Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

*Questionnaire request

  • JPG 25
  • PNG 59
  • 2024-10-23
  • —2024-10-27
  • 84 votes
{'title': '*Questionnaire request', 'choices': [{'text': 'JPG', 'votes': 25}, {'text': 'PNG', 'votes': 59}], 'closes_at': datetime.datetime(2024, 10, 27, 15, 0, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2024, 10, 23, 3, 18, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 84}

Content

This is a slightly unusual survey.

Recently, as I've been making things differently and experimenting, the weight of each file has changed quite a bit due to the painting and shine of the images.

Usually, the average is about 110 images per article, but when it's heavy, it can be around 100, and when it's light, it can be as much as 120.

Currently, I distribute images in PNG format, but this survey is to see if it's okay to distribute them as JPG files.

For those who don't know, PNG has less degradation but the file size is heavy.

JPG has some image degradation, but in return it is overwhelmingly lighter in size.

I've uploaded a reference image to MEGA, so if you want to see the difference, please check it out.

I would appreciate it if you could answer which one is better.

JPG is light, so it may be possible to convert it to PDF and upload it.

Thank you very much🙇‍♀️

今回は少し特殊なアンケートです

最近色々と作り方が変わったり試行錯誤していると、画像の塗りやテカりなどで結構1ファイルずつの重さがかなり変動していきます

通常1記事で110枚ぐらいが平均ですが、重いときは100枚前後、軽いときは120と結構変わります

現在PNG形式の画像で配布していますが、これをJPGファイルにして配布するのはアリかどうかを確認するアンケートです

詳しくない方に説明するとPNGは劣化が少ない代わりにファイルサイズが重いです

JPGは多少画像が劣化しますがその代わり圧倒的にサイズが軽いです

参考画像をMEGAにアップロードしたので、違いの差を見てみたい方はご確認下さい

その上でどちらが良いのかを回答していただけたら幸いです

JPGだと軽いのでPDFに変換してアップすることも可能かもしれません

よろしくお願いいたします🙇‍♀️

这次的调查有点特别。

最近,我一直在改变制作方式并经历反复试验,并且由于图像着色和光泽等因素,每个文件的重量波动很大。

通常情况下,每篇文章的平均长度约为 110 页,但当内容较多时,约为 100 页;当内容较少时,则变化较大,为 120 页。

我们目前以 PNG 格式分发图像,但这是一项调查,以确定是否可以将它们作为 JPG 文件分发。

对于那些不熟悉它的人来说,PNG 的恶化程度较小,但文件大小较大。

JPG 具有一定的图像质量,但尺寸要轻得多。

我已经将参考图片上传到MEGA,所以如果你想看看差异,请检查一下。

如果您能回答哪一个更好,我将不胜感激。

由于 JPG 很轻,因此可以将其转换为 PDF 并上传。

感谢您的支持🙇‍♀️

*Reference image

Comments

Lazarus

If JPG wins, does that mean more images when they're available? Or is it just a file size concern with no other effect?

敦也 霧島

I was considering using JPG instead of PNG if there were many voices saying that JPG was okay. In that case, there is an advantage that you can upload more images. However, considering the current situation, it seems like there are more opinions on PNG 😅 Therefore, it may be best to have the excess content viewed as a bonus, as has been the case until now.

Jared M Kennedy

I would prefer png bc of lossless data but tiff. Is amazing for illustrations is generally the best it is larger than both but I have heard a myth that if you compress your tiff file it cuts it in half compared to file sizes in png and jpeg .jpeg loses data and when compressing it even further is possible making it worse

敦也 霧島

Thank you for your opinion🙇‍♀️ I tried converting it to TIFF right away, but it turned out to be unexpectedly heavy, so it didn't make much difference💦 But it's really helpful to have this kind of information😊 Thank you for your continued support🙇‍♀️