So...what's the deal with probability? (Patreon)
Content
Several people have been (justifiably) curious about the status of the probability series, which makes it feel like a good time for another thought-dump via patreon post!
Basically, at the moment there are 5 videos which I feel, well, only so-so about.
1) Chapter 1
2) Combinations
3) The independence assumption
4) Bayes' rule
5) Thoughts on the classic Bayes' rule example
Through the past year, even though people have been abundantly clear about the fact that they would like a series on probability, for whatever reason I have found it difficult to get excited about doing these videos.
Part of this is due to an intrinsic ambiguity in what people mean when they say "probability". The high schooler might want to understand things like conditional probabilities and Bayes' rule. The college student may have in mind understanding all the different common distributions and their use cases. The pure math college student may want to understand its foundations from measure theory up. Someone getting into machine learning may want to build to things like Bayesian networks, information theory, KL divergence, etc. And others still may want something focused more directly towards statistics.
Unlike other parts of math with multiple disparate use cases, each of these directions would, in my judgement, have very different implications for what constitutes the "essence". This makes it rather challenging to confidently choose a direction to focus on, and to center the series on any coherent theme.
Also, in any videos I make, I actually like to avoid thinking about a particular target audience, and instead to focus on underlying ideas for the content which other internet expositions don't seem to have, the hope being that more originality widens the reach. And to that end, I just don't know that what I'd put out on probability will be meaningfully different from other offerings on the internet.
I can already hear some of you thinking "ooh, I have some ideas, let me help." That's great! You should put those ideas together in your own bit of exposition, and if it's good, I'll do everything I can to help offer feedback and get it out there. For my part, I will at least temporarily take a break from the probability series here. Or, perhaps more accurately phrased, I'll be more honest with myself about the fact that I'm not really working on it at all these days.
I'm sensitive to the fact that some people have come to this Patreon page specifically seeking to support probability videos. If that's you, all I can say is bear with me, and I'll do my best to make sure that the projects which are more actively in the pipeline are worth your while.
I'm honestly not sure what to do with the existing videos listed above. They're not something I feel proud enough of to throw up on the main channel as they are, so perhaps I'll return back later to clean them up. . . Thoughts and ideas are welcomed.
The plan moving forward?
As far as more "essence of" series content is concerned, I'd actually like to turn back to linear algebra and fill in what I see to be the incompletenesses of that series, and where I have a much clearer view for what is worth putting out there. I already made the one on Cramer's rule, which is meant to be one of several connecting the content of the series to more computational methods typically taught in a linear algebra course, and I'd also like to give an intuition for transposes, and to build up to singular value decomposition.
The pace at which I get to these has everything to do with how well I keep the schedules I have in mind for the coming stand-alone projects.
In general, I'm quite aware of how inconsistent I have been in the past about following through on creations that I promised in earlier videos. Just know that this does not stem for caprice, or a disrespect for the audience. Quite the opposite, in fact. Sometimes it's only when I go partway into a project that the shape of the end result becomes clear, and I care deeply about only pushing for final products that feel most worthy of the audience's time.
-Grant