Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hi. Right-wing politicians, lawyers, and grifters (and some liberals) want to convince you that trans youth are the victims of a social contagion and that the majority of those who transition will detransition. This is a lie that puts all trans people at risk.

Files

Trans People Are Real and Detransitioning Isn't That Big A Thing – EARLY ACCESS & AD-FREE

Hi. Right-wing politicians, lawyers, and grifters (and some liberals) want to convince you that trans youth are the victims of a social contagion and that the majority of those who transition will detransition. This is a lie that puts all trans people at risk. Hosted by Cody Johnston Executive Producer - Katy Stoll Directed by Will Gordh Written by Ella Yurman and David Christopher Bell Produced by Jonathan Harris Edited by Gregg Meller Post-Production Supervisor - John Conway Researcher - Marco Siler-Gonzales Graphics by Clint DeNisco Head Writer - David Christopher Bell Chapters: 00:00 - Intro 02:53 - Is Being Trans Really on the Rise? 11:06 - “Desisting” is low 19:24 - The Cass Review 24:49 - The Countless Op-Eds 36:47 - The Ghouls Behind The Detransitioners 46:27 - Why Are Transphobes?

Comments

Brendan Dion

Should this be something like "... and DetransitIoning Isn't that Common" or something? Because detransition can be a BIG thing, at least when forced upon someone.

Eric Herde

Wow Matt, super embarrassing to have even Joe Rogan be a little skeptical of your right-wing propoganda!

The Green Way

Cody, I love you, but this ones really goes to the writer. Really amazing job. Thank you.

Jess Hrudey

One thing that you kind of allude to in the discussion of the Swedish study but don’t quite say is the problem of looking at the suicide rate against population matched controls. You do mention regarding how it is more difficult to be out and trans in society and that likely accounts for higher suicide rates against the general population. But the way that Fox report presents it suggests a causal link between transition and suicide. Even before looking into the research that shows improved well-being with transition, that comparison to the general population alone is already rife with problems and clearly not any kind of evidence for causality. Again, you kind of allude to this but I just thought perhaps its worth also mentioning that that comparison is not showing a causal relationship the way Fox seems to be suggesting. I dunno, maybe I’m just being persnickety. Good work all around though!!

Mady

thank you Cody and team! this is what I pay the big bucks for!! ❤️❤️❤️

Tarren Renn

So, as someone who is transgender and has been for about 25 years, the second Trump presidency has me a bit terrified. I used to be extremely suicidal and spent a lot of time going in and out of psychiatric hospitals, and when I started transitioning that number dropped down to about nothing. I have been really trying to figure out what Trump's executive order means for me. My medical records show that I am transgender, but my id and birth certificate has been changed to say that I am male. I have no idea what gender I am by Trump's executive order.

Pietro Gagliardi

The "trans teens are more likely to kill themselves" bad argument is the exact same bad argument as "crime rates are higher among Black people". And as for that one Dutch study, Europe is still *really weird* about women playing soccer; there's a reason the US and East Asian countries are miles ahead of the rest of the world when it comes to the quality of women's soccer... (But hey, it's not outright illegal anymore, like it was for most of the 20th century! Progress???????) We really do need to have a bigger conversation about how a disturbingly high percentage of parents think their children are property and must be molded into obedient elf slaves who think identically to the parents and how things like teens being trans are, in their own words, "taking our children away from us". That's a major part of this. It's probably why the Dutch study is so incurious as to why they got the results they did. We also need to talk about parents being surprised by children Suddeny And Without Warning changing — that "ParentsOfROGDKids" site description is creepily similar to vaccines-cause-autism crap. I'm not going to get into my own gender wonk (rest assured I've got some) but I will point out, and I'll probably also point this out publicly when the video goes live: one particularly notable experience I had in college was taking a Psychology 101 course and learning that actually yes, psychologists do have ways to determine whether children may be trans, and maybe we need to start giving children way more credit as a society than we currently do. It's getting increasingly hard to not be convinced that centrists were always secretly homophobic and transphobic and were just waiting for implied social permission to be openly that after having to pretend to not be for electoral victories before 2024. Even if that social permission isn't real and their hatred is still in the minority. That needle thing is an open call for torture, plain and simple. And remember: it's not going to end with kids. They will go after trans adults if they aren't stopped. It's just easier to start with kids.

Alice Lewis

I never ever thought I could hear someone quote De Beauvoir and follow it with saying “that puuuuuusssss” twice and have it somehow still be in good taste and not contradicting whatever the De Beauvoir quote was. 10/10.

Teddy Roberts

Trans guy here, love the video! I wanted to share some of my experience talking to detrans people, who decide for internal/personal reasons to stop transitioning - for a small number of people, that does happen. Detrans people might not continue to socially or medically transition for maaaany many reasons, and those without external factors are definitely a minority, but they are around. But they very, very rarely are transphobic or go on this anti-trans tyrade. Trans people (and people who think they are trans, but end up detransitioning) often hit rock bottom mental health wise before they make some kind of change related to their transition - whether that's coming out, socially transitioning, or taking steps towards medical transition. For a lot of people INCLUDING detrans people, if they were not able to do whatever that necessary step was for them at the time, they may not have lived long enough to change their mind about it. I have heard some detrans people who were in this boat say that they can't regret their transition when they look back on it, because it's the reason they made it through a really, really tough time in their life. For a lot of detrans people too, their support network and friend groups are often made up of other trans people and queer people, who ultimately helped them to work their shit out. It'd be a real slap in the face if a detrans person turned around and said "listen to me, because, hear me out, I'm always right about everything: you're all infected with the woke mind-virus!" TLDR - I think a lot of these vehemently anti-trans detransitioners are... I don't know... Sellouts? Grifters? Flakey, worst friend you've ever had vibes? It's just extremely odd behaviour from everything I know about irl detrans people. Detrans people have MUCH more in common with trans people rather than cis people.

Chazzaroo

Enthralled by a gay Nosferatu does sound like a good Saturday night though

Frog Hands Frog Legs

I detransitioned and i don't regret taking hrt at all. It helped me get over ny gender dysphoria, and then I realized that I don't want to pursue transition and don't identify as male anymore.

Nick Perez

Really appreciate the dyslexic friendly font in some of the quote graphics. +1

David Correa

Not exactly related to the issue but this is too funny not to share. The other day, my girlfriend‘s daughter asked me if I heard that MLK was a pedophile. Apparently her dad told her this. It didn’t take long for me to find out that it was something said by none other than Matt fucking Walsh.

Sylvie Nelson

Thank you so much for making this video. It’s extremely insightful. With the recent flurry of executive orders targeting us trans folks it’s really great to see and know that there are still a lot of people who care and are on our side. I swear your YouTube channel and podcast are like the only palatable way I can get news now because at least I can get some laughs.

George

Some more news 2025 reading list already popping off

Matt Ellen

🩵🩷🤍🩷🩵

Diana

Thank you, As a trans woman, I just wanna say thank you for this episode, I really don't even know what to say the world is so fucked right now and I'm glad some people care.

Kenzi Graham

Hi. I'm real. Thank you. 🩷🏳️‍⚧️💙