Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Videos

  • 475729281.mp4

Downloads

Files

Comments

Mir

It can definitely depend on the circumstances, but for me especially with youth i mostly end up on the deserves treatment side, also because I think everyone deserves a chance at rehabilitation and this could pretty huge step forward to that.

Alexander Ihle

As a fan of the games, I can't express enough how disappointing this season was; especially after the amazing adaptation of the first game in season one. Ellie was adapted terribly for the second season of this show. They hamfisted scenes from the game that are now incongruent with the show characters they've written. It saddens me to think that people who decide to play through the albeit imperfect, yet beautiful story of the second game will have a lesser experience. The writer seems to have perfectly understood Joel for Season 1 and his scenes in Season 2, but despite having the game writers to lean on, massively failed to understand Ellie's character, perspective, and relationships.

Saj

I think unless there’s a very good reason why treatment would be ineffective (e.g the youth or adult in question is a sociopath) everyone should have access to treatment. It’s not an excuse for causing harm, but most of the harm we cause is related to the harm we’ve accrued (emotional, physical, economic etc.). Everyone is the hero of their own story and usually has sympathetic reasons for what they’ve done. Most abusers are also victims. That’s the Last of Us’s whole deal, so it fits into the conversation really well. Given how polarizing our social politics have become, I think it’s a conversation very much worth having. Humans are pretty socially obsessed with punishment, because it (or the idea of it) makes us feel better, but it’s not actually a great way to change behavior. To nerd down hard for a minute, positive punishment (the addition of an aversive stimulus to stop a behavior) has to be applied in a very specific way in order to eliminate something, and we often don’t have the capacity to fulfill those criteria. It also usually has additional fallout, and can create its own problems. If punishment worked, no one who went to prison would ever offend again. Rehabilitation, education, and social/financial support is what actually reduces harm, not retributive justice. That doesn’t mean I want to let people off the hook for shitty behavior, but I’m pretty grounded in thinking that what I want is the behavior to stop more than I want to be able to feel good about someone suffering for the harm that they caused.

Mir

If you want to you should maybe do a Patreon poll to ask whether of not we’d like to watch you play the games or not, I know i’d watch it 🫡

Saj

Also, I’m still looking forward to you watching the “after Nora” scene from the game. They did a version of that here, but its tone and role in the story/character development are really different (which is kindof what I was worried about). I don’t want to come off as a game elitist. I love some of the changes they made in the show (e.g. I think the Owen/Mel scene hits harder, especially because you already know in the game that Mel is pregnant), but overall I think the show is a little weaker at telling the story they are trying to tell.

Saj

So say we all

Chris U

You are having an issue separating game Ellie from show Ellie. They have different experiences with different content that changed how she reacted and thought about things throughout the season. I can't really elaborate on the changes to characterization of Ellie without spoilers so I will use Joel as an example. Joel was different in season one from the first game, but it seems you didn't pick up on the subtleties and changes to his character between the game and the show. Joel in the show is older than Joel in the game which makes Pedro's choice to play him as broken instead of hardened make complete sense. There is a reason why in the flashback he couldn't even answer Ellies questions, while in the game he frustratedly explains his actions. In the game he doesn't really feel like what he did was wrong because of his actions but because of how Ellie felt about them. Show Joel believes his actions were wrong but saving Ellie was more important, thus why he can't even state what he did. These changes butterfly to effect many characters and along with other changes like Abby's group only hurting Joel instead of Tommy as well. There are a bunch of changes that lead to the characters being and acting different that are a result of the changes from a video game to a show.

Chris U

The reason why Ellie explodes at Jessie is that Jessie's love and friendship is always conditional on how it impacts the community. His romantic feelings, his sense of justice, his adherence to the rules, everything is conditional on the nebulous concept of community. Everything he does is for the ingroup and everyone calls him a saint because he only interacts with his ingroup. Ellie doesn't trust systems doesn't trust communities she applies her love and trust and sense of justice universally to those she thinks are worthy of it and it is unconditional. That is why she sees Jessie as a hypocrite and a false saint.

Chris U

I could be wrong but I think the boat she picked up on the island was not the boat she was originally in. It was the same type of boat, but not the same boat. Notice how it was intentionally beached above the ocean height so it wouldn't float away, not bobbing in the water being pushed into the island.

Carol Grein Ericson

I agree the game part when she comes Back foram Nora is heavy in the game….

Chris U

I don't know if you heard but when Mel and Owen are fighting about Abby they say she was behind enemy lines. This means something on the third day makes Owen and Mel at least think she is in Seraphite territory. Why do you think that Mel and Owen think that, and if she is why do you think that she would go there?

Carol Grein Ericson

I totally support treatment before judgement day: Prison is intended to serve as both punishment and an opportunity for correction. Even if someone is suffering from PTSD as a result of their own actions, that does not remove the need for accountability. The trauma they experience might be part of the consequence of their actions, and addressing it should be part of their rehabilitation, not a reason to avoid consequences altogether. 2* Someone suffering from PTSD, especially when connected to violent behavior, can still pose a risk to other inmates or staff. Protecting the mental health of the individual must be balanced with ensuring the safety of others around them. If threats or disciplinary measures are needed to maintain order, they might be justified depending on the context. 3* Crime is Complex, Each case must be examined individually. Some crimes stem from untreated mental illness, others from social pressure, trauma, or poor decision-making. PTSD may be a consequence of guilt or a deeper issue, but it doesn’t erase the original harm. Justice systems should evaluate psychological states carefully but must not lose sight of the damage caused, especially if the victim or society still suffers.

Ericsson

I like the adaption but it really doesn't hit the same a lot of the time. The scenes where Ellie tortures Nora and where she returns to the theatre bring me to tears every time in the game. The blend of rage, fear and disgust in her face while she loses a part of herself, and then the absolute state of shock and pain she returns in (she also had to go thru hell to even get to Nora) is beyond tragic. And it's also a great contrast to the composure, focus and resilience she usually exhibits in the game. And her and Dina's relationship was already strained at this point, so coming home in this state of distress leads to a really sweet moment of reconciliation. Non of this lands in the show since the events, performances and context have been altered to much. As a filmmaker myself it's really interesting to see how all these seemingly small changes compound and change the experience. I'm not saying game = perfect, show = bad btw. There's moment I actually prefer in the show or wish had been covered in the games, I just bring this up coz it's two of my favourite scenes and while they're technically the same on paper, practically they feel SO different.

Carol Grein Ericson

As a gamer, I really loved the adaptation. There are still a few decisions Neil made that I’m unsure about, but I trust him and Halley to deliver something great. Super excited for season three, Abby’s point of view is going to be really interesting!

Ericsson

"is that just to tell us there's an attack on the village?" Omg I think you're right. I kept wondering what the point of that scene was. How that scene didn't end on the cutting room floor is beyond me. Passive protagonist, saved by the bell, no new information for the audience and let's not even talk about how on earth she drifted all the way to the island without drowning or getting hypothermia 🤡 possibly the worst scene of the show

JoJo

On the treatment question - I think everyone should be offered treatment. I feel that people who hurt others are often hurt themselves, so we all deserve to have those people treated and less likely to seriously harm others again. At the risk of sounding like Jesse, I think it's the best thing for the whole community, not just the individuals themselves 🙂 I can see both arguments though, it's definitely a morally grey topic.

JoJo

And as for the episode, I'm wondering if Dina might save Ellie? She was in the Theatre as well, but we never saw her at the end. She would have heard the gunfire, may have seen the situation with Ellie, Tommy, and Jesse. Even wanting to protect the baby, I think she'd take the shot if she had it. Guess we have quite the wait before we find out 😅

Caruki

They explained in the podcast how they also wanted to have a scene like that in the game but couldn't fit it in. It's basically to drive home the point how Ellie is obsessed with her revenge goal that even a near death experience does not shake her. Stu even commented on it when she goes back to the boat. Everything tells Ellie to stop, the scene with Jesse about Tommie and then the capture and almost killing. Also it shows how the people she wanted to save (Scars and the boy before) do not discriminate between wolves or not wolves and how even the young boy is already so indoctrinated that he readily gives the sign to kill her.

Ericsson

All those points make sense and and see how it's thematically relevant, they wouldn't have written if it wasnt. But I still think it's very clunky, non of it is news to us and I think it's a weird choice to replace all those hectic events from game Ellie's day two and three (which communicate the same points) with this little last second detour

Michael M

I enjoyed the finale, although like many, I thought the short side-quest to Scar island was kinda weird and the scars "leave her" seems odd given they were about to disembowel Ellie - sliting her throat takes seconds. My understanding is that was an intended game scene that got cut - and for the show, I bet that little excursion will pay off next season. The sudden shift to Abby's perspective is what happens in the game as well (and REALLY angered many of the game's fans) - but taking the other side/person's perspective is a pretty large theme of The Last of Us - forcing you to walk many miles in someone else's Converses to get you to shift who you identify with is an interesting technique.

Ghost Mom

If you were to play the game and record it, I'm sure a lot of us would love it. You'd get the answers you want, and while I didn't dislike this season as much as a lot of people did, Last of Us 2 is an incredible game with a great story and you'd get the resolution a lot sooner, because we ar likely going to be waiting 2 years at least for only 7 more episodes, and it's still said it won't be concluding the ending of the second games story, which means 4-5 years for the conclusion or just playing the game.

Andreas

I love watching your reactions, but ever since episode 3 my OCD gets badly triggered by the slightly open drawer in the background. The bottom drawer in the middle. Please close it 🙏

Kiera

Put a post-it over it on your screen or something!

HerShadow

I think Dina shot Abby but I can't remember if she was actually close by

Gekas 01

Where is the ending? cant find it here or on yt. pls help :(