Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Conclave: Vidyard, WeTransfer

Comments

ali

The fact this is coming to us on Pride is so amazing <3

Vee

this dropped just when i was looking for something to watch before going to bed, i am once again #blessed. it's late so i'll be back tomorrow with more coherent thoughts but in the meantime: lmfaooo i was waiting for your reaction to the last twist the entire time and it did not disappoint. happy pride!! 🏳‍🌈🏳️‍⚧️ what a great movie to start the month with and before you think to yourself that you were mistaken in looking for The Gay One, it's Lawrence actually :) he's canonically bisexual in the book (although, uh. non-practicing.) Bellini also has some strong Implications iirc. and of course Benitez has transcended these things in more ways than one.

Rebecca D

I loved watching this with you. I forgot how fucking stunning this movie is! ❤️

ten

this movie MOVED me in a way I didn't think it would from someone with a religious background 😭 can't wait to watch it with you

Vee

alright, long comment ahead. finally somewhere i can info dump because i actually know something about the topic, yaay - i understand why you said at the beginning of the video that even one queer character would be fantastic in a movie about the vatican, but i need you to know that an estimated 40 to 80% of the Roman Curia are gay. including some of the more outspoken homophobes, as usual. there are many inside sources for this information, the most recent and exhaustive one being Frédéric Martel's In the Closet of the Vatican. i read this one during research a few years ago, and while it was one of my less academic sources (Martel's a journalist) it was also the most entertaining. i recommended it if you'd like to listen to messy ass old homosexuals spilling tea about each other. - "they're doing incredible things with red in this movie" they really are! Lisy Christl was rightfully nominated for an oscar, i believe the artisans worked for 5 months on the costumes, including the rings and crosses which are tailored to each character's political leanings. they also chose a specific shade of red that's no longer used irl, i watched this before last year's actual conclave, and then i watched the real conclave (#latinist) and i was disappointed by how cheap the clothes looked lol. also speaking of colour, they're doing incredible things with blue as well, being the colour the sisters wear, but it fades into the background and mostly serves to highlight the brighter and more eye-catching red, which is thematically incredible. it's very noticeable in the scene after the bomb, just before Benitez adresses the other cardinals about war, there's a shot of him surrounded by empty blue seats. so good. - the parts that aren't translated/subtitled are in latin, mostly prayers or oaths etc. i would say that's on purpose what with the general message of the movie but when Tedesco drops some random latin in the middle of his italian it is translated, so who knows. also on latin, paradoxical for me of all people to say this, but the catholics who want latin liturgy to come back are usually all insane, unfortunately. there's a church near my house that practices the tridentine mass (a specific form of roman rite) and they are just straight up notorious fascists! - speaking of fascists, lmao the face you made at the 'pope in the hitler youth'. that was Ratzinger, ex-Benedict XVI. his father was a police officer who refused to join the nazis and Ratzinger was briefly conscripted into the hitler youth. he says he was forced to join and couldn't avoid military service and never fired a shot anyway, which may very well be true, but he was also fucking awful so who cares really. - regarding the two figures we keep zooming in on inside the sistine chapel. that's judgement :) on one side are the souls rising towards heaven, and on the other, the one Lawrence keeps looking at, the damned descending to hell and being tortured by various demons. i believe i remember you saying you've been to the sistine chapel so you probably remember how overwhelming it looks. the ceiling is the part that's usually showcased, unsurprisingly. michelangelo painted it when he was 30, and the church was at the apex of its power under the very ambitious Julius II. it's a very high renaissance 'We are the Most Powerful Institution Around' type of production. the last judgement was painted when michelangelo was in his 60s, during a more difficult moment for the Church, at the height of the Reformation and after the 1527 sack of rome. you can definitely see it as a kind of 'embrace the Church and ascend, or Die in hell' message. cardinals do have to face it irl when they cast their vote, and every time Lawrence does so he stares at the demons and the sinners because he doesn't know if he's doing the right thing. he's not acting out of faith but for political machinations, and so when he votes for himself not only is there a literal intervention from god in the form of the explosion that brings in the light, but the demons are also in full view. good stuff. anyway, thank you for reacting to this! this movie's even better on a rewatch, once you know the final twist and you can really see how deeply the gender politics are incorporated, and the sound design with the constant breathing and the birdsong, the use of light for moving forward and outward, the women's movement while the men are static. it's so good. good catch spotting those lines on the wall btw, i hadn't even noticed! great detail. hope this was at least a little useful even if just for your recent middle ages research, and have a good break!

Francesca

I am not religious, but still the part of the movie I get emotional about is that Benitez walked into the Vatican and found a singular person he thought was meant to be the next Pope. He looked and found an imperfect, but good man and believed in him and then he is chosen as Pope and the man he believed in looked at him with hope and belief.

E. Soup

WAIT WHAT. I need to read the book!

E. Soup

So, I think the reason this movie was suggested, other than Benitez being intersex, is that people ship Lawrence and Benitez. There aren't a TON of moments in the movie to ship them but the ones that exist... I mean I definitely get it. If you look it up on tumblr you'll find sooo much fanart and I imagine they have a presence on ao3 as well. Also when I first watched this I thought Benitez was trans at first and I was about to fall out of my chair (possibly what you thought as well??). Oh well. The world wasn't ready for that yet.

Vee

yes! honestly the movie is a pretty 1:1 adaptation, i was surprised at how closely it followed the narrative structure of the book (though i think the book itself could have used 50 more pages or so). the only difference is that we're inside lawrence's (or lomeli in the book) head, so we get this like, passing comment about how he knows what it's like to desire and be desired by both men and women. and the rest of his bitchy little commentary lol. but don't go into it expecting a lengthy exploration of catholic sexual repression, there's zero time for that. and everyone's too repressed anyway. the one content warning i'll give is that book lawrence has what i would barely hesitate to call an eating disorder, so there can be comments about food, weight, other people's bodies etc, if that's a concern.

ineovv

Ohhh! Thank you for typing all this out, this is so interesting! Will definitely check out the book you mentioned.

ali

Something about Tedesco hittin' the vape after the Tremblay Adeyemi cafeteria drama sends me into fits of giggles every time.

ali

The way I burst into tears the first time I heard Benitez say "I am what God made me." Bless you, Pope Innocent. Wish I lived in whatever universe he is Pope in.

cobratattoos

this is truly one of the movies ever

Max

I watched the movie the first time when the irl conclave was going on, but damn I forgot how stunning it was in every aspect!!!

Brittany Diamond

Damn dude, thank you so much for this essay. Gonna need business weeks to process gays in the Curia.

Vee

diversity win (??) one of the most homophobic institutions on earth is mostly composed of deeply repressed and/or hypocritical homosexuals!

Pavlína Nováková

Not me peacefully watching your reaction to Conclave, only for my doorbell to ring and Jehovah’s Witnesses to ask if I want to talk about Bible study. Is it a sign or just the ultimate irony? 😭

E. Soup

I have now read the book! You're right, it could have been a bit longer to flesh out the ending a little more, but I really liked it. I was surprised by something in the ending but I realize why they changed it for the movie, probably made it a little easier to explain.