Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Alright… it’s that time again 👀🔥

As we begin to wrap up S2 of Severance we’re opening up the next long-form show slot and as we usually do, you are choosing what we watch.

👉🏻 We’re looking for shows with longer episodes (up to ~60 mins)  

👉🏻 This show will run 2 episodes per week

Here's how it all works 👇🏻 

✍🏻 STEP 1 — Submit Your Show (Right Here in the Comments) One show per person, please. But before you comment, please scroll through and make sure nobody has already suggested your show. Duplicate suggestions will not be counted, so check first!

👍🏻 STEP 2 — Like Your Favourites: Once suggestions are in, get liking the shows you want to see us react to. The 10 shows with the most likes will make it through to the poll! 🗳️

Thank you so much for helping us choose these amazing shows! 🙏🏼

Appreciate you all, always ❤️

Damo & Nick

Comments

Iztari

Andor

Kimmi

White Lotus

Nick

I think that would be great for them

Harrison

The walking dead

Kelly S

Supernatural

Lewis Mangold

Don’t know if you guys have seen Breaking Bad? But if not, would love it

Daniel

The West Wing! 40+ minute episodes. It's a drama but also has quite comedic elements, and is definitely from a different era of American politics. One of the greatest shows of all time. It's on HBO so you guys should have no issues finding it.

Tracy

Supernatural.

Tom Fehr

SUCCESSION. It has everything D&N would love. Complex emotional/tragic storytelling, incredible acting (Jeremy Strong has one of the best performances over 4 seasons you’ll ever see), and the funniest dialogue on TV. 💰

Quisty

Squid Game

Nick

The Boys

Tess

Teach You A Lesson

tiramisujen ≽^•⩊•^≼

Not a long form show, it wont be considered so you might want to use your suggestion for something else (1 suggestion per person)

aidangreen

Really hoping for this, they’d handle that show so well just like Game of Thrones

QuasiRNG

Better Call Saul

Weird Magic

Until they do Lost - I will never vote for anything else

Sia

Deadwood

Sara-Jayne

The haunting of hill house (but I’d like to group all five Mike Flanagan Netflix shows as they’re each only 1 season and it’s pretty much the same cast and crew) So hill house, then Bly manor, then midnight mass, midnight club, house of usher.

Ana Adame

They have already seen hill house...I believe it won to be a poll but nobody voted for it because they had seen it :(

Angela Chung

I'm rewatching this currently and am just blown away (again) at how well written it is.

Jesse L

westworld

Dave P

The X Files

EngineeredTwist

Yes, PLEASE Firefly. Very short commitment, very reactable.

MZ

Mad Men

Dana Sow

I want so badly for them to react to it. I need a a reason to do a rewatch lol.

Jesse L

stranger things!

James

Honestly one of the best I have ever seen on all levels from acting to writing to set design all the way down to costumes and the worlds every layer was fantastic also 2 seasons perfect length the way they did it, sometimes shows can get dragged on too long but the best ones know when the story needs to be wrapped and besides the wire and or is one of the only other shows that got the length right i believe

James

Masters Of The Air

Reagan

Buffy the Vampire Slayer

Clinton

Yellowjackets

tiramisujen ≽^•⩊•^≼

I think it came second in the last poll so I have high hopes :) If they love Severance they'll love LOST

Kimng

The Fosters

Kab

I want them to watch it so much! All the notes that would be taken haha. I'd imagine it to be so fun to hear their theory crafting

Em P

The Mentalist 🔮

Steph

Yes please to this one! I love Fallout!

Kimmi

Run it up guys ❤️

Shreyansh

I think it will be either Lost or Succession

Chuck Loncon

Yes, please. The wife worked on that one. Love the show and the people.

TE

This is a little more niche but I’ll give it a shot… Grimm

Emily G

Outlander ⚔️

Noah G

yes!

Ana Adame

Fallout would be AMAZING after having watched Chernobyl lol

Ryan Holmes

I'm not sure if they have even seen the movies yet

flink

They would absolutely enjoy Lost. Lots of notes, lots to process during intro/outro. I’ve been loving the GOT reactions I’m watching now. Lost would be just as enjoyable if not more so. They won’t be disappointed!!

Sheri

The Expanse

Ryan Holmes

All those notes for half the shows plot points to turn into nothing. But I do love Lost

Alex

The Last of Us

Emma

Yes please!! Would love to see them react

Ryan Holmes

I like suggestions like this that aren't over 100 episodes

Nephthys

Veronica Mars

Tyler

Silo

Ana Adame

Yes, Psych! I always forget about it during these suggestions. I always forget it's a long show and not a short show 😅

Theresa Lohwasser

Was just ging to comment this hope more people will agree

Bretton

Daredevil Easily the greatest written show I've ever watched.

Mikel Hatcher

This is the best show that hardly anyone has seen. I think it's because the channel it aired on wasn't very popular. I've seen almost everything over the past 40+ years and this show is in my top 5. I doubt it will win any polls but everyone should check it out.

Matt Jund

Definitely! It’s one of those shows that has so few reactions online and it’s perfect for them

JennaB

Ohhh, great suggestion! Probably won't win but hopeful for someday!

JASON

I HOPE THIS WINS!

Nate Terry

Battlestar Galactica (2004)

Tilds

Peaky Blinders

Melissa Redstag

SAS Rogue Heroes. It’s like band of brothers and peaky blinders had a baby

Ronnie Plane

Need The Righteous Gemstones. Yall would be dying and not enough reactors watch it.

Flora

Shogun

Michael

Another crazy conspiracy show for them yess

TLC

Already suggested below Up votes here will not count.

TLC

Already suggested below, up votes here will not count

Owen

TLC

Lost is already suggested below. Votes here will not count

TLC

Nick has seen it...Damo watched one episode 13 times 🤣 and all he remembers is there's a horse.

TLC

Already suggested below..Nick's seen it.

Tilds

🤣

Owen

Boardwalk Empire

Cici G

I was just about to comment this!

Kimmi

So true ! Theory city 🏙️

Danilo C

The Haunting of Hill House. Or rather I should say the Mike Flanagan Netflix shows (The Flanaverse, as the fans call it). It's 5 mini series (each has between roughly 7-10 episodes). They are, in release order: The Haunting of Hill House The Haunting of Bly Manor Midnight Mass The Midnight Club The Fall of the House of Usher Their stories are not connected and you can technically watch them in any order, or you could skip some (The Midnight Club is not well regarded by most fans and not many would complain if you skipped it). I think it would be awesome if guys started diving into horror on the channel and the Flanagan shows are an amazing entry point for people who don't like horror, especially The Haunting of Hill House. All shows are technically horror, but they use horror more as a medium for telling stories about grief, mental health, faith, family and a bunch of other themes. And a big plus for you: they are GREAT shows for theories, deep analysis and discussions like you do. If you are a bit squeamish about horror in general, a few warnings: each show has varying amounts of the typical horror tropes you'd expect (a few jump scares, some gore, etc) but none are overused and are just there to add a bit of "oomph" to the storytelling. The characters and their personal stories and relationships are really the main focus of all the shows. If you're gonna pick just one, Hill House is probably the one to go with. It was the first one and it's universally liked by both horror and non-horror fans. It's probably my favorite Netflix show of all time. I also really like Midnight Mass, it's absolutely worth a watch, especially for the mystery.

TLC

Already suggested below Votes here will not count. Also limited to one suggestion per person.

Danilo C

I like Lost but it's one of those shows that have very high highs and very low lows. Some of those middle seasons can be a drag to watch.

Brooks Tate

Breaking Bad or The Wire

TLC

One suggestion per person

Jordan Wiegand

I disagree depending on what you call the middle seasons. Seasons 3-5 are probably my favorite seasons.

TLC

Both have already been suggested

Bish M

Mr. Robot

Christine13

Medium (Stars Patricia Arquette, who plays Miss Cobel on Severence)

TLC

The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel.

WabbitTrax

This is one of the best shows of all time and at only 37 episodes total it is a very short investment for such a great experience ❤️😁

WabbitTrax

The Last Kingdom - Destiny is all!

TLC

Does not fit the long form category and will likely not be considered by the guys. Save this for the next short form poll.

Kenneth Rahn

The Blacklist .. James Spader at his irreverent best !

Kilgore Trout

Pluribus. Thoughtful scifi like Severance from the creator of Breaking Bad. Only 9 episode first season, so we can get it done in a month and move on to another suggestion.

Clint

Sopranos. Definitely.

JennaB

Black Mirror

Kelly

Was going to comment this. Probably won't win which sucks because it's one of the greatest shows of all time.

Kelly

Dead Like Me

Ryan Holmes

There's no way no one else has seen this

Brandi Davis

I really want this to win-- it's right up their alley!

Dr Ozzy

Came to comment this. It is so far up their alley.

Emily G

I surely hope so too! I don’t know if enough people will have seen it for it to win but it’s amazing and has way too few (hardly anyone) reacting to it. 🤞 Let’s hope!

MB

Need it like air

peach

The residence (2025)

peach

There aren't many episodes for this show but it does have long episodes, so I'm hoping this wins ^^

Lindsay

Twin Peaks

Erin’s Cafe

This needs to have a lot more votes, great suggestion.

TLC

Need to pick one and delete the other.

TLC

Already suggested below , votes here will not count

TLC

Already suggested below, votes here will not count

Erin’s Cafe

Hannibal (2013-2015) not enough people talk about how good this show was

TLC

At least one of the guys has seen it, and it has already been suggested below.

Nick Kessler

PLEASE DO NOT WATCH LOST!!!! It is 50 seasons each with 30 episodes!!

Ispahan

SAS: Rogue Heroes - the origin story of the British Army Special Air Service during WW2. Only 2 seasons so far (a 3rd is in production). Brilliant cast and story, created by Steven Knight (who also created Peaky Blinders). It aired on BBC1 initially. Very few reactors have selected it. Shame, it’s a banger! Oh well, now I see it’s been already suggested down there. Don’t mind me and go vote for it.

Ispahan

Westworld is great!

Ispahan

One of the greatest HBO shows.

Nicole

I voted for it! Lol

Nicole

Such an underrated show!

Chosos Wife

Oh sorry I was half asleep haha deleted it and submitted something else

TLC

Pretty sure Nick has seen it but I may be wrong.

TLC

Already suggested below

TLC

Already suggested below

TLC

Only about 120 episodes, roughly the same amout of screen time as Modern Family.

TLC

Already suggested below

TLC

Already suggested below. Votes here will not count

TLC

One suggestion per person please

immapotat

I need it -spongebob

Derek Jolstead

They both adore Breaking Bad, it’s in their top shows of all time. BCS would be perfect for them but sadly doesn’t seem to have enough support right now over other shows.

Derek Jolstead

These would be iconic reactions, but I have my doubts it ever happens lol.

Brooks Tate

Ok then. How about… breaking bad or the wire.

harrison barber

A boy can dream~ you know they'd LOVE Pete

Brandi Davis

It absolutely is and so under reacted to...

John Ross

Couldn't agree more on this pick! And it's relatively short (only two seasons), but impactful.

Clint

Oh for real? I didn’t see someone had already put it. My bad.

Jordan

Interview With The Vampire PLEASE! <3

bmr209

Sherlock (BBC)

Nikki_KnotDoneYet

I also loved the music — unique and deeply impactful

Krystal

Yes, I love this show!

Krystal

Big Little Lies (HBO)

Snuggelbum

True Detective Season 1

CattFink!

Yes ! ! ! This would be a fantastic show to watch with the guys! I really think they'd enjoy it. Lavender Gooms and Ghee Buttersnaps agree.

Melissa Manning

Hardly anyone reacts to this show and it’s one of my few comfort shows that they’re not reacting to now!

Melissa Manning

This is another one that I looove that no one reacts to!

drj8302

Shrinking

Melissa Manning

House MD! You’ve got a Brit playing an American and it’s a great show but most of what I was going to suggest is already on here so whatever is chosen I’m cool with

Link

The Newsroom

Sacid Ve

oh, yes to this

Matt108

My first thought with how excited Damo was for a mystery show

Kaisa

oh yes! i didn't finish it, and i've been meaning to start from the beginning. watching with these guys would be awesome!

Charl de Villiers

When it comes to black comedies with absolutely brilliantly written characters, Fargo is unbeaten

Xilenita

Hoping one day it'll make it to a poll. They need to meet Jack!

carcin

The Leftovers

Sasank M

So surprised to see so many fans for this show. Makes me very happy. Might not win the poll though.

BRAD

loved this show!!! lots of seasons tho

Yue .Yuu

I second that!

Emmo

How to get away with murder

kiralye

Need this to win!!!

Tamar Joosten

Already mentioned below. Please add your votes there! Because the votes here will not count. (And I love Supernatural, so... :-)

Tamar Joosten

Agreed! And just imagine all the plot-twist-detective-swirling (and hilarious overthinking) they can do with this show!

Roman.

Fringe

Brandi Davis

It has been in a few polls so it definitely needs to be a lucky loser lol they just don't know how much they need to watch it

Mark Gunn

Defo black sails

Tracy

Thanks - but I was the first to add it. I was the second person to comment.

Monique

The Crown

Kirsty Johnston

I'd love to see this, no-one ever reacts to it

CN

I liked LOST when it first aired, but I'm only excited for their reaction to some of the episodes... Would rather not spend the slot on the whole show for more than a year. Quite a number of episodes with low reactability, I think.

CN

Haven't seen, but heard great things about Andor. Do you guys feel, it's important to have Star Wars 1-9 fresh in mind to watch?

CN

Sweet, yes please! Only 14 episodes and really very reactable. Such a classic! Also, sidenote: Will grow your YouTube following! Massively beloved show!

Dana Mae

Nope! If you are watching chronologically, the order would be Andor, Rogue One then New Hope. Andor is one of the best shows I have ever watched, inside or outside of the SW universe.

Joseph Good

I love lost. But think it's a mistake for a watch-a-long or reaction. The notes and theories will be pointless. It gets slow and tedious. Even watching by myself I have trouble finishing the show.

Dana Mae

This is the one I was looking for. Such a good show!

CN

Thanks! Sounds great

Liam D

Everyone has to support this. Andor gives you an entirely new appreciation for Star Wars

mla0219

Sons of Anarchy

Snuggelbum

no, please not. it is basically just feminist scare propaganda slop.. way too political for my taste..

william surowiec

Really hoping this DOESNT win. Too many episodes, we’d be stuck with this for over a year. 121 episodes of an old broadcast TV show that kept viewers hooked by not telling them anything.

Kab

Ohhh really? I just watched reactions to it (all the seasons) already twice this year and I still want more haha. This year was the first I watched Lost again after it originally aired and I felt in love with it even more now But then again i only watched cut reactions, not the entire thing.

Jordan Wiegand

A lot of these shows suggested will be a long watch, it just is what it is. They’ll be opening another long form slot soon.

william surowiec

Yeah they will, just not as long as Lost. 6 seasons is a lot of work to get to a finale that was widely hated. Current competition The Sopranos, the Wire, The Boys, Succession all achieved the more enjoyment and reaction in half as many episodes with more action. At least Severance was 2 seasons if it’s not your cup of tea. This is a brutally long slog of a show that most people won’t keep up with and will likely tune out at some point.

Trevor Patterson

Team Lost. Voting for it every time and super excited to see their notepads.

Weird Magic

@william surowiec - it was widely misunderstood at the time - (I think) I've watched every reactor to Lost on YT and there are only 1 or 2 I can think of that didn't get and/or like the reaction. If you binge this show, it is very very very well loved and understood, and there is a very large Lost fanbase that will eat up these two watching it.

Daniel Holzschuh

Pluribus and Widows bay are must watches for this channel

Mindbomb

I'll add... very quotable. A sci fy, A comedy. overarching mystery.... cool hats

Allison F

Killing Eve! One of the best shows featuring Sandra Oh

rj

YESSSSSS

rj

What We Do In The Shadows (tv show)

Susen

Heated Rivalry (only 6 episodes and would get lots of YT views) - and it's sport adjacent. ;)

Susen

Yes, I love all the Psych-O's here.. so quotable! And they could have fun watching for the pineapples!

Reagan

I would LOVE it if The Sopranos would win😭

tiramisujen ≽^•⩊•^≼

Doesn’t meet the long form episode criteria so won’t be counted. Might want to use your suggestion for another show (1 suggestion per person on this poll)

Ana

Arcane, it’s animated! But definitely one to see at some point if you guys haven’t already

william surowiec

It wasn’t. Watched it live. Excellent pilot. Then they wanted to make more money and made up more nonsense to keep people hooked on a mystery that didn’t have much to it. It’s the How I Met Your Mother of Long Form Shows. Once you see the finale you can hardly stomach watching it again. It’s also 121 episodes meaning anyone who isn’t interested in this has all the reason to save money and move on. There are a ton of better shows with reasonable episode counts that don’t alienate more than half the community.

cosmominto

YES!!! The comedy sprinkled in is just so good too

bmr209

I wouldn't mind seeing them watch it again!!!

Trevor Patterson

Dear Powers that Be. If this gets picked. Tell them to go into the show completely blind, not even read a description or blurb about it.

James

Agreed it has nothing to do with even being a star wars fan, even if you have never seen star wars it's still a phenomenal show on its own merits

Heather

Disagree

Heather

Broadchurch