Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

Why Was There No Truck?! - First Pairing Poll

  • Black Canary/Dinah 67
  • Nocturne/Talia 50
  • Both Dinah and Talia 107
  • 2026-08-05
  • —2026-08-12
  • 224 votes
{'title': 'Why Was There No Truck?! - First Pairing Poll', 'choices': [{'text': 'Black Canary/Dinah', 'votes': 67}, {'text': 'Nocturne/Talia', 'votes': 50}, {'text': 'Both Dinah and Talia', 'votes': 107}], 'closes_at': datetime.datetime(2026, 8, 12, 3, 22, 31, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2026, 8, 5, 22, 48, 19, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 224}

Content

Alrighty then, beings of all shapes and sizes! As I mentioned in the release of Why Was There No Truck?! yesterday, it is time to start figuring out what the actual pairing for this story is going to be. Now, in case some of you (gasp) didn't read that post in full, the polling results from back in May were finalized. The currently plan for this story is to have Alyssa + 3 girls. If, and only if, we get much farther along in the story and someone new clicks with everyone in the relationship (as happened unexpectedly with Hancock in Halfway Broken), a fourth might be added. Otherwise, the total polycule will just be Alyssa + 3.

This means you need to think carefully about your vote here.

This Amalgam universe is big, with the majority of the DC, Marvel, My Hero Academia, and Worm characters around in some fashion. Likewise, there are a sprinkling of additional characters from franchises like Overwatch as well (we've seen Winston and Mercy both mentioned already, working with Overwatch remotely for now). I have plans for this story to extend well beyond Gotham in the long run. Meaning, for all intents and purposes, we are early in the story still, despite the fact that it's nearly hit the 100k word marker. My Hero Automata was nearly half a million, Displaced Hero and Halfway Broken have both already cracked half a million and aren't done yet. I don't exactly write short fanfiction works :-p.

Frankly, everyone from Psylocke to Wonder Woman, or Dragon to Miruko, are all technically possible pairing options for this story. Even locally, to this section of the story, Batgirl is a possible addition to the pairing (I'm a sucker for redheads, of course she's an option!). I'm hitting you all over the head with this so you don't instinctively just hit the button with the most girls. There is absolutely nothing wrong with taking that option, I've done the in-story setup that teased the possibility after all ;-). I just want you to consider it carefully before you dive right in and hurry to fill the three available slots!

Now for the options! For this poll, I'm focusing on the girls already on the team that have shown an interest in Alyssa so far. This doesn't exclude Nico or Crystal as options in the long run, if you're interested in adding the resident goth girl whose canonically bisexual, or the other blonde if she and Cyborg don't last :-p. For now, though:

1) Black Canary/Dinah Drake

The setup for this one is already right there, to be jumped on this month if people are interested, as she joins Alyssa in that bath she's off to at the end of the most last release :-p. It doesn't have to happen, though, as she could have easily followed Alyssa for more serious reasons. I've failed as a writer if you hadn't already caught on to her interest in Alyssa...but one of the things I want to point out that might be a little less obvious is that she's already shown a bit of a specific kink as well.

This is a mild spoiler, but relevant to the voting. Dinah is into the idea of Alyssa using her telepathy and commands in the bedroom (or out of it, but related to sexy times). Any such would, of course, be 100% consensual. It you're into the idea of something like hypnosis play or fun implanted commands? Well, Dinah is too ;-). Don't worry, I greatly dislike the creepy places this is sometimes taken too. So anything they do in that direction will be depicted in a fun, safe, healthy, and consensual manner.

Nocturne/Talia Wagner

The setup for this one isn't as immediate, but obviously I've shown Talia as having interest in Alyssa! Much like with Dinah, I've also subtly set up a few hints for her interests. Specifically, in Talia's case, she's both into watching Alyssa do things to other girls (and just watching other girls in general) and she's a bit of a switch. Unlike Rylia is Stripper, Alyssa isn't much of a switch, which means for Talia is would likely be a case of 'submissive with Alyssa, dominant with the other girls in the pairing.'

I haven't hinted at it, so it's a bit more of a spoiler, but also relevant is that I intend Talia to be a bit of an exhibitionist as well. An additional point of note for her is that, due to her interest in voyeurism, she's the most likely to actively encourage Alyssa finding additional lovers.

Both Dinah and Talia

Yep! This is very much an option. So far, I've been happy with the chemistry all three of them have, and the kinks I've subtly given each girl line up well for both of them to slide smoothly into the relationship. Talia isn't strong enough of a telepath to set up commands for Dinah like Alyssa could, but she is enough of one to make use of them if Alyssa set them up first, which Dinah would enjoy. Since Talia is a switch, and one that likes to watch, they are honestly a solidly well-fitted puzzle if this choice is taken.

That said, a special note for this option is that I've also made it clear Nico is somewhat interested in Talia. This could serve as a way to bring the resident goth girl into the fold as well, so long as people were okay with that filling up the pairing pretty early with so many options still out there. However, to make it perfectly clear, if Dinah is chosen and Talia isn't, then Talia and Nico will likely end up together. Possibly with some sex scenes for the pair of them shown. Similar to the way I showed a scene of Hina/Perona in Halfway Broken. Either within the fic, or as an extra at some point.

Right! The immediate options have been laid out for you, folks! Get your votes in!

Comments

Sequal

Personally, I have never been a fan of Dinah, even if I like her more here than elsewhere. My vote goes to Talia, with Nico as an intriguing future option as the characters develop.

Daemonioros

This one is incredibly tricky for me. I heavily prefer Talia over Dinah. And with all the options present in this amalgam both is a bit much since I absolutely want to keep options open for some other possibilities. Problem is that I also really like the idea of Nico/Talia. And the only way to ensure that in this poll is to pick Dinah. Which is my least favourite option in this poll. Can there not be a neither for now option? And then potentially some other options in the future? Otherwise likely just going for Dinah since I really like the Talia/Nico idea.

Novus's Fanfiction Works

If Talia is selected and Dinah is not, the option to bring Nico in is still present and would likely be the next poll. That would end up Alyssa/Talia/Nico/+1.

Novus's Fanfiction Works

Honestly, I've only ever really encountered her in Young Justice and I liked her there. I've never been interested in the Green Arrow content, where she shows up more, I think? She ended up being an early member as many versions of her are native to Gotham, and I wanted at least one native on the team.

Silvereagle21

I would have gone with none of the above for now. But since that is not an option, then I will go with Talia as I like her more.

Novus's Fanfiction Works

*sweatdrop* Honestly didn't consider that might be needed, and Patreon doesn't let you add new options to polls once they are up. Sorry...

Captain2003Rex

Hmm, it would seem that despite your attempts to highlight the possibility of other potential pairings in the future of this story, some of the voters are still kinda knee-jerking towards the extra speedy pair-up. Admittedly the setup is already there, and it would definitely be fun, but still, I find that a tad… vexing lol.

Novus's Fanfiction Works

*shrug* I admit I half expected it, given that I have already done some setup for both Talia and Dinah. That said, I wanted to make the downside crystal clear so no one can complain too much later :-p.

Silvereagle21

Understand. Even if it is a bit frustrating, especially since you emphasized how big the universe was and how many options there are in the future in this post.

Blackelements

Of the three, I'm voting Talia. That said I'd prefer neither, instead going Alyssa / Rachel Roth / Amy Dallon / aged up Missy Byron / Jinx / aged up Aisha Laborn. The way I see it is something like this: Alyssa has Nico call in back-up to try and untangle the whole curse cluster problem in Gotham (and introducing Alyssa to more mages to maybe train with) which is where she meets Raven and Jinx, with Raven deciding to stay and help with monitoring the aftermath (and training Alyssa) which is how she and Alyssa get closer and try dating. Jinx also decides to stick around to try to seperate her from her bad past that won't leave her back with the Titans (and the good benefits / not being monitoed as heavily by Robin, with his near Batman level paranoia). Later the team moves to Brockton Bay as either Gotham is cleaned up enough that Bats can just keep on top of things like with other cities and the team wants/needs a new project and Laserdream does want to clean up her home, plus give Amy some new friends (Amy may have already met some/all of them if they needed to call in a healer as backup and laser pulled her family over for a Gothem incident). Alternatively they head to Brockton to help with a disaster (Leviathan?) and maybe stay some time after to help with clean-up or something (Bakuda bombing or fixing it's aftermath, maybe?). While there Alyssa and Raven could click with Amy, helping with her home life such as being empaths they point out to Vicky that Amy is gay, or maybe bi to help with the endless double dates, helping her accept her attraction to Vicky as normal (they aren't blood related after all), getting Carol to stop being an over baring hardass (especially if she constantly thinks Amy is gonna turn into Marquis) and get Amy proper pay for her work at the hospital (can be discounted some as volunteer work but still give Amy some much needed indipendance, maybe the hospital already has all her back-pay in an account but is waiting on her to turn 18 to give her it to keep it away from Carol) and work more regular hours (instead of daily overtime on top of school), maybe even help Amy bring out her inner snarky goth while helping her to relax. Eventually pushing her to follow after Laserdream and jump ship, joining Alyssa's team (much more likely to go smoothly if the team moved to the Bay fully, especially if it's after basically fixing Gotham). With Missy it could start with them doing joint patrols to work with the PRT, later her opening up to them about her frustrations (their outsiders and new friends, they likely won't blindly side with the PRT over her) leading Alyssa to designing her some weapons that work with her powers the PRT will accept while Raven helps convincing the PRT to let her do a costume re-design (playing up the PR aspect or part of their co-operation, maybe sicking Laserdream and Carol on them?). Missy's years of discontent as a Ward (the lack of proper armour and weapons, no control over her image especially if she still joined really young and is in the same type of childish outfit as a near adult) combined with enjoying working with the new ream in town (she knows their likely not just faking it if they came to help at BB for Laserdream) and her personal friendship with Alyssa and Raven is what finally pushes Missy to leave the PRT and join Alyssa instead (with her getting good benefits, even better weapons and a full image redesign, making her even closer to the pair). With both Missy and Amy joining (maybe even the same time - a lucky coincidence surely), their bond as fellow Bay heroes evolving to a real friendship, further helping the two and increasing how thankful they are towards Alyssa and Raven, even evolving into crushes on them or deepening already existing crushes, the pair did help them a lot after all, giving them both real acceptance they feel they felt they lacked (Missy - bad home life and PRT/Wards ignoring her issues so long / Amy - Carol being Carol and her guilt at her intrest in Vicky), this leads to Alyssa and/or Raven noticing their intrest and them deciding to "test the waters" and offering to try some dates with the new girls with it evolving into a real relationship. Then we have Aisha, likely being a gremlin, ending up being saved by Alyssa and/or Raven, multiple times even. This obviously rings alarm bells for Alyssa (due to the Majors experience and skills plus empathy) and leads to them digging into her personal life and saving her from her horrid home life (her mom too, if she's a victim instead of an addict selling her daughter for a fix). The time with them in the immediate aftermath has her getting closer to Alyssa (when she's relaxing and not in her serious work mode) and befriending Jinx (their both gremlins, everyone else has to deal with it). Later when she triggers (or however else she becomes Imp) she decides to go to who she trusts most, joining Alyssa's team (possibly also to fuck with her brother, Grue, assuming they haven't already taken down the Undersiders) This could also be where she re-unites with Missy and/or Amy, having already known them either in or out of costume (or both) . Her and Jinx then decide to appoint themselves to keeping the team relaxed (for the CHAOS!), especially the leader Alyssa and her harem of over workers (already friends with the four and feel indebted to some/all of them) possibly with Alyssa finding it hilarious and making their position official, as long as they keep where and when it's appropriate in mind. Later Aisha and Jinx, having fallen for the four, decide that to REALLY help them relax between missions is to get in on the relationship proper to help them relax more intimately (either to hide their crushes from each other or as a joint idea on how to act on said crush) leading the pair to try and slowly seduce our polycule with possibly funny results. This later leading the four to accept how natural having Aisha and Jinx as part of their group has become, them realising the six together just works so well after so long that they decide to reverse the seduction on the pair, surprising them before settling properly as a polycule of six officially.

Raftler

Talia is more interesting. I also would like a slower acquisition for the harem so just her for my core.

Artemis

I vote Talia, I like her as a character and she deserves some more time in the spotlight. Also, after reading Gail Simone's run of Birds of Prey I can't mentally un-ship Dinah and Barbara.

Crescent Sunrise

I want only one of these girls because you mentioned Miruko, and I don't care how we get there, I want my Muscle Mommy Bunny! XD

Novus's Fanfiction Works

*sweat drop* You know Miruko is 5'2", not the super Amazon rule34 artists draw her has for some utterly bizarre reason...right?

Novus's Fanfiction Works

Honestly, I didn't expect anyone to want 'none' for her current team. Given it might be a while before the other options come up.

Novus's Fanfiction Works

*sweat drop* Sounds like you need to write your own story there. Most of that isn't doable in this one. The Teen Titans don't exist, with a Young Avengers team having taken over Jump City. That particular Robin isn't even around, Cyborg is on Overwatch, and Raven hasn't shown up on Earth yet. Brockton Bay doesn't exist, with New Wave being based elsewhere. You've also gone full harem smut story with your plotting, which isn't the '3-4' max that will be involved with the pairing for this story.

Novus's Fanfiction Works

Wait, they are shipped together in Birds of Prey? Or just shown as having chemistry? I admit I've never read the Birds of Prey run.

UHDNRT

One thing you could do to give more options available as well, is for the initial pairing to just not work out. If the both option wins, that would be my recommendation. Have one of them pull back after a little bit, to 'free up' space in the polycule. Then run a pole later on to see whether or not they should come back to the relationship

twilightwanderer

I'm finding this to be hard one and not in a good way. I'm presumably in the minority in that I don't read your stories for the smut, so I don't feel the need to rush to a pairing just for that. Honestly, you did too good a job selling the scope of the world and the story, and I'm also finding myself more interested in alternative pairings available for Dinah and Talia than I am in either or both or them with Alyssa. (sidenote: to me, ships are only preferences, and I'll generally read any pairing if it's well written and the story otherwise engages me) For Dinah, I read enough Birds of Prey when I was younger to primarily ship her with Babs, who's right there. At the same time, while I can't put my finger on it, I'm just not feeling Alyssa and Dinah click on anything more than a physical level so far. As for Talia, I never read Exiles so I don't have as much grasp on her character, nor do I have any preexisting ships with her, and I can at least picture her and Alyssa becoming an interesting pairing. With that said, I'm actually really curious about her and Nico, who's been a favorite of mine since I found the Runaways back in high school, and I'd be a lot more interested in seeing it develop as a standalone first rather than as a secondary concern to their collective relationship with Alyssa. As far as potential pairings for Alyssa, I'd be interested to see how she clicks with Mercy, or maybe even Symmetra if she's around. If Miss Martian is on Earth right now I think they could have some fun interactions. There's (presumably) a version of Spider-Gwen on her way to Gotham right now to help with Carnage, and I can't wait to see them interact. Thanks to the Kusanagi memories/skillset, I could even see Alyssa being able to relate to someone like Lady Nagant, or (from a different direction) Dragon. I'm not saying I want any or all of them as confirmed pairings (obviously I named more people than there are total positions), just that at this point I'm more interested in Alyssa's potential future chemistry than I am with what she has available this minute. Ultimately, given free choice, I would prefer no permanent pairing be set at this point. I'm not necessarily against some dating or even fun times happening now, but I'd rather it be kept casual or at least allowed to develop without locking in stone that it will be a final pairing as opposed to letting them (whoever they may be) have a more organic relationship with the option to drop it if it doesn't seem to be working or doesn't have anywhere to go. Since that's not an option, I guess I'll pick Talia, since I feel like she clicks a bit better with Alyssa, it doesn't lock in too much early, and it leaves the door open for something with Nico.

Crescent Sunrise

I know she's only 5'2", though I'm not sure how that changes her being attractive and muscular.

Novus's Fanfiction Works

I guess I've just usually seen the term 'Muscle Mommy' used to refer to amazon type characters. Wonder Woman or Power Girl type bodies :-p. I've seen a LOT of art of Miruko drawn that was and it annoys the heck out of me. Not because some people want to draw it that way, but because its so common that art at her actual height is vanishingly rare T-T.

Novus's Fanfiction Works

Ehhhhh. Generally speaking, that sort of thing causes drama and angst. I hatttteeeee writing drama and angst. Worse, it causes the same drama and angst with readers who liked the pairing too, so I get stuck with real life drama and angst to top it off. There's a reallllyyy good reason I don't generally write that sort of thing as a result. Katie, in Pandora's Box, is the only time I've written a possibility of it, and even then was only willing to try it due to them being so young.

Novus's Fanfiction Works

I'm honestly surprised that several people wished there was a 'neither' option. Honestly, if Patreon let me modify polls after starting one, I'd add it. I was apparently operating under a possibly-faulty assumption that people would want SOMEONE from the current team paired with Alyssa, and Talia and Dinah were the two I set up for that.

Blackelements

Eh, I'm not really capable or interested in writing myself, even if I have some interesting ideas occasionally. That said with the 3-4 max then I'd still say skip the current team and have the first pairing be Alyssa/Amy Dallon, with their connection being Laserdream (escaping Carol being a viable plot idea still?). Second then would be an aged up Missy Byron (looking to get independance/away from chaffing under the PR rules from the PRT). Finally Raven would be last to join, though she could easily join Overwatch when she first lands on earth (they help her first or using Gothams fucked magic side to hide further) but she'd likely remain closed off until Trigon bites the dust, like in her stories, though with a fellow empath on the team Alyssa could easily break past some of those walls early, same with her revealing some of her past with Amy easily finding out she's half human, connecting her to the team more than she did the Titans before Trigon.

Masmher

I too would have gone with none of the above for now.

Arya13579

I mean, it's only been up for a day, you could restart it. Personally, I don't see why she can't just have some sticky fun with either/both, and not jump straight into a full relationship with either/both. Casual sex is a thing, would satisfy the horni fans for a bit, and a relationship could develop or not as seems good for the story. EDIT: Or a friends with benefits situation that might deepen or stop if she enters a relationship with someone else later who doesn't approve. There's a lot of options that don't need such a decisive decision. EDIT 2: Of course, I'm also aromantic, so take my opinion with a grain of salt lol. The relationships aren't why I read your stories.

Crescent Sunrise

Fair enough, I definitely know what you're talking about. Though sometimes the perspective the artist chooses can make the character appear bigger as well. Though the ones where she is literally towering over someone is hilarious, like, what are they, three feet tall? XD

twilightwanderer

I feel like they're all adults, they're capable of dating for a while, mutually deciding that they don't work together romantically, splitting up amicably, and still remaining friends and functional teammates, no drama or angst needed. Heck, it's a running joke in lesbian circles that lesbians are usually friends with their exes. As for reader drama, that could be its own poll: see if it's just the few of us commenting or it the general readership of this story would be okay with a casual relationship or an amicable breakup further down the road (heck, make it a strongly agree, somewhat agree, ambivalent, somewhat disagree, strongly disagree, don't care style poll to really understand the response). Ultimately, you're the author and you don't need to write anything you're not comfortable with, I just wanted to point out that drama doesn't _have_ to be a part of the process.

Novus's Fanfiction Works

If I thought there was a legitimate chance a 'niether' would win, I might. Given how many people went straight to 'both,' despite me pointing out the many fish in the sea, that seems extremely unlikely.

Crescent Sunrise

I did notice at least one person comment on the idea that neither of these ladies get picked, I know you can't edit the poll options after the fact, but maybe with just how many potential options there are to be in the future, it might be worthwhile to scrap this poll and make a new one with "Neither" as an option. Because it would really suck to have all the slots filled in the first two polls (which feels like a very likely scenario with the options you gave.)

Novus's Fanfiction Works

If I thought there was a snowball's chance in hell of that option winning, I would. But the vote count is right around where it usually tops out (typically 200-240), and more people are in a rush to add both of them than any other option.

Kyllix

Maybe it'd be a good idea to play it more casual, or a friends with benefits kinda deal. Or just amicably splitting up later like someone else said. Especially since there's no none of the above/ not now option. Yes I am definitely trying to have my cake and eat it too. You can probably guess what I voted for in the previous poll :3

Zachrey Mueller

I think Dinah should get it first with Talia a little bit. Perhaps to help develop her kinks and show her kinks developing more that would allow her to seway into Nico and give people their Dinah/ Talia pairing for a little bit

Novus's Fanfiction Works

I've mentioned many times over several different stories that I refuse to write casual flings, sorry :-). I prefer writing stable relationships.

Kyllix

Fair enough. ^^ I prefer it that way as well most of the time, there's just too many options here though :3

Dominique Brassel

People why are you bloody voting both we don't have any slots available for much horny and you guys want to fill have the space at the very beginning as our wonderful author said there are way to many options in our future in this story and filling out our quota now will be something we will regret I say....... Also I would have thought a none of the above options would be included with how many potential love interests are yet to appear......