Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

https://ws.onehub.com/files/ydfnutty

Comments

Samantha Bailey

That man that shot the detective not only came out of his house and was scared that someone was running around his house but would have been listening to the news to know what was going on because he mentioned the car outside his house. Him and his family don't fit the victimology of the serial killer, so why come outside to investigate instead of calling the cops?

Zach Faulkner

So different states have different laws of where your property begins when it comes to self defense. Some are inside the house itself as you mentioned, others are anywhere within the property line that belongs to you. This case takes place in New York which in terms of self defense, the second they stepped foot onto his yard they were in a place where justifiable self defense would be legal. My opinion is with the news out there that there is a serial killer on the loose, the car and officer matching the description given out by the media, the fact he was on the mans property with a weapon. This is a justifiable shooting in self defense. Add into that you need the mens rea (aka the intention to do wrong). This man was operating under the mindset that he was in danger and needed to defend his family so therefore he did not have the intention to commit the act of murder. My opinion, this man is 100% innocent of any criminal charges. The family might be able to sue in civil court for financial compensation and that I think is more 50/50 based on your jury. Now obviously nothing is ever guaranteed. We actually just had a trial end a couple of weeks ago where it was the opposite situation. A woman noticed her neighbor had multiple doors leading outside open and tons of lights on. She called the police to do a wellness check. When the police arrived they began looking around the perimeter of the house to make sure this wasn't a burglary in progress. The home owner noticed people creeping around her yard and got scared so she grabbed a gun. As an officer walked by a window he looked in and noticed the a woman holding a gun and raising it to point at him. He yelled for her to drop the gun and she didn't so he pulled his gun out and shot and killed her. In my opinion, the law was on the officers side. He did his duties based on the protocol of his department, he saw a person pointing a gun at him which he didn't know if it was the home owner or a burglar and so he defended his own life. The jury saw it the other way. They found him guilty and sentenced him to 11 years for manslaughter. So that goes to show that the jury is never predictable.