Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

This has now taken place. The stream should be available. https://youtube.com/live/un3J8R8h4d8?feature=share

Files

Understanding Maddie...

Patreon for unedited, ad-free, early access and live streams: https://www.patreon.com/TherapistREACTS Youtube Channels: Music Reactions: https://www.youtube.com/@Connection_through_Reaction Movies & Shows Reactions: https://www.youtube.com/@CtR-Movies-Shows Mental Health and Therapy Channel: https://www.youtube.com/@TherapyinACTionOfficial All clips used for fair use commentary, criticism, and educational purposes. See Hosseinzadeh v. Klein, 276 F.Supp.3d 34 (S.D.N.Y. 2017); Equals Three, LLC v. Jukin Media, Inc., 139 F. Supp. 3d 1094 (C.D. Cal. 2015). The information provided here by Stuart are only intended for informational and entertainment purposes and are not a substitute for advice, diagnosis, or treatment regarding mental health or other medical conditions. You should contact your GP or equivalent to obtain advice with respect to any health (physical or mental) issue you may be facing.

Comments

CalicoJill

I remember how off you thought the scene was when Maddie was first introduced, and I think it was meant to feel slightly off, now knowing what we know. She came on overly sweet and naïve. One hand outstretched to Vi, open, the other behind her back symbolizing her deception. This might be too sticky a subject to go into on a livestream so I understand if you don't want to get into it, so by all means ignore this if it's not something you feel comfortable talking about in a stream. But the whole thing with Maddie, I'm reminded of the scandal in the UK a while back, where undercover police officers infiltrated eco-activist groups, and had physical relations with their targets... The women who were targeted sued the police, as their consent was given under deception. Despite "just doing her job", I think it can be argued that Maddie's actions were a serious violation as I'm pretty sure Cait wouldn't have agreed to a physical relationship if she knew Maddie was an Ambessa plant... then she goes on to rub salt in the wound by telling Caitlyn "I did appreciate your warmth." before going to execute her... before that moment I actually felt sorry for her because with Vi back in the picture, she didn't have a chance... but after that... I'm glad her and her little chesire cat grin are dead.

Connection through Reaction

eleana UwU ⸱ 2h ago Maddie hate kinda annoys me a bit. In the show there are literally worse characters than her i will explain why. Maddie was just doing her job, she was a Noxian spy from the start loyal to Ambessa. Ambessa put her there, in Caitlyn’s bed to test Cait’s loyalty and obedience when Ambessa advised her “stop hooking up with business partners” and we all know Ambessa can’t stand disloyalty and disobedience.Under the instructions of Ambessa, Maddie is the one who put the pin on the bomb in the last episode preventing the explosion that was going to happen on Victor coming at the gates of Piltover. Actually her story: Her name is Maddie Nolen. She was born in Noxus, where she was taught the Noxian beliefs at a young age. At some point, she joined Ambessa’s forces, before being chosen to be a sleeper agent for her, and was sent off to Piltover as a plant 🌱 waiting to be activated should the Noxians need to seize control of the city. Once Maddie went in Piltover, she enlisted in the Piltover Police Department, eventually becoming an elite Enforcer. Waiting for Ambessa to come over and take more orders. She is a Noxian spy and sleep agent to reveal secrets to Ambessa, because Ambessa wants to have full control Fact from the lore now: Noxians are Vikings. They believe in the old norse gods, Odin, Thor, Loki, Freya etc their religion and belief: live your life as a warrior, sleep with and kill as many people as you can to please the gods, and die in the battlefield so you go to Valhalla. This is how they honour a Viking: only if he dies on the battlefield. In my point of view, even if they took Ambessa down she was still Victorious because she achieved the two things she wanted 1) make Mel a weapon (unleash her potential) so she will be ready to take Ambessa’s throne and deal with the Black Rose, thus Ambessa acknowledged Mel as “the wolf” 2) Ambessa’s goal as any Viking is to die as a warrior in the battlefield so she goes to Valhalla So did Maddie.. Maddie was actually the loyal one until she died (that’s a very honourable for a Viking, keeping an oath until death and die in the battlefield) - this is their religion and beliefs. From Maddie’s perspective, It was Caitlyn who betrayed Ambessa that’s why Maddie was there to be a sleep agent and spy and spotify a betrayal, follow orders and execute the one who betrayed (Caitlyn) And about the sleeping agent, Viking gods encourage it. Vikings are brutal man, (i love Vikings)🤣

eleana UwU ShadowWolf

I came here to post this🤣Baaah you caught me first😎😎😎👍🏻

Adrian

The Maddie hate was funny at first; but it got old so fucking fast. The root of it is the toxicity of the shipping community, because people were, unironically, yelling about how they wanted her to get killed off and how they hated her so much for the sin of *checks notes* being Caitlyn’s rebound several months after Cait and Vi broke up, *long* before her being a traitor was revealed. She is an interesting character who I wish we learned more of.

NP

Sorry if I am out of the loop, but what is the shipping community?

Adrian

It’s the subset of any fandom that is focused heavily on the (relation)ships of the fandom. Primarily romantic relationships. (It can be more toxic than a pool of radioactive waste because shipping communities have a very known history of crossing the line into sending fans and creators death threats, doxing, and other such bullying, because they felt their favorite ship was threatened) Ergo, for Arcane, a lot of the initial hatred Maddie received was from the toxic (and more vocal) side of the fandom who despised her for getting in the way of the CaitVi ship.

Hleler

I think the majority of it is just: We see and hear so much from other characters, the entire show is filled with morally grey characters who do terrible things for mostly understandable reasons. Singed might be responsible for the most misery in the show but it's all to save his daughter. Ambessa will destroy anyone in her path but ultimately it's to protect her family and the family name, and she deems Hextech/Warwick/Viktor the only possible way to fight back against the Black Rose who won't stop until they take Mel. With all the backstory, reasoning, and motivations we get for all the characters, Maddie being "a soldier just following orders" just doesn't garner all that much sympathy. And at first the story also makes it seem like she's a spurned ex turned backstabber, which for most people is a lot more relatable than ruthless warlord or mad genius chemist. It's a little like Umbridge in Harry Potter being a power abusing teacher getting more hate than the actual wizard Hitler in the series. We don't get any backstory or redeeming qualities, and people tend to feel more strongly about things they can relate to

Mog vGB

I was actually relived when she turned out to be safely hateable, as I was feeling very bad for how one sided her relationship with Caitlyn was - I wasn't looking forward to the sweet little Scottish babe being unceremoniously chucked aside.

Desint

OK. When Maddie was a Noxian sleeper, than her behaviour really makes sense. But is there any reliable evidence, that she actually was a spy from the beginning? I know her backstory but can't find any sources other than fandom and fantheories. I ask myself if there was any foreshadowing in the series. So far can't find any. One theory says she was a Noxian spy from the first moment, another means she was corrupted by Ambessa and I heard a 3rd one, according to which her betrayal could have been a spontaneous (mayby opportunistic) reaction to Caitlyn's defeat in s2e9. No idea how to figure out the right one right now. Did I miss something?

CalicoJill

Amanda (or maybe it was her voice actor. Now i can't recall) confirmed on twitter a bit after season 2 ended that she was Noxian the whole time. But until that point it was really just fan theories and picking apart ambiguous scenes.

CalicoJill

I actually had a whole journey of feelings about this topic. At first I just felt bad for Maddie because I felt it was pretty obvious that Cait and Vi would be endgame and I too would jump to be Caitlyn's rebound so i get it. So I assumed she would either get hurt, or they would kill her off to make it "clean" for the narritive. I was hoping it would be the first since Arcane doesnt really shy away from messy feelings/relationships, and narratively it felt cheap to kill off a character just to "get her out of the way" so to speak. So when they revealed her betraying Cait I just thought "ah so they're going to make her 'evil' so fans can be HAPPY she died and it 'gets her out of the picture'." and that still felt really cheap and unsatisfying, but it also wasnt confirmed yet that she was a Noxian plant the whole time. Then later Amanda confirmed on twitter that she was Noxian the whole time and it felt a LITTLE less cheap but made me feel gross in terms of deception and consent... so in the end I'm happy she died... but not for the reason I think most shippers are glad she died.

Connection through Reaction

I guess it depend where the information from places like the Wiki come from. Is that accepted as accurate? If not then how do you know what is accurate and not. If Maddie doesn’t appear in any other lore story then you’ve got to decide whether to take the information on wiki in its entirety and use it or whether to say you are just going to take whatever has been shown in the animated series. That leads to two different perspectives most likely. If you take the wiki as given then it seems more likely on the balance of probabilities that her allegiance was always going to be Noxian. Then the question is when did she leave there (and why) to come to piltover. Was she in Noxus long enough to have their belief system ingrained in her or is there some version of events where she didn’t like that belief system and escaped (seems unlikely). Then I guess the question is was this part of a larger plan all along and was it specific at the time. Was she embedded early on as a sleep agent to be awoken when the time was right. Did she only go over to piltover and become an enforcer shortly before ambessas arrival with the sole focus of looking for hex or for disruption. I do feel this part of a narrative was rushed. Even a 30 second sped up Timelapse of her background would have been really helpful. A lot of people don’t even seem to realise that she is even Noxian which seems a big oversight, unless it’s done intentionally but that doesn’t seem likely.

Nathaniell717

One thing is the senseless hatred that episode four kicked off. This type of toxicity is one of the reasons I don't want to be a part of any pop culture fandom. Sure, the creators fueled the passionate reactions by the way they did the "bed" scene - it's a jump scare, they introduced a whole time skip over it - and they gave us a "homewrecker" on top of all the other (much bigger) problems. But attacking Maddie's voice actress, or things like that, is way over the line. If only because Caitlyn herself has made sure there's no home for Maddie to wreck. The other thing is, does episode nine give people a reason to hate Maddie? Because I'm pretty sure of my own position here. I've endured nine episodes of not feeling anything really bad towards Maddie - yes, there was always more than one reason to be a little suspicious of Maddie (two for me - her opening scene with Vi, which is an unreliable narration for no apparent reason, and the conversation between Ambessa and Vi, where Ambessa very clearly makes the connection between the void she filled and Caitlyn's heart), but nothing that lifted me out of my chair. But the execution scene? That's the first scene where Maddie is effectively herself - if she's always been a Noxian agent, none of her previous interactions can be seen as honest or in any way determinative of her character. And this is where I personally take my right to despise Maddie. Because it's one thing to be loyal to Ambessa, to a task, to your country, or something like that, I can understand and actually admire that. It's one thing to construct the whole execution as a statement - Caitlyn betrayed Ambessa and is now on her knees in front of literally the entire Piltover and her unit. Again, how coldly Maddie pulls the trigger is completely understandable for me. But the fact that she chooses that remark about warmth as her only sentence - that was uncalled for and cruel. And what exactly does Maddie mean by that? To reduce Caitlyn to a piece of warm meat? Or to note that the sex - and thus her job - wasn't actually entirely unsatisfying? Sorry, but I have no sympathy for Maddie at this point. And I'm not even trying to speculate that Maddie isn't aiming for Caitlyn's head, but for her spine - because I can't even clarify to myself whether that was meant to tell us something (because there would probably be reasons to do it that way), or whether they chose it just for the way it looks in the end (no ponytail standing in the way, it's a bullet against the skin in a scene that's very quick...). I can't say I really hate Maddie - that's too strong an emotion to waste on a character I didn't care about most of the time, but I certainly don't feel bad for not feeling sorry for her. In fact, I hated Caitlyn a lot more across season two because she's my favorite character and that gives her the means to disappoint me in a real way. But if I had to comment on where I myself see a problem with how they handled the whole storyline with Maddie - she's ultimately just a victim of how extremely they pushed Caitlyn into being a generator of tension and shocking moments this season.

Nathaniell717

I totally agree with you on the consent thing. And that alone is enough for me to maybe understand Maddie's reasons (and be perfectly ok with them) - while at the same time completely despising the way her work as an agent was done.

CalicoJill

You summed up my feelings better than I could have lol. Hate is such a strong word for a character I wasn't particularly invested in. But you touched on something that is so obvious and yet wasn't something I ever really thought about - The unreliable narrator aspect. The fact that Maddie's whole job is to lie and infiltrate means you really can't take anything she says/does at face value until that mask off moment at the end... which makes my skin crawl even more than it did before... so thanks for that. And now that I'm thinking about it, I remember when episode 4 came out and people were so desperate to think that Maddie was looking pensive/sad in the scene where Cait is honoring her mother's statue, because they were telling themselves that Cait had just dumped her. At the time I just thought she looked sad because Caitlyn was sad and she was being empathetic. Then when episode 9 happened and we have the knowledge we do now, I thought perhaps it was a look of disappointment that Cait was starting to grieve and mourn in a healthy way, thus making her less zealous in her anger and less pliable for Ambessa... And NOW I'm like... it doesn't freaking matter what the expression was because her whole freaking job was to lie so it's impossible to know!

Nathaniell717

I'm admittedly tired of the nonsensical way people act about Maddie (just as I'm tired of some of the types of hatred towards Caitlyn or the intense Vi blaming that a certain segment of fans engage in), but that doesn't change the fact that I'm not willing to change my opinion of her. That last sentence actually made me feel sick for a moment - and Maddie just doesn't have anything else I need to be puzzling over. I never focused on Maddie in that scene at Cassandra's statue until others started talking about it. For my part, Caitlyn has always been a loner who has a hard time relating to others on a personal level in any way. We've seen her do that with two people - Jayce and Vi. And it clearly wasn't easy for her with Vi either - the way she has enough confidence and willingness to reach out to Vi to effectively immediately run away from the interaction and get back to what she does best - talking about business, I think speaks volumes. But I understand that jumping around the neck of the first girl she fell for, just because she obviously really wants to, probably wasn't in the proper lady manuals she was raised by at home. And I feel the same way here. Cait is clearly suffering - and turning to the person who shares that moment with her. But that's it. There's still that empty space between her and Maddie, a distance she's either unwilling or unable to bridge. And for the role Maddie played here? The first time I saw it, Maddie here acts like someone who is probably in love and understands that the other person is suffering. I can't find any factual evidence for anything else without going into pure speculation. Whenever I've watched it again - I always pause at how often they show us Caitlyn with someone else behind her back in the second act. This is the girl who put together the entire first season plot all by herself - and now she always has a shadow behind her (and in that one moment when no one is watching her she immediately jumps on Vi - maybe they should have made the leash even shorter).