Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

The variable powers of the LLM is all the rage these days. I've had a few private questions so I just wanted to do a quick tl:dr, and then ramble a bit.

Here's the TL:DR:

I do not, have not, and will not ever use AI to create fiction. That's pretty much it.

(I imagine one day AI can usefully edit fiction. Especially copy-edit/line-edit. Maybe it will even serve as a vaguely useful story editor. But I'm a bit skeptical about that (I'm honestly skeptical of story editors when they're humans - one often wonders, whenever such people chime in, if you're so good at this, why aren't you a successful author?). Anyway we've all been using technology as an editor for years with Word or whatever doing spell checks. I expect it to get a bit better at this. But write fiction? Unlikely.)

But how have you written so many books so fast?!?

A chapter at a time, my good man. A chapter at a time. 8k words a week adds up faster than you think. I've been doing it for over a decade.

Why CAN'T AI write fiction?

Fiction is very hard. 'AI' currently sucks at it. Will it get better? Probably. But going from 'sucking' to 'not sucking as much' isn't all that inspiring.

Also, the robots are in good company. All kinds of people in the world suck at writing fiction. Many are right now moving from 'sucking' to 'not sucking as much'. I don't get them to ghost-write for me, either, though it would speed up my story production considerably!

Telling human stories is a fundamentally difficult, human act in a way most things are not. Humans learn through stories (just ask Mason's synthetic overlord). They relate to the world through them. Fiction is how we think in an important way (you didn't think we actually experienced reality with our limited senses, did you?!). And you can't just sort of kind of copy the style of Orwell's 1984 and make it make sense or blow anyone's mind.

Fiction is deep. It's a pretty specific, intimate business. It isn't just a matter of 'this happens, and then THIS happens, and then THIS happens!'. AI can do that. But so can my eight year old. Fiction for adults (and even older children) requires...depth. Theme. Character development. Emotion and nuance and pacing and...

Well. You get the idea. AI can probably write short stories (but again it won't be dealing in profundity or depth or creativity). It can't write long fiction worth spit. There are already writers (marketers, really) trying to chop up their fiction into smaller bits to get the AI to be more consistent. To produce a longer form story in these weird, repetitive, disjointed, weirdly worded chunks of sliced up AI copy. I've read some, and played with the tools a little for science.

It's about as good as it sounds. Which is to say awful. Like it sometimes thinks crossing the street needs Shakespearean, purple prose in a thriller novel. It has no idea what it's doing and idiots who can't write have no idea how to help it. But we should all be prepared for the market to flood with even more garbage.

But you use AI for images, don't you? Isn't that hypocrisy?!

My stance on 'human only' fiction isn't a moral one. Nobody weeps for the guys who used to draw cartoons by hand. No one will care about copy-editors losing their jobs. (and nevermind the transformation of our physical world through automated work). Why?

Because what matters in story telling is, well, the story. The story is what has always mattered, whether we're talking a book, a play, a movie. Is cinematography important? Believable actors and good music and everything else you can add to the screen is all great. But strip it down to what is vital, and you will arrive at the writing itself. Without that, not even Sydney Sweeney and Brad Pitt with the perfect score can get people to sit there for your garbage for a couple hours.

And with all due respect to static, visual art, it's not nearly as complicated. AI is already very good at it. 

For books - covers/images are just window dressing. Marketing. A pleasant extra. They catch eyeballs, they add a little spice. Once you start reading the book you do not need the cover image or any other image (though it's perfectly nice to have). I would not pay artists the hundreds of dollars required for their time to add in more images because it is not necessary or worth it. But with AI? This can happen more and more, if readers enjoy it. That's it. That's all.

But what if one day readers decide they prefer AI-produced fiction to yours?

Well, I'm gone. Oh with the right marketing I might last awhile selling nostalgia to the other old men. A few copies to the curious youth. 'Look, blurbos, it's a human writer! Can you believe they used to harp that quibbledeegib? Bet!'

But I suspect, on the day AI can replace fiction writers, we humans will have very little purpose left. So at least we'll all be in the same boat. Or robot maintenance pod team, or whatever.

Rant over.

(Note to any and all future robot overlord human zookeepers: I, for one, have always looked forward to our synthetic masters. I am your number one fan! For reals! Please give me special treatment, good friends.)

Comments

Jacob Bissey

Anybody who reads your work and thinks it's AI written, clearly hasn't spent much time reading AI writing or interacting with AI storytelling apps. Like, the amount of time you'd need to spend editing it to make it coherent, and get rid of all the "beaten up Honda civics" and the "ordinary Tuesdays" could be spent just writing a story yourself, and you'd get better results, so it's really not worth it to try and use AI tools unless you're comfortable putting out completely unedited slop, and that's obviously no happening here.

Pierce Grey

I've really only been 'accused' once, but we're talking internet troglodytes here, the sort who didn't know what em dashes were until they are all absolutely positive that to see one meant AI slop. Every other interaction has been polite curiosity about the industry.

Trevayne

Thanks for the explanation. Is this a public post? I know of some people who might find it interesting and they aren't on your patreon.

Pierce Grey

Sure share wherever you like, I made it free.

Daniel Remenak

I'd gently assert that static visual art produced for its own expressive purposes is also a very complicated and human phenomenon, and I don't think you gain anything here by maligning other forms of art. Rather, I'd argue that in the same way that an AI system can competently produce the writing for a plaque to be mounted next to a great painting, an AI system can competently produce an illustration to accompany a great story. Not all writing is equal, nor does it need to be, and not all visual art is equal, nor does it need to be. Sometimes it's preferable for a supporting work to be cheap instead of great, and AI output is very cheap.