"Caught In Our Pajamas" - Chapter 1 (Patreon)
Content
The apartment’s front door creaks open and footsteps lead to our bedroom door and stop outside. A long silence fills the room as the door opens and then the hallway light falls directly across our bed. Blake stirs next to me, voice thick with sleep, not fully awake yet. “Five more minutes, babe...”
Danny stands frozen in the doorway, hand still on the knob, his eyes moving slowly from me to Blake and back again. His jaw is tight. His shoulders are shaking. He clutches a fist to his teeth to stifle a laugh. “Bro. Bro! Is that... fuckin Barbie?!?”
The sound of Danny’s voice makes Blake go very still and it wakes me up as I’m snuggled against Blake’s back as the big spoon. I look over Blake’s shoulder at Danny standing in our bedroom door. “Mmm. Fuck off Danny. It’s too goddamn early...” I snuggle into Blake.
Danny’s eyes are wide, darting between the two of us like he’s watching a tennis match as he tries to figure out which one to tease. The shaking in his shoulders gets worse. He pulls out his phone. “Nah. Nah nah nah nah nah. I am not fucking off. What am I looking at right now?” He points the camera, not even subtle about it. Two grown men, snuggling in their bed, wearing matching pink Barbie pajamas…
Blake shifts, rolling slightly onto his back. The blanket slides down and his pink top with a doll’s face on the chest becomes fully visible. He blinks up at Danny, still half-asleep, his brain clearly buffering. “Why are you in our apartment?”
Danny lets out a wheeze. He’s biting his bottom lip so hard it might bleed. “You told me I could come over. But you’re just gonna lie there in matching... in MATCHING...” He gestures wildly at the pajamas, at the identical pink fleece, at the fact that I am literally wrapped around Blake like a koala on a eucalyptus tree.
Blake looks down at himself, then over at me, then back at Danny. Something clicks behind his sleepy brown eyes and a slow, unbothered smile spreads across his face. “Anniversary gift.”
Danny makes a sound like a tea kettle about to blow. “ANNIVERSARY?! What anniversary?! You’ve been together for like - ” He catches himself, looks at me, looks at Blake, notices the two matching pink coffee mugs on the nightstand, the little heart-shaped drugstore greeting card. “Is that a fucking CARD?”
Blake reaches over and pulls the blanket up, tucking it around us both with zero urgency, like Danny is a mild inconvenience he’ll get to eventually. “You jealous or are you just here to make noise?”
“Seriously, Danny...” I open my sleepy eyes. “Do you have a purpose other than pestering us on a Sunday morning?”
He steps fully into the room now. “A purpose? Bro, I came over because you said I could use your PlayStation. That was the deal. I show up, you let me run 2K, I leave.” He pauses, looks at the pajamas again. His phone is still up. “Actually no. New plan. I’m not leaving until somebody explains to me why there’s two grown men in matching Barbie PJs with a love card on the nightstand between matching fucking coffee mugs!”
Blake is still snuggling. My arm is draped over his waist under the blanket, thumb tracing a lazy circle against his hip like this is completely normal, like Danny isn’t standing three feet away and vibrating like a chihuahua. “There was a sale. Two for one.”
“Two for ONE?!”
Blake shrugs one shoulder. “Seemed wasteful to buy just one.”
Danny turns to me, eyes pleading, like maybe I’m the reasonable one here, the one who can explain why his bro is lying in pink fleece cuddling another dude like they’re in the gayest Hallmark movie ever. “Joey. Joey, look at me. Are you telling me you WANTED to wear this? Voluntarily? On your body?” He gestures at my pajama top. “Because Blake I get. Blake would wear a trash bag if you told him it was cute. But YOU?” He leans in, grinning like a shark. “What’s the real story, pretty boy?”
“Dude...” I roll off of Blake and onto my back and stretch hard, fully annoyed, then stumble to my feet and show off the full outfit. A long-sleeve pink fleece top and matching pants, little Barbie logos all over, with the doll’s face featured in a large graphic on the chest. I pull out the hem of the top and look down at the stretched image. “They’re fucking adorable! It’s called whimsy, you dope. Why can’t you wrap your tiny brain around the idea that we like to look cute for each other?”
His mouth falls open. He slowly pans the phone’s camera up and down my full outfit like he’s filming a crime scene. “Whimsy. He said whimsy. Did you hear that, Blake?”
Blake props himself up on one elbow, blanket pooling around his waist. He’s watching me with a lazy half-smile, eyes still heavy with sleep, looking at me like I’m the greatest thing he’s ever seen. “I heard him.”
Danny runs his hand over the back of his neck like he’s trying to physically process what’s happening. “Okay okay okay. Let me get this straight. Matching pink PJs with dollies on them. After sleeping tangled up like two pieces of fucking pasta. Next to a love card.” Danny looks up at me. “And you’re not embarrassed? Not even a little?”
Blake sits on the edge of the bed. “Why would we be embarrassed?”
“Because it’s CRAZY, Blake! You’re a six-foot-three dude! You play basketball! You have tattoos!”
Blake looks down at his arms with the full tattoo sleeves. “And?”
I rise from my side of the bed. “What’s the boy version of being pussy-whipped?” I mumble as I scratch my balls and shuffle towards the door, headed for the kitchen. “I’m gonna make coffee, babe. Full pot? Danny doesn’t get any, though!”
A low laugh rumbles out of Blake’s chest. He stretches, arms above his head, the pink fleece riding up just enough to show a strip of stupidly ripped stomach. “Yeah, full pot. And he gets one cup if he starts to behave himself.”
Danny gives up and follows me to the kitchen because of course he does. He leans against the counter, arms crossed, watching me move around the space. “So real talk though. How long has this been going on? The matching pajamas, the cards, the cuddling?” He ticks each one off on his fingers. “Because last month Blake told me you were his new boyfriend and I figured, Oh cool, Joey and Blake, what a great couple. But now I’m looking at a fucking gay boy pajama catalog come to life.” He tilts his head. “What changed?”
From the bedroom, muffled by his pillow, Blake says, “Nothing changed. We’re in love.”
“Plus we usually sleep naked, so consider yourself lucky we were even dressed...” I fumble the coffee maker into life.
Danny’s eyebrows shoot up so fast they nearly leave his face. “You sleep NAKED? And you put on the cute pajamas just for the occasion?!? That’s somehow worse. That means you CHOSE to be domestic.” He pulls himself up onto the counter, sneakers dangling.
“FYI, I am not cooking breakfast for Danny,” I call out to Blake. “He’s rude.”
The coffee maker gurgles to life, filling the small kitchen with that rich, dark smell. From the bedroom, the sound of Blake shifting under the covers, the rustle of pink fleece against sheets.
Danny watches me getting breakfast together, eyes flicking back toward the bedroom doorway. “Rude? I’m RUDE? You guys told me to come over! You said ‘door’s open, come on in.’ That’s an invitation, Joey. I didn’t break any laws.” He pulls out his phone again, scrolling. “Also I’m posting this.”
Blake appears in the kitchen doorway, leaning against the frame. He’s still in the pajamas. His hair is a mess. He looks like a sleepy pink grizzly bear that wandered out of hibernation. His eyes find me first, then slide to Danny. “Don’t post that.”
“Or what?”
Blake doesn’t say anything else. Just looks at Danny with those calm brown eyes. The kind of look that doesn’t need words.
Danny’s thumb hovers over the screen. “Okay so like... you two are cute and all. Genuinely. But somebody needs to explain the card. The little heart stickers on it. Was that your handwriting, Joey?” He points at the nightstand visible through the doorway.
“Yes.” I’m thoroughly exasperated with this conversation. “Why can’t you handle the idea that we’re in love? It’s very fucking normal, you know. It isn’t 1952!”
Danny throws his hands up. “I never said it WASN’T normal! It’s surprising! There’s a difference!”
Blake has drifted closer. He’s behind me now, not touching me, just standing there with his arms crossed, watching Danny pace. Something almost territorial about the way he’s positioned himself. Not aggressive, just... present.
Danny turns to me, pointing. “Okay. I need you to look me dead in my eyes and tell me this is real. Like REAL real. Not just ‘oh he’s hot and we fuck so we’re together’ real. Because I’ve seen you go through people, Joey. You don’t do commitment.”
The coffee maker beeps. Steam curls up from the pot, and Blake reaches past me to grab mugs from the cabinet, his chest brushing against my shoulder. Even fresh out of bed he smells amazing to me.
Danny leans in, dead serious now. “So what’s different about him?”
“Ugh...” I grab Blake by the hips and pull him into my body. Our matching pajamas turn into a giant muscular blob of athletic masculinity as I wet my lips and kiss him, deep and slow, sweet and loving.
Blake’s hand comes up instinctively to the back of my neck, fingers threading into my hair, and he leans into it like breathing. No performance. No audience awareness. Just two people who know exactly what the other likes.
“That’s what’s different, Danny. Get it now?” I start gathering eggs and cheese from the fridge.
Blake licks his bottom lip where my mouth just was. He’s still half-smiling, eyes a little glazed. He turns and grabs the coffee pot, pouring himself a cup like he hasn’t just been kissed stupid in his own kitchen.
Danny’s voice drops lower. Less theatrical now. Something almost genuine underneath the clowning. “Yo, for real though. I’ve known you two separately for like three years. Blake’s my boy from the court. Joey’s my boy from everywhere else. And I never once saw either of you look at anybody like that.” He sets his phone down on the counter. “I’m not being weird. I’m just saying. That shit looked real.”
Blake takes a sip of coffee, leaning against the counter next to me. His pinky finds mine. Hooks it. “It is real.”
Beat of silence. Then Danny’s whole face cracks into a grin. “Alright. Fine. Whatever! I believe you. But I came here to play 2K so somebody better tell me where the controller is before I lose my mind.”
“There’s a drawer in the coffee table,” I say with what I hope is a dismissive wave. “Controller is inside. Keep the volume reasonable. It’s fuckin Sunday. The fuckin Lord’s day...” I start whipping the eggs while Blake grates the cheese.
Danny’s already moving toward the living room, practically bouncing. “The Lord’s day? Since when do you homos go to church?”
Blake grates the cheese while sipping his coffee, completely domestic. “He doesn’t. He just says that when he’s annoyed. And don’t call us ‘homos’ in our own place. You are rude.”
The apartment settles into a strange kind of rhythm. Danny drops onto the couch, flips the TV on, and the familiar sounds of the 2K intro splash across the room. The kitchen fills with the sizzle of butter hitting a hot pan, the whisk of eggs, the gentle scrape of cheese against a grater. Three guys in an apartment on a Sunday morning. It almost feels normal. Except two of them are wearing matching pink pajamas with Barbie dolls on them.
I make cheesy scrambled eggs like a fuckin pro - I think those eggs might be why Blake fell in love with me. I plate them up, and Blake and I sit at the kitchen table to eat while Danny plays his game.
By the time Danny is ten minutes into his game, volume creeping upward despite direct orders, he cranes his neck over the couch. “Bro can I ask you something personal?” He doesn’t wait for permission. “Are you the top or the bottom in this relationship? Because I need to know for science. I’m trying to figure out which one of you broke the other one.”
“What the actual fuck is wrong with you, Danny? Were you raised by wild animals?” I shake my head but answer anyway. “We’re verse, if you really need to know!”
The controller freezes mid-motion. He turns his whole body on the couch to face the kitchen. “So you boys go BOTH ways! You let this man put it in you, bro?”
Blake is eating eggs. Calmly. He takes a bite, chews, swallows. Looks up at Danny with those sleepy brown eyes. “Yup.”
The eggs are good. Really good. Fluffy, perfectly seasoned, the cheese melted into every bite. Blake keeps stealing glances at me while he eats, that soft look he gets sometimes when he thinks nobody’s watching. Except Danny is always watching.
He spins back to his game, muttering. “For the record, I bottom too, sometimes. No shame there. Just while we’re all being so open. No homophobia from this boy!” He pauses. “Unless that type of self-hating shit is hot now. Is it hot?”
Blake looks at me across the table and just shakes his head over his plate.
“Should we ask him?” I say quietly. “I still say he’s gonna be way too much...” We’ve been discussing adding a third to the bed, and Danny was Blake’s suggested candidate.
From the couch, not even looking away from the screen, Danny says, “I can HEAR you, y’know...”