"Caught In Our Pajamas" (Patreon ORIGINAL) (Patreon)
Downloads
Content
The apartment’s front door creaks open and footsteps lead to our bedroom door and stop outside. A long silence fills the room as the door opens and then the hallway light falls directly across our bed. Blake stirs next to me, voice thick with sleep, not fully awake yet. “Five more minutes, babe...”
Danny stands frozen in the doorway, hand still on the knob, his eyes moving slowly from me to Blake and back again. His jaw is tight. His shoulders are shaking. He clutches a fist to his teeth to stifle a laugh. “Bro. Bro! Is that... fuckin Barbie?!?”
The sound of Danny’s voice makes Blake go very still and it wakes me up as I’m snuggled against Blake’s back as the big spoon. I look over Blake’s shoulder at Danny standing in our bedroom door. “Mmm. Fuck off Danny. It’s too goddamn early...” I snuggle into Blake.
Danny’s eyes are wide, darting between the two of us like he’s watching a tennis match as he tries to figure out which one to tease. The shaking in his shoulders gets worse. He pulls out his phone. “Nah. Nah nah nah nah nah. I am not fucking off. What am I looking at right now?” He points the camera, not even subtle about it. Two grown men, snuggling in their bed, wearing matching pink Barbie pajamas…
Blake shifts, rolling slightly onto his back. The blanket slides down and his pink top with a doll’s face on the chest becomes fully visible. He blinks up at Danny, still half-asleep, his brain clearly buffering. “Why are you in our apartment?”
Danny lets out a wheeze. He’s biting his bottom lip so hard it might bleed. “You told me I could come over. But you’re just gonna lie there in matching... in MATCHING...” He gestures wildly at the pajamas, at the identical pink fleece, at the fact that I am literally wrapped around Blake like a koala on a eucalyptus tree.
Blake looks down at himself, then over at me, then back at Danny. Something clicks behind his sleepy brown eyes and a slow, unbothered smile spreads across his face. “Anniversary gift.”
Danny makes a sound like a tea kettle about to blow. “ANNIVERSARY?! What anniversary?! You’ve been together for like - ” He catches himself, looks at me, looks at Blake, notices the two matching pink coffee mugs on the nightstand, the little heart-shaped drugstore greeting card. “Is that a fucking CARD?”
Blake reaches over and pulls the blanket up, tucking it around us both with zero urgency, like Danny is a mild inconvenience he’ll get to eventually. “You jealous or are you just here to make noise?”
“Seriously, Danny...” I open my sleepy eyes. “Do you have a purpose other than pestering us on a Sunday morning?”
He steps fully into the room now. “A purpose? Bro, I came over because you said I could use your PlayStation. That was the deal. I show up, you let me run 2K, I leave.” He pauses, looks at the pajamas again. His phone is still up. “Actually no. New plan. I’m not leaving until somebody explains to me why there’s two grown men in matching Barbie PJs with a love card on the nightstand between matching fucking coffee mugs!”
Blake is still snuggling. My arm is draped over his waist under the blanket, thumb tracing a lazy circle against his hip like this is completely normal, like Danny isn’t standing three feet away and vibrating like a chihuahua. “There was a sale. Two for one.”
“Two for ONE?!”
Blake shrugs one shoulder. “Seemed wasteful to buy just one.”
Danny turns to me, eyes pleading, like maybe I’m the reasonable one here, the one who can explain why his bro is lying in pink fleece cuddling another dude like they’re in the gayest Hallmark movie ever. “Joey. Joey, look at me. Are you telling me you WANTED to wear this? Voluntarily? On your body?” He gestures at my pajama top. “Because Blake I get. Blake would wear a trash bag if you told him it was cute. But YOU?” He leans in, grinning like a shark. “What’s the real story, pretty boy?”
“Dude...” I roll off of Blake and onto my back and stretch hard, fully annoyed, then stumble to my feet and show off the full outfit. A long-sleeve pink fleece top and matching pants, little Barbie logos all over, with the doll’s face featured in a large graphic on the chest. I pull out the hem of the top and look down at the stretched image. “They’re fucking adorable! It’s called whimsy, you dope. Why can’t you wrap your tiny brain around the idea that we like to look cute for each other?”
His mouth falls open. He slowly pans the phone’s camera up and down my full outfit like he’s filming a crime scene. “Whimsy. He said whimsy. Did you hear that, Blake?”
Blake props himself up on one elbow, blanket pooling around his waist. He’s watching me with a lazy half-smile, eyes still heavy with sleep, looking at me like I’m the greatest thing he’s ever seen. “I heard him.”
Danny runs his hand over the back of his neck like he’s trying to physically process what’s happening. “Okay okay okay. Let me get this straight. Matching pink PJs with dollies on them. After sleeping tangled up like two pieces of fucking pasta. Next to a love card.” Danny looks up at me. “And you’re not embarrassed? Not even a little?”
Blake sits on the edge of the bed. “Why would we be embarrassed?”
“Because it’s CRAZY, Blake! You’re a six-foot-three dude! You play basketball! You have tattoos!”
Blake looks down at his arms with the full tattoo sleeves. “And?”
I rise from my side of the bed. “What’s the boy version of being pussy-whipped?” I mumble as I scratch my balls and shuffle towards the door, headed for the kitchen. “I’m gonna make coffee, babe. Full pot? Danny doesn’t get any, though!”
A low laugh rumbles out of Blake’s chest. He stretches, arms above his head, the pink fleece riding up just enough to show a strip of stupidly ripped stomach. “Yeah, full pot. And he gets one cup if he starts to behave himself.”
Danny gives up and follows me to the kitchen because of course he does. He leans against the counter, arms crossed, watching me move around the space. “So real talk though. How long has this been going on? The matching pajamas, the cards, the cuddling?” He ticks each one off on his fingers. “Because last month Blake told me you were his new boyfriend and I figured, Oh cool, Joey and Blake, what a great couple. But now I’m looking at a fucking gay boy pajama catalog come to life.” He tilts his head. “What changed?”
From the bedroom, muffled by his pillow, Blake says, “Nothing changed. We’re in love.”
“Plus we usually sleep naked, so consider yourself lucky we were even dressed...” I fumble the coffee maker into life.
Danny’s eyebrows shoot up so fast they nearly leave his face. “You sleep NAKED? And you put on the cute pajamas just for the occasion?!? That’s somehow worse. That means you CHOSE to be domestic.” He pulls himself up onto the counter, sneakers dangling.
“FYI, I am not cooking breakfast for Danny,” I call out to Blake. “He’s rude.”
The coffee maker gurgles to life, filling the small kitchen with that rich, dark smell. From the bedroom, the sound of Blake shifting under the covers, the rustle of pink fleece against sheets.
Danny watches me getting breakfast together, eyes flicking back toward the bedroom doorway. “Rude? I’m RUDE? You guys told me to come over! You said ‘door’s open, come on in.’ That’s an invitation, Joey. I didn’t break any laws.” He pulls out his phone again, scrolling. “Also I’m posting this.”
Blake appears in the kitchen doorway, leaning against the frame. He’s still in the pajamas. His hair is a mess. He looks like a sleepy pink grizzly bear that wandered out of hibernation. His eyes find me first, then slide to Danny. “Don’t post that.”
“Or what?”
Blake doesn’t say anything else. Just looks at Danny with those calm brown eyes. The kind of look that doesn’t need words.
Danny’s thumb hovers over the screen. “Okay so like... you two are cute and all. Genuinely. But somebody needs to explain the card. The little heart stickers on it. Was that your handwriting, Joey?” He points at the nightstand visible through the doorway.
“Yes.” I’m thoroughly exasperated with this conversation. “Why can’t you handle the idea that we’re in love? It’s very fucking normal, you know. It isn’t 1952!”
Danny throws his hands up. “I never said it WASN’T normal! It’s surprising! There’s a difference!”
Blake has drifted closer. He’s behind me now, not touching me, just standing there with his arms crossed, watching Danny pace. Something almost territorial about the way he’s positioned himself. Not aggressive, just... present.
Danny turns to me, pointing. “Okay. I need you to look me dead in my eyes and tell me this is real. Like REAL real. Not just ‘oh he’s hot and we fuck so we’re together’ real. Because I’ve seen you go through people, Joey. You don’t do commitment.”
The coffee maker beeps. Steam curls up from the pot, and Blake reaches past me to grab mugs from the cabinet, his chest brushing against my shoulder. Even fresh out of bed he smells amazing to me.
Danny leans in, dead serious now. “So what’s different about him?”
“Ugh...” I grab Blake by the hips and pull him into my body. Our matching pajamas turn into a giant muscular blob of athletic masculinity as I wet my lips and kiss him, deep and slow, sweet and loving.
Blake’s hand comes up instinctively to the back of my neck, fingers threading into my hair, and he leans into it like breathing. No performance. No audience awareness. Just two people who know exactly what the other likes.
“That’s what’s different, Danny. Get it now?” I start gathering eggs and cheese from the fridge.
Blake licks his bottom lip where my mouth just was. He’s still half-smiling, eyes a little glazed. He turns and grabs the coffee pot, pouring himself a cup like he hasn’t just been kissed stupid in his own kitchen.
Danny’s voice drops lower. Less theatrical now. Something almost genuine underneath the clowning. “Yo, for real though. I’ve known you two separately for like three years. Blake’s my boy from the court. Joey’s my boy from everywhere else. And I never once saw either of you look at anybody like that.” He sets his phone down on the counter. “I’m not being weird. I’m just saying. That shit looked real.”
Blake takes a sip of coffee, leaning against the counter next to me. His pinky finds mine. Hooks it. “It is real.”
Beat of silence. Then Danny’s whole face cracks into a grin. “Alright. Fine. Whatever! I believe you. But I came here to play 2K so somebody better tell me where the controller is before I lose my mind.”
“There’s a drawer in the coffee table,” I say with what I hope is a dismissive wave. “Controller is inside. Keep the volume reasonable. It’s fuckin Sunday. The fuckin Lord’s day...” I start whipping the eggs while Blake grates the cheese.
Danny’s already moving toward the living room, practically bouncing. “The Lord’s day? Since when do you homos go to church?”
Blake grates the cheese while sipping his coffee, completely domestic. “He doesn’t. He just says that when he’s annoyed. And don’t call us ‘homos’ in our own place. You are rude.”
The apartment settles into a strange kind of rhythm. Danny drops onto the couch, flips the TV on, and the familiar sounds of the 2K intro splash across the room. The kitchen fills with the sizzle of butter hitting a hot pan, the whisk of eggs, the gentle scrape of cheese against a grater. Three guys in an apartment on a Sunday morning. It almost feels normal. Except two of them are wearing matching pink pajamas with Barbie dolls on them.
I make cheesy scrambled eggs like a fuckin pro - I think those eggs might be why Blake fell in love with me. I plate them up, and Blake and I sit at the kitchen table to eat while Danny plays his game.
By the time Danny is ten minutes into his game, volume creeping upward despite direct orders, he cranes his neck over the couch. “Bro can I ask you something personal?” He doesn’t wait for permission. “Are you the top or the bottom in this relationship? Because I need to know for science. I’m trying to figure out which one of you broke the other one.”
“What the actual fuck is wrong with you, Danny? Were you raised by wild animals?” I shake my head but answer anyway. “We’re verse, if you really need to know!”
The controller freezes mid-motion. He turns his whole body on the couch to face the kitchen. “So you boys go BOTH ways! You let this man put it in you, bro?”
Blake is eating eggs. Calmly. He takes a bite, chews, swallows. Looks up at Danny with those sleepy brown eyes. “Yup.”
The eggs are good. Really good. Fluffy, perfectly seasoned, the cheese melted into every bite. Blake keeps stealing glances at me while he eats, that soft look he gets sometimes when he thinks nobody’s watching. Except Danny is always watching.
He spins back to his game, muttering. “For the record, I bottom too, sometimes. No shame there. Just while we’re all being so open. No homophobia from this boy!” He pauses. “Unless that type of self-hating shit is hot now. Is it hot?”
Blake looks at me across the table and just shakes his head over his plate.
“Should we ask him?” I say quietly. “I still say he’s gonna be way too much...” We’ve been discussing adding a third to the bed, and Danny was Blake’s suggested candidate.
From the couch, not even looking away from the screen, Danny says, “I can HEAR you, y’know...”
Blake stabs a piece of egg, pops it in his mouth, chews slowly. His bare foot finds mine under the table, pressing against it. Casual. Possessive. The kind of touch that says “mine” without a word. That calm, unbothered energy he carries like a second skin. “He is loud. He’ll definitely talk too much...”
Danny’s thumbs work the controller but his head is clearly elsewhere. He’s been quiet for almost thirty seconds, which might be a personal record. “Wait. Hold on.” He pauses the game. The TV freezes on a player mid-dribble. “Oh my god. Are you two, like... are you recruiting me for something?”
Blake finishes his eggs. Pushes the plate aside. Looks at me with that steady, patient gaze. “Your call, babe.”
“You said you think he’s bigger than you,” I answer. “I’ve never done it with anybody really big. That’s the only reason I’d say yes...”
The sound of Danny’s voice makes Blake go very still and it wakes me up as I’m snuggled against Blake’s back as the big spoon. I look over Blake’s shoulder at Danny standing in our bedroom door. “Mmm. Fuck off Danny. It’s too goddamn early...” I snuggle into Blake.
Danny’s eyes are wide, darting between the two of us like he’s watching a tennis match as he tries to figure out which one to tease. The shaking in his shoulders gets worse. He pulls out his phone. “Nah. Nah nah nah nah nah. I am not fucking off. What am I looking at right now?” He points the camera, not even subtle about it. Two grown men, snuggling in their bed, wearing matching pink Barbie pajamas…
Blake shifts, rolling slightly onto his back. The blanket slides down and his pink top with a doll’s face on the chest becomes fully visible. He blinks up at Danny, still half-asleep, his brain clearly buffering. “Why are you in our apartment?”
Danny lets out a wheeze. He’s biting his bottom lip so hard it might bleed. “You told me I could come over. But you’re just gonna lie there in matching... in MATCHING...” He gestures wildly at the pajamas, at the identical pink fleece, at the fact that I am literally wrapped around Blake like a koala on a eucalyptus tree.
Blake looks down at himself, then over at me, then back at Danny. Something clicks behind his sleepy brown eyes and a slow, unbothered smile spreads across his face. “Anniversary gift.”
Danny makes a sound like a tea kettle about to blow. “ANNIVERSARY?! What anniversary?! You’ve been together for like - ” He catches himself, looks at me, looks at Blake, notices the two matching pink coffee mugs on the nightstand, the little heart-shaped drugstore greeting card. “Is that a fucking CARD?”
Blake reaches over and pulls the blanket up, tucking it around us both with zero urgency, like Danny is a mild inconvenience he’ll get to eventually. “You jealous or are you just here to make noise?”
“Seriously, Danny...” I open my sleepy eyes. “Do you have a purpose other than pestering us on a Sunday morning?”
He steps fully into the room now. “A purpose? Bro, I came over because you said I could use your PlayStation. That was the deal. I show up, you let me run 2K, I leave.” He pauses, looks at the pajamas again. His phone is still up. “Actually no. New plan. I’m not leaving until somebody explains to me why there’s two grown men in matching Barbie PJs with a love card on the nightstand between matching fucking coffee mugs!”
Blake is still snuggling. My arm is draped over his waist under the blanket, thumb tracing a lazy circle against his hip like this is completely normal, like Danny isn’t standing three feet away and vibrating like a chihuahua. “There was a sale. Two for one.”
“Two for ONE?!”
Blake shrugs one shoulder. “Seemed wasteful to buy just one.”
Danny turns to me, eyes pleading, like maybe I’m the reasonable one here, the one who can explain why his bro is lying in pink fleece cuddling another dude like they’re in the gayest Hallmark movie ever. “Joey. Joey, look at me. Are you telling me you WANTED to wear this? Voluntarily? On your body?” He gestures at my pajama top. “Because Blake I get. Blake would wear a trash bag if you told him it was cute. But YOU?” He leans in, grinning like a shark. “What’s the real story, pretty boy?”
“Dude...” I roll off of Blake and onto my back and stretch hard, fully annoyed, then stumble to my feet and show off the full outfit. A long-sleeve pink fleece top and matching pants, little Barbie logos all over, with the doll’s face featured in a large graphic on the chest. I pull out the hem of the top and look down at the stretched image. “They’re fucking adorable! It’s called whimsy, you dope. Why can’t you wrap your tiny brain around the idea that we like to look cute for each other?”
His mouth falls open. He slowly pans the phone’s camera up and down my full outfit like he’s filming a crime scene. “Whimsy. He said whimsy. Did you hear that, Blake?”
Blake props himself up on one elbow, blanket pooling around his waist. He’s watching me with a lazy half-smile, eyes still heavy with sleep, looking at me like I’m the greatest thing he’s ever seen. “I heard him.”
Danny runs his hand over the back of his neck like he’s trying to physically process what’s happening. “Okay okay okay. Let me get this straight. Matching pink PJs with dollies on them. After sleeping tangled up like two pieces of fucking pasta. Next to a love card.” Danny looks up at me. “And you’re not embarrassed? Not even a little?”
Blake sits on the edge of the bed. “Why would we be embarrassed?”
“Because it’s CRAZY, Blake! You’re a six-foot-three dude! You play basketball! You have tattoos!”
Blake looks down at his arms with the full tattoo sleeves. “And?”
I rise from my side of the bed. “What’s the boy version of being pussy-whipped?” I mumble as I scratch my balls and shuffle towards the door, headed for the kitchen. “I’m gonna make coffee, babe. Full pot? Danny doesn’t get any, though!”
A low laugh rumbles out of Blake’s chest. He stretches, arms above his head, the pink fleece riding up just enough to show a strip of stupidly ripped stomach. “Yeah, full pot. And he gets one cup if he starts to behave himself.”
Danny gives up and follows me to the kitchen because of course he does. He leans against the counter, arms crossed, watching me move around the space. “So real talk though. How long has this been going on? The matching pajamas, the cards, the cuddling?” He ticks each one off on his fingers. “Because last month Blake told me you were his new boyfriend and I figured, Oh cool, Joey and Blake, what a great couple. But now I’m looking at a fucking gay boy pajama catalog come to life.” He tilts his head. “What changed?”
From the bedroom, muffled by his pillow, Blake says, “Nothing changed. We’re in love.”
“Plus we usually sleep naked, so consider yourself lucky we were even dressed...” I fumble the coffee maker into life.
Danny’s eyebrows shoot up so fast they nearly leave his face. “You sleep NAKED? And you put on the cute pajamas just for the occasion?!? That’s somehow worse. That means you CHOSE to be domestic.” He pulls himself up onto the counter, sneakers dangling.
“FYI, I am not cooking breakfast for Danny,” I call out to Blake. “He’s rude.”
The coffee maker gurgles to life, filling the small kitchen with that rich, dark smell. From the bedroom, the sound of Blake shifting under the covers, the rustle of pink fleece against sheets.
Danny watches me getting breakfast together, eyes flicking back toward the bedroom doorway. “Rude? I’m RUDE? You guys told me to come over! You said ‘door’s open, come on in.’ That’s an invitation, Joey. I didn’t break any laws.” He pulls out his phone again, scrolling. “Also I’m posting this.”
Blake appears in the kitchen doorway, leaning against the frame. He’s still in the pajamas. His hair is a mess. He looks like a sleepy pink grizzly bear that wandered out of hibernation. His eyes find me first, then slide to Danny. “Don’t post that.”
“Or what?”
Blake doesn’t say anything else. Just looks at Danny with those calm brown eyes. The kind of look that doesn’t need words.
Danny’s thumb hovers over the screen. “Okay so like... you two are cute and all. Genuinely. But somebody needs to explain the card. The little heart stickers on it. Was that your handwriting, Joey?” He points at the nightstand visible through the doorway.
“Yes.” I’m thoroughly exasperated with this conversation. “Why can’t you handle the idea that we’re in love? It’s very fucking normal, you know. It isn’t 1952!”
Danny throws his hands up. “I never said it WASN’T normal! It’s surprising! There’s a difference!”
Blake has drifted closer. He’s behind me now, not touching me, just standing there with his arms crossed, watching Danny pace. Something almost territorial about the way he’s positioned himself. Not aggressive, just... present.
Danny turns to me, pointing. “Okay. I need you to look me dead in my eyes and tell me this is real. Like REAL real. Not just ‘oh he’s hot and we fuck so we’re together’ real. Because I’ve seen you go through people, Joey. You don’t do commitment.”
The coffee maker beeps. Steam curls up from the pot, and Blake reaches past me to grab mugs from the cabinet, his chest brushing against my shoulder. Even fresh out of bed he smells amazing to me.
Danny leans in, dead serious now. “So what’s different about him?”
“Ugh...” I grab Blake by the hips and pull him into my body. Our matching pajamas turn into a giant muscular blob of athletic masculinity as I wet my lips and kiss him, deep and slow, sweet and loving.
Blake’s hand comes up instinctively to the back of my neck, fingers threading into my hair, and he leans into it like breathing. No performance. No audience awareness. Just two people who know exactly what the other likes.
“That’s what’s different, Danny. Get it now?” I start gathering eggs and cheese from the fridge.
Blake licks his bottom lip where my mouth just was. He’s still half-smiling, eyes a little glazed. He turns and grabs the coffee pot, pouring himself a cup like he hasn’t just been kissed stupid in his own kitchen.
Danny’s voice drops lower. Less theatrical now. Something almost genuine underneath the clowning. “Yo, for real though. I’ve known you two separately for like three years. Blake’s my boy from the court. Joey’s my boy from everywhere else. And I never once saw either of you look at anybody like that.” He sets his phone down on the counter. “I’m not being weird. I’m just saying. That shit looked real.”
Blake takes a sip of coffee, leaning against the counter next to me. His pinky finds mine. Hooks it. “It is real.”
Beat of silence. Then Danny’s whole face cracks into a grin. “Alright. Fine. Whatever! I believe you. But I came here to play 2K so somebody better tell me where the controller is before I lose my mind.”
“There’s a drawer in the coffee table,” I say with what I hope is a dismissive wave. “Controller is inside. Keep the volume reasonable. It’s fuckin Sunday. The fuckin Lord’s day...” I start whipping the eggs while Blake grates the cheese.
Danny’s already moving toward the living room, practically bouncing. “The Lord’s day? Since when do you homos go to church?”
Blake grates the cheese while sipping his coffee, completely domestic. “He doesn’t. He just says that when he’s annoyed. And don’t call us ‘homos’ in our own place. You are rude.”
The apartment settles into a strange kind of rhythm. Danny drops onto the couch, flips the TV on, and the familiar sounds of the 2K intro splash across the room. The kitchen fills with the sizzle of butter hitting a hot pan, the whisk of eggs, the gentle scrape of cheese against a grater. Three guys in an apartment on a Sunday morning. It almost feels normal. Except two of them are wearing matching pink pajamas with Barbie dolls on them.
I make cheesy scrambled eggs like a fuckin pro - I think those eggs might be why Blake fell in love with me. I plate them up, and Blake and I sit at the kitchen table to eat while Danny plays his game.
By the time Danny is ten minutes into his game, volume creeping upward despite direct orders, he cranes his neck over the couch. “Bro can I ask you something personal?” He doesn’t wait for permission. “Are you the top or the bottom in this relationship? Because I need to know for science. I’m trying to figure out which one of you broke the other one.”
“What the actual fuck is wrong with you, Danny? Were you raised by wild animals?” I shake my head but answer anyway. “We’re verse, if you really need to know!”
The controller freezes mid-motion. He turns his whole body on the couch to face the kitchen. “So you boys go BOTH ways! You let this man put it in you, bro?”
Blake is eating eggs. Calmly. He takes a bite, chews, swallows. Looks up at Danny with those sleepy brown eyes. “Yup.”
The eggs are good. Really good. Fluffy, perfectly seasoned, the cheese melted into every bite. Blake keeps stealing glances at me while he eats, that soft look he gets sometimes when he thinks nobody’s watching. Except Danny is always watching.
He spins back to his game, muttering. “For the record, I bottom too, sometimes. No shame there. Just while we’re all being so open. No homophobia from this boy!” He pauses. “Unless that type of self-hating shit is hot now. Is it hot?”
Blake looks at me across the table and just shakes his head over his plate.
“Should we ask him?” I say quietly. “I still say he’s gonna be way too much...” We’ve been discussing adding a third to the bed, and Danny was Blake’s suggested candidate.
From the couch, not even looking away from the screen, Danny says, “I can HEAR you, y’know...”
Blake stabs a piece of egg, pops it in his mouth, chews slowly. His bare foot finds mine under the table, pressing against it. Casual. Possessive. The kind of touch that says “mine” without a word. That calm, unbothered energy he carries like a second skin. “He is loud. He’ll definitely talk too much...”
Danny’s thumbs work the controller but his head is clearly elsewhere. He’s been quiet for almost thirty seconds, which might be a personal record. “Wait. Hold on.” He pauses the game. The TV freezes on a player mid-dribble. “Oh my god. Are you two, like... are you recruiting me for something?”
Blake finishes his eggs. Pushes the plate aside. Looks at me with that steady, patient gaze. “Your call, babe.”
“You said you think he’s bigger than you,” I answer. “I’ve never done it with anybody really big. That’s the only reason I’d say yes...”
Blake’s foot presses harder against mine under the table. He doesn’t look up, but there’s a smirk pulling at the corner of his mouth. “I didn’t say he was bigger than me. I said he thinks he’s bigger.”
His whole face lights up like Christmas morning. “I AM bigger than you, Blake. That’s not a rumor, that’s a fact. I’ve seen you in the shower at the gym. I’m totally huge!”
Danny joins us in the kitchen and leans on the counter across from us, arms crossed. He’s trying to play it cool but his leg is bouncing. He’s looking at me now with something new in his expression, more... curious. “So let me get this straight. You two are sitting there in your little matching pajamas eating your cute breakfast and you’re seriously discussing letting me join your... what? A threesome? A throuple?” He runs his tongue across his bottom lip. “Because I will say yes. Just so we’re clear. I would absolutely say yes.”
“This is not a throuple!” I add without hesitation. “This is a one-time-only thing. I just like the idea of watching Blake fuck another guy. And he wants to watch me give head because I’m really good at it.”
Danny stares at my lips. “You’re really good at it?”
Blake nods once. Matter of fact. Like he’s confirming the weather. “Really good.”
Danny pushes off the counter and takes a step closer to the table. His voice drops, that theatrical energy replaced by something more raw. “Okay. Okay okay okay. So let me understand the logistics here. We fuck. Once. Blake watches you suck my dick. Maybe I fuck Blake? Maybe I fuck you? And then what? We go back to being bros after?”
Blake is staring him down, calm, assessing. His arm stretches along the back of my chair. “That’s the deal.”
“Can I be honest?” Danny doesn’t wait for a reply. “I’ve thought about Blake before. Once or twice. He’s got that whole... quiet big guy thing going on. And you...” His eyes travel down my pink pajama top, slow. “Yeah. I’d say yes for sure!”
Blake’s fingers brush the back of my neck. “He’s enthusiastic.”
Danny leans on the table. “So when do we start?”
“Go take a shower,” I tell him calmly. “You stink from that body spray and I can’t have my bedsheets getting that stank on them!”
He looks down at himself, offended. “I do NOT stink! This is Dior Sauvage!” He wrinkles his nose. He reads the room, looks at Blake’s face, looks at mine. His shoulders sag. “...Fine. You got clean towels?”
He doesn’t wait for an answer before he disappears down the hallway toward the bathroom, and within seconds the sound of cabinets opening and closing echoes through the apartment. Then the shower turns on.
The second Danny is out of the room, Blake’s whole demeanor shifts. Not much. Just a fraction. He turns to face me, his voice low. “You sure about this, babe?” His thumb traces along my jaw. “Because once he’s in our bed he’s gonna be loud and annoying and he won’t shut up. And if you don’t like it we can stop. I’m not so committed to this that I’m willing to see you uncomfortable or whatever...”
He leans in, his mouth close to my ear. His breath is warm and smells like coffee. “I do want to watch you though. That part’s true. I think about it so much...” His hand slides down my chest, palm flat against the pink fleece. “You really are the best at it.”
“You’re so fuckin sweet I wanna puke,” I say with a full-face grin, leaning in to kiss him hard and sloppy. “Danny is annoying as hell when he’s being chatty, but I have a gut feeling that he’s gonna be amazing in bed. He’s cocky but confident. Plus did you see how fucking excited he got? That’s exactly the kind of energy I was hoping for with a third...” I start clearing the table. “Are you good with this? You’re the one that’s gonna fuck him!”
He watches me clear the table, leaning back in his chair with his legs spread, completely relaxed. That lazy confidence that makes him so goddamn sexy. “I’m good with it.” He says it casually. His eyes follow me moving around the kitchen, wiping the counter, rinsing the pan.
The shower cuts off. The pipes shudder and go quiet.
Blake’s chin rests on my shoulder. “You wanna set the rules or should I? Because if he gets too loud I’m gagging him.”
“I think his energy might be fun. It’ll be like roleplay, maybe. When it’s just you and me we get all tender and lovey. I bet with him we can just fuck and get all feral! He’s not a lover. He’s a fuck boy!”
A low sound rumbles in his chest. Not quite a laugh. Something darker. “Fuck boy. Yeah.” His teeth graze my earlobe.
The bathroom door swings open and Danny steps into the hallway wearing just a towel wrapped low around his waist, like he lives here. His body is exactly what you’d expect from someone who talks about the gym constantly: broad shoulders, defined chest, a trail of dark hair leading down below the towel line.
He walks into the kitchen with water droplets on his collarbone. “So. We doing this or what?”
Blake pulls away from me and leans against the counter. Arms crossed. The shift is immediate. He’s not the soft, sleepy boyfriend anymore. “Rules first.”
“Rules? This ain’t a board meeting, bro!”
Quiet. Steady. “Joey’s in charge. I’m in charge. You do what we say. You don’t finish until we tell you to. You don’t touch Joey unless he tells you to. And if you can’t handle that, walk back to the bathroom and put your clothes back on.”
His jaw tightens. His eyes flick to me. There’s a challenge there; he wants to see if I’ll back Blake up or fold. “That’s a lot of power for two people in Barbie pajamas.”
“We won’t be in them for long,” I say, pulling off my pajama top. Danny swallows hard enough that it qualifies as a gulp. Blake takes off his top, too. “You’re here to service our fantasy. We’ve just decided that you’re our fuck boy. That’s your role. You good with that?”
His eyes track my bare torso. His tongue drags across his bottom lip. “Fuck boy.” He says it like he’s tasting it. “I mean... yeah. Yeah I can be your fuck boy. That’s hot actually.”
The kitchen feels charged now. Three shirtless guys, one of them in a towel, the other two bare-chested in matching pink pajama bottoms. Blake’s body is broader, more filled out, with thick arms, a solid chest.
Danny takes a step forward. Then catches himself. Looks at Blake for permission like he suddenly understands the hierarchy. “So what do I do first?” It’s the quietest tone he’s had so far.
Blake pushes off from the counter and walks casually to the bedroom. He pulls the comforter back and sits on the edge of the bed, legs apart, elbows on his knees. “Get naked. Then come in here.”
Danny looks at me and we cross the small space to join Blake in the bedroom. That competitive energy is still there but it’s mixing with something else now: anticipation. His fingers grip the towel at his hip. “What about you, boss?”
He’s talking to me. Not to Blake. His dark eyes are locked on my bare chest, water still dripping from his fade down his neck. “You gonna watch me strip or you wanna help?”
I walk over with full eye contact and pull his towel off. The towel drops and his dick springs free. He’s not lying about the size thing. He’s thick, half-hard already, foreskin uncut.
“Sit on the bed next to Blake. I’m gonna go down on you while Blake watches.” I kneel next to the bed. “And no kissing. That’s just for me and Blake. Got it?”
Danny lets out a breath like he’s been holding it since he walked in. “No kissing. Got it. That’s... yeah. Okay.” He moves to the bed and sits, the mattress dipping under his weight. Blake is on his left and I’m kneeling on the floor. Two sets of eyes on him.
Danny’s trying to play it cool and failing. His cock is getting harder by the second, twitching slightly under my gaze. He spreads his legs wider without being told. “So you’re really... like... down there...” He swallows. “I just wanna say I showered like you told me to. Real thorough.”
“I noticed,” I tell him from the floor, leaning in to smell him as I hold his cock.
He looks down at me kneeling between his legs. His dick jumps. “Bro, you look so fucking pretty on your knees. Like genuinely. This is insane.” He reaches toward my hair instinctively.
Without hesitation Blake catches Danny’s wrist. “We said no touching. Joey, do you want him to touch you?”
“No. Not yet.” I wet my lips and look at the hard cock in my hand. “Blake, baby, play with my hair. Danny, just lean back and enjoy yourself.” Danny’s thick cock is leaking precum and I lick it off and wrap my fingers around his balls. They’re heavy and large and low hanging, shaved smooth. I put the left one in my mouth and suck it while I look Blake in the eyes. “Mmmmm.”
Danny’s whole body jerks. A sharp exhale punches out of him and his head drops back. “Oh fuck oh FUCK.” His hands fist the sheets. He’s trying so hard not to touch me.
Blake’s fingers slide into my hair. Slow. Possessive. He threads through the strands and grips gently at the root, watching my mouth work on Danny’s balls. “Good boy,” he tells me quietly.
Danny’s cock is fully throbbing now. It’s a good eight inches, maybe more. His abs flex every time my tongue moves.
Blake’s grip tightens in my hair when Danny opens his mouth to say something. Blake cuts him off. “He didn’t ask you to talk.” Danny’s mouth snaps shut. His chest rises and falls. He looks at Blake with wide eyes.
“Show him that thing you do, babe,” Blake tells me without breaking eye contact with Danny.
I break out in a full grin that probably makes me look even prettier between Danny’s thighs. “I fuckin love you, babe…”
Danny doesn’t know it yet, but I don’t have a gag reflex. My lips slide down Danny’s thick shaft. My mouth is spread as wide as it can go and I eventually come to a stop with my nose in his pubes. He smells clean and I swallow around his embedded shaft and run my tongue along the underside.
His entire body goes rigid. Every muscle locks up. His mouth falls open and no sound comes out for a solid three seconds. “WHAT THE FUCK - ” His voice cracks. His hands grip the sheets hard, following the no-touching rule. “You didn’t even... you just... the whole thing? The WHOLE - ”
Danny’s cock throbs deep in my throat. A vein pulses in his neck as he looks down at me with an expression caught between disbelief and worship.
Blake’s hand stays in my hair. Steady. Gentle. He’s watching with a calm intensity that means he’s hard inside his pink pajama pants. His thumb strokes behind my ear. “Yeah. He does that.” He says it like it’s nothing, like watching his boyfriend deepthroat another man is just another Sunday morning activity.
“Oh my god. Oh my GOD. Blake you’re so lucky. You get this every night? How do you sleep? How do you FUNCTION?”
He shrugs. “Discipline.”
Danny laughs but it dissolves into a groan when my throat constricts around him again. His thighs are shaking. He bites his bottom lip hard. “I’m not gonna last if he keeps... ah, fuck. FUCK. Can I touch his hair at least? Please? I’m begging.”
I moan as I pull back slowly, his cock shiny with my saliva. “Nah. Blake, why don’t you play with his nipples. I’m trying to decide if I want him to cum for us or if we should make him wait...” I hold the base of that thick cock and gently slap it against my cheek as Blake reaches across to Danny’s chest, leaning toward Danny with unhurried energy. His fingers find Danny’s nipple and pinch. Not gently.
A sound comes out of Danny, high-pitched and needy. His back arches off the mattress as Blake rolls the nipple between his thumb and forefinger. His other hand stays tangled loosely in my hair. Danny is sandwiched between us, his dick twitching against my cheek in a wet smear.
His head rolls to look at Blake. Something vulnerable flashes across his face, like he hasn’t been expecting Blake to be good at this. “You’re... really calm about this. Like you’ve thought about touching me before or something.”
He doesn’t answer. Just switches to the other nipple. Twists.
Danny’s hips buck. He looks down at me, desperate. “Please let me cum. I’ll do anything. I’ll be your fuck boy forever. I’ll never talk shit again.”
Blake speaks low directly into Danny’s ear. “You’ll still talk shit. That’s what makes teasing you so fun.” His eyes find me. “What do you think, baby? Make him wait or give him what he wants?”
“Well, he tastes really good so I definitely wanna swallow it... Plus he’s gonna get hard all over again while we prep his ass for your cock.” I lick the precum from Danny’s cock to taste it again. “Yeah. You know, he smells really clean. And kinda like me because he used my body wash. Blake, do that armpit thing to him that I love...”
Blake lifts Danny’s arm and inhales the scent before he licks it slowly, dragging his flat tongue through the sparse hairs. He does this to me all the time and it drives me insane with pleasure. I resume sucking that whole thick cock and my throat swallows him as Blake’s tongue drags slow and wet under his arm.
“This is... Oh no.” Danny might be losing his entire mind. His body is responding to everything simultaneously. His nipple is hard under Blake’s fingers, his armpit is sending electric shocks down his spine, and my throat is doing things to his thick cock that shouldn’t be physically possible. His abs are clenching in waves. He starts babbling.
“I’m close I’m really close Joey I’m fuck you’re so good at this you’re so fucking good at this why does your mouth feel like - ”
Blake bites down on Danny’s armpit hairs. Not hard. Just enough.
“FUCK - ” His hips stutter. He’s fighting it. Trying to hold back like some part of his brain thinks he needs permission. “Can I cum? Please? Somebody tell me I can cum because I can’t hold it.”
Blake pulls back from Danny’s armpit. Looks down at me. His hand pets my hair gently. “Baby. You wanna swallow it or do you want him to beg more first?”
Danny is desperate. Writhing. Looking between us like a man in purgatory. “I will literally pay you. Name a price. ANYTHING.”
“I’m gonna pinch the base of your cock so you can’t cum. Then I’m gonna massage your taint with my thumb for a bit. I won’t make you wait too much longer...”
His face contorts into pure agony. “You’re EVIL. You’re actually evil. I thought you were the nice one!”
My thumb finds that sensitive strip of skin between Danny’s balls and his hole. I press in, firm and deliberate, while my other hand clamps down on the base of Danny’s thick cock like a cockring. Danny’s whole body lifts off the mattress.
His fists pound the bed once. “Oh god. Oh that’s... that’s so mean. That’s so fucking mean and I hate you and I love you and - ” His head thrashes sideways. Blake is right there, watching his face with quiet fascination.
He’s leaning close to Danny now. Close enough that their lips almost touch. He doesn’t close the gap. Just watches. “How does it feel?”
Danny is breathless. Eyes glassy. “Like I need to cum so bad I might cry.”
The faintest smile. “Good.”
Danny’s cock is angry red, veins bulging, twitching against my grip. Precum is running down from the tip in a clear stream that keeps growing. His balls are drawn up tight, full and heavy. Every time my thumb presses against his taint his hips jerk involuntarily but he can’t finish. The pressure at the base won’t let him.
He looks down at me with wet eyes. His voice comes out broken. “Please please please please.” He looks at Blake. “Please, man. Tell him.”
“Hey!” I give Danny a sharp glare. “Blake doesn’t tell me what to do. Right, baby?”
A slow smile spreads across Blake’s face. He leans back on his hands, watching me work. “Right, baby.”
Danny’s head falls back and he groans at the ceiling like he’s praying. “You’re both fucking tyrants and I’m the bitch in the middle and this is - ”
My thumb circles his taint in a slow, deliberate pattern. Not enough pressure to make him cum. Just enough to keep him right at the edge, suspended in that torturous space where every nerve ending is screaming. His skin is flushed from his chest to his ears. The confident, loud, always-has-something-to-say Danny is reduced to a writhing mess on our bed.
Blake reaches over and drags one finger through the growing pool on Danny’s belly. Holds it up. Looks at me. “He’s leaking a lot.” He puts his finger in his mouth and tastes it. His eyebrows lift slightly. “Not bad.”
Danny’s staring at Blake with his mouth open. “Did you just... are you two fucking with me?”
I decide he’s had enough. Plus I really, really love swallowing cum and his precum tastes nice.
“Cum.” I wrap my lips around the thick head and take two inches of him between my lips and suck hard as I lick. I release the pressure from the base and he explodes into my mouth. His cock pulses thick and heavy against my tongue. Rope after rope, hot and salty.
I maintain eye contact with Blake as he plays with my hair the whole time. He keeps pinching that nipple, calm as ever, watching my throat work. Danny’s eyes roll back and his hand flies to my head on instinct.
Blake catches Danny’s wrist without looking. Pushes it back down to the mattress. “No touching.”
A single tear rolls down Danny’s cheek and he doesn’t even notice. “I can’t... it’s too much... he won’t stop swallowing and I can’t - ”
His hips are jerking in stuttered little thrusts, fucking my mouth as the last pulses drain out of him.
Danny collapses back, panting. Destroyed. Then he turns his head toward Blake. “Your boyfriend swallows you like that every day?”
His hand is still in my hair. He strokes gently. “Every day.”
Danny covers his face with both hands. “I’m never gonna recover from this.”
“He tastes really different, babe!” I climb up and use Blake’s powerful thighs as a chair, then kiss him firm and deep with the taste of another man’s cum still on my tongue. “It’s saltier than yours, right? But sweeter than mine...”
Blake kisses me back deep, tongue sliding against mine, tasting Danny on me. No hesitation. He pulls back with a thoughtful expression. “Yeah. Saltier. But not bad.”
I sit sideways on Blake’s lap and look down at Danny, now just a puddle of a man. “That was fun, bro.” He’s still got his hands over his face. He spreads his fingers to peek out at us. “You’re sitting on his lap and kissing him after I just came in your mouth?!? That’s the most disrespectful shit I’ve ever seen. And I fuckin love it!”
His chest is still heaving, nipples hard and pink from Blake’s attention. He looks fucked out and we’ve barely started. “So what’s next? Because I came hard but I feel like you two have a whole agenda planned. You said something about prepping my ass for Blake’s cock.” He licks his lips. “Is that what’s next?”
Blake’s arm wraps around my waist. He presses his lips to the back of my neck.
“The prep is actually our favorite part,” I tell Danny. “We go slow...” I stand and cross to the other side of the bed and return with a pump bottle of lube, setting it on the nightstand.
“So I’m gonna play with Blake while he gets you ready.” Blake and I finally take off our pink pajama bottoms. Both pairs are soaked through in the crotch and Blake tosses them casually into the hamper near the door.
Danny stares at our cocks as they spring free. We’re both around seven inches long and cut. Blake is thicker, so Danny is either lucky or cursed, depending on what he’s into. His eyes bounce between them, doing the comparison. His jaw works. “You’re both... that’s not fair. You’re both built like that and you walk around wearing Barbie pajamas?” he says.
“Roll onto your belly and spread your legs for Blake,” I tell him without acknowledging his subtle dig. “He’s gonna finger you. If you’re lucky and he’s in the mood, he might eat your ass...”
Blake grabs the lube from the nightstand. No rush. Danny rolls over. Face down, ass up, like a good little fuck boy bottom. His face presses into the mattress and he looks ridiculous and hot at the same time. His back is muscular, tapering down to a firm ass that’s rounder than expected. He spreads his legs like he was told. “This is so gay,” he says.
Blake is already kneeling behind him. “You just came in my boyfriend’s mouth. We’re all pretty fucking gay, bro.”
Danny’s voice is muffled into the pillow. “That’s different.”
“How?” Blake asks.
“Whatever. Please just shut up and do the thing,” Danny says. “I’m a little nervous…” He says it quietly, showing vulnerability for maybe the first time since I’ve known him.
Blake’s hand spreads Danny’s cheeks apart. He looks down at him with that calm assessment, the same way he looks at everything. Clinical. Patient. His slick finger traces around Danny’s hole in a slow circle. Not pushing in. Just teasing. Danny’s whole body tenses.
Danny’s fingers grip the sheets. “Why are you just... circling? Do it.”
Blake glances at me. “He’s impatient.”
“He’s actually really gentle for this part,” I find myself trying to reassure Danny.
Blake’s thick finger presses against the tight ring of muscle. Slow. Steady. The little hole clenches tight around just the tip.
“Go slow, babe. It looks like it’s been a while for him…”
“It’s been like a year since I bottomed,” Danny grumbles into the sheets.
Blake is kneeling at the edge of the bed while he works. I squat down beside him and caress him all over, casually expressing my comfortable love for my boyfriend while I watch him prepare another man’s asshole.
“Relax, bro. Exhale…” Danny follows Blake’s command and his hole peeks open.
Blake’s lubed finger sinks in to the first knuckle. Danny’s back arches like he’s been shocked. His hole grips tight around the intrusion, clenching and releasing in little involuntary pulses.
Danny’s face is buried in the pillow, a muffled groan vibrating through the fabric. “Oh. Oh that’s... yeah. Okay. Okay yeah.” He visibly melts into the mattress.
Blake holds still, lets Danny’s body adjust. His other hand rests on Danny’s lower back, warm and steady. He works the finger in slow circles, not pushing deeper yet. “Breathe,” he says.
Danny does. The muscle relaxes more. Blake sinks to the second knuckle.
“FUCK. Your fingers are thick,” Danny gasps.
I’m running my hands all over Blake’s body, his shoulders, his chest, his thighs. Lazy and loving. Blake leans into the touch, still focused on the task at hand. His cock is fully hard now, resting heavy against his thigh. Danny’s hole is fluttering around Blake’s finger. Tight. Really tight. But he’s pushing back against it, small movements, like his body is remembering how to do this.
Danny turns his head to the side, one eye visible. He looks wrecked already. “How many fingers is that?” he asks.
“One,” Blake says.
“That’s ONE? Fuckin sausage hands! I already feel like you’re splitting me in half,” Danny says with a chuckle.
Blake curls his finger. Finds the spot. Danny’s whole body jerks. A high-pitched moan escapes him that he clearly didn’t authorize. “WHAT THE FUCK!”
“Not yet, babe. The poor bastard just exploded down my throat. Don’t tease him with prostate play already.” I start massaging Danny’s lower back and ass cheeks to help him relax.
Danny turns his head. One eye finds me, now fully vulnerable in a way that doesn’t suit his everyday loudness. “Is he gonna eat my ass or what? Because I really want him to...”
Blake looks at me, fingers still buried. Waiting for my permission to put his mouth on another man’s asshole.
“Please?” That word sounds foreign in Danny’s mouth. Like he’s never said it before. His hole clenches around Blake’s fingers and he bites the pillow.
“Your call, babe,” I tell Blake. “No pressure either way. I’m good if you do it and I’m good if you don’t wanna go there.” I squeeze Blake’s hand and look him in the eyes with a sweet smile.
Blake holds my gaze. His fingers are still inside Danny, still working, but his eyes are only on me. He nods once. Slow. “I’ll do it,” he says.
Danny’s head snaps up. “Wait really? You’re really gonna - ”
Blake withdraws his fingers, slick and shining. He looks at Danny’s hole, slightly gaping now, twitching at the emptiness. “Be quiet and stay still,” he says.
His broad shoulders settle between Danny’s spread thighs. He looks over at me for one more second and then lowers his face. His tongue presses flat against Danny’s hole.
The sound Danny makes is a broken, guttural moan that he tries to swallow and can’t. His hands fist the sheets. “Oh my GOD. Oh my fucking god.”
Blake eats ass the way he does everything in life, slow, deliberate. Thorough. His tongue pushes inside, drags up to circle the rim, pushes back in. Methodical. Like he has all day. Danny’s thighs are shuddering already. His back dips lower, pushing his ass higher into Blake’s face. Completely involuntary.
His voice cracks. “Is he good at this, too? Of course he’s good at this, too...”
I casually rub Danny’s back and ass while Blake works. He’s done the exact same thing to me countless times and I know how wonderful it feels. I also know how infuriating it is that it takes so long to get an asshole ready for Blake’s thick cock. “How’s he doing down there, babe?” I ask into Blake’s ear. “I’m so fuckin hard just thinking about watching you wreck that little hole for me…”
Blake pulls back just enough to speak. His lips are wet. His chin is slick. “He tastes nice inside.” Then he dives back in. No further commentary.
Blake’s tongue pushes deep. Danny’s hips rock back desperately, chasing the sensation, grinding against Blake’s face. Blake lets him. Just keeps working. Mouth, fingers, mouth, fingers, progressing through the steps as Danny gets looser and looser.
Danny surrenders into it finally. Eventually he lifts his head, looks back over his shoulder at Blake’s face, at his calm expression, at those thick fingers disappearing into him. “How does it look back there?” he asks.
Blake looks at Danny’s hole, then at me, that quiet check-in he does. His fingers are buried knuckle-deep in another man’s ass. Something about the domesticity of it is obscene. “He’s loosened up. Looks ready to me.”
“Oh he’s ready, babe. What position should we use? I want him in a really good angle so I can watch...”
Blake lifts his face. “Hands and knees. Face him toward you so you can see his face when I push in,” he says.
Practical. Calculated. Blake knows exactly what I like to watch.
Danny is trembling. Blake pulls his fingers out. Wipes them on Danny’s ass cheek. Danny pushes himself up onto his hands and knees. His arms are wobbly. His cock hangs heavy between his legs, dripping. He turns to face me and his expression is wrecked but he’s grinning. “Hey, guys. Fuckin wow,” he says.
It’s such a stupid thing to say. But Danny looks at me as I climb onto the bed to find my perfect viewing angle. Behind him, Blake is positioning himself. The mattress shifts with the change in weight. The sound of Blake slicking his cock with lube is loud in the quiet room. Danny’s hole is slightly open. Glistening. Used. His muscular back is arched, head hanging between his arms.
Danny is quieter now, just for me. “Be honest. Is it gonna hurt?” Blake presses the thick head against Danny’s entrance. Doesn’t push. Just rests there. Waiting.
Danny’s whole body goes rigid. His eyes lock onto my face. “Talk to me. Please.”
“No, bro. It won’t hurt. Not a lot. That hole is very ready. Probably more ready than you’ve ever been while bottoming. My man knows how to fuck a boy right.” I sit cross-legged on the mattress a few feet away. My cock is hard and leaking but not in a desperate way. I need to see this. This was the whole reason we wanted to add a third guy to the mix. “You’re so fuckin sexy, Blake. Lemme see what you look like when you fuck a tight hole...”
Blake holds my gaze over Danny’s back, then he pushes forward. The head pops in. Danny’s mouth falls open. No sound comes out for three full seconds. Then, “Oh. Shit.”
Blake doesn’t stop. Steady pressure. Inch by inch. His thick cock stretches Danny’s hole wider than fingers ever could. Danny’s arms buckle and his face drops toward the mattress but he catches himself, eyes finding me again like a lifeline. Blake is watching his own cock disappear. That focused expression. Jaw tight. Hands gripping Danny’s hips.
Danny’s voice breaks into something high and desperate. “It’s so THICK. Joey it’s so fucking thick I can feel it in my stomach. How do you take this every night?”
Blake bottoms out. Hips flush against Danny’s ass. He holds there. Completely still. “Breathe,” he says.
He can’t. Danny’s chest is heaving. His cock is twitching untouched, every muscle in his body is clenching. “I can’t breathe. I can’t. You’re splitting me in half.” He’s not lying. His hole is stretched tight around the base of Blake’s cock. The rim is gripping the shaft. From my angle it’s a perfect view. Danny’s face contorted, Blake’s abs flexing with restraint, and that obscene joining where one body ends and another begins.
Danny’s eyes lock on me, pleading. “Tell him to move. Please. I need him to move or I’m gonna lose it.” I hold Danny’s hand and squeeze it reassuringly and shift my focus to him for a moment. “Let him do his thing, bro. He knows what he’s doing. You gotta get used to the fullness. Then he’s gonna fuckin destroy you!”
Danny’s fingers squeeze my hand so hard it almost hurts. His eyes are glassy, mouth hanging open. “Destroy me. Great. That’s comforting. Fuck, Joey...”
Blake pulls back slowly. Halfway out. Then pushes all the way back in. One long stroke.
Danny’s eyes roll. His grip on my hand spasms. “OH - ”
Blake finds a rhythm. Slow and deep. Each thrust bottoms out with a soft slap of skin against skin. He’s not being gentle, he’s being deliberate. Every stroke drags against that spot inside Danny and the effect is immediate. Danny’s cock bounces with each thrust, untouched and leaking onto the sheets. I can see everything. The way Blake’s cock pulls Danny’s hole outward on the backstroke. The way Danny’s face crumbles a little more with every push in. The way Blake’s hands grip those hips like he owns them.
“I’ve never been so full. Joey he’s so deep I can taste it. Can you see? Can you see his cock going in?”
Blake speeds up slightly. Not much. Just enough. Danny’s head drops, forehead almost touching the mattress, then snaps back up to find me because he physically cannot stop looking at me.
“I’m not gonna last. If he keeps hitting that spot I’m gonna cum without anyone touching me.”
Blake’s voice is flat. “Then cum. This isn’t about you, bro. This is for me and Joey. If you gotta cum then go ahead...”
Danny’s face twists, torn between desperation and disbelief. “You’re telling me to cum but also telling me it’s not about me? What the fuck kind of - ”
Blake thrusts harder, punctuating the sentence with a deep stroke that makes Danny’s whole body jolt.
Danny’s words dissolve into a moan. His untouched cock is throbbing, angry red, dripping a puddle onto the sheets. His hole grips Blake’s shaft with every stroke. “I don’t wanna cum yet but I can’t hold it. I’m trying. Joey I’m TRYING.”
Blake’s pace is steady now. Not fast but powerful. Each thrust shoves Danny forward on the mattress. The headboard taps the wall in a quiet rhythm. His abs flex and release, flex and release. Sweat rolls down his chest. Danny is unraveling. His arms give out and his face hits the mattress. His ass stays up though, muscle memory from being fucked before. His back arches deeper, presenting himself like he’s built for this. The wet sound of Blake’s cock pumping in and out is constant. Obscene.
Muffled into the sheets. Desperate. Danny whimpers, lifting his head to find me with ruined eyes. “Boss. Please. I’m begging you. Your boyfriend is destroying my ass and I can’t hold it.”
“Fuckin crybaby...” I keep my eyes locked on Blake’s and let go of Danny’s hand. I reach under Danny and grab his cock and squeeze it once.
He immediately explodes while Blake keeps fucking him.
The orgasm rips through him like a seizure. His back arches violently, mouth open in a silent scream that finally breaks into a wail. His cock pulses in my grip, shooting thick ropes onto the sheets, onto my hand, onto everything. A real fucking one-man bukkake. “THANK YOU THANK YOU THANK YOU - ”
Blake doesn’t stop. Doesn’t even slow down, just thrusts right through Danny’s orgasm like it doesn’t matter. His jaw is clenched now. “He squeezed me so tight, babe,” he says.
Danny is face down, his spent cock still twitching in my loose grip. Every thrust makes his whole body jerk like a puppet. “I can’t. It’s too sensitive. I’m too sensitive. Please finish, bro - ”
Blake grabs a fistful of Danny’s hair and pulls his head back. Keeps fucking. “You said anything. You said you’d do anything.”
Danny’s neck is exposed. Eyes streaming. Looking at me. “I did. I said that. Fuck.”
Blake’s pace is increasing. The slap of skin is louder now. Faster. His breathing is heavier. He’s close. I can tell by the way his shoulders tense, the way his grip tightens.
His eyes find mine. “Where do you want me to finish?” I don’t need to say it. He knows. I slide over and get on my knees next to Blake and open my mouth.
He sees it. That silent understanding. His hips slam forward one final time, burying himself to the hilt. Danny screams into the mattress. His oversensitive hole is being split open by Blake’s deepest thrust yet. His hands claw at the sheets and he screams.
Blake pulls out. Fast. The wet pop of his cock leaving Danny’s hole echoes through the room. Danny collapses flat, limp, hole gaping and twitching, a mess of lube coating his inner thighs. Blake swivels at the hips and his hand finds the back of my neck and he shoves his cock in my waiting mouth. No warning. Deep. I can taste everything, lube, sweat, Danny’s insides. Blake’s thick shaft hits the back of my throat and his hips stutter.
He fucks my mouth with short, desperate strokes. His abs are clenching. That tension in his shoulders is building fast. On the bed, Danny has rolled onto his side and is watching through tear-streaked eyes.
A hoarse whisper from Danny. “That’s the hottest thing I’ve ever seen in my life.”
Blake’s grip tightens on my neck. His rhythm gets erratic. He’s right there. “Gonna cum. Drink me, babe...”
He buries himself deep and holds there. His cock pulses against my tongue, thick ropes of cum flooding my mouth. His thighs shake. A low groan escapes through his clenched teeth.
I know the rhythm. I swallow between pulses and reach around to squeeze his plump ass cheeks in time with each gush. I drink it down easily and swallow. “I fuckin love you...”
Blake’s hand loosens on my neck. Fingers trembling slightly. He pulls out slowly. “I love you, too,” he says. He says it like it’s nothing. Like he hasn’t just cum down his boyfriend’s throat after fucking another man in the ass. His thumb wipes a drop of jizz from the corner of my lip.
Behind us, Danny is propped on one elbow. Staring. His hole is still gaping, twitching occasionally. His face is a disaster, hair plastered to his forehead. He looks like someone who just survived something. He sits up, wincing. His hand goes to his lower back. “I can’t feel my legs. Literally. I’m not exaggerating. My legs are gone.”
Blake lets his cock fall from my lips and pulls his pink Barbie pajama bottoms back on. Casual. Like he’s getting dressed after a gym session. “You good?” he asks Danny.
Danny looks down at himself. Covered in his own cum. Sheets destroyed. “Am I good? I just had a religious experience on your bed and you’re asking if I’m GOOD?” He looks at me. “Is it always like this with you two?”
“Um. Guys...” I stand up naked and throbbing and soaked with precum.
The room goes quiet. Both heads turn. I’m standing at the edge of the bed and I’ve been hard this entire time. Watching. Waiting. Not touching myself once. Blake’s eyes drop. That soft post-orgasm haze evaporates instantly. His jaw tightens.
“Oh. Oh, babe!” Blake swallows hard. “You didn’t... like that whole time? You didn’t touch yourself at all?”
He’s already moving. He steps toward me, hand reaching out instinctively. That quiet intensity sharpening into something possessive. “You need me to get you off? Or do we let Danny do it?”
The question hangs in the air. Blake is asking, but his body language says he already knows the answer. He wants to hear me say it. Wants Danny to hear it too. Danny is still sitting on the ruined sheets, hole exposed, cum drying on his stomach. His spent cock is making a valiant attempt at hardening again. Quiet. Almost reverent. “Blake, please, can I... am I allowed to touch him?”
All eyes on me. Waiting for the call.
“That’s up to him,” Blake announces.
I look at Blake. I reach out with both hands and intertwine our fingers. “What do you wanna see, babe? I can fuck his ruined hole. I can cum down his throat. I could just jerk off and paint him with jizz... I’ll do whatever you wanna see, baby.”
His fingers tighten around mine. His eyes flick between our intertwined hands and my face. That calculating look, like a director planning a shot list. He’s quiet for a moment. Thinking. “Fuck his throat.”
Danny’s head snaps up. “Wait - ”
Doesn’t look at him. “Anything. You said you’d do anything.”
He opens his mouth to protest but something in Blake’s tone kills it. He closes his mouth. Swallows. “Yeah. Okay. Yeah.”
He scoots to the edge of the bed. Sits there with his legs dangling, still naked, still wrecked. His hole is puffy and used. He looks up at me with an expression that’s half nervous, half thrilled. Blake guides me forward by our joined hands. Positions me right in front of Danny and drags him off the bed and onto his knees before me. Close enough that my cock brushes Danny’s cheek.
He flinches at the contact. Warm skin against warm skin. He looks at Blake for permission even though he knows the rule. No kissing. No touching unless told. “Can I use my hands?”
Blake thinks about it. Looks at me.
Danny’s breath is hitting my shaft. Hot and uneven. His lips are parted. He’s trying so hard to be good. His fingers grip his own thighs, fighting every instinct to reach out and grab. Looking up at me through his lashes. “Please?”
“Sure. You can use your hands. But do not fucking gag yourself. I hate that fucking sound. If you can’t throat it just suck and lick.” I look to Blake. “Find a good spot to watch from, babe. Think he can swallow my whole load? I’ve been edging this whole time...”
Blake smirks and walks to the side of the bed, leaning against the wall with his arms crossed. Perfect viewing angle. My back, Danny’s face, everything. “I wanna see his throat work.”
Danny’s hands come up immediately. One wraps around the base of my shaft. The other cups my balls, rolling them gently. He looks up at me with something between worship and defiance. “I don’t gag. For the record.”
He says it like a challenge. Like he needs to prove something. His tongue drags flat up the underside of my cock. Slow, wet, deliberate. His eyes flutter shut.
His mouth opens wide. He takes the head in first, tongue swirling around the tip. Testing. Then he sinks down about halfway. His jaw stretches and he holds there, cheeks hollowing. No gagging, exactly as he’d bragged. His hand works the bottom half in twisting strokes. His other hand squeezes my balls gently. He pulls back to the tip, spit everywhere, then sinks back down.
He looks up at me. Mouth full. Eyes watering but still not gagging. He hums around the shaft.
“Fuck, babe! He’s pretty fuckin good at this.” I put my hands in Danny’s hair and tug gently. “I’m really close so show off your best moves while you can, bro...”
The praise hits him somewhere deep. His eyes light up and he doubles down. His head bobs faster, taking me deeper with each stroke. His tongue does something complicated on the way up, swirling, pressing against the underside, flicking the slit.
His hand twists at the base in counterpoint to his mouth. Spit is dripping down his chin, coating my balls. He’s making a mess and he knows it. His cheeks hollow on every upstroke, creating suction that’s almost unbearable. Blake hasn’t moved from the wall. His arms are still crossed but his posture has shifted. He’s leaning forward slightly.
Blake pushes off the wall and takes two steps closer.
Danny starts swallowing around me rhythmically. Milking me. His hands grip my thighs for leverage.
I look at Blake. I reach my hand out. “Come kiss me while I fill his throat, babe. I’m about to blast.”
He doesn’t hesitate. He takes my hand and crashes our lips together. Deep and hungry. His tongue slides into my mouth while his other hand grips my jaw.
It’s almost obscene. My boyfriend’s tongue in my mouth while another man’s throat works my shaft, tears rolling down his face. I can feel every swallow. Danny’s hands tighten on my thighs. He can feel the shaft pulsing, thickening, getting ready. He knows what’s coming. His eyes are squeezed shut, tears leaking from the corners, but he doesn’t pull back. Doesn’t slow down.
Blake breaks the kiss just enough to whisper against my lips. “Fill his throat. I wanna watch him swallow.” His hand slides down my chest. Possessive. Pinching my nipple. He kisses me again, harder this time, biting my bottom lip.
My cock is throbbing against Danny’s tongue, twitching in his throat. He pulls back, keeping just the head between his lips. His tongue presses flat against the underside, applying pressure. He looks up. Sees Blake kissing me. He moans around my cock, the vibration traveling straight through me.
Blake looks down at Danny. “Take it all.”
Danny nods with his mouth full and relaxes his throat.
I place Blake’s hand and my own on Danny’s head and then dump a huge load of edged cum down his throat.
Danny swallows hard, frantically working to keep up with the sheer volume of backed up cum that’s been building in my balls. He almost gets all of it. A thick glob escapes the corner of his mouth, spilling down his chin. Then another burst catches him off guard and streaks across his cheek, his nose, his eyebrow. By the end of it his face is glazed.
He pulls off, gasping. A string of cum and spit hangs from his lips. He sits there on the edge of the bed, chest heaving, face painted, looking like a masterpiece of degradation. He wipes his eyebrow with the back of his hand. Smears it worse. “That was... a lot. Were you saving that since last week?”
Blake is looking at Danny’s face with quiet satisfaction. His hand is still on top of Danny’s head, fingers tangled loosely in his hair. “Good boy.”
Danny’s whole body shudders at those two words. Visibly. His cock twitches against his thigh. “Don’t... don’t call me that.”
Blake smirks and asks, “Why not?”
He looks up, cum dripping off his jaw. “Because I’ll get hard again and I physically cannot survive another round.”
“Don’t worry, bro. We’re done with you for today.” I turn and face Blake and we make out hard, hands all over each other for a long while as our soft cocks rub between our bodies.
I finally break the kiss. “That was really great, Danny. Thanks for helping us celebrate our anniversary.”
He grabs a corner of the sheet and wipes at the cum on his face. It doesn’t help. He looks like he needs a shower. Again. “This was the most disrespectful thing anyone has ever done to me. I want you to know I’m not mad about it!”
Blake pulls back from me. Thumb tracing my bottom lip. His eyes are warm and lazy, the post-sex version of Blake that only I usually get to see. He glances at Danny. “You can use our shower again.”
Danny stands up. His legs are shaky. He takes one step and winces. “My asshole hurts. Like genuinely. I’m gonna feel this for a fuckin week.”
He gingerly walks toward the bathroom naked. At the doorway he stops and turns around. His expression shifts to something more serious underneath the usual clowning.
He points at me. “Was this just a one-time-only thing? Because I’m just gonna say, if you two ever need a fuck boy again, I have literally zero pride left and I will say yes immediately.” He pauses. “Also, happy anniversary or whatever.” He stumbles away.
Blake pulls me closer by the waist. Lips against my ear. “He wants to come back.”
“Think he’ll make fun of our cute matching Barbie pajamas next time?”
A low laugh vibrates against my ear. His arms tighten around my waist, pulling our bodies flush together. Our soft cocks press against each other and he doesn’t move away. “He’s gonna make fun of everything. That’s his whole personality.”
The shower turns on down the hall. We can hear Danny humming something. Blake pulls back and looks at me. That quiet intensity is back. Not sexual this time. Something softer.
“Happy anniversary, babe.”