Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Videos

  • 451525782.mp4

Downloads

Content

What in all things non consensual healthcare is going on here...

Files

Comments

Saj

A really lovely intertextual thing about the start of this episode is that Ashley Johnson is Ellie’s voice actress, literally the person that birthed the character. She kills it too.

Sandis Ābele

By the way, not watched all of it yet, but wanted to mention that - The woman at the very start (the pregnant one) is Ashley Johnson - she is the original Ellie, voiced and mocapped her in the game :D And Troy Baker (who played James last ep, stabbed with dagger) was the original Joel! I loved both of their performances in the games.

sarah pickles

so cool that you did it and got it all done reedy for season two and let not completely forget the last episode i mean jole finely called ellie babby girl at the end.and how cool is the face that the last epeasode opens with ellies mom palyed by the voice acter of the game ellie called Ashley Suzanne Johnson shuch a nice call out for the game fans

TaroGhostie

"i was the guy who shot and missed" really parallels the story of sam and his brother, when sam died and his brother shot himself in the head, is almost the same scenario as when sarah died and joel shot himself in the head, but he missed, imagine him having to experience the same scenario again but from the outside, even more explanation as to how he reacted in that moment

Rocky Flocky

its crazy how alike they look as well, Bella Ramsay could easily be Ashley Johnson's kid

Carol Grein Ericson

Wow !!! 11 mi inn and my head exploded!!! This explains a lot !!! Love it !!!

Saj

There are a number of things that I really appreciate about this episode, and the story as a whole: A) seeing Ellie’s birth and Marlene’s connection to her fleshes Marlene out in ways that are implied but we don’t have the same empathetic in for in the game. It makes her harder to hate. B) related, it’s unusual in media for men to be shown making deep emotional connections and it’s also rare for women to be depicted as putting emotional connection aside “for the greater good.” I think in life, either gender can take each role, so it feels more authentic to me and heighten’s the moral ambiguity of the situation. C) I love that Joel’s rampage is coded as tragic, not triumphant. The music is somber, his actions are brutal. The creators very much don’t want to make it emotionally easy for folks to completely side with Joel here. Yes his reaction is completely understandable, but that doesn’t make it “right.” Specifically for the consent politics you mention of not the trolly problem of it all. Those consent politics will very much feature going forward, they aren’t left, they’re leaned into in part 2.

LegionaresCZ

Is it wrong the fireflies didn't ask for Ellie's choice? It's easy for us to say because we've seen Ellie's determination, but they don't know her. If she says yes, great, if she says no, they're faced with the same trolley problem - does the one who's death can save what's left of the world have any actual right to refuse? It gets a little game theorist, but essentially they are just preventing one "loop" of the trolley problem, there is effectively no scenario where Ellie walks out of there, asking her can either lead to the same positive outcome, or it can lead to a negative outcome if she tries something reckless - it introduces no benefit.

Rocky Flocky

I always took Ellie's "Okay" at the end not as an "okay I'm accepting what you are saying as true" but as "okay, this is what you are choosing to tell me and this will form our relationship going forward". This scene plays out almost exactly the same in the game, and I just remember the music swelling before the scene abruptly cuts to black, leaving me to stare dumbstruck at my own reflection while the credits played out. I highly recommend you go back and watch that last exchange and credits without stopping it or talking, because the music and the lack of dialogue strikes such a note to end on that really makes you reflect on what the crux of this story is.

eleana UwU ShadowWolf

They made 2 changes in the episode 1) (this is the only change that i was pissed off about). in the show Ellie said to Joel, “I will follow you anywhere you go” but in the game, it was Joel who said to Ellie “I will follow you anywhere you go” 2) the scene in the hospital when Joel is taking out everyone, in the game, he’s actually taking out everyone while listening to Marlene’s recording device and all of her recordings were for Anna, Ellie’s dead mother, and in one of the recordings Marlene said “I am running out of options working with the doctor, I don’t have another choice. Your daughter will be with you soon.” And about the doctor that Joel killed and the question you asked about that doctor, we can’t answer because it would be a huge spoiler because the story of what will happen next, it will be the whole series story.. (one of them considers the doctor) And Ellie’s surgery wasn’t just a risk, it was 100% that she was going to die so the cure would work

Kayla🫶

this is exactly what it is imo! ellie never really believed joel, she desperately wanted too😭

eleana UwU ShadowWolf

Fun fact ashley johnson is the actress who Played Ellie in the game and Ellie’s mom (Ana) in the series Last episode (8) we saw the original Joel from the game and in episode 9 the real Ellie from the game 🙈😊

SirPanacheXVIII

I loved your reactions of the entire season. I can't wait to see season 2 and also your reactions on it. I'm sure I'm not the only one, but I would find it so interesting if you happen to react also on the game and see how it compares. There's some good montage of it on Youtube that takes around 3-4 hours long. The acting and motion capture are so well done, it's like watching an anime. I'm sure you would find some things interesting to analysis and it also can be done in livestreams. It's just a suggestion, I don't know if it something you are interested in, but if not see you for season 2 anyway.

Versek

Wild hearing someone recognize Ashley Johnson from Blindspot when that show to me has always been "the show Ashely is doing which is why she cant be on Critical Role".

gzilla97

Agreed, and it almost seems like she chooses right then and there that she will accept his answer regardless of any doubts she may have. It’s like she intentionally sets aside any of her opinions on the matter (kind of like making a sacrifice) and somehow closes the door on the cure/hospital and follows Joel. I don’t know if that’s a correct assessment…but, anyway, that last scene is just magical. Props to Neil Druckmann.

Brandon Van Dzura

One minor detail I love about this episode is when he enters the pediatric surgery wing and walks past the children's mural. The first thing that comes into view is a white elephant, a symbol for "a possession that its owner cannot dispose of without extreme difficulty, and whose cost, particularly that of maintenance, is out of proportion to its usefulness." It maps pretty well onto the way that Joel values the life of Ellie, over the life of humanity, essentially. Ellie is his white elephant.

JoJo

Ayy another CR fan! I thought the same 🤭

Silvanorix

I will politely point out this series was tainted by the cultural war, the choice in the original story was more easy, it is clearly stated that the operation is an uncertain gambit, because they have tried before and always failed (she is not unique in that sense), so there are no innocents in that hospital, they have sacrificed many people already; also they are not trying to save the patient, it is stated the operation is basically a vivisection "to understand", there is no clear cure in sight. Now about Joel, this TV version it is not him, they made him ugly in the ways that matter, his soul his character, in the original story he is a bona fide hero! this TV project was a way to retcon the horrendous sequel. All that I have said can be easily verified by watching the original story as a movie (there are let's play videos available in youtube of it including the hospital bit, and the aftermath/epilogue). Thank you for your awesome work, and good luck with your PhD! <3

Nathaniell717

Just off the top of my head, I know of one other place where they made a change that I feel like I should think about - the very last conversation between Joel and Ellie is practically a copy/paste from the game except for one sentence where Ellie, after admitting the truth about Riley, says "And I'm still waiting for my turn". I've always taken this as the only place in the entire game where she clearly vocalizes her survivor's guilt, but why they skipped that one sentence here is hard to say. And in the end it's an adaptation, things can't really be exactly the same. Because if they could be, my most important question would be - where's my "Joel looking for a pallet to get Ellie across some water" scene? Really? The most iconic element of the entire TLOU gameplay and they managed not to use it once? I'm incredibly disappointed, 0 out of 10, absolutely inaccurate adaptation :D

eleana UwU ShadowWolf

I know. At least the changes are from the same creator, so they are not major changes. Just tiny ones. But enough to piss you off.. i wanted Joel to say “i will follow you anywhere you go” instead of Ellie (in the show) just like they did with the game

Nathaniell717

I have to disagree with you. I understand what you mean about the culture war, Joel and the sequel - and how they may be related. I'm not going to elaborate because even if I did without factual spoilers, I'm setting up some way of thinking about things here and that's not fair to Stu or anyone else who hasn't played the second game. So I'm going to ignore this completely. But as far as factual information that comes up in the game about immunity, surgery, and what the Fireflies were doing about the vaccine before this point - none of that is as simple as you make it out to be. Yes, unlike the show, in the game we can find recordings of the surgeon (and Marlene) talking about it. But nowhere in them is there a single piece of factual information that confirms that there is anyone else who is immune. The surgeon talks about doing tests on infected subjects, which may indicate immune individuals, but in no way does this confirm their existence. On the contrary, he states quite clearly that "Ellie's infection is like nothing else he has seen before". She is definitely special. And don't get me wrong, I'm not denying that it's possible to interpret the recording as confirming that some other immune people exist - but it's by no means clearly stated. Same as the Fireflies not trying to save the patients - from what I recall, Marlene's recording says that there's simply no way to save the host, and she has to deal with the fact that for her it's not a host, but a kid she knows and has an emotional attachment to. Not being able to save someone is not the same as not trying at all. And I could go on and on like this, because virtually all the information we get in this regard is very vague - and can be interpreted in more than one way. But what ultimately remains (except for our interpretations) is that we know that Marlene believes it could work (and so does the surgeon in the game). And that's pretty much all we get in this adaptation as well. And we can argue about what chance of success it would have, if the Fireflies are even capable of it, if they might even be equipped to do something like this... but it's not like we have so much information that we can go beyond mere speculation. As for how the absence of this changes our perception of this particular final decision - yes, I agree that it does. But is it really "game changing"? Because Joel's decision wasn't driven by logic, or information, even in the game - it was always emotional (he only finds that information after he makes the decision, and only if we waste time picking things around). That said, it can only really change how we ourselves perceive what's going on. And for me personally - I don't think anyone is trying to portray the Fireflies as some sort of paragons (Marlene is a bit more humanized in the game than in the show, in my opinion), just like I can't look at Joel as an "ugly" character from my perspective. The show puts much more emphasis on Joel in general and on his own moral dilemmas - and leaves us to question or judge them if that's what we want. Does this make him "ugly," or just... human in a world where our own moral rules are obviously not quite valid anymore. I probably love him more here than I do in the game - and even there I never saw him as some poster hero. I don't want to contradict your interpretation (no, I see it as valid in many places - though I see the same thing differently myself) - but it's an interpretation, not really any "hard" facts.

MJ Eid

Lol i cant believe you are subscribing to patreons to spread this crap.

MJ Eid

We need a Moderator for these two comments. Make sure you dont read em stew. VVVVV

Silvanorix

Thank you for your feedback, It was a super engrossing and interesting read. I appreciate your time explaining your ideas in such a clear and nuanced way. Have a lovely rest of the week ^__^ <3

onemile

I know that it's not meant to be viewed this way, but I've always had the opinion that an additional aspect that adds to the tragedy of the circumstances of Ellie's surgery is that if there were a doctor with more knowledge than the quack that is working for the Fireflies, the whole situation could have been avoided. Who would kill their only know subject on the whim that your hypothesis could work after running tests for less than a day? I know that there is more info about his research process in the game, but honestly that only highlights his incompetence and desperation. Seeing all the characters tormented by their choices, knowing that if they had more knowledge they wouldn't be in the current situation. (feel free to tell me that this take is bs, and I'm completely wrong about everything)

MJ Eid

There’s no proof he was a quack. All we know is what Marlene told Joel.

Silvanorix

@onemile I just love your take on the matter so much it made me laugh with glee ^__^, you are absolutely right! "quack" is an adequate description, I always thought it made more sense to further research and even wait if the immunity was hereditary. In retrospect I think they exaggerated them as cardboard villains so Joel could look more heroic, he needs to rescue the "damsel in distress from the evildoers" no much moral quandaries left after the fact XD ...thank you for sharing your opinion! it made my day *giggles*

donglordthe3rd

I'd like to point out one thing that I haven't seen mentioned yet. The approach of the Fireflies, where they're not letting Ellie know what was actually going to happen in some sort of "we know this is for the greater good", is a parallel to the episode where FEDRA told the infected child they'll get him sorted.

Connection through Reaction

Yeah. Strangely enough I have a memory of saying that somewhere either in a video or to someone else. I can’t remember where exactly lol.

Jim Golino

Joel was also a monster in his own right. I mean, he definitely killed innocent people etc. He was a hero in Ellies eyes sure, but the villian in many others. Much like Joel is a villian in someone specifics eyes in sequel. It's almost like it depends on perspective and that is the point. Not being able to empathize or see a story from a number of perspectives is more of a you problem, and not a creator problem

Michael M

A couple of thoughts: I believe the game's creator (and Executive Producer on show) has said that the assumption is the Dr could do what he said - although I don't see how that remotely would be possible - that Dr wasn't terribly old- he looked 40's to me, which means he was YOUNG when the world ended, like maybe a med student or a very young Dr - and I doubt he's gotten a lot more education post-apocalypse. And where are they going to produce a cure? Not like a thriving biochemical industry is up and running. It took a YEAR to develop the Covid-19 vaccine and that was for a coronavirus, something we are familiar with, and the entire world was pouring $ into development - not a novel treatment for a mutated fungal pandemic. Another thing is I don't trust Marlene - if they did develop a cure, I guarantee you fireflies would get it 1st, maybe then, after overthrowing FEDRA, the public, and would anyone in FEDRA survive let alone get the cure? Marlene is ruthless, she'd use a cure as a powerful tool in her revolution. Obviously not getting Ellie's concent is unethical- but also, who goes straight to killing Ellie immediately? A longer approach with tests along the way - could her blood serve? What about the fungus in her arm, why not start there? You don't kill the goose laying your golden (fungal) eggs as step 1! Oh, and it originally was the "Trolley Problem" not transplant - you can divert a trolley that is rolling to 5 people tied to the tracks or divert it to only kill 1 on another branched track - it's an illustration of Utilitarianism - doing actions that are for the greatest good, by causing the least suffering - but alter it to "you can keep the trolley from killing 5 by diverting it to kill one of your friends or a family member & it shows Joel's dilemma is more akin to that version- a limit to Utilitarianism as a philosophy as the "right" ethical decision disappears.

Jim Golino

Just saying your question about the doctor cant be answered bc it would be a spoiler is a spoiler lol. Just saying lol, now he is going to be cued in to focus on that as a plot point

eleana UwU ShadowWolf

This is not a spoiler because i haven’t said anything about the dr… ;)

Ericsson

Unpopular opinion: The whole discussion about no one asking Ellie is missing the point, it's a huge distraction from the central conflict. It doesn't matter that Ellie would've agreed, it doesn't matter that the fireflies are objectivly doing the wrong thing by not getting her consent (the show is establishing over and over how people in this post apocalyptic world will find ways and reasons to justify immoral decisions)... What matters is that Joel KNOWS Ellie would want to see this through, no matter what. "It can't be for nothing." But he's not willing to lose her, even if it means disrespecting her greatest wish and denying humanity a shot at a cure. The story isn't about ethics in the medical world, it's about Joel and Ellie and their love and trauma.

Kath

Maybe it’s because I watched episode eight right before this one, but I have the creeps. Two very different men who wanted to keep Ellie to themselves or she’ll die. David wanted a pet and Joel wants a daughter. Both put their own needs and wants ahead of hers. All the time they were hiking, Joel was comparing Sarah and Ellie.

HerShadow

does humanity deserve to survive if to do so they need to kill a child that didn't got the chance to make the choice for herself? My personal opinion is no, if that's the cost then mankind is beyond saving. Why? 'Cause for every single person saved it's fine if it's not their own child. It's the ultimate form of hypocrisy and the ereasing of compassion and empathy for good. What's the point of saving humanity if they stop being human?

Sam Bryce

i'm playing catchup with your reactions to this as i've only recently joined, and i'm SURE someone must have told you by now but want to point it out anyway because its great: The guy who played James in the previous ep (younger cult guy not the gross preacher), Troye Baker, and Ellie's mom in this ep (Ashley Johnson, you know her as Patterson in blind spot) were the original Mo-Cap and voice actors for Joel and Ellie in the games! The studio gave them both cameos in the show :D

Chris Shepard

It's bad enough that Marlene wasn't giving Ellie a choice, it's worse that Joel wouldn't give her a choice either. But probably worst of all is the fact that even if they had gone through with it there was absolutely no guarantee, no 100% certainty that it would work. Meaning Ellie could have died for nothing anyway. So I definitely think the overall message here is having the choice, the option and the consent.