Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Content

Hey everyone,

Boy, let me tell you, this project ended up being *way* different from what I initially expected.  At the start, I had in mind doing a simple followup of the Fourier transform video showing where it comes up outside of the classic example of decomposing frequencies.  I thought maybe a little uncertainty principle here, maybe a little Riemann zeta function there, maybe something else because the rule of threes, and badda boom badda bang.

But the more I starting scoping this out, the more interested I got.  I had not been previously aware of Doppler radar before, but it seemed like the perfect middle example between the time-frequency trade-off to the position-momentum one.  As I mentioned in video, the specific way I phrased the Doppler radar example is a little different from the trade-off faced in practice (which involved choosing the right "pulse repetition frequency").  I toyed a script laying the full thing out, but it was just too much that was too beside the point.

Digging into de Broglie's thesis was also an unexpected turn that arose in putting together this script.  I had never thought of special relativity being at the roots of these things, when in fact it seems to have been a very core part of de Broglie's thoughts during the years of his Ph.D. work.  As soon as he described the crude comparison with the spring setup, I just found myself thinking "man, one way or another, I've got to animate this into some video..."

Hope you enjoy!
-Grant

Files

Previews only

Uncertainty principle? It's not about quantum.

The Heisenberg uncertainty principle is just one specific example of a much more general, relatable, non-quantum phenomenon. Apply to work at one of my favorite math education companies: http://aops.com/3b1b Special thanks to the following Patrons: http://3b1b.co/uncertainty-thanks You are the ones making this possible: http://3b1b.co/support For more on quantum mechanical wave functions, I highly recommend this video by udiprod: https://youtu.be/p7bzE1E5PMY Minute physics on special relativity: https://youtu.be/1rLWVZVWfdY Main video on the Fourier transform https://youtu.be/spUNpyF58BY Louis de Broglie thesis: http://aflb.ensmp.fr/LDB-oeuvres/De_Broglie_Kracklauer.pdf More on Doppler radar: Radar basics: https://www.eetimes.com/document.asp?doc_id=1278808 There's a key way in which the description I gave of the trade-off in Doppler radar differs from reality. Since the speed of light is so drastically greater than the speed of things being detected, the Fourier representation for pulse echoes of different objects would almost certainly overlap unless it was played for a very long time. In effect, this is what happens, since one does not send out a single pulse, but a whole bunch of evenly spaced pulses as some pulse repetition frequency (or PRF). This means the Fourier representation of all those pulses together can actually be quite sharp. Assuming a large number of such pulses, it will look like several vertical lines spaced out by the PRF. As long as the pulses are far enough apart that the echoes of multiple objects on the field from different targets don't overlap, it's not a problem for position determinations that the full sequence of pulses occupies such a long duration. However, the trade-off now comes in choosing the right PRF. See the above article for more information. Music by Vincent Rubinetti: https://vincerubinetti.bandcamp.com/album/the-music-of-3blue1brown https://soundcloud.com/vincerubinetti/ ------------------ 3blue1brown is a channel about animating math, in all senses of the word animate. And you know the drill with YouTube, if you want to stay posted on new videos, subscribe, and click the bell to receive notifications (if you're into that). If you are new to this channel and want to see more, a good place to start is this playlist: http://3b1b.co/recommended Various social media stuffs: Website: https://www.3blue1brown.com Twitter: https://twitter.com/3Blue1Brown Patreon: https://patreon.com/3blue1brown Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/3blue1brown Reddit: https://www.reddit.com/r/3Blue1Brown

Comments

Anonymous

How do non-commutative variables come into play?

Evan Miyazono

Wow, that turned out even better than I could have imagined. Well done! Also, I might be just seeing it wrong, but I think you might not have done \pm 2\sigma on the momentum bracket size

Anonymous

I liked very much specially in the end of the video when you described locality and velocity using a red arrow and a blue sphere. It was great! Very good, Grant!

Anonymous

It was just fantastic!

Chris Jennings

Your little graphic with the turqoise position cloud varying in diameter, and the origin for zillions of momentum vectors varying in direction, is just a superb depiction of ... Unsharferelation! (my new favourite word)

Benjamin BairMoshe

You can delve so much deeper into this topic. If you look into gamma spectroscopy, you get peaks where isotopes release gammas. The accuracy (called resolution) of these peaks increases as the efficiency decreases. This means it takes a lot more time and many more measurements to get a very accurate picture of the spectrum. You can also observe the Phenomenon in information theory. Really, what you are doing when you are detecting quantum particles is you are transferring information from the particle itself. The Fourier Transform is really showing us the two types of information we can detect from a particle. Chebyshev is actually the one who gave us the exact formula of the maximum and minimum amount of "certainty" you can have when looking at frequency space and time space. Just as an aside, you mentioned that photons change in time, but actually the definition of a photon is that all of its information is in the space domain. Electron information, for example is present in both space and time (positive time), whereas positron information is present in space and negative time.

Fabio Bobrow

I wasn’t supporting you on Patreon, you already have lots of patrons and I prefer to focus on people with fewer ones. But after this video it was impossible not to become a patron. What an amazing video, really! Congrats and thank you for that!

3blue1brown

Let's hope you're right! This is the thought that inspires me the most.

3blue1brown

Thanks! For what it's worth, my strategy moving forward is to use Patreon funds to bring on more talented math communicators, allowing for some combination of higher quality and higher quantity on this channel. You will see the first products of this in the upcoming two videos. My hope is that the marginal value of dollars pledges on this page is just as high as it would be for a smaller page.

Anonymous

Very cool - this is the first new video since I signed up as a sponsor. I've been studying QM on a formal mathematical level for about a year, after years of more popular-level interest, and am fairly new to Fourier transforms and how the uncertainty principle is intrinsic to wave mechanics as opposed to a specific QM concept. This video lays this out very nicely. I'm also a hobbyist musician and music buff, and am well aware of how percussion instruments are considered "indefinite pitch", but had never before thought of drum shots vs. piano tones in terms of the uncertainty principle. This is great!

Sohan

I know this is a few days late, but I just recently got a chance to watch this video and I wanted to add my two cents. Unfortunately, this video was a bit of a letdown for me. I thought that the classical portion was great and super well-motivated, but your claim that the quantum uncertainty principle can be made intuitive strikes me as very misleading. Yes, the Heisenberg uncertainty principle can be viewed as a simple consequence of the fact that position and momentum space are related by a Fourier transform, but I think the premise that position and momentum are conjugate variables is EXTREMELY non-intuitive. It seems to me that the conclusion of your video was a bit too strong. This could cause misconceptions such as the idea that the quantum-mechanical wavefunction is a physical wave in the same way that a sound wave is. My other issue with this video was that the discussion of the mass-spring system didn't actually help me understand de Broglie's original argument. It seemed as though you were recapping de Broglie's thesis for people who had already read it rather than summarizing the argument for an audience who had never seen it before. Making this section of the video stronger may have helped clear up the issues I mentioned earlier (possibly better motivating the relation between position and momentum). Overall, I felt like the presentation of the uncertainty principle itself was solid, but the surrounding discussion of quantum mechanics was muddled and seemed to imply that the subject only appears non-intuitive because people who study it haven't thought hard enough about classical wave phenomena. I hope this criticism is constructive, and I'd be happy to discuss it with you further if any of my points aren't clear (or if you disagree about any of them). I'm a huge fan of your content and I hope to see you discuss more topics outside of pure math in the future!

3blue1brown

Hi Sohan, thanks for the detailed writeup. The only way to improve is with well thought-out and well intentioned criticism like this, so I really do appreciate it. I can see what you mean where if someone took the spring analogy too literally, as opposed to just interpreting it as a standing for a generic phenomenon involving cycles over time, it runs the risk of insinuating that the "wave" of a wave function is like that of a rope or water. I certainly agree that the crux of whether or not HUP is intuitive comes down to position and momentum being conjugate, and the analysis with SR is what did it for me. But perhaps it just ended up too rushed and lacking detail in the time I was willing to allot it for this video. Even just a sentence or two about how it's okay if that fact seems counterintuitive may have helped the narrative. Again, thanks for the thoughtful feedback.

Genese Harris

Keep it up! 🖒🏽👏🏽🌐

Anonymous

Very interesting. As a quantum chemist, I never understood how this Fourier intuition ties with the general stament of the uncertainty principle, which holds for any two operators that do not commute with each other. I mean, when you look at the proof as presented in many QM textbooks, it basically involves some algebraic manipulation and some tricks, but I guess I am missing the big picture.