Writing 'bad paths' (and good news) (Patreon)
Content
First some good news: I just came back from a visit with my parents for the fist time since my mom's cancer operation this april. She finally had enough energy to handle a visit, the little she had before we decided she would use on my two little nieces, because they need it more. And, we live 6 hours apart, so every visit is a procedure at this point. Such a relief to finally be able to hug her and see that yeah, she's worn out, but she's looking and feeling so much better. Slow recovery, but considering that she's old and just went though the biggest cancer operations they do in sweden (11 hours on the table) everything is going to plan. Hopefully my brain can retire that particular worry now. It's been a rough two years.
Some annoying news: Grammarly, my preferred grammar/spelling companion for a decade has decided to go full in on AI and rebrand to 'Superhuman.' Before (at least with the Pro version I had) it was easy to turn off the rewrite suggestions and other things that might use generative AI and that would impact my writing style. I could decide exactly what I wanted it to check for, which was essential since I had both code to deal with, and my rather eccentric mangling of words and structure. But, this last step proved to me that there was no coming back from this. I cancelled my subscription, and is currently trying to delete my account, though for some strange reason they had removed the easy remove button and I needed to submit a ticket. And, not surprisingly, they said they were swamped, so who knows when that will happen. Need to find something to replace it with, but with everything being AI now it looks difficult.
Now, the reason why I decided to write this post.
Writing the 'Bad Paths'
As I am sitting here writing the next demo (Ortega/Innocent) I was remembering some comments I have been seeing about how nice/easy some things are in the early demos. Especially getting over being angry, repairing relationships and the like. As some who can check comments in the code might see, there are a lot of things I have not yet added. But I feel like there is an interesting discussion why I have chosen to write these particular variants first. So let's get into some path construction details!
Emotional Cohesion
I tend to stick to one main mindset for Sidestep as I write the first drafts. Then I go back and add variables and choices to widen the possibilities. This happens in intervals, and depending on when I release the demo, any particular section might have had more or less stuff and variants added to it. This is a time and energy thing, where I try to focus on pushing things forward rather than polishing what is there. But if this was the main reason, there should be as many bad/angry/complicated versions as there are easy/nice/forgiving ones, right? Yes. There is something else at play here.
Plot Progression
In any particular scene, there is what we can call the 'plot progression.' This is the main driver of the demo, the events that will happen and in which particular order they occur. Sidestep needs to make decisions and take action to drive the story forward. Some of these will be mandatory (you need to meet with Hollow Ground at Parkfield, though for many Sidesteps that is slightly out of character) because to deviate would mean either missing massive amounts of game, derail the story beyond the point of recovery, or force me to take over the reins and have certain things happen anyway. The latter one might seem similar to something being mandatory, but they are quite different.
For example, Sidestep talks themselves into going to Parkfield because it needs to happen. If I would have allowed Sidestep to go "lol, nope" then I would still have needed to force that crash somehow. Not only would I need to write an entirely separate scene setting up to that, I would also preferably need to impart some Hollow Ground info somewhere. Either this would be a LOT of extra text, or it would feel even more forced (Hollow Ground kidnaps you, a truck hits you as you cross the street, and so on). I do have one alternative entry to that scene, because it didn't feel forced if you were captured at the Auction. You still miss a major scene, but it is because of your own actions and failures. So, the simpler alternative would be to have Sidestep justify their actions.
This brings us to the next concept:
Derailment/Pathing
The baseline structure of the game is split/reconvene. Most of the time this is very quick, you have a choice, some variant dialogue/reactions, and then the scene continues along the same track. In action/tension scenes this might take longer, as there is a physical difference if you go right or left, if you attack or hide and so on. But there is still a scene fuse at the end of the action sequence. Bigger splits in paths do happen, but rarely. Sometimes they lead to missed scenes (don't do the Mortum date at Joes, don't do the Argent minddive) and sometimes they lead to long sequences where the paths are entirely different (the auction, post crash Retribution). The last ones add SO much work I try to avoid doing them unless I feel they really add something. They are the reason Revelations has been so slow (that and real life being an absolute bastard). If I had just had one/two endings (crash in your own body, innocent or guilty) like originally planned, everything would have been SO fast. But I really like this twist, and what I will be able to do with it.
So, if we keep in mind that any deviating from the standard structure will lead to slowing progress and more writing, we then gets to the next concept:
Real Consequences
If I allow certain reactions, paths and outcomes, I also feel that I need to let the consequences be felt in game. It might take a while, there might be variables bubbling that will come up eventually, but I want to take it into account. Otherwise we lose the feeling of immersion and consequence that I really want. The feeling that the world is reactive to what Sidestep does, even if it's not always in the ways that they think.
For example, originally I had the option in Retribution for Ortega to break up with Sidestep and pick the puppet instead if certain relationship variables were hit. The scene itself was a blast to write, and the original fallout was fun. However, I eventually realized that this would lead to a changed dynamic between Sidestep and Ortega that would lead to vast amounts of different reaction text and internal thoughts, for a path that maybe would affect 2% of the playthroughs, if that. I had the choice between either removing that path, or let Sidestep act out of character for the rest of the book, or spend an unproportionally long amount of time adding alternative text most players would never see. I picked the first option, and removed that outcome. Which leads me to:
The Predictability Problem
When I write, I often write in an exploratory manner. That means that I know where I want to go, but not necessarily how to get there, and, above all, not how the characters will feel/act as they do so. This means that when I write a first draft, I try to be in the mindset of a Sidestep that is amendable to what is going on. This means no massive distractions or arguments that could potentially lead to side paths being triggered.
If I start writing a heated argument that truly goes for the jugular, that might mean to Sidestep walking out of the scene. Or that the reaction will color the rest of the scene. Or that new and more complicated outcomes will be available. This is good, up to a point. However, from experience I have realized this can lead me down the wrong paths, just like in the example about Ortega breaking up, above. I have had great issues with that now at the start of Revelations, where I've had to repath/scrap/rewrite so many things because I had written to a point where I logically could not see a way it would tie back again to the main storyline. And believe me, I do need to fuse things at this point.
But, I hear you protest, not all bad reactions lead to different outcomes. This is true. Sometimes you are forced by circumstance to work with someone that you can't forgive because they betrayed you (ahem, Mortum). However, I have learned to be patient and wary by now. If I know the end of a scene/path, it is a lot easier for me to write reactions without writing myself into a corner, going off the rails, and having to scrap what I have written because it doesn't fit later. This is most often a Sidestep that is paranoid, angry and/or difficult (complimentary). But it doesn't have to be.
For example, in the demo where you meet with HG after breaking into their house there is a possibility to be not only more brutal (why not set fire to the place? Blow it up? Try to kill HG?) but also to be more open/friendly (why not stick around to meet Nocturne? Be more family oriented?). Each would have consequences where I am not sure where the cascades would lead at this point. Thus they exists as notes/options/snippets right now and are not in the demo until I have written further along so I know how big/complicated the deviations would be.
Fix it in Post
And finally, there is the playtesting. I trust my playtesters to point out paths/options/reactions I have overlooked, and paths that needs to be filled out. I see your comments right now, and they do end up in my notes. I just prefer to push forward right now than to fill out.
My personal Sidestep is a nasty little piece of work, I look forward to adding more of those sides into the game.
TLDR
My first and second draft demos focus on cooperative Sidesteps to prevent story creep and minimize my need to rewrite and revise. It is not because I see this as the canon Sidestep.