Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

It wasn’t long before a support group arrived. Three Lances of [Knights] along with three healers, including Luelle, the [Wound Binder] who’d healed Galan after his near-assassination. She only poked at Brin briefly before handing him over to a [Nurse].

The [Nurse] started looking for the clasps on Brin’s armor, but of course there were none. He used glass magic to pull it off of himself, though he appreciated her assistance in pulling his body off the back pieces that were between him and the ground. Any movement at all was agonizingly painful, and he didn’t do any more than he had to.

She also only prodded him for a minute before deciding that she, too, would spend her time better by aiding the other injured first.

The newly arrived [Knights] defended the area, while some busied themselves by starting to dig through the wreckage. The [Watchful Knights] among them put their ears to the ground and then directed the efforts to the areas where they thought there was most likely buried loot.

The Arcaeneans who’d evacuated this place probably assumed they’d be back some day. Many of them must’ve buried their precious things rather than bring them on a trip to who knows where.

It wasn’t long before someone struck gold. Even better than gold, actually. Cheese. Three big wheels of it. The first was destroyed in seconds, broken apart and doled out to the men. Brin got a big fistful, though it was hard to eat. He settled on summoning a fork out of glass and then floating it to his mouth that way. He’d never been an “eat an entire fistful of cheese” type person back as Mark, but today it tasted like manna from heaven.

After that, there was a lot of waiting. The men filled the time by recounting their stories of what had happened after they separated. Hedrek’s tale was the most eagerly anticipated, but Marksi was insistent that his and Brych’s fight against the batlike familiar should go first. Then, of course, they needed to tell Hedrek and Brych all about their escape through the underground tunnels. Anwir was present in every one of these stories, but only as an absence that everyone danced around. They weren’t ready to deal with that right now.

It was nice to catch up with the guys, but why weren’t they moving? Brin expected that they would be heading back to the Order’s camp fairly soon, but after a half hour there was still no movement. It was a frustrating example of “Hurry Up and Wait.” He didn’t know why they were just sitting here, lying down in his case, and no one thought he was important enough to confide their plans in. Another group of [Knights] came with more servants, more healers, and more supplies. They had tarps and blankets so that the wounded wouldn’t have to lie in the dirt while they waited for whatever it was they were waiting for.

Since there was nothing else to do, he was forced to watch the healers at work, and that was always a gut-churning sight. In this world, the System often let people perform beyond the scope of their ignorance. For glass, that made it so that a high leveled [Glasser] could produce crystal-clear windows despite never changing his recipe. For healers, it was even worse. Luelle smeared mud mixed with fragrant herbs onto the mouth of the [Knight] whose lips were missing. Then she wrapped a scarf around it and said a prayer, and the worst part was that Brin was sure this was going to be more quick and effective than any of the best surgeons back home.

Lothar knelt in the dirt through it all, eyes open but unseeing. Once or twice, a healer approached him or Galan would try to speak to him, but he never responded, lost in the intersection between [Broken Doll] and [Paladin].

Eventually, the healers made their way to Brin. He endured a horribly embarrassing sponge bath right there in the open, in full view of both gods and man. Then they covered his broken limbs in plaster casts before finally clothing him again. He put his armor on top of that, because it made him feel stronger and he could use glass magic to hold everything in place.

Soon another group from the Order arrived, now with cots and tents. Brin began to understand. They were moving the whole Order into the city. This was their new camp; they were claiming ground.

He also had his Invisible Eyes above the city, and he watched the movements of the armies. Galan and Lyssa discussed the war behind wards, but he could tell by their tense features and the movements of the armies that things weren’t looking good.

One army would send a group of men to claim a spot that a rival army had already claimed. Each time, the men would back off with apologies on both sides; they didn’t understand yet that the overlaps weren’t accidental. The leaders were trying to amp up tensions, and the men hadn’t caught on yet that they were supposed to hate the comrades that they’d fought and bled next to.

He saw a group of [Knights] from a Prinnashian Order attempt to enter Arcaena’s fortress citadel. They flung strength, magic, and even a battering ram at the doors, but there wasn’t so much as a scratch.

When a different Ollandish Order approached, the Prinnashian Order left, and the Ollandish Order turned around as well, both of them pretending that they hadn't been trying to sneak into the citadel while everyone else was pacifying the city.

All the while that little wagon the Lance had brought along still sat in the middle of the street, untouched and unnoticed.

“Hey, Cid. What was the point of bringing that wagon, anyhow?” Brin asked.

“I have no idea what you’re talking about. What wagon?” responded the Prime.

Brin’s mouth went dry. It wasn’t dread, exactly. More like anticipation. He sent his Invisible Eye to try to look inside the wagon, but his magic didn’t penetrate. He’d have to check in person. He cast a Mirror Image of himself on the ground, then went Invisible.

He thought about calling to Marksi, to bring him along. But no, Marksi knew that Brin shouldn’t be walking around in his state. He’d stop him just as surely as Cid would.

Slowly, in great pain and with more magic than muscle, he rose to his feet and started walking. It was a slow, shuffling walk. He was practically an invalid. But he made his way, slowly but surely, to the city center and the erstwhile home of the [Witch Queen].

As he walked, he watched the wagon with his Invisible Eyes. There was currently no one near it, and no one was near the doors to the citadel. No one was watching except for him.

Cati Breckon, his friend, or so he had thought, slipped out of the back covered portion of her wagon and sprinted up the stairs. He could tell it was her, though her status was hidden, her face was masked, and she had a cheap cloak of camoflague–well, cheap by his terms. She’d probably spent every cent she’d earned from Talra on it.

If other [Illusionists] were watching, others who didn’t know her very well, this could be any woman. But that was a lock of Cati’s hair peeking out from under her hood, and that was Cati’s dress, the same one she was wearing when she told Brin that she saw her death approaching with the dawn.

Cati moved quick, pulled on the giant doors of the citadel, and they opened for her. She slipped inside, then pulled the door shut behind her.

Brin followed along as best he could. The stairs were the hardest part. He couldn’t completely use the glass in his armor to lift himself in the air. He wasn’t sure why that didn’t work, but it didn’t. He used his Bog Standard spear as a crutch, and step by step he climbed to the top.

Then he hobbled over, and pulled on the door. They were locked. He wasn’t the one who could open these doors. Arnarra had been wrong. Witches could be so damn stupid sometimes. He would laugh if that didn’t make his ribs hurt.

He pounded on the door and yelled through. “Cati! Let me in! It’s me, Brin.”

He heard light footsteps moving across a stone floor, and then she opened it. “Brin?”

Brin shoved his way inside, which wasn’t as easy as it sounded when everything hurt this much. Cati instinctually closed the door behind him. She’d pulled down the hood and removed the mask, and any traces of hope that this might not be her fled.

He shook his head. “For Solia’s sake, Cati. Is every girl that has a crush on me a secret [Witch]?”

She snorted in derision. “I don’t know what you’re talking about. First off, I’m not a [Witch], and secondly, you’re the one who has a crush on me. I like Rhun.”

“How did you open that door?” asked Brin.

“It just opened. I admit, this looks a little weird, but I can explain! I thought… well, if maybe I got here first… and I did! Look! Look here!” She danced over to a huge vase set near the opening. It was four feet tall and solid gold. “Just this alone and I’m set for life!”

“Good. Then grab it and let’s go,” said Brin.

Cati blinked in surprise and then said, “You don’t want to explore just a little more? Haven’t you noticed where we are?”

Brin had noticed. He’d seen this place in Aberfa’s dream visits. This was the main hall of the citadel of Arcaena. The ceiling was so high that it seemed to be the crown of the world in the dim light. The walls and ceiling were extremely ornate, and lavish furniture and expensive ornaments hung around the edges. The floor in the middle was clear, however, and a massive portrait of Arcaena herself was built into the floor. Each brick colored to make up the whole, like pixels on a screen.

As Aberthol, he’d never come to this part of the castle. He wasn’t allowed anywhere near it. He was starting to become sure that those memories were real, locked away in the physical matter of his brain until he was in a frame of mind to accept them.

Aberfa had shown him this room in dreams, but she’d always obscured the [Witch Queen’s] face. He still didn’t know why. He didn’t recognize her at all. It was sheer hubris that he assumed that he would, that Arcaena herself had made a point of approaching him personally. Still, he’d thought seeing her face would’ve given him some kind of insight. She looked exactly how you would expect. Proud and cold, possibly beautiful but in the way that a frozen mountaintop is beautiful.

“No. I don’t want to explore the [Witch Queen’s] terrifying fortress, alone and with more broken bones than whole ones,” said Brin. “The fact that we took three steps inside and didn’t immediately turn into toads is already pushing our luck. We should go.”

Cati looked down. “You’re right.”

Brin turned to the door and pushed on it. He couldn’t open it again without her help.

“Let’s just… let’s just take a peek, ok? Behind those doors, and then we’ll come back here, grab this vase, and go.”

“You can’t expect me to believe this. You can’t expect me to believe you just came here to grab some gold. Cati, why are you really here? Tell me now, and I swear, whatever you’ve done, I’ll protect you. But you have to come clean now. How long have you been spying for Arcaena?”

Cati frowned in deep disappointment. “I’d expect that from the Prinnashian guys, but not from you. You think every woman secretly sympathizes with Arcaena? That wasn’t true before this war started, and it certainly isn’t true after I saw what her soldiers did to Awsta.”

Brin shook his head. “Then help me. Make this make sense.”

Cati stared back, intense and angry, and he met her gaze evenly until she broke. “I… don’t know what first made me think of doing this. But as soon as the idea came into my head, I knew that I would do it. There are answers here. There are things I need to see. I’m going. Just a peek.”

She didn’t wait for him to argue, but strode across the hall, right over Arcaena’s face. Brin followed. As stupid as this was, as much as he wouldn’t admit it out loud, he was curious as well. Who would he be if he didn’t indulge his curiosity? If he wasn’t the person who needed to do things, to know, to dare. He’d be back in Hammon’s Bog.

He didn’t step on Arcaena’s face, though, and hobbled his way in a wide circle around her.

Cati opened the door on the opposite side of the room and walked through. Brin could probably give a map to Arcaena’s throne room, because it was towards all the places that Aberfa had never dared to show him. He’d never seen this hall, where the portraits hung. Each was twenty feet high, and depicted a different [Witch]. Some young, some older, all full of confidence and power. Arcaena’s old coven, perhaps? Or perhaps old subordinates, long since dead.

Cati didn’t give the room “just a peek”. She didn’t glance at the portraits at all, but made her way with single minded determination towards the doors on the other side.

Then at the end of the hall, there was an archway. Cati opened two doors that were twenty feet high and made of pure marble as if they weighed nothing, and took one step inside.

When Brin finally reached her again, his breath caught in his throat. 

It was there. The throne. Up on a raised dais, surrounded by braziers of pure white flame. The rest of the room was so dark that he couldn’t see the walls, and while the flames perfectly illuminated him and Cati, they didn’t penetrate the fog of darkness all around them. They did light the throne up in perfect detail. The throne for a [Witch Queen]. Regal, dark, and dangerous, and brimming so much with the Wyrd that Brin had to pull his senses shut lest he be blinded.

“I take it back. I am a [Witch],” said Cati.

Brin laughed, and despite the overpowering Wyrd and the flames and the darkness, it did a lot to ease the tension. It reminded him of Myra, actually. She’d always made bad jokes at times like this, too.

Cati didn’t respond, though, and after a moment the tension returned twice as strong. She’d been serious.

“It’s not worth it, Cati. I don’t know what they told you, but if it were really that easy, there'd be a thousand Arcaenas running around. Don’t you dare step near that chair.”

“No. You don’t get it. I’m not just a [Witch]. I’m the [Witch]. I think… I think it takes seeing it to know,” said Cati.

Brin grit his teeth in worry. Even now, he couldn’t keep the wheels in his brain from turning. Arnarra claimed that all she had to do was sit on the throne to become Arcaena, but then why hadn’t she done it already? Because she couldn’t get through the doors? Brin knew a [Great Witch] was capable of more than that. No, it had been something else. Fear, maybe. A Fate or Wyrd-borne assurance that only Arcaena herself could sit upon her throne.

“I was thinking that if I were Arcaena, I would do like Sana did,” said Brin.

Cati looked at him in disgust. “That… that monster? An abomination with a hundred heads? That… thing?”

“A hundred heads, and each capable of independent thought, but each of them still Sana, the [Witch Mage], with all her skill and power. But why stop at heads? Could you make two full bodies, joined together at the fingertips? And if you could, what happens when those fingertips separate? I bet Arcaena is hundreds of people. Thousands. Little seeds, scattered across the realms.”

He was really onto something here, but he resisted the urge to pace. “This is how she… you mean to ascend. I’ve already learned that if I split my mind and separate the new consciousness from myself to a sufficient degree, it can be rewarded independently by the System. Arcaena is doing that at a massive scale. Advancing in the high levels is next to impossible, unless you can gather experience from a multitude of sources all the time.”

Cati’s face went through a series of emotions. Anger, fear, wry humor, grim determination, before finally settling on abject horror. “I can’t be her. I’m a good person, Brin. I… I can’t be the one who did those things.”

Brin remembered where he was, and who he was with. “We should go.”

“The closer I get to the throne, the more I remember about her. I think I can take another step and still be me,” said Cati.

“It’s not worth it. Let’s just leave,” said Brin.

“But don’t you want to know? Awsta, and all of Talra. All they suffered. And me, and even you. Everything we’ve been through. Don’t you want to know what it was all for? What is the point of all this? Just so that one crazy woman can get to heaven the long way around? There has to be more than that.”

Brin leveled his spear at Cati’s throat. “Take one more step towards that throne and I will end you.”

Cati called his bluff. She reached out with a finger and pushed his spear away. While not exactly the closest of friends, she knew him well enough by now to know that he would have even more questions than she did.

“Yeah, you’re kind of right,” she said. “All the split bodies, they’re helping her level. But that’s just a side-effect. That’s not what they’re for. Hm…”

Brin licked his lips. “Then what are they for?”

Cati’s gaze was locked on the throne now. He could run her through. He should, and she would never see it coming. But he didn’t.

“Do you ever think about [Witches]? Do you ever think about how stupid they are?” asked Cati.

“All the time,” said Brin.

“I thought I would start to sympathize with them the closer I got, but now I can tell. She… I… she. Above all, she hates most [Witches]. By the gods, they are dumb! See, they think they can move the Wyrd. Destructive, they think to lie and turn everything to their will. They think they can create a reality of their own choosing. But reality thinks otherwise, and has a will of its own. It turns their lies to their own destruction. The Wyrd thinks, don’t you see? Those fools. And to the gods, [Witches] are hated above all.”

“You literally taught these [Witches]. Why not tell them how it should be done?” asked Brin.

“I did!” shouted Cati. “The fault lies at the foundations, it lies at the very inception of this nation. I meant to give stability and ease. I imagined a place of growth and civilization. Free from the apathetic laziness of slaves, my pleasurable people would be industrious and free. And for a while it worked. But then they began to let pleasure enslave them. They became a lazy and complacent civilization lacking in growth. Ease led to stagnation. I’ll need a new nation, built from a new foundation, one without cracks. And I’ve done it.”

Brin repeated the earlier question. “Why does Arcaena create so many bodies, if not for the experience. To spy?”

Cati shook her head. “The proper path of a [Witch] is to serve the Wyrd, completely. She doesn’t dominate it. And [Queens], they are in the same prison. They also must serve their people above all. Arcaena sought freedom. Unconstrained, not weighed down by the responsibility of her own power. She wanted a real life. This way, everyone can have what they want. She has the power to fulfill all her responsibilities, and give them the proper weight, while still being unconstrained by it. Her people can serve her, captive to their [Queen] and not dominating her completely. The Wyrd can mutually serve her in turn, so long as she remains on the proper path.”

“You call what Arcaena’s doing the proper path? Are you standing close enough to that throne to know what she did to me? To Lothar? I could name countless others,” said Brin.

Cati took another step forward.

 “Not one more!” Brin shouted, lifting his spear.

She ignored him. Her voice was cold, and had a slight accent. An Arcaenean accent. “These bodies are justice, too. That’s the price: I live the same lives that I give to my people. I endure all the pain that is felt as a consequence of my decisions. And as a result, who has felt pain greater than I have endured? My people’s lives are better because justice’s price is paid with my own body.”

Cati took another step forward.

Brin gripped his spear tight. It was time. He didn’t dare let her get any closer. He couldn’t kill Cati, but he wasn’t sure this was even Cati any more. It was time. But then, rather than keep moving, she turned around to face him. Tears were streaming down her face.

“I get it. I see it now. I see it now and I understand.”

“See what?” 

“I’m ok with it. It’s all ok.” 

“What’s ok?”

Cati’s gaze firmed and the coldness returned. “We spoke of justice. Did you think you had avoided my wrath? Did you think that you have preserved your army from my retribution and that there wouldn’t be a cost? You have invaded my lands, destroyed my walls and sanctuaries. My citizens, harried by your soldiers. There will be a reckoning in blood. I would have had your soldiers pay the debt, but now I will harass your citizens. They will find no sanctuary. No walls can save them from destruction. Your lands will be invaded and all will pay the price of my retribution, until you know my fury and my justice.”

This close to the throne, there was no lying to the Wyrd. Brin saw the truth in her words, but he also saw that she was using a general “you”. She didn’t actually have any retribution for him personally. She wasn’t even tricked by the fact that he wasn’t Aberthol, and even so the Wyrd decided that the scales were balanced decidedly in his favor: She’d done worse to him than he’d done to her. Starting with attacking Hammon’s Bog, then unleashing Aberfa upon him, and even the curse currently swimming in his veins right now. Indirectly or not, on purpose or not, she’d brought him a lot of trouble, and the Wyrd knew it.

He’d never get a better chance. He stepped forward, lashing out with his spear and…

He was outside. The citadel walls slammed shut. He was unhurt, but the haft of his Bog Standard spear had been snapped in half.

He’d gotten off easy.

In halted, painful steps, Brin made his way back to the Order’s camp and the new war that was brewing.

Comments

Alan

I feel an intense amount of joy whenever I see the update notification for this story.

ThoMiCroN

camoflague->camouflage*

Nathan Emerson

Im guessing her plan is to use the tunnels to put zombies everywhere and attack everyone.

Ottstop

ANOTHER HUNDRED WITCHES BY BRINS SIDE!!!

Chrysos au

Hate this chapter so much. After all Brin has seen, done and suffered though, there is no way he wouldn't have tried his best to kill her once he was sure she was Arcanea. The whole chapter feels like a April fools joke.

Sheepdog

Hard agree this makes no sense whatsoever

Andrew

Thank you!

Ran

Everyone is a witch. 🤔 I wonder why she let him in, if that was the part of her that still thought she was Cati, and why she let him live. I wonder why the Wyrd thinks she has any justice on her side at all, after invading everyone to kick off the war to begin with.

Chris

So.... they didn't actually "win" anything with all that stuff in the last few chapters. And brin (and everyone else in occupying the city) just let her walk right in and claim her power again.

Conor

Yeah does feel a bit weird that Brin just let her do it.

Crow Says Caw

Well played whomever commented about Cati going for the throne! Should’ve guessed it from the name - Cati, connects to Hecate a bit, bunch of English names similar that have witchy vibes too Great stuff! Loving this so much

Crow Says Caw

I’m hoping it’s the fake out before the proper ending? I don’t particularly want this arc to continue further also. Want him to defeat this antagonist and move onto the next Writing is fantastic tho, can’t deny

Grish99

once he was sure of what? that cati is just one of x number of bodies that arcanea have? or that hes way weaker than her at his best and currently hes half a cripple? sure of what exactly?

1FantasyFanatic

I mean Brin has always been weak and cowardly. He’s just also a good guy so when pushed he’ll give his all. But seriously with all his advantages would anyone be able to keep up with him if he was actually driven and ruthless?

1FantasyFanatic

Brin is and seems to forever remain a weak willed coward until he has no choice. It’s why I really don’t like his character.

Adunn

Myra mention, hope she comes back into the story somehow soon.

Lessthan

I can't believe Brin's ignorance here. Just found out that any [Witch] can sit on the throne and become the Witch Queen? Sure, we'll let an almost random woman basically sprint into the throne room, not believe her when she admits to being a [Witch], and, finally, allow her to play with forces beyond mortal kin. I would also like to point out that Brin himself was supposed to be a sleeper agent and he JUST saw Lothar, who was so committed to righteousness that he became a [Palidin], flip into puppet mode and kill a bunch of GOOD people. I understand that this was a big plot twist reveal, so this had to happen somehow, that the information had to be revealed, but I don't understand why this. Brin could have gotten there too late. He could have been too injured to actually go and sent a hologram, which would have been unable to act. Cati was an acquaintance at best. Am I the sociopathic one because I wouldn't let an acquaintance into the same room as a magical, armed nuke?

Lessthan

I did catch that Arcaena split herself into many people. But, at the beginning of the conversation, Brin didn't know that.

Hypnotical

I'm assuming Arcanea enchanted Brin the same way she did the Lance and literally everyone else who couldn't see the wagon. The fact he was able to put up any resistance at all is probably a sign of his mental defences.

Hypnotical

I thought you were gonna say Myra is clearly another Arcanea splinter.

Lessthan

Sure, but Brin didn't "break free" before attacking her. And Brin has ungodly amounts of mental resistance. And, if I'm understanding implications, the drones doesn't have her true power unless they sit upon the Throne.

Jasus

I liked the reveal with cati but i have to agree that Brin was to passive here. He could have stopped it many times and did not. And that seems way to nonchalant. Maybe write in that he is not able to stop Cati because of the wyrd, magic or because he is not near enough to stop her.

glare31337

I don't think she was ever out of power, really. Her Cati body just returned to the hive mind, dropping off her memories and experience. I believe it was confirmed the main body was physically distant doing Burrow Kingdom shenanigans awhile back, which is why the escaped familiars never rejoin the war. Unclear if she can have two main avatars simultaneously but I doubt it will make much of a difference in the short term. Book's ending and we are leaving Arcaena anyway.

glare31337

I think this chapter suggests that she cheeses the scales in the wyrd. She has enough bodies in common classes suffering from the other kingdoms' rule that she is able to twist it in her favor. I'm sure it doesn't help that a ton of people were, either directly or indirectly, suffering from the alliance's war effort. I think the Aberthol POV where he realizes how disgusting most of the army acts is supposed to hint at this. Cati herself seemed to have been SA'd around this time. Perhaps not proportional to what Arcaena was/is planning to do to everyone else, but [Witch]'s almost always get the better deal in the wyrd and she has plenty to work with.

Strawhat Steve

Oh my God. Cati complained at one point about her friend getting more experience for doing the exact same stuff. The System nerfing Arcaena's Exp gains has got to be some of the most subtle foreshadowing ever. I thought at the time it was foreshadowing her being a [Witch] by showing that she was a bit spiteful and whaddya know, I was right. It only hit me like an hour after I finished reading the chapter.

Swinter

Wow, this is "Exposition, the chapter". Last chapter showed you can write good ones (even if it should have been a multitude of Weaker foes, not an absurd amount of equally strong or stronger foes), but this is back to absurdity. It's reeking of Tell rather than Show. It's got insane character decisions by Brin, and it's got an almost reverse Deus Ex Machina. Again it's a situation that would have played out Way better if Bring + Gang hadn't actually been in the nick of fighting. That they somehow found their way into the castle After the fact, had a trial or something with Cati for some reason with them, and Then she'd betray them like this. It's just... All rather poorly put together and feels random and out of place.

wanderer117

Arcanea didn't invade everyone, just some towns in the bog lands. She tunneled under the lands of Ferania and maybe Parishna to evacuate her population from the coming war but this was a defensive war on her part. edit: she also cursed a bunch of boarder towns for unknown reasons. so not 100% a defensive war

Tadas

Cool villain! There was a lot of talk about paths in last 2 chapters like path of blade, Hedreks path, Witches path, Kings path. I guess it's a build up for a path for Brin as well. I don't really know what that is. He doesn't have the same love for magic Lumina has, nor is he as knightly as Galan or Cid. I think he will get a unique one just like Hedrek. Thematically I think it will be some kind of flavor of magic and war. One of the first achievements he got was [Warbound] and he is constantly in one war or another. Maybe something involving Marksi, he is a dragon after all with insane growth potential. It's interesting that he said that one of the ways of farming exp for high levels is to have multiple bodies and his recent skills seem to be well suited for that. Maybe we will see army of Brin. Excited to see where the story goes.

shabbybook

Brin not acting until he did is unbelievable and unrealistic

Tadas

We have seen witches mess with peoples heads since book 1. I think it would be trivial for Arcanea to manipulate Brin, especially because it wouldn't involve anything Brin doesn't want to do in the first place. Just small nudges for curiosity and hesitation for attacking a friend.

Rabauke

When did he always be weak and cowardly? Did we read the same story? He didn't tried to kill her right on the spot because he thinks that not all witches are evil and that you can resist the temptation of evil like he did all the time. He didn't tried because cati was his friend. He believed, hoped that she would hear him out. Also he loves secrets. He got more information than any other person we know about the witchqueen.

wanderer117

Recapping what we know Arcaena has many bodies, most of them don't know they are part of a greater whole. In the wyrd wrongs done to her unknowing bodies count as wrongs done to Arcaena. Arcaena also has robes that 'regular' people can put on to channel her power. Aberfa and Brin though those regular people were secret witches but what if they are also Arcaena seeds? That implies there are many ways for her to focus her power, not just the throne. So why is the throne special? Maybe it's the prime focus, and needs a seed to sit on it periodically so the Arcaena system keeps working? Then why not leave a seed to sit on the throne, why sneak Cati in at the last minute? Perhaps the wrongs done to Arcaena seeds aren't fully shared, and she needed a seed on the throne that had been personally harmed by the armies of A F and O?

Lucas Gulick

It's hard to look a friend in the eyes and hurt them.

Lucas Gulick

I really like this chapter, it tied together the Arcaena plot line quite neatly. The dialog could maybe use another pass, and if Brin was described as a bit more injured in a couple places it would probably help tie the chapter together

wanderer117

In the sliding scale from friendly unknowing Cati seed to avatar of Arcaena when is the right point to strike? It's a hard question, especially since by waiting longer Brin gets more information.

CentaureHeart

Too bad you feel that way. I think it's fitting.

Ran

It would make sense if Cati/Arcaena was subtly influencing him (like she was the rest of his lance not to notice her), but it would be nice to get confirmation about that if it's the case.

wanderer117

I kind wish Brin didn't attack her at all. I get the moment in the story but he knows that he's in her place of power, he avoids walking on her portrait earlier in the same scene. I wish he tried to lawyer her, and that got him banished. Something like 'While the army invaded your lands most of the civilian population were your victims and the victims of the armies. You are fighting kingdoms not democracies, the citizens have no representation, and little power to change national level decisions. By taking the wrongs done to you by the armies and placing them on the civilians you are doubling a wrong, not balancing the debt.'

Hallow

Honestly I like this chapter. I understand why some people don't, but I like it. The way the story has progressed so far makes this feel almost inevitable, in a like fate kind of way. Brin, too weak to fight barely on his feet, sees what seems to be a friend and follows. Brin, who's whole life has been impacted by Arcaena, wants to find out what's happening. The friend knows it, he knows it. He walks with her as they get closer to the throne, the friend is enticed just as much as he is. They both know the path they're walking. They both know that it would be in Brin's best interest to stop her. They both know he won't. He wants to learn as much as he can. Especially considering he came from a world that gave him almost unlimited access to knowledge. It must be a struggle to not know and have no way to find out. No cosy endings all tied up where he can understand things. The tension builds, naturally. Brin is aware he's unable to fight a battle, but he tries to stop her. In his heart, he knows he left it too late, but at least he can delude himself into believing he tried. Even if there's not a Wyrdic argument for why he'd let it happen, it feels like fate. An inevitability. Cati entered at a time where Brin was free enough to follow her, at a point where he was able to see her enter, he just so happened to see a cart where one shouldn't have been. And Arcaena-Cati begins to reclaim her throne while he's right there. The Wryd has Fate Weavers and things, honestly I could see this all being something that is almost destiny. (Perhaps fate was influenced to land in this way, although I think if that's what happened it would be better to leave ambiguous. Like, from a story point of view confirming such a thing openly would feel a bit too authorial.)

Grish99

I want to remind everybody that arcanea is a witch and witches are full of shit and lies, and arcanea is witch queen so shes the queen full of shit and lies. The Throne? probably just nice looking chair, The whole co operating with wyrd? propably narcists way of explaining why she can't do some stuff. Remember something like 8/15 of witches we know up to now are fck up in the head with class that rewards manipulation.

Sam

Great chapter! Thanks Miles, can’t say I was expecting the hive mind, but it’s cool. Certainly makes Arcaena into a true threat.

wanderer117

Brins path might be headed towards supercomputer with a side of terminator army. Create a persistent magical effect with a purpose in the wyrd, give it a glass body (monitor and keyboard or killer robot) and seed it with a fraction of his mind, one that can grow and act independently but is still fundamentally (or at least magically) Brin.

CentaureHeart

If it hadn't been Cati it would have been someone else. Even if Brin had killed her instantly it wouldn't have changed anything. There would have been another one to show up and sit on the throne. Turns out Arcaena is even more terrifying than initially thought.

Jasus

Yes i fully agree but there has to be indicators in the text that he is under control of the wyrd maybe even fighting it but is helpless to stop it.

Reader A

Surprise surmuthaheckinprise! Just when I think the story can’t get better, you do a plot twist. I didn’t think Cati had any more importance to the story beyond what she was 😭 but I thought she’d been super cryptic before and now here we are. It’s making me wonder, if Arcaena can turn herself into all these people, who all else is Arcaena. Could Brin be Arcaena? Or does she just split into all these women? He was a part of her nation so her whole nation could be herself, not just her but you know what I mean. Idk

BubblyGhost

Eh, I'm ambivalent to this chap. Didn't really like it but didn't hate it. Didn't really felt like any emotion got evoked from me

Adunn

Oof that would be sad. Brin would find a way to save her

Hypnotical

LOL same! When I finished it all I thought was "interesting," and my brain spun up a dozen crackpot theories. Too busy sleuthing to feel one way or another.

Marlin

Seems pretty clear to me. The closer Cati gets to the throne the more her Arcaena persona takes over. The moment she said “She… I… She.” it was time to get serious with his threat. If she’s starting to lose the ability to tell Cati apart from Arcaena, she shouldn’t be allowed to go any further. The reasonable response is “step back or I shoot,” not silent acquiescence. That’s for Cati’s safety as much as it is for the alliance’s, since she ostensibly disappears when the master personality takes command.

BlaueFeder

I have to also agree here. Recently, too many twists and turns came out of literally nowhere. We need some hints and thoughts beforehand to make sense.

Gerald Monroe

I don't like how there's no agency for Brin in this chapter. What is revealed is there's no winning, Arcaena is almost impossibly powerful, and obvious basic moves like "stab with a spear" are pointless. I mean if Lothar and the necromancy bombs being disarmed don't stop Arcaena what's the point?

wanderer117

The Arcaena witches have been saying, with no obvious support, that Arcaena is unstoppable from book 2. This is the first time we're seeing concrete support for that idea. That doesn't mean they are correct, but what you're feeling is what the witches want you to feel.

Chien Do

The proper Naruto path montage? That will be quite OP. Other author I read balance that power with apathy and indifference toward life, cause you feel like a literal god, experiencing multitude of lifes, suffering, injustice. Idk. A part of me, nah, all of me want cheerful Brin back. This delusionist class, like Scarred, was taken out of necessity, to win the war, to overcome indecribable montrosities, but it is eating Brin over time. Same with the Aberthol bullshit. He revived the traumatic past of someone else to stay alive against Zaff. And same with the Aberfa bullshit, when he had to suffer her cruel insanity night after night to gain more knowledge, to properly find her and kill her. Author, why making our boy shoulder everything? And for Solia's sake, where is the therapist? For Brin and for me?

wanderer117

Arcaena can probably be male, the [Great Witch] clearly thought Brin was an Arcaena seed but Brin probably isn't because 1, his soul comes from earth, 2 he couldn't open the doors to her citadel and 3 he didn't unlock new memories when he saw the throne. Unless her mind/soul is limitless everyone isn't Arcaena. If her mind/soul was limitless she would already be ascended. I'm guessing thousands or tens of thousands not millions of seeds. She has to be using some evolved version of split mind / split soul. Brin at almost level 50 with an epic version of the skill backed by epic mental control can manage 50ish minds. I don't think a legendary skill backed by, say 1k mental control could manage millions of copies that blend in with the rest of humanity.

wanderer117

I don't think it's the system nerfing Arcaena's Exp gains. She is nerfing her seeds' gains when she siphons off a portion for her main self.

wanderer117

my head cannon is that Myra's mother is an Arcaena splinter, while Myra is a daughter of Arcaena.

Lionheart

One of my favorites in the story. The growing dread, the unwillingness to strike down a friend, the realization too late that he should’ve acted, and the evil monologue to top it all off.

Cyrus

Does anyone have the data of all the words of arcane that Brin know? I've been wondering this for awhile, but i don't think ive seen self referential words like 'I', 'are', 'am', or logic based words like 'therefore'. I'm prolly wrong, but i really could see the main character unraveling all this in the blink of an eye using those normal words in the wyd.

Slapjack

I'm not a fan of the last few chapters, it feels like there's been no real stakes and everything is just a contrived plot device. Nothing has really happened. Invading the city and outsmarting the necromancy bombs only for it to be worth nothing upon Arcaena's return. Hedrek making a heroic last stand, just to be brought back though deus ex machina. The tragedy of Lothar, just for him to somehow survive. What a shame man.

Slapjack

Thats been the last few chapters for me, no emotion evoked as nothing has really happened.

Strawhat Steve

Bogworld is cruel, and if you want to have any ability to affect how things turn out you have to suffer. I feel like that's the world the author has been building and I like how it's presented.

Chien Do

Okay, from the quite upseting mood of this chapter and by the end of this arc in general, can I petition for Sir Brin to get some action in bed. No seriously, hear me out. I know that Brin just speared Cati, tears streaming down her face, and got his shaft snapped in half. Rookie mistake, bro just got his Vitality down by 90% from the curse, of course his performance gonna suffer. Gotta be a pro about it, wait a few day and his spear will be better than Sir Lance-a-lot on Earth. Better yet, I bet my bottom money there must be people out there whose classes are Escort, Love maker, etc. with skills to prevent all the nasty unwanted consequences. I know Brin is the avatar of proper knighthood, gentlemen and most women in this universe are Witches (beside Lumina, but Mom is off limit; Davi's mom on the other hand is *wink wink*, also a witch), but yeah, Brin is swimming in teenager hormon, fountain of youth, please let him make sweet love to some nice girls. Bro really deserved it at this point. Okay, I hope you are uplifted somewhat by my awful jokes. No offence to anyone. But yeah, boys do love kittens. Always has, always will.

thomas johnson

I think we are forgetting that if she can do this process and thus create 1000 lives amongst the world and feel the suffering then that means she can be overturned by a witch. Someone who is careful or extremely wronged similar to Brin I wonder who is tied to her and has a bond to pick with her for not just torture but maybe even for perverting their purpose….oh maybe a doll/paladin. Similar to how Brin was the best weapon against his mother Lothar can counter Archean’s with a little help from a wyrd delusionist!!!!

Hypnotical

Saying that about the Hedrek chapter is crazy work!

Muntu Omnyama

So we have the greatest witch of all, in her place of power , already al,let her throne and there is no urgency or danger from Brin because…? I’m confused .

Justin Young

Additionally, Brin is in Arcaena now. His stance might have carried the proper weight if he had the mask / robes of a [Mediator]. "When in Rome" and all that jazz.

Mohit

I'm going through the list of people we met who might be Arcaena. Siphani seems like the most obvious suspect considering her level of power. Also we never got the full story on how she deceived Hogg's inspect. Aside from her maybe one of the members of the friend group. Zilly has some red flags that might lead to something but she also seemed to be willing to get rid of an evil class despite its power so idk. Myra and Davi don't have obvious suspicious signs besides their family members but then again neither did Cati. Idk but this opens the door to a lot of conspiracy theories.

Mohit

It seems easier to count the people who definitely can't be Arcaena. The 4 heroes of Travin's bog would never have been called by Solia if they were compromised. I doubt a priest would be her either. I also don't think the Tenerer cult would include her considering Tenerer seems to need to sign off on the members. Idk if I'm missing anyone.

worg

Plot twist, arcaena is in fact 80% of the human population in this planet now, since she forgot long ago they can reproduce among themselves, endlessly spawning new arcaena.

Tobias Nick

I have to agree. I liked this story a lot, but the latest chapters were so confusing and out of place. After his fight with Zaff the story did not make any sense anymore. What are all the high level people doing, where are the mages etc. I'm actually really sad about it.

worg

because fascination of what's happening and the need to understand what's going on behind everything. Come on, he did this sort of thing a lot of times, putting himself in danger to check on things.

Jonathan Robichaux

I gotta say, this chapter is pretty awful. None of this makes sense. The impetus for bring going to the wagon doesn't make sense, Cati doesn't make sense, none of the arcanea stuff makes sense, Brin doesn't makes sense. There's no reason for him to be falling for all this curiosity crap or I'm not a which junk, his wyrdic inspect should call it out immediately even with it hidden. This whole chapter feels like one big railroad that miles couldn't figure out how to implement.

Jonathan Robichaux

And the ending?! Brin just let's her assume power on the thrown, no consequences or anything? And the he basically shrugs, says o well, and trudges back to camp like a whipped dog? I know I'm being pretty harsh but this was such a rug pull from the entire story and brins baseline character

Jonathan Robichaux

Every time brin has to make a hard choice he pussies out. I think that's why I hate the current class selection so much too

wanderer117

Nah, but I bet her mother is. Myra grew up in Hammon's Bog. She had a father and a (relatively) powerful mother known to many people. But when doom came to the bog, her mother escaped when Myra didn't. Just like Cati avoided Awsta's fate. Because even Arcaena cheats. Her seeds are still part of her and she saves them from her minions and her plots.

wanderer117

Why would her children be her? Witches understand motherhood and while their children are tightly connected to them in the Wyrd they are not the same person.

TheShadowSlayer_

I still find Brin’s ego in regard to his attractiveness very weird. As far as we know, Mira is basically the only person to ever be interested in him before he became a knight, but he’s been whining about how much women like him since book four and every time it gives me cognitive dissonance. That witch-cursed girl also fawned over him, but so far it’s literally only been those two. Why is he so certain that he’s every girl’s wet dream??? Are you cutting out important context scenes??