Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Videos

  • 444044050.mp4

Downloads

Content

Wow.

Files

Comments

Blake Niethe

Loved this episode, emotional masterpiece.

Dibson

The writers did a great job with episode 3, as far as I know, none of this was part of the Game.

donglordthe3rd

this episode was amazing. these were only implied in the game and they really fleshed out their story here in the series.

Kae Devine

I've loved Murray Barlett (Frank) in anything I've seen him in but I sometimes wonder if he will ever get tired of playing the suffering gay man, haha. He has such a range, though, he portrayed Frank's optimism, anger, sarcasm, joy, and yes his suffering at the end absolutely perfectly. I play/watch for the story of Ellie and Joel but this episode is still my favourite just because of the great performances by Barlett and Offerman, and the complicated themes. Everyone is gobsmacked after the first viewing as it's one of those self-contained stories that sit with you for a while after and bring different thoughts up for days and weeks afterwards when you examine how it made you feel. I imagine you'll be turning it over in your mind for a while after this!

Connection through Reaction

Yeah. I want my wife to watch it, but I have to persuade her to, but give her enough information to make her interested but not so much it’s a bit spoilery. Certainly still thinking about it today.

Kae Devine

I think anyone with a long term partner feels it really deeply yeah, regardless of gender. Many of us imagine being in Frank's shoes and asking our loved one to do this, or imagine being in Bill's shoes and being asked to do this, and we sit thinking about whether or not we would be capable. I definitely can't imagine doing what Bill did and I can't even fathom where you would get that thing from inside you that makes you able to do it, if it's love, if it's strength or what. It's an incredible piece of storytelling.

eleana UwU ShadowWolf

I started crying from the moment Bill was playing the piano singing that song until the end… i cry every time i watch it. It is my second favourite episode of the series❤️‍🩹🥹

eleana UwU ShadowWolf

I’m not romantic. I hate romance. Seriously if ever date someone who’s romantic and shows up with candles and flowers i will run This was however beautifully romantic!! It was beautiful for me because it had the fatality in it.. that is the kind of romance i like (watching) From all the series and movies I’ve watched, this the only episode that made me feel the romance and jeeezz i always cry whenever i see the episode. From the moment Bill sings until their death. So bittersweet. By far one of my favourite episodes ❤️❤️‍🩹

CalicoJill

This episode gets me every time. The way this show touches things with so much subtlety and care, makes it feel that much more impactful. Speaking of Maslow's Hierarchy of Needs, I feel like this episode really encapsulates it. We see Bill who managed to fulfill those base requirements but it's Frank who comes in and starts to fulfill the top of the triangle. They're two very opposite people, but together they met each other's needs and really made a beautiful life together... a rare privilege given the world they were living in. They changed Bill and Frank's story from the game, and I'm so glad they did... They turned it into something far more beautiful in the show. In the game (and someone correct me if I'm off here, it's been a minute) Bill doesn't really progress past just survival, and Frank leaves and hangs himself. Their story is also told a little more through context clues and subtext while here we got to see their story first hand. You talked about assisted suicide and thoughts on that, and yeah, I get why it's a controversial subject. Even to myself, I can't quite square how I feel about it. On one hand, I believe it's a mercy. I couldn't imagine the pain it would take to even come to the point of considering it. But, I also know people are flawed, and our systems are flawed. Women in Canada are more likely to receive MAiD, and that doesn't surprise me when women (especially older women) derive a lot of their worth and esteem through giving, being caretakers, providing for others... when your health starts to fail and you feel you've become a burden, it can be quite easy to be sort of suggest sold the idea of MAiD. I believe there was also a Veteran here who had been injured in the line of duty, who was fighting for a wheelchair ramp for her home for years, and Veteran Affairs, instead of helping her meet her needs, offered her MAiD instead... I think the idea of it feels very compassionate, but I just don't know if we as a society are able to really safeguard something that, when done carelessly, there is no coming back from. I also wonder about those who provide the service and how they navigate feelings around it. I think even in some firing squads, some of the rifles are loaded with blanks to help alleviate feelings of guilt as no one knows for sure who's pull of the trigger is ultimately responsible.

TaroGhostie

I think giving people autonomy in choosing to die is very important and an incredibly good thing, it would stop these people from having to consider options such as suicide and give them a guilt free way to die by their own choice, we deserve full autonomy with our bodies, it makes it guilt free gives people time to get their affairs in order and means they have the time to really make sure it's the right decision, I think it's ma beautiful bill and if someone doesn't agree with it, then they don't have to use the resource, it's just nice that it's there

donglordthe3rd

the bill you guys have over there seems to be a good one (to me, but idk if there are some things in there that are not like good medical-wise or something because i wouldn't clock those). it sounds like there's a lot of stuff in place so that it's not abused, like there has to be two doctors to sign off on it and then it's very specific to who can avail it.

TaroGhostie

this story is probably the one thats the most different from the game and I highly recommend experiencing both

maris

I saw this was almost two hours and was very excited! Can’t wait for more. I joined your Patreon because of arcane, but you’ve been watching so many amazing shows, there’s no way I could stop lol

James Anderson

"How can we consider ourselves authors of our own stories if not allowed to determine when and how they end?"

Carol Grein Ericson

This episode is my favourite in the season ! So much to deep dive in humanity!

Carol Grein Ericson

About assisting end of life. You choosing when to go and how and going in peace knowing that it don’t caused more pain and heavy load on the people you loved and also without suffering. It’s all about it Dignity !

Saj

I think that one of the most powerful things that art can do is to development empathy in people: to give someone a window into a new umwelt that allows them to identify with it and extend their compassion. You asked earlier what we loved about this story (game and show) and at the time I said I couldn’t tell you without spoiling things. That’s largely still true but episode 3 encapsulates the previous for me and is endemic for the narrative as a whole. As a queer person, I grew up with mainstream media that either did not include me or included me as either a punchline or cautionary tale. Including queer protagonists and queer narratives that just *were* was really powerful for me, but more importantly it gave so many folks a window into queer experience in a way that was accessible to them. I can’t tell you the number of people that I’ve encountered (digitally or in person) that said some version of “I’ve never connected with a gay love story until I saw this, and it moved me deeply.” Statistically, the most impactful way to change hearts and minds is for someone to simply know or be connected to a person of a minority group. When you are able to apply personhood and empathy to a human you’ve been taught to fear, suddenly it’s really hard to hate them and by extension commit violence against them.

Rocky Flocky

So well said, this is why broad-based representation is so important. As a queer woman, I found it so hard to embrace my authentic self because all media I grew up with had always represented people like me as "other", regardless of whether that was the intent (even positive representations always made a big deal out of it and had to make it a leading characteristic). That's part of why I am so drawn to this show as well as Arcane, as they are some of the first instances of queer storylines represented with so much care and honesty and respect for real people without being specifically about "being queer". I think the fact that stories like this exist in genres such as sci-fi and fantasy makes them so much more accessible to the layman, as they allow us that real human connection (as Stu talked about) through things we are passionate about which may not have anything to do with subjects like sexuality (which is not an easy topic of discussion for many). This episode is, in my opinion, one of the most beautiful episodes of TV ever made and will never fail to move me in the most profound ways.

Rocky Flocky

Although for context, Frank does kill himself in the game but only because he left Bill but got infected and didn't want to turn. I much prefer this version though!

Marcos

hey there, nice video as always! I forgot how i thought how cute they were as a couple when i first saw it. The end was one of the changes the original game author wanted to put in the show and i believe it was a good choice he made. regarding infected animals. Initially the team thought about infected dogs and stuff during the development of the game but they gave a step back and decided to not ad them, so they could give the artistic idea of "nature fighting back humanity" Unrelated to this video by the way, do you know a anime called re:zero? i like this show a lot and the way the characters are written and how they deal with fear and trauma and how they develop as the show continues is pretty good, if you didn't watch it yet, i pretty much recomend

Martin Waits

Easily one of the best single episodes of any tv show ever.

Drabolik Lz

I played The Last of Us Part I since it first came out on PS3, and then again on PS4, PS5, and even on PC. It’s definitely one of my favorite games. I remember the story of Bill and Frank in the game was pretty different — it’s basically told through a couple of notes that you can totally miss if you don’t read them. And the ending is a bit different too. They did keep Bill’s personality in the show, but I really wanted to see his interactions with Ellie. In the game, those moments are the best — super sarcastic, funny… and Joel always playing the peacemaker between them 😂

Bug

agreed!

anadoob

Bill's poor tactical decision of firing from the middle of the street instead of a previously identified high spot is the most unrealistic scene in the show. :D He would never.

MJ Eid

unfortunately that version is very shallow and comical. And that is not the tone of the show. So i get why they changed it. It doesnt tell the stroy of "the last of us" this episode does.

Sarockinon

I had to watch this one over two sessions. On Sunday I naively thought “yay, the Bill and Frank episode, can’t wait to rewatch it with CtR!” I still tear up whenever you mention love and pain being two sides of the same coin. The penultimate timeline jump of this episode instantly transported me to the recent months’ spent caring for our cat’s accelerating illnesses. We discovered a mass in her chest shortly after Christmas and had two weeks where she took four med doses a day to get her healthy enough for a biopsy. So much stress waiting for those lab results only for the kidney disease to sprint almost directly from stage 2 to stage 4. We managed a couple of extra months together with daily administration of subcu fluids before she reached the point Frank did here in this episode. I was already losing it during these scenes and then there was the shot on the way to the boutique, with Frank taking in the sun and wind on his face. It hit way too close to home; spring had just arrived for Eevee’s last day and we spent part of the morning outside so that she could soak it in. I turned off the app for the rest of the day and am surprised I managed to come back to finish the video. Although it’s difficult at present, I am grateful to the Naughty Dog team for creating this thought provoking work of art.

Michael M

I think when you were talking about the fear of outsiders - it was the theory that areas with high human parasite loads (so viral, bacterial, fungal etc), typically in warmer areas - trust is low, vs areas like Scandinavia with much colder temps that don't support as many ways for humans to be infected, trust in "others" tends to be higher. It's an interesting theoretical explanation for (some) cultural differences. It would make sense, if every person approaching your town or village has a high possibility of carrying an infection that could infect you & your family, you may naturally be less open to strangers.

Jim Golino

In case you didn't have a chance to look it up, or weren't sure what you were looking at, Annie Wershing voiced Tess in the videogame. Sadly she passed a while back from cancer. #fuckcancer

Nicole T

I like Ellie’s subtle defiance when Joel tells her to repeat him. “What you say goes” may mean the same thing, but it’s not “I do what you say, when you say it.”

Enterprise24

Regarding the timeline, Joel's radio starting playing '80s music the night they left the Boston QZ, which was 1 or 2 days before this episode. Joel said that Bill's radio had an automated countdown that would auto-play '80s music if it wasn't reset every few weeks. So we can surmise that Bill and Frank died at least 2 or 3 weeks before before Joel and Ellie arrived at their home.

Thomas Cheetham

The green jacket gave me Joel vibes 😅

Kiera

It's not shallow if you read the notes and pay attention to how Bill talks about Frank. It was essentially the scene where Frank wants to make things look nice, but Bill doesn't understand it/want to - they just didn't get past that in the game, whereas in the show they had him get past that.

Validi Neon Draco

What came to me about Ellie not telling Joel about the kill in the basement, was that, teenagers do leave many things to themselves, if possible. Atleast I did. I kept secrets about both insignificant and important stuff. And sometimes I got in trouble for it. Maybe the thrill of the secret is more rewarding than telling anyone.

HerShadow

I like your thought's over how did they decide who gets in the QZ and who doesn't... ever seen the tv show Wayward Pines? It does deal with this dilemma... (that show would actually be a nice one for reactions from your perspective but it's not as known as this or GoT, wich is a shame 'cause the story is good)

HerShadow

Love this ❤ I'm from Switzerland, a country where suicide is illegal but by professionals assisted-suicide is legal for exactly the reasons you talked about here. It's criticized a lot worldwide but most swiss people are proud to have this by law, even if most do not consider it an option for themself, it's about respecting it to be an option for whoever needs it to be one, whatever their reason. It's about dignity and self-determination.

Chris Shepard

I think when Joel is stacking the rocks, it represents everyone really important to him that he has lost.

Maven Hershfield

I know I'm so late to this haha but the date came so quickly to him because it was his birthday... so the whole world ended and Sarah (his daughter) died on his birthday which is horrid

Maven Hershfield

ok well... I should have just kept watching before commenting lmao cus you got it like a minute later