Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Comments

James

did you watch in dub or sub?

Karmacean

Hi Stu! May I ask which version you originally watched in? Despite previous claims, I would still like to watch whichever was original for you so there isn't any confusion with translation differences in your reaction.

Matthew Chaisson

Thank you so much for the extra editing work in releasing a dub version too. Best of both worlds imo, and I am glad to go on this journey again with you. I’ve watched Frieren sub and dub (by myself in sub and then again with my now wife), and it’s a truly special show that has a lot of substance.

Mythara

I really like this solution, Even if one version is much less popular than the other it just makes the reaction more accessible to people. If it doesn't cause too much more effort why not? Also iirc the poll did show that while a minority, not a small minority would prefer the DUB. Thank you for your effort!

Joe

I sincerely appreciate you making the extra effort to offer both versions. Not many reactors would go out of their way to accommodate their audience like this. Thank you and I hope you enjoy this beautiful journey.

Mother Lame

As a mom I really appreciate the dub option 🙏❤️

Dai-chan

Im sure youll see later too with this show is Himmel was so in love with her and she was so late to it. Im so glad youre watching it!

JayD

The reason I prefer watching the dubbed version is that I can pay more attention to the visual details, which I feel can sometimes be just as meaningful as the dialogue. I'm also really grateful that you put in the extra time and effort to edit and provide a dubbed version as well. I really appreciate it. Thank you!

Hammerdash

Hey Stu, perhaps you have a good reason for keeping them separate, but if you wanted to you could put multiple videos in a single post to keep the comment discussion for each episode in one place. This would work for sub/dub versions or for the Dark PIP reactions. Just wanted to mention it in case you weren't aware.

Without A Net

Thank you for the extra work. You mentioned about Himmel’s actions having repercussions. It flows out into the real world as well. In 2024, there was a man in taiwan who intervened in a train knife attack. When asked, he said “its what Himmel the Hero would have done”. https://www.straitstimes.com/asia/it-s-what-the-hero-himmel-would-ve-done-taiwanese-otaku-who-stopped-knife-attack-on-train-says-anime-inspires-him I fully believe that Heiter was up on that cliff for a similar reason as Fern. That in that moment Himmels impact helped to save both their lives through each other.

Captain Eaglefort

So I didn’t even know you did AoT in both, for some reason I thought you only did subbed so I skipped it. I’m glad you did it then, and I’m glad you’re doing it now.

L S

for the fact that this show is higher rated than aot, fmab, etc and i can't lie, i am still disappointed by this pilot even on rewatch and would confidently say its nowhere near on the level of these other anime and pilot episodes are very important... also personally i really am not connecting to this immortal elf grieving people, because she is genuinely ignorant. i find it hard if not impossible to believe that she would be unaware of peoples lifespans, especially not when they're her "friends"... and i do not mean this in an offensive way, frieren really seems unbelievably socially awkward an unaware for the fact that she is an elf? if you cared then how could you forget? or is she just missing the impression she has of people as opposed to the people themselves cause as she herself says, didnt know himmel well despite spending a decade with him...idk man pretty hard to feel bad for that. in the words of dumbledore: "Do not pity the dead, Harry. Pity the living. And above all, pity those who live without love." and as a german i can't decide if the names are genious or genuinely stupid: their names essentially describe the characters core trait in one word- for instance heiter means cheerful. Frieren means freeze- she is cold... so i guess i wasn't entirely wrong about my "analysis" and a cold character not being compelling for a lot of people will be a given.

Mother Lame

I mean think of your life in seconds, can you remeber every detail of every second of the last ten years? Im sure a day for frieren is comparable to a second for us or a minute. Shes not ignorant more so shes more like a child in her emotional development imo, and honestly i think shes pretty relatable to people who disassociate a lot in life. Im currently remembering a lot of my memories in different contexts and understanding more how i felt and whats was actually happening or important in that moment.

Mother Lame

But yes the first couple of episodes almost lost me on my first watch but it gets so epic and emotionally beautiful its a 'journey'

Saurelly

You gave the most valid puppy dog eyes at the turning point of episode one. Truly emoting how the first episode made me feel. Very “aaaaw” coded

Thelaretus

I literally just came to suggest you to watch Frieren, and I found this... Perfect timing; I hope you like it. I was confused as to why you're watching the dub, but I guess you're posting the dub for free, and the sub for supporters. Makes sense.

Nervous

it's definitely no vinland saga, that's for sure

Kayla🫶

the dubs not free, he’s just posting it for accessibility purposes, bc a lot of his supporters wanted dub but more wanted sub, so he’s doing both.

The_Speck

As with everyone else, I very much appreciate the sub/dub being options. I like to use these as side monitor content to listen to your opinions on things, and I don't want to have to be focused to read subtitles all the time.

IsaacDoesStuff

Her behaviour and attitude makes sense, but explaining it would be spoilers. And yes the names are very silly.

Yuvi

Frieren has an excellent dub just wanted to let you know.

Soul LionHeart

Thanks for this 🙏 I listened at work and loved every moment

Michael Lee

I love thr call back about why she learned a spell to make grapes sour. Such a subtle way of showing how she cares for others.

Megan

the first four episodes were all released at the same time, so that you'd watch them all one after the other. in that way, they're supposed to be like, one pilot movie i suppose.

Marta Kira Ayanami

I'll give ENG Frieren dub a second chance, though I doubt I'll like it more than JPN Frieren dub /shrugs XD well, I gave PL Frieren a chance, so why not give ENG Frieren one... XD , right? :DxDD though the 'magini' translation in Polish Frieren dub made me laugh, and prolly not in the intended way, 'czarodziejka / czarownica ' etc exists for a reason.. ok, sorry for incomprehensible offtopic. XD

Tomey

I'm not subbed currently and just came to see which new anime he started. I can watch the whole thing. Probably not meant to be able to see it though...

Connection through Reaction

I could do it that way if that is better for people. I tend to edit one, then upload it. Whilst it is uploading I edit the other version and whilst that is rendering I finalise the post of the initial one. It is just the habit I've got into, but I could render them both out and stick them in the same post if that is easier for people.

Connection through Reaction

I make the first 2 episodes of every show accessible to everyone so they can see if they like the style, the content etc to help decide if they wish to join the paid version of the community.

Hammerdash

Well I'd prefer it, but I have no idea whether enough other people care to make it worth changing your established process. Continuing in the current way is certainly fine if people are happy with it.

Carl D. Llama

I missed the voting but oh man I'm excited to watch you go through this experience 😁

Ghost Mom

I am unable to watch subs due to poor eyesight. Not to say that I 'can't' read it but it requires a considerable more effort and focus, so I unfortunately don't get to enjoy when react channels do anime because it's always the subs. (which I dont really understand. I remember when dubs were super bad back in the 90's and 00's but they aren't really like that anymore.) regardless, I appreciate the extra effort you are making to put this together because I wouldn't be able to watch and enjoy it otherwise.

Philip Stephens

Honestly, for me I like watching the sub because I like to hear the original Japanese voices, even if I can't understand the language. So much of the performance is in the voice, as originally intended and directed, it just makes sense for me to watch the sub. Having said that, I've enjoyed other animes watching the dub (Steins;Gate for instance has a wonderful dub, although I've watched it both ways and enjoyed them both).