Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Videos

  • 470462942.mp4

Downloads

Files

Comments

Desint

Damn! I will have to watch the whole season again because of this episode. Everything looks so different now.

MJ Eid

She saw real fire flies by the tree Stu

Mir

At 33:47 she saw fireflies!

Angel

Awe nooo, I knew this ep would get you 😭 ♥️ Now I gotta cry all over again with you.

MJ Eid

Ellie made the wrong decision to call out Joel in the moment for Gail’s sake. But I completely understand why she did it. Even if it was wrong. The anger just over took her. She’s also a kid.

MJ Eid

Side note this episode was perfect . In my sole opinion.

Emma

I don't think it's that easy to say that Ellie made the wrong decision in that moment. Sure it would have been horrible to hear that as Gail, but I would much rather know the truth in the moment than carry on hugging the man who just killed my husband. I think people give Joel too much grace to be honest. I always see people defending him and loving him no matter what (which I think is probably because it's Pedro Pascal) but Ellie is so in the right with her feelings towards him this season yet people keep coming at her for being angry.

MJ Eid

She completely ruined the grieving process for Gail. So yes it was wrong. Joel did the right thing in not taking Eugene back, and he gave Gail the peace of mind knowing that he was thinking of her in his final moments. Her knowing the truth probably eats at her even in the present. There is a reason being 100% honest doesn’t exist. She didn’t need to know any of that. So like I said even though what Ellie did is 100% understandable. It was the 100% wrong thing to do in that moment.

MJ Eid

She wasn’t hugging the man who killed her husband. The infected killed her husband. Joel ended his life in a fairly peaceful way. He gave him a beautiful view and a picture of his wife in his mind in his last moment. The only thing Joel did wrong was lie to Ellie. He couldn’t have brought him back. There’s so much that could go wrong. He could get bit Gail could, and you can’t set the precedent that everyone who gets bit can come back and say good by to their loved one. I’m not giving Joel grace. I’m using logical reasoning.

Emma

I don't think it was the right decision for Joel to kill him without seeing Gail. That's probably where our opinions differ. I guess we can just agree to disagree on this one. And if Joel was intending on killing him anyway he shouldn't have made that promise to Ellie - that's the main point of that storyline - the fact that Joel keeps making this empty promises which causes Ellie to drift away from him.

MJ Eid

I added more to my previous comment addressing that fact. In the end I’m not mad or angry at Ellie. She was reacting how I think anyone would react after being betrayed by the person closest to her. But as Joel was the leader on the patrol he should have just told her the truth. It’s just too dangerous to bring him back. For sooooooo many reasons.

Emma

Yeah you're right in that. I guess my issue and one of my big ones with the character of Joel is his lack of compassion in situations like this. I mean the man knows he has to die at least be kind. Even when he was telling him to try and see Gail as his last image, it just came off as insincere to me idk. But yeah I totally get your point.

MJ Eid

And don’t worry I’m right there with you. Joel handled the situation in the wrong way especially with Ellie.. It’s like Gail said. She understands it needed to be done. But it was how he did it. Gail didn’t get the entire description of her husbands death. I’m curious to know if she would be as angry if she heard where Joel took him and the words he said. But that’s in a what if universe.

Carol Grein Ericson

Flawless episode. They added so many layers to the characters, and the “I love you” moment—something I missed in the game—was finally brought to life. In the game, it was left between the lines, but here, he said it out loud, and it was absolutely beautiful.

Michael M

When Joel's father put his hand on teenage Joel's shoulder - you could see THE watch on his father's wrist. It was an amazing episode. It had so much storytelling packed into it. I liked that Joel & Ellie had at least a bit of understanding and truth in their last moments together.

Enterprise24

The book Gail was reading, Earth Abides, is one of my favorite novels. It was published in the '40s, and it's a story about a virual pandemic that kills most of humanity. It follows a university student as he grapples with the end of civilization, forming a new community, and trying to pass on the ways of the old world to the next generation. It's rather "on the nose" for this TV show.

Ericsson

Love this episode. Showing all the flashbacks (which in the game are spaced out (no pun intended)) in succession works really well for the show format. Also they replaced a flashback where Ellie does a solo trip to the abandoned hospital to find info about what really went down, and replaced it with the Eugene/Gail scene. Which I think is a rare improvement over the game. Doesn't make sense for Ellie to track to a different state on her own like she just quickly sneaks out the house at night, and having the Eugene scene as the kicker to make her certain he lied to her is really elegant writing. One thing I'm really surprised by and am curious to see how it affects the story overall is that the porch conversation originally isn't revealed until the VERY end of the game, but I'm sure they know what they're doing. Either way, that scene gets me every time 😭

Ericsson

I didn't get it either until I asked my friend later if I missed something lol

CalicoJill

I have to agree. I actually find lying to be extremely difficult. I lied about somethin when I was a teenager, it brought me a lot of shame and anxiety... I eventually had to come clean, and since that moment, I've found it incredibly hard to justify any large lie, no matter how painful. I think honesty is the right thing to do, even if it's painful. It reminds me of the game Life is Strange: Before the Storm. The last choice you make in the game is whether or not to tell another character important to you about what a piece of shit her father is. You can either lie and she gets to preserve the way she sees him but you betray her trust after she's asked you not to lie to her, or you lie to her and you keep her trust but her relationship with her father can never be the same again. I believe the results chosen by the players is an almost exact 50/50 split. It's honestly a really interesting topic.

CalicoJill

Something I don't think I've seen anyone mention is the transference of Joel's father onto Seth. Seth being a cop, and berating Ellie brought Joel back to how he would protect Tommy from their father. It's part of why he jumped to protect Ellie even though she didn't want it. I love what the show has done with the entire Gail/Eugene storyline. I don't know why but, Eugene telling Joel he needed Gail's last words for him, hit me really hard. I couldn't imagine being in his shoes... and then the way it all tied back to Joels lie about the fireflies was just so well done. I think this has got to be my favourite episode between both seasons.

Alli

The first thing I thought of when Joel was curious about the moths is how they’re instinctively attracted to light. I think it’s a call back to the fireflies slogan “When you’re lost in the darkness, look for the light”. I think they never really left the space in the back of her mind, so much that she draws about them, dreams about them, and her smile drops at the sight of real fireflies.

Alli

i remember seeing so many people torn up about joel dying thinking ellie hated him. It feels a little better knowing that he knew she wanted to work on their relationship 🥲

Emma

Ah interesting to hear about the Life is Strange choice. I've hear that game is really good. Yeah...I think that's so true about the lying. It would just eat away at Joel, not to mention the fact that he's made Ellie an 'accomplice' to the lie which means that if she hadn't told Gail the truth she would have to live with it eating away at her too. It's so complex though!

Caruki

in the podcast neil druckman said that they read a lot of post apocalypse stories and this was his favourite book and where they took a lot of inspiration from. the story about Ish (the guy who founded the underground shelter where they were with Henry and Sam) is actually directly inspired by it. that's why they took it as the book Gail is reading

Ghost Mom

Ellie's last comment. "I don't think I can forgive you for this, but I would like to try." We don't get to see if they exchange anymore words, this possibly could have been their final moment before she watched him get murdered. I think It's a great glimpse into why she wants revenge so badly. Joel and the fireflies robbed her of a choice. Ellie's face after Joel confesses he loves her, is one of deep conflict. She wants to be beyond pissed at him, but can't for the fact that, finding people who care about her that deeply is something she always wanted. Being an orphan, and likely with just that one friend, she didn't get much of that. She decides she wants to try and forgive him because it's kind of hard to say "I hate you for not letting me die." She decides she wants to work towards forgiving him, and we see it the next day where she is annoyed with jesse and says "Im gonna do my patrol with Joel." Joel gets murdered and once again Ellie is robbed of a choice. This man went through hell to protect her all these years and she watches him go out in this horrible way. It's tragic that she now sees her only way to make it up to joel is to avenge him.

Ghost Mom

I also love how Joel says "I'll pay the price." I'm sure in that moment he's assuming the price is that he loses Ellie for good, but then skip ahead to the next day when Abby is confronting him, I wonder if he's playing that conversation back in his head. Obviously he was worried about them hurting Dina, likely a big party of why he didn't try anything, but when Abby tells him why she is there, you can tell he is accepting it. He probably didn't expect to pay the price in such a violent way, but it's clear by the way that he reacts, that he know he deserves it, or at least understands and accepts why Abby is doing it. The really tragic part is he dies thinking Ellie is in danger.

JSON_BOURNE

"See you next year" when they wouldn't actually see each other again 😥😥