Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

I always say that Gaywatch is a place for good faith discussion and debate, even (and especially) when we disagree. Well, at 5 hours and 45 minutes long, I really put my money where my mouth is with this one.

This saga dives into a ton of conversations I've been paying attention to and wanting to crack open for years: interpretation vs. intention, the particulars of queerbaiting, what makes for compelling narrative evidence, and more within the Byler context.

I revisited a few of my comments in editing, but didn't have the time to comb through so much material with season five just days away. However, since all of these topics are massive, unwieldy, and ever shifting: this is a gentle reminder that most of these thoughts and responses to the video are off-the-cuff just like any other reaction. Assertions are made with my best understanding in the moment.

I've realized after this experience that I am the Shane Madej of investigating queer canon likelihood, but without his (lovable) mockery of the subject matter. Like if Shane approached paranormal evidence in much the same way he always has but simultaneously really, really wanted ghosts to be real and loved them as much as Ryan does. <3

Context Note: I've only just found out that Mike is confirmed to not know Will is in love with him, in which case there are some comments in the video that are admittedly behind the times and need revisiting, as well as some comments that would be approached differently but reach similar conclusions.

Tech Note: My voice comes off a little harsh in the audio. Turning the down the volume a bit takes the edge off.

Files

The Byler Video

SUPPORT: Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/brittanydiamond ($2-$5 for uncut videos, early access, voting, livestreams, and more!) Ko-fi: https://ko-fi.com/brittanydiamond (one time support) CONTACT: Tumblr: https://gaywatch.tumblr.com Bluesky: @gaywatch.bsky.social #Gaywatch

Comments

bigmamag

Wow I certainly got bang for my buck! I love the analysis and the respect going on. Of course I hope you’re 100% wrong in two days lol but yeah I’ve done my time over the 26 years I’ve been in fandom and the skeptic in me sees both sides and is battening down the hatches on her ship. I think all of us have had a ship they wanted to be canon so badly and were crushed when it didn’t happen. I guess it’ll just be great if history is made, I’m sick of the only history being made in recent years being bad history, like I’m a millennial, I’m tired of living through historical events!

Brittany Diamond

Honestly, ever since Good Omens I feel like the odds are never zero (no matter what the skeptic side of me says). But it's been a couple years, we need a new step forward. 🤞🏻 Also, I forgot to put this in the post, but full credit needs to go to Ronald's video for, if not making me a believer, then making Byler a full OTP of mine. As I edited the reaction and looked at everything...yeah, the story there is just amazing. I'm so in. <3

bigmamag

For sure, and at least the fix it fic will be AMAZING :P

Susana del Mar

Ugh I'm soooo TORN, I'm deffinitely new to this shipping world so when I came across these 'Mike Wheeler is queer' type of videos I absolutely went down the rabbit hole that 'oh this must be the only possible explanation' so watching this is informative yet heartbreaking and still one can't help but hope in the tiniest possibility that it's actually true 😭 and I hope you're actually wrong 😆 3:22:00 Well she doesn't sign 'Love, El' anymore, just 'From El' 3:40:00 El & Mike do not have a scene after the 2 day jump Also the episode where Mike's mom talks to him about "all this that's been going on with Will" and the S4 finale, the episode where Jonathan talks to Will about him being gay are both written by the Duffer Brothers Thank you so much for doing this video, almost 6 hours of footage is insane and your efforts are very much appreciated. I watched it ALL 😅

Susana del Mar

Also there's this substack I've been following for over two years now run by someone that mentioned they're a scholar in something related to writing/cinema anaylisis, I'm not quite sure. They're like LEGIT, they've written SO many entries about Young Royals, which is how I found them because I was obsessed with the show. They talk about metaphors and mirroring; they've also written about many shows/films. They recently wrote about Stranger Things and provide quite a different perspective than all these youtube analyses, their conclusions about the shows' metaphors I haven't seen anywhere else and if the video got you into byler you're deffinitely gonna want to be reading their entry, especially because their focus is on the writing https://tvmicroscope.substack.com/p/stranger-than-you-think-example-stranger I'd love to know your thoughts if you read it 🙂

Tangent

Ahh I was waiting for this! Ive been into byler for a while now. I disagree with a lot of your points, though I also agree with some, but I'm too tired to think of what to write rn :') and wont have time before vol 1 airs so I'll just say I think the reason my interpretaion of season 4 is so different to yours all comes down to how differently I interpret the rain fight. To me that was definitely mike saying will doesn't like girls 'yet', while will was obviously hurt because of the reason he doesnt like girls 'yet', and scene itself was meant to make us as viewers wonder if will was gay - because while its a big hint to viewers mike does imply he doesnt like girls because he hasn't 'grown up' yet. That said, I really enjoyed your commentary and I'm so excited for season 5 as a whole, and am hoping for so many things, including byler

Susana del Mar

6:40 IT IS TIME!!!!!!! Byler ENDGAME!!! 💛💙