"Wrestling With Dale" - Part 1 (Patreon)
Content
Dale and I were home for summer break from sophomore year at our separate colleges. We were in our swim suits, wrestling on the lawn beside the pool. We did this all the time and had a habit of pushing things right to the edge and then pulling back just before reaching the point of hurting each other. So when he had my head pinned between his thighs and I started biting at his skin, it should have been par for the course. But I might have been nibbling more than biting...
“Bro, what the fuck?!?” Dale demanded. He pulled my hair while he kept my head pinned between his bare thighs. “Quit biting!”
My scalp stung where Dale had yanked my hair, but instead of pulling away, I let out a muffled laugh against the soft skin of his inner thigh.
“Ow- fuck, okay, okay!” I grabbed Dale’s wrist, but didn’t actually try to free myself. My lips were still pressed against the skin of his inner thigh, and I could feel his pulse hammering right there against my mouth.
“You just taste good.” The words came out before I could stop them, and the second they left my mouth, I squeezed my eyes shut, jaw tight. God, what the hell was wrong with me? We were just wrestling. This was normal. This was what guys do. Except this absolutely wasn’t, and I knew it.
I opened my eyes and looked up at Dale from between his thighs, my hair sticking up in every direction from his grip. “You gonna let go of my hair or what?”
He spread his thighs and released me, then let go of my hair. He looked between his bare legs. His skin there was smooth except for the red hickey mark I’d left behind. “Dude! What the hell is wrong with you?!?”
I scrambled backward on my elbows, the grass leaving green streaks across my bare back. My face was burning and I couldn’t look at him directly. “I don’t- I don’t know, okay. I just...” I dragged a hand down my face, pressing my palm against my mouth like I could shove the words back in. My swim trunks were tented in a way that was impossible to miss, and I shifted my weight to try and angle my hips away. “It was a joke. You had your legs around my head, and I just... it was stupid. Forget it.”
I finally risked a glance up at Dale’s face, and what I saw there made me flinch. “Look, I’m sorry,” I added a little too desperately. “That was weird. I’m being weird.” But my eyes dropped back down to that mark on his thigh, and my tongue darted out to wet my lips before I caught myself doing it. I looked away fast, grabbing a fistful of grass and ripping it out of the ground. “Can we just... go back to wrestling or something?”
He was so focused on the mark on his leg that he hadn’t actually looked at me. When he finally did, his gaze hit my crotch and he didn’t look away. “You have a boner...”
My whole body went rigid. The fistful of grass in my hand crushed into pulp as my fingers clenched. “No I don’t.” I instinctively curled forward, pressing my forearms against my lap in a move so obvious it might as well have come with a neon sign. “It’s just- it’s the wrestling. Adrenaline, or whatever.”
I was staring at the sky, refusing to make eye contact. “Can you just- Stop looking at me like that.” I swallowed hard. “I’m sorry, okay? I’ll just... I’ll go inside and- ” I started to stand, but my legs were shaky and I stumbled slightly on the uneven lawn.
“Wait!” He said it too fast. He should be kicking my ass right now but he wasn’t, so I paused. “Just hold on a sec, bro...” He started picking at the grass, too, not seeming to register that he was mirroring me. “Have you been, like... Doing stuff in college? Like, y’know... experimenting and shit?”
I froze mid-crouch, one hand braced on the ground. “Doing stuff?” I repeated it flatly, then I sank back down onto the grass, cross-legged, my shoulders hunched forward. “What kind of stuff are we talking about?” I picked at the grass again, tearing blades into tiny pieces between my fingers. I guess that’s our new thing now. “Because if you’re asking whether I’ve been like... figuring things out...” I trailed off. “Then, yeah, I have been. Have you?” The words came out barely above a whisper.
His voice was low, too, and he leaned in closer. “You, too? Is that a thing all guys do? It’s not, right?!?”
I let out a breath I might have been holding since freshman year. My hand stopped shredding grass. My posture loosened, and for the first time since I’d scrambled away, I actually looked him in the eyes. “I thought I was losing my mind! Like, I had this whole thing where I told myself it was just curiosity, or that everyone thinks about it sometimes, but then I couldn’t stop thinking about it, and...” I caught myself rambling and bit down on my lower lip hard. “So when you say you’ve been doing stuff... what kind of stuff are we talking?”
“First I just kissed a couple of guys,” he told the torn grass in his hands. “The first time was drunk and it was a dare. But I fuckin loved it...”
“Yeah?” My swim trunks did nothing to disguise what was happening, and I didn’t care anymore. “I didn’t even need the dare! Or the drunk part. There was this guy in my film studies class, and one day during a break I just... I leaned over and kissed him. No warning. He didn’t even kiss me back. Just stared at me. Turns out he wasn’t actually gay, just really friendly!” A short, self-deprecating laugh escaped me, but my eyes never left Dale’s face. “But you said you loved it. How much?”
“Enough to keep doing it with other guys. I even joined the student Gay-Straight Alliance to meet boys...” He chuckled and finally looked up at me. “I got kicked out. Turns out you aren’t supposed to do that!”
A laugh burst out of me, sudden and real. “You got kicked out of the GSA? Dale, what did you do?” But the laughter faded fast as I wiped my palm across my mouth, shaking my head.
I settled back on the grass and the playfulness drained from my expression. “You ever talk about it before? I never told anyone.” My fingers found Dale’s knee, just like they always did when I was trying to make a point that was more than trivial, but now touching him felt different. “I spent all year thinking about you, though. Every time I hooked up with someone, I kept...” I stopped. My jaw tightened. My thumb pressed into the soft skin just above Dale’s kneecap. “I kept comparing them to you. That’s fucked up, right?”
“That’s really fucked up!” He smiled, though. “For the record, I have never thought about you like that. No offense, like you’re handsome and all that, but I knew you were straight. And I’m not into straight boys. Not anymore.” He stared at the hand on his knee but didn’t push it away. “I kind of had a boyfriend for a while but it didn’t work out because he was super closeted...”
“You had a boyfriend?” I said it like Dale had just casually mentioned he’d been to the moon. I ran both hands through my messy hair, leaving it sticking up worse than before.
“So lemme get this straight,” I said, counting on my fingers. “You’ve kissed multiple guys, joined a club specifically to meet gay boys, had a whole relationship with a closeted guy, but you never once thought about your best friend from back home?!?” I gestured vaguely at myself, at the obvious situation in my shorts, at the hickey I’d left on Dale’s thigh. “I think I should be offended that I didn’t even make the spank bank!”
“Well I didn’t know you were like that until right now, dumbass!” He sat up a little straighter and chuckled. “So you still haven’t told me what kind of stuff you got up to at college. Spill!”
I groaned, dropping my head back dramatically before rolling it forward to look at Dale with a mix of reluctance and amusement. “You really want the whole catalog?” I picked at a blade of grass, pointing it like a tiny baton. “Okay. Fine. After that first kiss attempt I kind of... spiraled. In a good way, I guess. There was a guy in my econ study group who was openly bi and we made out in the library stacks like a couple of cliché college boys experimenting. Then there was this one night at a house party where I ended up in a bedroom with two guys and I just- Oof!” I stopped abruptly, my face flushing a deep scarlet that spread down my neck and across my chest. “It wasn’t planned or anything. One minute we’re all just talking on this couch, and then someone’s hand is somewhere it shouldn’t be, and then suddenly nobody’s wearing pants and there’s cum everywhere...”
My hand found Dale’s knee again, this time with purpose, fingers curling around the side of it. “So yeah. That’s my sad little story. Your turn. Tell me about the boyfriend! I haven’t ever done the dating thing with a guy. I guess I’m still in my slutty phase!”
“He was a baseball player on scholarship. And he was terrified that somebody might find out, so we had to sneak around. That’s what broke up the whole thing. I never felt like I got all of him, y’know?” He got a faraway look in his eyes that I was somehow jealous of. “But he was really good in bed. He’d known he was gay since forever so he had a lot of experience...”
“A baseball player.” I grinned, nudging Dale’s leg. “Of course you landed a hot gay baseball player!” The tone of the conversation was starting to feel less awkward, almost familiar, but the subject matter was entirely new territory.
“For real, though, Dale. I’m glad you had that. You deserve someone who was good to you.” The words carried weight beyond what I probably intended. “So... you said he had experience. What did you do with him?”
“We did just about everything!” He didn’t look at me for the next part. “Except I didn’t let him top me. I was too nervous. And he was big.” He drifted away again for a second but then snapped his attention back to me. “But what about you? You said you had a three-way with two other dudes?!?”
“I mean, yeah.” I shifted closer, close enough that our thighs were flush against each other now. “One of them topped me. First time anyone ever did that. It was... honestly it was kind of overwhelming? Like I didn’t know my body could feel like that. But I liked it. I really liked it.” I paused, chewing the inside of my cheek. My eyes drifted to Dale’s face with something careful and deliberate. “And the other guy, I topped him. So I’ve done both.” My hand slid from Dale’s knee up to his thigh, just slightly, fingertips resting against the edge of the hickey I’d left earlier. “You said you were nervous about letting your baseball player fuck you. Was it the size thing, or was it more than that?”
“It was all of it! Even if he hadn’t been so big, I was still too scared to try it. He told me it didn’t hurt when I fucked him, but I still wasn’t ready to try it. Did it hurt when you did it?”
“Yeah. At first. Well, not painful hurt, but uncomfortable as fuck.” I said it plainly, no bravado, no macho posturing. “Like, not gonna lie, for the first few seconds I thought I’d made a huge mistake letting him fuck me. But the guy knew what he was doing and he got me ready first and went slow...”
I squeezed Dale’s thigh gently, grounding us both. “It’s not really about the size of the guy. It’s about whether he makes you feel safe enough to relax.” I let that sit for a moment, watching Dale’s face. “If you ever wanted to try it with someone you trust... You know that I’d never hurt you, right?”
“Yeah...” He finally looked at my hand on him, then at my face. “I figured that was gonna come up...”
“Was I that obvious?” A small smile tugged at my mouth. I withdrew my hand and placed both palms flat on my own knees, like I was physically restraining myself from reaching out again.
“Look,” I told him, hoping not to kill the momentum. “I’m not trying to pressure you. If you wanna just pretend this whole thing didn’t happen, we can do that. We can get in the pool, splash around, go inside and order pizza- ” I swallowed. “But I’d be lying if I said I didn’t want you. I’ve wanted you for ages, Dale. Not just today. Not just because you had your thighs around my head and you tasted good.” My hands curled into fists on my knees. “So whatever you want this to be, I’m into it.”
He took the longest pause in recorded history before he finally exhaled and nudged me with his shoulder. “Bro, we are so gay!”
I looked down at my boner, then over at Dale. He had a boner, too, and the laugh that erupted from me was so loud and sudden that I doubled over, hands on my knees, shoulders shaking. “Yeah, we are so gay right now!” I stood up, making zero effort to hide anything anymore, and the absurdity of it hit me all at once: two best friends standing in a backyard in swim trunks, both visibly hard, covered in grass stains and hickeys, laughing like idiots.
“We should go in the house,” he announced, like that was the obvious next step.