Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Linked below is the model Tom just got (at a steep discount from that listed price) for an AMD Ryzen 390 Strix Halo 64GB laptop! Over the next week or so he will be testing this with the mindset that this could be much cheaper soon, and try to thus not just evaluate its quality and capabilities - but advise to gamers and professionals what price would make this "worth it".

And so - what do you want tested? What aspect of Strix Halo or this laptop are you most interested in? And for fun - what general AMD APU (both present and future) questions do you have for Tom and Dan? (Warning: It is unlikely Linux or AI will be tested, this is more of an evaluation to see what price this would be worth it to more mainstream shoppers)

This is a conversation not just about testing today's laptops, but what we want from the future of them! You have ~16 hours (Till tomorrow afternoon) to submit!

https://www.hp.com/us-en/shop/pdp/hp-zbook-ultra-14-inch-g1a-mobile-workstation-pc-wolf-pro-security-edition-p-b90jjua-aba-1

Comments

Timo H

Putting some Switch(2) larping, what is toughest hdmi(?) output resolution to eg tv that it can run some relatively new game in high resolution to see what it can do? I assume display out allows higher res than native screen to truly max it in some game.

Dark Side of the Force

Tbh biggest thing I want for these big APU is for them to get to a certain level of performance at cheaper price. Let's say 50-60 class dGPU from nvidia performance at around $200-300 premium, and affordable memory upgrades, either (cheaper soldered memory upgrades) or (Lpcamm).

TechnoLadz

Honestly, I'd love to see AMD compete more in the dedicated GPU space on laptops. The RTX 5090 laptop barely outperforms (typically 5% faster) than a desktop 5070; at 175W. If optimised correctly, AMD could have near identical performance to the RX 9070 desktop, at 175W; whilst using the cut down die - and that's not even N48X. Meaning, AMD for $1100-$1400 (5060, 5070 range), would smash not only the 5060 and 5070, but compete exceedingly well with laptops above that too.

TechnoLadz

100% agree. The highest end Strix Halo would look great at around the $1300-$1500 price range in laptops.

Dark Side of the Force

As for laptop testing, I would like to see you just stressing these laptop out in weird manners and see how stable the platform is. Maybe do something like running multiple screens. underpowered chargers, sleep behavior, sleep behavior when having external power source that was yank out in the middle of sleep, etc to see how good AMD & HP has done with the laptop. Though if you encounter a problem I would suggest to clean install windows ISO and use AMD driver directly, that seems to help with problematic windows image from some OEM.

TechnoLadz

Aside from memory bandwidth, what is stopping AMD from doubling the number of WGPs in Strix Halo for it's successors and beyond? Is it thermals/power needed, die size or price?

TechnoLadz

What is your biggest criticism of Strix Halo currently?

boomstick

When the price hits that magical break point ($1300 to $1500 imo) and consumer demand increases, will the supply/yields be able to keep up?

I Dude

One of the use cases that I have for such a laptop is gaming on the go (flying to the location and staying at a hotel for the week.) I see it comes with a 140W USB C charger, so my question is two fold- 1. If I hook it up to a 65W or 95W USB C does the laptop downclock its self to stay under the power budget (I have used dell laptops that become basically unusable in this mode), or does it use 65W/95W from the USB C and then pull the rest from the battery, (in essence extending the battery using wall power instead of charging while using)(as a note, many airplane outlets are limited to 65W) 2. Similar to your other Minis Forum Tablet, does the HP Laptop trickle charge off of said 65W/95W USB C while in the off state/sleep mode. I guess to add to the discussion for later, I would be willing to pay up to $1900/$2000 for something that ticks all the boxes (15"+ OLED more than 1080p, 120Hz, 32GB+ Ram, 1TB+ SSD, Thin Chassis, 65Wh+ Battery), but I would really like a 15" or 16" model if I'm shelling out that much cash. As configured in the link posted, I think I would stop at $1600/$1700. Bonus questions: Is the storage and Wifi Upgradable (I understand that the RAM is soldered for signal integrity). Does the laptop support S3 Sleep (classic Sleep, not the windows modern standby Sleep) What sort of settings are available in the Bios, I know we wont have AM5 level of settings, but there has to be something right? I have heard that many PC components' stockpiles will be exhausted by the end of July/ August. Wouldn't a niche Laptop like Strix Halo not fall in this category, considering that there isn't much stock in the first place?

AI Generated Fish

Yeah, I had intended to use my g16 coming back from Europe. Tripped a breaker or something on the plane, ended up not being able to use it at all.

Prior is the theme 999

Congrats to nvidia for becoming the worlds first 4 trillion dollar company! Who would’ve thought 8gb of vram would take them so far! This is further proof that 8gb is enough! Look at the results!

AI Generated Fish

Id like to see it compared against 4070/5070 laptop and 5070ti laptop. How much weaker is it and does extra vram make up for lack of bandwidth? Personally, strix Halo is completely disinteresting to me. I have no use for 16 cores on a personal laptop and they locked the "better" GPU behind that core count. I believe it will lose to 4070 mobile in most scenarios so it's maybe a $1000 - 1500 product for me.

AI Generated Fish

Id love for them to hit 70ti/80 performance. But they have to be in more than 1 laptop.

Trevor Renfro

I'm very interested in finding out both how to get such products as mini PCs instead of laptops, and how to identify that they're Halo products. I might switch my desktop PC to a Halo product if it's actually a mini PC with enough cooling, USBs, and similar. APUs like consoles have always seemed to be less processing latency, less power consumption, less heat generation, less buggy (due to fewer different pieces), and similar.

KingKoro

Hi Tom and Dan, if medusa halo really is a 2027 product and strix halo is out now, meaning it's a long wait, what should/can AMD do in between? In my opinion AMD should release a bigger 384-Bit LPDDR5X variant of strix halo so OEMs are prepared for designs with even larger APUs. Of course it can't be a drop-in replacement for medusa halo if it uses LPDDR6 but should help a quicker adoption regardless.

Dave Scholze

With Strix mini-PCs and Notebooks, I am more and more wishing for Mini-PCs where you can add an external GPU via a full PCIe connection (maybe an Oculink successor). Imagine a Strix Halo Notebook with such a connection: powerful enough for on the go and a hell of a machine when at home and connected to said eGPU. What are your thoughts on that kind of future? Could this replace full desktops eventually because of the convenience?

Valentyn

Most of the laptops in my life I've received from my employer. These have always been, and continue to be, Intel-based. When I look around at all the companies in my field (Energy), I see mainly HP EliteBooks and Lenovo ThinkPads - all Intel-based (running SKUs like 1165G7, 155U, or 228V). Given the popularity of Ryzen on desktop and the rich offer of AMD mobile APUs, why isn't AMD more prevalent among corporate laptops?

Lucas

Strix Halo has a capable gpu but is still a little too expensive for mainstream gaming laptops. Do you see a future where APUs and their inherent advantages become the default for anything but the most specific professional workloads? My understanding is that the 256bit Memory Interface is just inherently more power hungry. Can this be solved to make APUs both performant and power efficient (enough)?

Lo_Res_Gamer

ZBook: Since you've been theorizing the unified memory of the iGPU could allow use of LLMs > 16 GB as a possible use-case for Strix Halo: How does it perform running local AI? Can the large memory compensate for the weakness of the iGPU vs. current mid-range GPUs like the 5070 Ti or 9070 XT? Future * Halo: As AMD uses more advanced nodes (relative to best available from TSMC), this should accelerate the capabilities of iGPUs and iNPUs. What kind of performance do you expect from Zen 6 or Zen 7 "Halo" APUs, assuming such products come to market?

xz

I simply think 395 Max+ based systems are far too expensive right now unless you actually use them for the marketed niches. If AMD had released an APU with the 8060s igpu and one X3D CCD, and this could be found in mini pcs around ~$1000 and in laptops around ~$1400 that’d be pretty great i think.

AI-Soldier789

Record unclear and messy audio and try AI software to denoise the audio and look if the NPU is fully used and how long the proccessing takes and how good the sound is.