Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

29.01.25 8pm - 9pm (GMT). Will try to stick to the hour! This isn't a presentation by me - this is a group collaborative discussion to try and answer this question.

Files

Is Silco a good father figure to Jinx?

Patreon only live stream.

Comments

Last Thing

I know if this goes out on youtube the comments will be a battlefield

Simpelicity

Is being a good father figure the same as being a good father?

HeyItsVayy

Looking forward to the stream! Can’t wait to hear what Stu has to say. A lot of people jump to conclusions about Silco so I hope we get some good discussion.

Connection through Reaction

Think I should put it up? I guess the question is will turn more people away from the channel than it will bring in!

TaroGhostie

I'd love to see an analysis or formulation of viktor before jumping into season 2, but im happy to jump into it regardless i just really love viktor and find his story SO compelling

Last Thing

I don't think it will turn anyone away but I know that people are going to be fighting eachother in the comments if enough see it. Comments are good for engagement so ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

Crystal Raeth

Personal opinion but I always felt Silco loved her more then a daughter, romantically to a degree

CalicoJill

I think Silco loved Jinx, but I don't think he was a good father. I recognize that he has a lot of good qualities and shows a lot of care towards her, but the bad things are too egregious and tip the scales heavily towards "No." I think it's interesting because, Silco didn't see a small child that needed a home and out of the goodness of his heart, took her in. He was fully set on killing her and her entire family until he saw himself in her. I don't think he took her in with the intent to love her so much as use her and mold her into a version of himself ("It's okay... We'll show them.... we'll show them all.") but I do think along the way he actually did come to love her... or who she had become anyway. That entire scene where he baptized her was to "Let Powder die"... the parts of her that still cared about her family, the parts that he saw as holding her back.... because "Jinx is perfect." in the same way that Jinx felt rejected by Vi for the part of her that is Jinx, Silco also rejected the parts of her that are powder. (granted I believe we are one continuous chain that can't really be separated into halves like that, but that's the way Jinx seems to view it). But the thing that really clinches it for me, is that Jinx really doesn't seem to have anyone other than him, and when Vi comes back, she wants more than anything to reconnect with her and Silco is so threatened by the idea that Jinx might choose Vi over him, that he spends much of the season trying to kill her. The one other person in her life that she clearly still cares about, and Silco tries to kill her. I don't care how much he loves her, to me that's an unforgivable act.

Jazzy

You are entitled to feel what you want of course but I think the majority will strongly disagree

Geschnetzeltes

Honestly a valid opinion.. I don't like to think like that much, but the writers were considering something along those lines in early writing stages, it kinda still is this codependent eeri relationship because of the layered effed up-ness that they added for interpretation

Crystal Raeth

My reasons for this is the way they interact with each other they cross the lines physically as father and daughter.

Llama Lana

You didn't understand Jinx' character at all then. The whole point of Jinx is that she's stuck being a little girl emotionally because of all the trauma she's been through. Whatever happens and how much time passes, she's still that little girl holding on to Vi and looking at her dead parents on the bridge in her emotional attachments. That's why Vi "leaving" her affected her that much more - she might have been 11, but inside, she was a 3 year old girl who's already been abandoned once. Her emotional outbursts when she's left at home are also very dysregulated for her age. She's like a toddler having a meltdown after you drop them off at preschool because they don't understand you're not leaving forever, times 100 because of her trauma. Jinx might be a young adult, but the trauma is still there, and it makes you feel the same way it felt at the age you experienced it no matter how much time has passed. She was attached to Vi at the hip, and after what happened, it's no wonder she has an even more unhealthy and immature attachment to Silco. She needs him like a toddler does, listens to him like a toddler would, wants to please him like a toddler would and trusts him completely. That's why him hiding Vi and considering giving her up for even a second is SUCH a betrayal to her. The relationship is supposed to make us uncomfortable. It's a grown man and a young woman behaving like a dad with his 3 year old. It's supposed to emphasize just how much Jinx has been affected by everything emotionally, and how much she depends on Silco. But it also shows how much Silco cares for her. He provides her with all the support and patience she needs, even though she needs as much as a toddler. It's not sexual at ALL. The "lines they cross" are mostly just her sitting in his lap, which is exactly how little kids sit on their parents' laps. And even Silco is not entirely comfortable with it, if you look at those scenes, but he lets her do it because he understand that she needs that.

Crystal Raeth

Great you understand Jinx doesn't change he never stopped her or showed any indication that he didn't like it. He can listen to her wants and needs like any normal father would.

Tahlia Bro

their relationship is supposed to be kind of uncomfortable (largely because of jinx being kinda trapped in a child-like mind), but it definitely isn't intended to actually seem like silco had romantic interest. It's clearly not healthy, but there is no real indication of romantic interest at all.

Crystal Raeth

Ya true it just leaves the idea in the air that's why I said it was just an opinion not factual