"Out Of The Sketchbook" - Chapter 2 (Patreon)
Content
Time passed. Riley’s head was on a pivot, bouncing from subject to page every few seconds. Andy felt himself getting more comfortable with each passing minute. At last Riley set the pencil down and handed the sketchbook over for Andy to see.
“There. Happy?”
It was stunning. The Andy on the page looked like something out of a dream – soft, exposed, achingly attractive. Riley had drawn the uncertainty on his face, the tension in his jaw, the way his chest caught the light in pools of shadow. He leaned back in his chair, arms crossed. “That’s what you look like to me. All the time. Every single day.” His voice was quiet and raw. “Now you know why I can’t stop. You get it now?”
“I’m starting to get it.” Andy sat up on the bed, still shirtless, realizing he was slightly hard in his sweatpants. He studied the drawing in silence for a while.
“You know, I’ve been thinking lately,” he finally said softly. “About myself. About just how straight I actually am...”
Riley didn’t move, didn’t breathe. Then he leaned forward in his chair. “What did you just say?”
He rolled the desk chair closer until they were face to face, close enough to touch. “Because if you’re fucking with me right now, that’s cruel. Like actually cruel. I’ve spent months drawing your face every single day and you bring girls back to this room and I just sit here pretending I’m not losing my mind.” He looked furious and terrified at the same time. “So I need you to look at me and say that again. Because if you mean it, things change. And I can’t go back to just being your weird artsy roommate after that.”
Andy looked up reluctantly. “I Googled it. It’s called bi-curious. I’ve always kinda known it, but I never had a word for it until now.”
“You Googled it,” Riley repeated. “What exactly did you search? ‘straight boy might be gay’ or ‘what does it mean to be attracted to other boys’ or what?”
“I’ve just always fantasized about doing stuff with guys, but I figured every guy did that,” Andy said calmly. “Then I realized that isn’t always true. So I started looking online and I found out it’s a whole thing. Like maybe I’m bisexual? I still love fucking girls, but for as long as I can remember I’ve wondered what it would be like with a guy.” He finally met Riley’s eyes. “And you’re handsome, and it turns out you’re really into me, and you’re not exactly straight, either.”
“No. I’m not straight at all,” he said simply, like it was the most obvious thing in the world. “I’m gay. Completely totally gay. I came out to my family when I was fourteen. But I’m not the flag waving type or whatever...” A ghost of a smirk crossed his face before dying.
“So let me make sure I understand,” Riley continued. “You’re sitting in front of me with a hard-on telling me you want to maybe explore your bi-curiosity. With me. Your roommate who’s been obsessed with you since September. You figured out you might be into guys by Googling it, then today you realized you liked my drawings of you.” He laughed, breathless and disbelieving. “So what exactly are you asking me for right now?”
“Can you help me figure out if I actually like it?” Andy asked. “With a guy, I mean. Without judging me or expecting anything?”
He repeated the phrase slowly, like he was tasting something sour. “Without expecting anything. You want me to help you figure out if you like guys. By doing what exactly? Holding hands? Cuddling? Or are we talking about the fact that you’re hard right now?”
Riley pulled back just enough to really look at him. “I’m not gonna judge you. That’s not my thing. But if we do this and you figure out you like it, that changes things.” His hand came up and he swept his thumb across Andy’s cheekbone. “So yeah. I’ll help you. But you gotta tell me what you want. Use your words. Be specific. Because I’m a guy who’s been constantly horny for you, and I need to know exactly where the line is before I cross it.”
“I watch a lot of gay porn,” Andy said. “Like exclusively gay stuff the last few months. I wanna try all the normal stuff I see those guys doing with each other. Nothing crazy like fisting or ball torture or anything. Just regular sex stuff...”
A laugh burst out of Riley, genuine and surprised. “No ball torture. Got it. Very specific exclusion.” He wiped his eyes with the palms of his hands, still grinning. “Okay, so, normal stuff,” Riley said, running both hands through his hair now, losing his mind slightly. “You wanna try things with a guy, but you’re nervous and you’ve never done it, which means the first time’s gonna be awkward no matter who you’re with. So what do you wanna try first? Kissing? Touching?” His voice was steady, but inside he was vibrating.
“Fuck. Wait. Really?” Andy said, excitement creeping in as he sat up straighter on the bed. “I’ve been dreading the day I’d have to bring this up, and now it’s just gonna happen?!?” Now his words came racing out. “I have this whole thing about giving a blowjob, but I know that’s not step one. Would kissing be step one? Girls always say I’m a really good kisser! Like I’m attentive and gentle and shit. So kissing first and then a blowjob? Did you know there are online forums devoted to straight guys who dream about sucking a dick? Like whole forums with thousands of comments! Isn’t that wild?!?”
Riley’s eyebrows shot up. “Okay, so you’re definitely obsessed with giving a blowjob!” He stared for a solid three seconds before pressing his palm to his forehead. “You went from ‘I think I might be bi-curious’ to ‘I want to put my mouth on your dick’ in five seconds. That’s gotta be a record.”
Andy laughed and took a breath. “So, but, yeah. Kissing and touching first, then, I guess.”
Riley got to his feet and rolled his shoulders like he was getting ready for a fight. “Okay. Fine. Kissing and touching first.” He stepped in and stood between Andy’s knees at the edge of the mattress. “But I’m being honest with you right now. I’ve wanted to kiss you since we met.” His hands found Andy’s bare shoulders. “So when I do, it’s not gonna be some polite little peck on the lips. I’m gonna kiss you like I mean it. And if that’s too much, you gotta tell me to stop.” He sat down next to Andy, giving him time to pull away. “Ready?”
“Dude, I’ve kissed girls like a million times,” Andy said with a grin as he turned to face his roommate for his first gay kiss. “I’m not scared of this part.” He wet his lips, pulled Riley close, and just went into full make out mode.
Andy kissed like he’d been starving for it, aggressive, wet, no hesitation. Then he realized that this was nothing like kissing a girl. Riley’s mouth was rougher, his jaw sharper, there was beard stubble under his lower lip.
Riley kissed back hard, sliding one hand into Andy’s hair and tilting his head for a better angle, the other hand traveling down his bare chest, fingertips dragging. He bit Andy’s lower lip. Not gently. Then he pulled back, breathing ragged between their open mouths.
“Holy shit,” Riley breathed. “You don’t kiss like someone who’s never done this before. You sure you’ve never kissed a guy?”
“Never. I don’t get why you’re confused,” Andy said. “That’s just how I make out with girls. It’s basically the same. Except you need to shave.”
“Excuse me? You want me to shave?” Riley touched his own jaw reflexively and looked genuinely offended for half a second before a grin broke across his face.
He leaned back in, not kissing, just hovering, his lips brushing Andy’s ear.
“Yeah, it’s not the same. Girls are soft. They let you lead. You can feel them melting into it.” His tongue traced the shell of Andy’s ear. “Guys fight back. We push. We take.” His hand slid lower on Andy’s stomach, fingertips grazing the waistband of his sweatpants, resting there without going further.
“You kissed me like you own me, and I gotta say, that’s not what I expected from a curious straight boy figuring things out his first time. What else do you do with girls that you wanna do with me?”
“Well,” Andy said, “First of all, I’ve never been the only topless person during a make out...”
Riley looked down at his own shirt like he’d forgotten he was wearing it, then he grabbed the hem and pulled it over his head in one motion.
Underneath, Riley’s body was a canvas. Tattoos covered his chest and ribs, a sleeve of geometric patterns down his left arm, something in Latin across his collarbone. He was lean but not skinny, more skateboard and genetics than gym. He sat there beside Andy, half naked, completely at ease in a way that only someone who’d been secretly wanting this for months could be.
Riley grabbed Andy’s hand and pressed it flat against his bare chest. “Feel that? My heart’s going crazy. You did that.” He leaned down until his nose brushed Andy’s. “You’re sitting there looking like that and I’m over here trying not to climb on top of you.” His hips shifted forward almost involuntarily. “Still just curious?”