that you stole from under the bed and vandalized? And you didn’t beg my boyfriend to dump me after you ambushed him at his therapy appointment?”
Bella and Sarah both turned to stare at Rachel, open-mouthed in shock, as if Mindy had just accused her of streaking across campus.
“I was trying to help you!” Rachel said. “Your mom needed to stop you from going down the wrong path.”
“Am I the wrong path?” Rani asked, arriving at the group. “I’m a fucking wonderful influence, I swear.”
Mindy didn’t chuckle. “You were trying to get me in trouble so that my mom would pull me out of school or something. Well, whatever you did, it didn’t work, so there.”
Rachel’s lips tightened. “What do you mean? She didn’t set you straight? You listened to your new friends and that incubus you’re dating instead of your own mother? Mindy, you should follow the straight and narrow path! You’re like me!”
“Straight and narrow?” Rani asked, emphasizing ‘straight.’ “Was that a pun? Or are you just incapable of reading the room? Or walkway, in this case.”
“I didn’t mean it that way!” Rachel said. “It’s not Mindy’s fault if she’s a homosexual! That sex-beast, Arthur, has lured and corrupted her! He’s turning all of his girlfriends bi so that he can do things to them! It’s disgusting!”
Sarah and Bella shared a look.
Rani covered her mouth, either in shock or something else. Her shoulders shook, and Rachel realized she was laughing at her. Yvonne stared at Rachel in disbelief. Even Mindy looked surprised.
“Well, she has a point,” Mindy said, looking at Rani. “Arthur helped me come out of the closet, and he’s totally converted Selene to bisexuality.” She giggled after she said it, as if it were funny.
“I think Yvonne had more to do with that than Arthur,” Rani countered, her voice choppy as she tried to restrain her laughter.
“It’s not a laughing matter!” Rachel said. “It’s disgusting! You shouldn’t do those things with men or other women!”
“Okay, I’m trying to be very calm here,” Yvonne said, keeping her voice low as she stepped forward. Rani and Mindy both looked at her in alarm, but Rachel didn’t know her well enough to tell if this wasn’t her normal speaking voice. “I’m getting the sense that this might be some kind of inside joke, so I want to make sure, but do you think being gay is wrong?”
Rachel frowned. “Well, God loves everyone, but according to Scripture, yes, it’s wrong! It’s unnatural!”
“Rachel!” Bella shouted.
“Okay,” Yvonne said, her voice calm. “I’m going to assume that’s ignorance on your part, but I hope–”
“It’s not ignorance!” Rachel argued. “I’m not an ignorant person! Arthur is a horrible influence! He’s corrupting everyone around him into sexual deviants! Mindy’s proof! When the semester started, she was a good person! Now, she’s having sex and drawing nudes of herself with Arthur and other women! She needs to repent!”
Bella and Sarah stared at Rachel as if she were speaking in tongues. Yvonne’s peaceful expression vanished. She surged forward, but Mindy and Rani both put a hand on her shoulder and held her back.
Rachel stumbled backward, and Sarah caught her out of reflex.
“We should go,” Rani said. “We don’t want to keep Arthur, our extremely pacifistic boyfriend, waiting.” She spoke directly to Yvonne, who seethed at Rachel.
“God loves you, even if you’re gay,” Rachel said. “I’m not saying that I hate gay people, just that there’s a better way!”
That did nothing to cool Yvonne’s temper, but Mindy appeared conflicted. Rachel assumed she appeared conflicted because she knew that what Rachel said was true.
“You can make better choices. You don’t have to live in sin!” Rachel said.
Mindy smacked her forehead so hard that Rani looked at her instead of Rachel. The gesture freed Yvonne’s arm, and the backhanded smack that cracked across Rachel’s face was unrestrained. It sent her spinning, and she fell onto her butt on the sidewalk, her hands outstretched behind her to catch herself.
“Whoa!” Bella said, backing up a step.
Yvonne didn’t follow up the smack; she gave it to Rachel and wagged her finger at her. “Grow up, educate yourself, and never say any of that homophobic bullshit in my presence again.”
Rachel touched her cheek, feeling the heat as she sat on her butt after falling and scraping her hands on the concrete. The pain shocked her more than anything else, but it still stung. “Don’t bully me for my beliefs!”
Yvonne took a deep breath. “So help me, God.”
“Songbird,” Rani said, patting Yvonne’s shoulder. “Let it go. Come on, let’s walk away. She’s just a dumb Baptist bitch who thinks some god from the Middle East cares a lot about who she dates. Come on.”
Rachel looked incensed, but no matter who she looked to, no one moved to help her. Everyone was on Yvonne’s side, even her friends.
Rani, however, moved toward her. Rachel flinched away, but Rani only offered her hand to help her up. “She shouldn’t have hit you.”
“No, she shouldn’t have!” Rachel said, regaining her feet with Rani’s help.
“But you fucking deserved it,” Rani said, as if finishing her sentence. “You need to examine why you feel the need to hate people, and work on it. Be better, okay?”
Rachel dropped Rani’s hand and wiped it on her skirt, not because it had been touching Rani, but because of the gravel on her palm. The gesture, however, wasn’t something anyone around her missed.
“We’re going,” Rani said, turning away and guiding Mindy and Yvonne further down the path.
Mindy looked like she wanted to gut Rachel, and she glowered at her as Rani turned her aside and pushed her and Yvonne down the path. She kept looking over her shoulder as they walked away, but didn’t come back. Rachel wondered if she ever would. If the intervention with her mother hadn’t worked, what hope was there for bringing Mindy back from the darkness?
“Wow,” Bella said, as if she, too, couldn’t believe what had just happened. “That was insane.”
“I know, right? That was so rude,” Rachel said, rubbing her slapped cheek. “I can’t believe she slapped me! It’s a free country! I’m allowed to have my opinion.”
Sarah and Bella looked at each other. They shook their heads.
“No, Rachel, she means you were insane. You sound like a crazy person half the time, but that? Mindy’s your friend! She doesn’t deserve you telling her she shouldn’t be gay, that she shouldn’t be who she is! I don’t know that Yvonne girl, but whatever her story is, you’re lucky all she did was slap you. Hell, even I kinda want to slap you right now.”
Rachel scoffed. “Oh, come on. That’s not what I said!” She looked to Bella for help. Bella looked at Rachel, but her eyes held only disappointment.
“Rachel, go back to the dorm,” Bella said. “I don’t think this party is going to be the right place for you.”
Rachel looked surprised. “You guys made me come! Remember? You said I had to, and that you wanted me to chaperone you so you didn’t get into trouble.”
“No, we wanted to get you out of your room,” Bella said. “We were trying to offer you some kindness! You need to loosen up and hang out with normal people, but it seems like you’re obsessed with condemning everyone around you. So this won’t work. I can’t be your friend if you’re a homophobe.”
“I’m not afraid of them!” Rachel said. “I just think what they’re doing is—”
“You don’t need to finish that sentence,” Sarah said, holding up her hand. “Just stop, okay? You hurt Mindy’s feelings, and her girlfriend’s. And even after that, Rani was willing to give you a hand up, and you acted like she was dirty because she’s gay? Or was it because she was Indian? Or a different religion than you?”
“It’s because I had gravel on my palm!” Rachel insisted. “I didn’t think she was dirty. I mean, her costume is dirty, but she’s not dirty because she’s brown! She’s dirty because she’s a lesbian slut! She sleeps with everybody!”
Sarah sighed. “Go back to the dorm, Rachel. Or don’t. We don’t care, but until you get your head on straight, you can’t hang with us.”
“But we’re friends,” Rachel said, protesting. “Don’t let them tempt you away from me.”
“Jesus Fucking Christ,” Bella said, despite Rachel’s flinch at the savior’s most commonly used middle name. “Will you stop? That, right there, that’s why you don’t have any friends and why you’re going to lose the ones you have. Stop judging people and start listening to them. Please.”
“What about the party?” Rachel asked. “You need someone to watch your back. There are guys there. What if they spike your drinks, or you drink too much because you don’t realize how many you’ve had? It’s not safe!”
“We’ll be fine,” Sarah said. “The Alpha Theta Epsilon girls have systems in place for that kind of thing. They don’t let anyone do any harm.”
“Do you need us to walk you back to the dorm?” Bella pointed to the building that was at the end of the lit path. “Or are you good from here?”
“I can walk back on my own,” Rachel said. Tears pushed at the edge of her eyes, and she wanted to cry, but she didn’t want Bella or Sarah to have the satisfaction of making her cry. She walked away, heading back up the hill toward the dorm in a rush.
Bella and Sarah stood on the sidewalk for a moment, then turned toward the party. Plenty of people were around, walking toward the parties on Greek Street or heading out to trick-or-treat in the neighborhoods around campus. A few had eyed the argument as they walked, but no one had stopped to spectate. They rushed off to trick-or-treat or party, whichever they preferred.
Rachel didn’t care. She turned aside from the dorm entrance and walked around the building. She kept raging as she walked until she reached the courtyard between the music building and the admin building. The courtyard was peaceful, with a dry fountain and even more Halloween decorations scattered around and in the dorm windows. She stopped at the edge when she heard soft music.
A bow drew across the strings in a sorrowful lament Rachel didn’t recognize. It sounded sad, and as she turned the corner, she found the young man playing it. She almost laughed when she saw him, but she stifled it into a bewildered smile. It disrupted her raging mind and brought her peace to see him.
Standing by the fountain, alone, surrounded by jack-o’-lanterns and playing his violin, was an angel. He was tall and lean, with muscles that drew Rachel’s eye even though she knew they shouldn’t. His somewhat gangly limbs held the violin as he played with expert skill. His eyes were closed as he cradled the instrument beneath his firm chin.
The white toga he wore had a skirt the same length as hers, but it covered his entire torso, leaving his arms bare. The golden halo on his head was fake plastic with LEDs inside. His back had feathered wings that looked hand-crafted rather than store-bought. They folded and unfolded with a string. Below the robes, he had sandals that wrapped over his calves. Strong calves, she thought. The ensemble contrasted with the spooky decorations around him. Though the young man had quite an attractive face, perhaps he intended his outfit to be a Lucifer costume. He was supposed to be the most beautiful of the angels.
Luckily, she recognized him despite the costume. She’d seen him once before, and Sarah had told her his name was Theodore, Theo for short.
“Oh, you startled me.” The young man laughed, and his voice made Rachel jump. She realized she’d been walking toward him without realizing it and had stepped on a crunchy leaf, which made him stop playing.
“I’m sorry. I didn’t mean to stop you from playing,” Rachel said. “It’s a beautiful song.”
“It’s okay. I was just practicing,” he said. “And thanks!” He set his bow down in the case. “I didn’t write it, though, obviously. Hi, I’m Theo.” He offered her a handshake, and she took it. His grip was firm, but not cruel, and her heartbeat spiked at his touch.
“What’s your name?” Theo asked after she didn’t give him one.
Rachel opened her mouth to speak, then closed it without giving him a name.
Theo raised both eyebrows.
“Are you going to make me guess?” he asked, then studied her face. “Hermoine?”
Rachel looked down at herself, realizing that between the gray skirt and white top, she might be considered a ‘schoolgirl’ with no connection to Hogwarts. Still, her dark brunette hair made her look similar to the character from the posters. She’d never read the books. Her parents kept a long list of banned media from ever entering their house. Harry Potter made the list because it glorified witchcraft and rebellion. If there was one thing her parents couldn’t abide, it was fictional children who received praise and rewards for breaking rules.
“Um,” Rachel said, trying to correct him. “No, I never read those books or saw those movies.”
“Hmm. Okay, don’t tell me,” Theo said, shaking his head. “Is it an anime? My roommate watches some, but I wasn’t allowed to as a kid, so I don’t know any. I was pretty sheltered, to be honest.”
“Me too,” Rachel said, without meaning to.
“You, or your character?” Theo asked. “Are you giving me a hint?”
Rachel shook her head.
“Oh, okay,” Theo said. “So what’s your name then? If you don’t want to tell me, it’s okay; just give me someone else’s name. I’ll believe you.”
Rachel blinked, trying to follow what he was saying. Someone else’s name? That would be lying. Why would he want or expect her to lie to him about her name?
“Or I can give you a name,” Theo offered. “I bet your name is Gabriella, right? Michelle? Something angelic, I’m sure. It’s not Lucy, is it? That’d be embarrassing.”
“Because you’re dressed as Lucifer?” Rachel asked.
“No, I’m dressed as Michael,” he said. “I had a sword that went with the outfit, but I figured it was better not to carry it around campus.” He gestured between them. “But Lucy’s supposed to be the most beautiful angel in heaven, so the name fits you.”
Rachel’s cheeks burned red, and she turned away. The casual way in which he said the offhand compliment made her pause. Was he trying to seduce her? Was it because of the skirt?
“Sorry, that was corny,” Theo said as he put his violin away. “And too forward. I’m not used to talking to girls, so I fumble sometimes. I went to an all-boys school, and my parents were pretty strict, so unless you want to discuss music or religion, I’m out of my depth.”
“Religion?” Rachel asked, her eyes narrowed. “Which religion are you?”
“Well, that’s a funny way to ask that, but I think I’m a mix of Judaism, medieval Christianity, and a dash of Greek mythology,” Theo said, and gestured to himself.
“Not your character,” Rachel said. She laughed as she said it. He made her laugh, and she was giggling like a fool, like Mindy might when she wanted a man to notice her. That made her stop laughing. “I meant you.”
“Oh,” Theo chuckled. He closed his violin case, and Rachel was sad to see the instrument go. She’d enjoyed his music and wanted to hear more. “I’m Baptist.”
“Me too,” Rachel said. “What church do you go to?”
“First Baptist of Crofton,” Theo said. “You?”
“First Baptist of Riverton,” Rachel said.
“Oh, nice, the one at the edge of the forest?” Theo asked. “I go hiking there sometimes.”
Rachel nodded.
“So what are you up to tonight?” Theo asked, crossing his arms. “Trick-or-treating, partying, or is that just what you normally wear?”
Rachel shook her head. “No, I’d never wear this. I did this because my roommates pressured me into it, but then they ditched me for a party.”
“Oh, do you want my coat?” Theo asked.
Rachel raised an eyebrow. It wasn’t that cold out, but it was nice of him to offer. “Sure?”
He passed her his coat. “I can’t wear it with my wings, anyway.”
Rachel nodded and slipped into it. It offered warmth and smelled wonderful. Masculine. She didn’t need to know how good his coat smelled, but she still pulled it closed and took a deep breath through her nose.
“Uh,” Theo said, pointing down. “I meant to cover your legs if you were uncomfortable in your skirt.”
Rachel blushed. “Oh, right! Thanks.” She took off his coat and held it in front of her, which soothed her nerves.
Theo smiled.
“I’m new to this whole Halloween thing,” Rachel explained. “I might not be cut out for it.”
“And let me guess,” Theo said. “You don’t like the idea of trick-or-treating or partying either, right? I was supposed to go to a party tonight, but I’ve been thinking about going to one of the practice rooms instead. I was never big on Halloween. We always did harvest festivals growing up.”
“Exactly!” Rachel said. “Yes!”
Theo chuckled. “That’s why I’ve got this costume. It’s been my harvest festival costume for years.”
“We always dressed up as Bible characters, too,” Rachel said. “I was Ruth last year.”
“Really? You seem more of an Esther to me,” Theo said.
Rachel chuckled. “So what was that song you were playing?” She stepped closer, keeping her hands folded in front of her.
“Oh, it’s Jack’s Lament, from a movie my roommate showed me. The Nightmare Before Christmas?” Theo said, though he sounded unsure of the title and whether Rachel would recognize it. “The music is intricate, so I bought the sheet music for it, and I’ve been memorizing it.”
“I haven’t seen it,” Rachel said. “It sounds like something I wouldn’t be allowed to watch.”
“Your parents are pretty strict even though you’re at college?” Theo asked. “You’re still following their rules?”
Rachel nodded. “Their rules still apply, don’t they? It’s different for you. You’re a boy.”
Theo shrugged. “I suppose the guidelines are still important. It’s nice to keep the traditions, and the teachings are important for living a moral life.”
“But?” Rachel asked.
“Hm?” Theo asked. “No, no buts.” He shrugged. “I guess there’s more leeway because there’s no threat of punishment, but the threat of consequence replaces that. When we’re children, we saw through a glass darkly, right? Our parents had to make rules so that we’d learn right from wrong. Now, we’re adults, and we have to decide how to protect ourselves. Like, do we want to celebrate Halloween and use it as an excuse to dance, drink, and carry on? Our parents won’t punish us for it because they won’t find out, but that doesn’t remove the consequences they protected us from as kids. We’ll have to deal with hangovers, property damage, and the general destructive nature of drunkenness. So shouldn’t we be discerning with how we spend our time and use it more wisely?”
“Yes! Exactly!” Rachel said. She stepped forward again, excited. “That’s what I’ve been saying! There’s a better way than this debauchery!”
Theo chuckled. “Do you want to watch The Nightmare Before Christmas? It’s a cute introduction to Halloween. Kinda spooky, but it doesn’t promote anything too sacrilegious. It has witches, though.”
Rachel considered, but she shook her head. “I’d rather listen to you play,” she said as she sat on the fountain’s edge. She set his jacket over her legs and crossed them, preserving her modesty as though his jacket were a blanket.
“Really?” Theo asked. “I’m flattered, but I’ve got nothing on the original score. We could always listen to it.”
“The original score?” Rachel asked.
“Yeah, but I guess it wouldn’t make much sense to you out of context,” Theo said. “I’ll play it for you. I’m not a singer, though, so it’ll just be instrumental, and I might make mistakes.”
Rachel nodded. “That’s okay.”
“Do you want to go to the music building instead of sitting outside? It’s getting colder,” Theo explained.
“Oh, are you cold?” Rachel asked. She offered his jacket back, but he pushed her offering hand back toward her.
“I’m fine,” he said. “But it’s not good for the strings.” He pointed to his violin case.
Rachel nodded. Theo offered her his hand to help her to her feet. She took it, and he squeezed it before letting go. Rachel held her hand as she walked, remembering the phantom of his touch.
“So what’s your major?” Theo asked, making the small talk of every college student.
“Oh, uh, undecided, but I’ve been thinking about early education,” Rachel said.
“Oh, cool, my sister went for that. She’s a little older,” Theo said. “She graduated two years ago.”
“What school does she work at?” Rachel asked.
“She doesn’t. She got married last year and stayed home to raise their kid. My nephew, Joshua,” Theo said. “She says it’ll save them a ton on daycare costs.”
“That’s what I want to do,” Rachel said. “Be your wife and mother, I mean, but it’s not like I can get a degree in that.”
Theo nodded, then hesitated. “Well, I’d rather you be my wife than my mother, just to avoid any potential Greek tragedies.”
Confusion overtook Rachel at his words, and she looked at him with her forehead wrinkled.
“You said you wanted to be my wife and mother,” Theo said. “I was just saying I’d rather you pick the former.”
Rachel blushed crimson. “Did I? I, uh, I meant a wife and mother. A. Not yours. I mean, I’m not saying—”
Theo laughed, cutting her off. He shook his head and held up a hand, giving her a second to recover from the words spewing out of her mouth.
“It’s okay,” Theo said. “I knew what you meant. I just thought I was being funny.”
Rachel’s shoulders sagged in relief, and she took a deep breath. “I’m so sorry. I can’t believe I said that.”
Theo chuckled. “It’s okay. I know you didn’t mean it. I haven’t even asked your father for permission to date you yet.”
“Would you do that?” Rachel asked. “I mean, if you wanted to date me, would asking my father’s permission be something you were willing to do?”
“Of course,” Theo said. “I mean, I’d have to get to know you as a friend first, and go to your church a few times to get to know your family. Then I’d ask your father, but yeah.”
Rachel smiled. “That sounds nice.”
“Is that something you’d be interested in doing?” Theo asked.
“Maybe,” Rachel said, though she meant to say yes. She couldn’t be forward, or let the lustful thoughts she’d been having ruin this for her. Here was a tall, handsome, godly man who seemed interested in her for more than her body. He kept his gaze respectful, and hadn’t tried to look up her skirt even once. “I’m sorry about my costume. I’m not causing you to stumble, am I?”
Theo shook his head. “No more than I’m causing you to stumble. My skirt’s about the same length, right?” He gestured to himself, and Rachel took the invitation, letting her eyes wander over his body. He didn’t have the deep muscle definition Arthur had, but his body was well-shaped. She caught glimpses of him as they walked. Strong arms, talented fingers, well-defined legs, flat pecs, and the start of abs, with just a layer of softness between them. Strong and soft, like a man should be.
“Rachel?” Theo asked.
“No, you’re fine,” Rachel said, her voice a notch lower than she meant it to be. “I mean, you’re not causing me to stumble. I can handle it. It’s not like girls are lustful. We can control our desires better than boys can.”
Theo nodded. “I guess that’s true. I never thought about it like that, but I guess you’re right.”
Rachel nodded and walked through the music building’s door as Theo held it open for her. After signing in, he led her to one of the practice rooms, and she sat in the chair and listened to him play. He used the music stand for most of the songs, but he knew Jack’s Lament by heart, and she loved it without knowing the lyrics. He was right that the music was complex, and it showed his talent when he played it.
It also showed her that he was a man of principle. Not once did he attempt to seduce her or make a move on her despite their being alone. Granted, there were cameras on the ceiling, and windows in the doors, but the building was empty. Not once did he suggest they slip into a dark stairwell and kiss, or explore each other’s bodies.
Arthur would have. Arthur couldn’t keep his hands off women, and he used them as if they were already married, taking them when and where he wanted them. He was a lustful beast, but Theo? Theo was better than Arthur in every way. He’d never succumb to lust and push her to do things she wasn’t ready for before marriage. After marriage? She’d submit to Theo, and he’d guide her in her wifely duties. Rachel bit her lip as she watched Theo play, imagining him setting his violin aside and turning off the light.
With how short her skirt was, it’d be easy for him to reach under it and feel how wet her panties were as she imagined their future life. She could hold on to his shoulders as he played and toyed with her. He could use the fingers that vibrated against the violin strings to tease an orgasm out of her before the night was finished. She’d sing for him, and he’d treat her the way a husband should, like his queen, and she’d submit to him, fulfilling his every desire like a faithful bride.
“Do you want me to walk you back to your room?” Theo asked.
“Hm?” Rachel asked, snapping out of her daydream.
Theo smiled. “That was the end of the score,” he said. “And it’s getting pretty late. I was thinking of turning in. Do you want me to walk you back to your room?”
“Oh, sure,” Rachel said. “That’d be nice.”
Theo’s smile was nervous and awkward, but he packed up his things, and soon they were walking again. She stuck close by him, as if ready to hold his hand, but she knew it was far too soon for that. Plus, they were in public. They should be alone for their first time holding hands. She didn’t want to make other people uncomfortable with their PDA.
“I’m sorry I spaced out there at the end,” Rachel said. “I was just lost in the music.”
Theo nodded. “I get it,” he said. “It’s a great score.”
“Played by a talented musician,” Rachel added. “You were fantastic. I mean, the way your fingers moved along those strings, and the deftness of your arms, every movement was like a dance you were playing the music to.”
Theo laughed. “Wow, I should bring you to all my practices. You’re a great cheerleader.”
Rachel chuckled. “Well, let me know about your next performance. I’ll cheer you on.”
Theo nodded. “I will. Just do me a favor?”
“What?” Rachel asked.
“Don’t wear a cheerleader outfit. That would cause me to stumble.” He laughed, joking, but Rachel only blushed and nodded. She didn’t want to cause him to sin, but she enjoyed knowing he noticed her, liked her, and wanted her. She felt pretty and attractive, and it did something to her insides to think that she was worthy of that attention. The attention she’d gotten from guys in the past had been teasing her for being a prude, and never genuine interest. They were always interested in her more attractive friends.
“Oh, of course not,” Rachel said. “That’d be something to wear at home, after we’re married.”
Theo chuckled. “You move fast! Let’s work up to dating first, then try at least one date before you propose, okay? But no skimping. I want a stone the size of this halo.” He tapped the fake halo on his head.
Rachel laughed, joking along with him as they walked into her dormitory. He took her to her suite entrance, but didn’t ask to come inside and remained a pace away from the exit.
“I guess this is where we say good night,” Theo said. “Sleep well, Rachel. It was lovely meeting you, and I hope to see you again soon.”
“You too, Theo,” Rachel said. She passed him his coat, and he took it. His hand brushed hers as they exchanged the coat, and she watched him go, his violin case at his side.
She smiled and stumbled into her suite with the weight of desire weighing her down. The others weren’t back yet, and her suite was empty. With her room to herself, she changed into her pajamas and brushed her hair, then looked in the mirror and imagined herself in a wedding dress. Was it ridiculous? Yes. Was it ignoring the problems she’d have to face in the morning when it came time to face her suitemates? Also, yes. She didn’t care. It wasn’t like Mindy would be there anyway. She’d been ‘sleeping over’ with her boyfriend every weekend, getting up to things she’d have to answer for on judgment day.
Rachel took a deep breath, set her brush on her desk, and slipped into bed. She took her extra pillow and placed it between her legs to support her spine. As she lay there, on her side, the thoughts of Theo kept coming. His blonde hair, brown eyes, and cute smile made her breath quicken. She imagined their whole life together playing out before her eyes and realized it’d be the same as her life always had been.
Theo stood beside her bed, smiling at her. She didn’t know why he was in his angel costume, and she was in that ridiculous skirt. The only thing she cared about was Theo coming toward her, kissing her, tilting her head back with his hand on her chin, and letting her lips meet his.
His kiss was much better than the ones she imagined with Arthur. Even thinking of that comparison made her angry, as if Arthur were breaking into her fantasies without her summoning him.
“What’s this?” Arthur asked, stepping into the room. “An angel trying to seduce a woman I’ve already claimed as one of my whores? Tsk, tsk, Theo. Tsk, tsk. Thou shalt not covet an incubus’ meal.”
Theo pulled away from Rachel and grimaced.
Arthur laughed as he stood by the door. He wore red body paint all over, with a pair of large black horns on his head, and nothing else. The long, thick thing swinging between his legs wasn’t his tail, and Rachel’s hips shifted in the real world, grinding the pillow against herself. She slipped her hand under her waistband to protect herself from the pillow, or so she told herself.
“What are you doing here?” Rachel asked, confused. “I’m with Theo.”
“Only because you couldn’t have me,” Arthur said, leaning against her doorframe in a pose straight out of a movie.
“That’s not true,” Rachel protested.
“You know it’s true,” Arthur said. “Deep down, you don’t want to be an angel, or a good girl, for the rest of your life. You want to see what it’s like to sin.” He curled his finger toward her. “Come with me. Surrender yourself to my power, and I’ll show you pleasures Theo couldn’t hope to compare to. All it will cost is your soul. Give me your soul, and I’ll give you experiences Theo can’t.”
“What do you mean?” Rachel asked. “He’s a man, like you. He has everything you do.”
“Not everything.” Arthur winked. “He’s got less… experience.”
Rachel’s eyes dipped to Arthur’s crotch, watching as he rose to greet her. She swallowed and looked at Theo, who stood beside Arthur, wearing his angel costume. His body wasn’t as masculine or as fit as Arthur’s, and he wasn’t as handsome, but he was all those things without the comparison.
“You have to choose one of us,” Theo said. “Who will you submit to? Me? Or Him?”
“You can’t serve two masters,” Arthur said.
Rachel turned her head back and forth, looking between them.
“Shouldn’t we be sitting on her shoulders for this?” Arthur asked, chuckling.
“Don’t be ridiculous,” Theo said. “That’s disgusting.”
“No, sex isn’t disgusting,” Arthur countered. “It’s beautiful. Come with me, Rachel. Sit on my shoulders, and I’ll show you beauty. You’ll see worlds you’ve never known existed, except in those dreams you’ve had of me. This isn’t the first time you’ve lain in bed, thinking of me, doing things to yourself to relieve the growing lust I thrust into you.”
Theo shook his head. “You are a beauty, Rachel. Come with me. Let’s be together forever.”
Rachel looked between them, unable to decide. She had to choose, sure, but her body wanted to choose sin, even though her mind screamed that Arthur was the wrong choice. Her soul was in peril, and she needed to make the right decision.
“Can I, um, can I see your sword, Theo? Before I make my choice?” Rachel asked.
“Do you need to?” Theo asked. “Can’t you take it on faith that I can fulfill my husbandly duties?”
“She can,” Arthur said. “But should she have to? She doesn’t need faith to know that I can please her.”
Rachel looked at Arthur, then at Theo. She looked between them several times, then hung her head in shame. “I’m sorry, Theo.”
Arthur laughed as Theo hung his head. “Better luck next time, buddy,” Arthur said, clapping him on the back. “She’s made her choice.”
Theo flew away, taking the rest of the room with him and leaving Rachel and Arthur alone in the dark. The bed was the only piece of furniture left, and Rachel stared at Arthur, who stood at its foot.
“Poor Theo,” Arthur said. “If only you had spied on him in the shower. Then you’d have known what he was working with.”
Rachel didn’t answer. Shame overwhelmed her, but with it came lust that stirred deep within her, making her grip the sheets between her fingers.
“That’s what you enjoy, right? Watching?” Arthur asked. He spread his fingers, and heavy chains clasped onto Rachel’s wrists and ankles. They pulled taut in a second and restrained her to the bed. Arthur snapped his fingers, and the door behind him creaked open. Succubi that Rachel recognized entered the room. Each bore his mark over their womb, their naked bodies on full display. Kelly, Katelyn, Mindy, Rani, Selene, and Kat clung to him. With them was the new girl, Yvonne, whom Rachel had met on the walk. Sarah and Bella came in last, clinging to Arthur as well.
“Your suitemates already gave me their souls,” Arthur said, his grin widening at her horror. “Everyone enters my contracts of their own free will, just like you.”
Rachel shook her head. “I changed my mind. I want Theo.”
“Do you?” Arthur asked. “Is that what you desire? More of the same? The safety of the familiar, for the rest of your life, so that you end up just like your parents? You know how loveless their marriage is. How much they hate and resent one another. Do you want that for yourself? Or do you want to try something new and adventurous?”
Arthur crawled toward her on the bed, kissing his way from the manacle around her ankle, up her calf, to her thigh.
Rachel twitched, struggling against the restraints, but they wouldn’t let her go. She didn’t want them to.
“I’ll make you a deal,” Arthur said. “If you don’t enjoy yourself tonight, you’re free to go back to Theo and live your life. But if you do? You’re mine. For eternity. Just like them.” He gestured to the women who’d been clinging to him a moment ago. They knelt behind him now, still offering themselves to him as he turned his attention toward her.
Rachel swallowed.
“Or we can end this now,” Arthur said. “Say ‘Theodore,’ and I’ll let you up from this bed and send you to him.”
Rachel pressed her lips closed as she considered her options, but in the end, the want in her body was something she wasn’t sure Theo could satisfy. Arthur, however? She’d seen what he could do before, and Mindy’s stories and sketches gave her an idea of what pleasures he could offer beyond what she’d seen. Arthur came recommended.
“I’ll do it,” Rachel said. “But tonight is the last time, Arthur,” she said. “Tomorrow, I’m going to go after Theo.”
“Sure you will,” Arthur said, grinning with disbelief. “And I’ll be back tomorrow night, making you cry out my name as you find your release, my little Jezebel.” His long tongue stretched forward, and the girls behind him moved forward. They pinned Rachel’s arms and legs despite the restraints, holding her down and positioning her as Arthur lowered his face to her.
He kissed and probed her with his tongue, sliding it between her, mingling his saliva with the wetness that beaded within her. She moaned at the pressure between his lips and gasped as a woman’s hand slid over her hips. Mindy reached toward her, sliding her fingers over her and spreading her lower lips for Arthur as he massaged her with his mouth.
Rachel gasped as his tongue entered her, and she arched her back, grinding her butt and shoulders into the mattress.
“Such a dirty girl,” Arthur said, leaving his fingers beside Mindy’s as he pulled away from Rachel. “You deserve to be punished for this. You know that, right?”
“Yes, Master,” Rachel said.
“You pretend to be so righteous,” Arthur said, sliding his finger into her. “But every night you lie in bed, and touch yourself to thoughts of me, and my harem. You’re curious about what it would be like to kiss Mindy. To do more than kiss her. Admit it.”
Rachel shook her head. It wasn’t every night. There had been nights, though, since she’d seen them together, that she’d thought of him. Just him. Not the others. Doing things with a man was bad enough, but with women? That was too perverted. She was a sinner, yes, and she might be hopeless, but even she had her limits.
“No,” Rachel said. “Never them. Only you.”
“And yet Mindy is rubbing you right now, isn’t she?” Arthur asked, grinning as he held up both hands. “And you haven’t said your safeword. You want her to do this to you, to give you this pleasure, even though it’s wrong. Especially because it’s wrong. Admit it.”
“No,” Rachel said again, as if she could make herself believe it.
Arthur licked his fingers, then offered them to Mindy. She sucked on them, moaning as she did so. He pulled them from her mouth and slid them against Rachel, then inside her, filling her with his finger. She moaned, gripping the chains that spread her arms and legs. She bucked, but the others held her in place, embracing her.
“Oh please,” Rachel begged. “Please.”
“Please what?” Arthur asked, sliding his finger out of her and trailing it up her stomach to her breast. He gripped her nipple, holding it between his thumb and forefinger. “Use your words, Jezebel. Tell me what it is you want. Beg me for it, like a good girl.”
“Please, help me get there. Help me reach release,” Rachel said. “Free me from your spell.”
Arthur scoffed, then lowered his face to her body. He kissed her breast, suckling on her before he kissed his way lower, and lower. His tongue tasted her flesh in gentle nips between his teeth. Then, his tongue circled her clit, drawing sigils on it with erratic flicks that made her see stars. Whatever powers he had as an incubus, it was already too late for her to escape the inevitable. She was doomed, damned, and under his spell. It was nice to dream about Theo and wonder what life might be like, but Arthur had already claimed her soul.
Oh sure, he might pretend to get frustrated with her in public. He might demand that she see a therapist, but only to mold her thinking to match his. He wanted her mind, body, and soul, and he was already two-thirds of the way there. All he had to do now was claim her body, and she’d be his.
Rachel gasped as his tongue continued to play with her. The hands that held her massaged her, groped her, and rubbed her in ways she never knew women’s hands could. It was dirty, even dirtier than the other things she’d imagined Arthur doing. What hell awaited her after she died if this was what her mind showed her every night?
No, not every night. Tonight. She’d given in again, thrown herself into lust at the first temptation, knowing that she could sink to her knees and pray for forgiveness tomorrow. She’d spend a lot of time on her knees tomorrow, but tonight, she’d explore the pleasures Arthur promised her.
Rachel clenched and bucked, but it was no use. The other women held her, and Arthur gripped her thighs, holding them apart as he rose and brought himself to her. He met her eyes as he sank into her, and she trembled at the onslaught, shaking as he powered through every clenching muscle in her body. She was wet and eager for him to grant her release.
Arthur did not disappoint. His round shoulders and massive muscles made easy work of holding himself over her. He hovered as if he had wings of his own, and kissed Rachel’s neck as he pumped his hips, sawing in and further in with every stroke.
“Oh,” Rachel gasped. “Oh!” She trembled as his teeth sank into her neck, and she came.
Her entire body curled in on itself as if she could implode before a spasm in her back bucked her the other way. Her legs twitched and writhed, spreading against the sheet and clamping against the pillow. She pulled her fingers out of herself and covered her face with her pillow in time to muffle her scream of pleasure. Rachel bit down hard on it to stifle herself, but it did nothing to stop the wave of pleasure coursing through her.
Rachel’s entire body trembled and shook long after the wave of intense pleasure passed, and she sagged against the bed. She was sweaty, and sticky, and needed a shower, but no body wash in her shower basket would ever make her feel clean again. She was dirty, and she knew it, and yet she couldn’t help herself.
Regardless of what promises she made or lies she told, Arthur would be back to visit her tomorrow night, and she’d submit to his perversions once more. It made her crave forgiveness and wonder if she’d ever be able to meet Theo’s eyes again. Only time would tell.
“Damnit, Arthur,” Rachel panted to herself as she looked at Mindy’s empty bed. “This is all your fault.”