Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hey folks,

I hope you are all keeping well. Just an update to let you know what's what:

Episode 25 Progress:

We had a really good week on episode 25, with Cell getting through a lot of new images. This meant that I didn't need to spend much time on art, so I mapped out the art for two previously unstarted scenes (Katie scene and the second group scene). The majority of Cell's time was spent on the art for the Katie scene (which he has pretty much completed) and he has just gotten started on the second group scene. There are some teasers from the Katie scene at the bottom of this post, and we'll have some teasers from the group scene in next week's post.

In addition to planning out these scenes and providing the art list to Cell, I also continued to write and our line count has gone from 27000 lines to just over 28500, so I'm pretty happy with that.

I have about 5 or 6 scenes that are ALMOST complete, so I promise that I will concentrate on closing these off, before starting to write any new scenes. Once they are all closed off and tidied up, sometime around the end of this month, I will then publish a full list of completed scenes versus non-completed scenes, so you'll see exactly what's left for us to do in the last couple of months. And that will provide a good measuring stick for progress as we knock scenes off each week after that.

Our planning / art process:

I've had a few questions about our process for planning scenes and the tie-in of art vs writing, so just wanted to give a little insight into our process. If you have no interest in what goes on behind the curtain of the development process, then feel free to skip this section...

From speaking to a few other devs, their process seems to be that they write out the full scene script first before doing any art. Some of them plan the scene and then write, others just jump into the writing and see where it takes them. And then once the writing is complete, they then do all required art.

For WTHI: I have done this in the past for some scenes, but in general, I like to have a fair bit of the art already done, WHILE I'm writing, rather than waiting until the very end to add in the art. As it's a visual novel, I find having images in front of me will sometimes cause me to add new/unplanned stuff to the scene OR sometimes just having images to show me how the scene will look actually helps me with the writing process. The more art I have, the more this feeds into the story... and the more story I write, the more extra art I need to finish the scene... So in general for WTHI, the writing and art sort of grow organically together, rather than one or the other coming first.

How it generally works is: I plan out the scene (Lady, location, scenario, key plot points/ action that's going to happen, etc.). I then send this plan to Cell in one of two formats, depending on the urgency / how soon we need a specific scene to get started.

Format 1: I give Cell a general layout of the scene (the items mentioned above) and he gets started on it, leaving plenty of gaps for later, once the writing is fleshed out. He bounces samples my way, and I let him know if he's on the right track / or if changes are needed. I then take these images as a starting point and start writing... and then as the scene unfolds, I send specific image / tweak requests to Cell. This process is good for a scene that I don't plan on writing in the immediate future (i.e. if Cell has a week or two head-start, before I start writing). It's good for me, because I just need to share my general idea of the scene, and Cell can get started. It's bad for Cell, because he has to do a load of images for a scene with just a brief outline, so he needs to stay in regular contact to make sure what he is working on ties in with my plan.

Format 2: I give Cell the overall plan (as above), but I also provide a full itemized list of every image needed for the scene (with some gaps that we can fill in later). This approach is used for a scene with more urgency (i.e. I'm about to start writing or I've already started). This is good for Cell -As he just has to follow the description given for every single image. It's trickier for me, because I have to visualize and describe every image needed for a scene, BEFORE I start writing in earnest.

So, we use both approaches depending on how busy we are on other scenes, how urgent the scene is, and/or how complex the scene is going to be.

Then as the writing / art progress or new ideas / tweaks pop up, I let Cell know and he provides the extra art, or sometimes, I just do the extra images myself as I'm writing. Sometimes it's hard to describe a specific pose / scenario I'm looking for in an image, so it's easier to just do it myself.

On occasion I might try something that doesn't work out, so I ask Cell to help finish and vice versa, where Cell might be struggling with a particular image, so I jump in and help out (we both have different areas of art that we are better at or just have more patience with).

Writing can take a couple of stages and drafts. Stage 1 is the plan, then I write the first draft, where I just free-flow write: For the second draft, I read in detail and add / remove stuff as required. And then a third draft (or more) is required to check the variables, pathing, structure and to make sure everything ties into previous and subsequent scenes.

Similarly for the art, we tend to spend a lot of time on the set-up (getting the environment set up, the lighting, the cameras/POV, add the characters, pick their outfits, etc.). Once that's done, we start the art. The art tends to get done in batches, and each batch will require fixes, corrections (either a complete re-render or sometimes just some fixes in photoshop). So similar to writing, the art is an iterative process.

Not sure if this is of interest to people, but I received a few questions about it, so wanted to share. Let me know in the comments if it was boring / waste of typing. Thanks

Last weeks' poll:

I asked last week what people's preference was regarding waiting the next 11 weeks for the full release or getting a taste of episode 25 next month and then the final part a couple of months after.

A small handful told me to go fuck myself! (That's fair :)) Some voted for a partial release next month, but the vast majority of folks voted to release the whole episode in one lump at the end of November, so that's what I'm going to do.

I received a valid question asking why can't I do both? i.e. for the minority of people that want a partial release next month, why can't I send it to them, and for the majority of people who want to wait for the full release, they can ignore the partial release and wait for the full release. But unfortunately that's not a valid option for a couple of reasons:

1) For the people who want to wait (majority of folks) - It's one thing waiting along with everyone else, but it's a lot more difficult waiting, if they knew that there is a release out there and people are playing it, so it's just not feasible to ask them to ignore this.

2) Spoilers: Even if people did decide to wait, it would be impossible to avoid spoilers from people who have played the release (Spoilers here, on discord or on other forums would 100% happen.)

3) Piracy. Once I make a partial release, it is 100% guaranteed to be pirated and posted on many forums. So for those who decided to wait, not only would they know that there are 100s of patrons playing the release, they would also know that there are 1000s of people playing a pirated version while the patrons continue to wait patiently. I have made numerous requests for people here not to pirate my game or post it on pirate websites, but unfortunately there is always at least one asshole that posts it. Yes, these peoples' lives are so sad, that one of the few kicks they get in life is taking a project that I have worked on for (average) 60+ hours a week for the past seven years (and quit my job, so this is now my only source of income) and they release it for free, just for a few "likes" from anonymous people online.

For episode 25, I am looking into some implementing some anti-piracy measures, so watch this space... It will be very low-level (more like a speed-bump than a barrier, but I'm going to give it a go.) And I'll also be looking into ways to "personalize" the copy of the game you receive to make it easier for me to "catch the rat" and hold them accountable. :) Not sure if I'll make it work, but I do want to try something to "protect" the final episode.

And on that note, even if you don't share my game, I would appreciate it if you didn't post my teasers or the details in these posts on other forums. It's supposed to be a perk of being a patron.

If you are one the very few patrons that feel that you have a right to release my game to 1000s of people for free, and take umbrage with my above comments, then please feel free to kindly fuck off. :)

For the 99.9% of you that don't distribute my game...As always thanks so much for the support. You are the folks keeping this game going and I really appreciate it.

Rant over, let's please not light up the comments section with a debate on piracy! :) :)

As always, please let me know if you have any questions or comments (NOT related to piracy as I don't want to debate it, thanks :) ), let me know in the comments section or via DM (direct message). And a reminder that all relevant links, plus an FAQ (Frequently asked questions) section can be found in my landing page here: https://www.patreon.com/posts/37183736

Thanks a lot,

CG

Teasers:

Just a few from another scene :)

Files

Comments

Avaricious

Thanks for the insight into the creative process, I found it fascinating. Not enough devs talk about the work that goes into making a story come to life, especially if it's a story people csn connect with in a meaningful way. I would also be interested in knowing where the inspiration comes from for storyline and characters. So thanks for sharing and hope you have a great week 😄👍

CG_Gaming

Thanks for the feedback. Much appreciated. I'll put something together about characters and storyline in a future dev update. Thanks again.

Wolfgang Kümmel

Hello CG, Thank you for the interesting insights into the creative process of such a very extensive story. I think it's important to be able to appreciate the scope and requirements of working on such a project. You are obviously a well-rehearsed team that gets along well. During the completion of the individual scenes, there are certainly always a few spontaneous ideas to improve one or the other. So in this respect, this section of your report is extremely interesting, at least for me, and by no means a waste of typing! Pirated copies are particularly harmful to the developers and also to honest buyers and players and every measure against them must be supported at all costs! I'm in the middle of the original game from episode 11 onwards, after finishing the improved version (season 1 of the Steam version), and I'm now enjoying the further development of the story with great excitement. Thank you for your great work and the great pictures, I love Katie! 😊

CG_Gaming

Thanks a lot, Wolfgang. Much appreciated. And glad you liked the dev update and teasers. 😀

Lord Eagle

Looks great, and I'm glad you'll release everything at one time. Might be a bigger file to DL, but I know it will be worth it! I do hope you will still use MEGA as that is my favorite site from which to DL all my files. Thanks in advance, and also for the pic teasers!

CG_Gaming

Thanks. And yes, I'll use MEGA and Google drive.

Matt Gorman

Don't you do a public release anyway for the ones who want to play it without paying? I mean, those sites are how the vast majority of people who patron games find them in the first place.

tezster

Fairly certain they're all pirate sites in that the game is made available without the creator's consent. Sure, some creators may "play along" and provide some tacit level of approval, primarily because it's almost impossible to stop and you're damned if you do, and damned if you don't.

Walter L.

It's definitely a bit more than that, many creators actually start drumming up publicity for their game on these pirates sites, especially a certain well-established one, and I, like probably many other supporters, have found this game there, with the full knowledge and at the start even the goal of Cheeky to spread the first few episodes there. And Cheeky was happy to post and communicate with us and was happy over every positive review. Many teams have found themselves together there, including people who work and have worked on this game, to this day many games get started there. That's why I have to admit, I don't really like the whole approach of "evil pirate sites." when it's not even clear how big this whole genre would have become without them. I get it, once you have gained enough support here or elsewhere, the game being pirated becomes a detriment, so I am all for giving games at least a few weeks of exclusivity before anyone shares them.

Walter L.

You know I want you to earn money and be successful, but sometimes I feel as if you have become a bit too negative. Don't you remember how you started out? WHERE you started out, where you found Cell and Ace? Those sites or at least one of them are not just negative for game devs, as you should well know. Without them, I wouldn't have found any of the games I support or have supported. I don't want to start a whole discussion about it, but I am a fan from the first episode, and you know where I found that episode and you, even if I use a different name here. Don't get me wrong, I am all for giving a dev time, before you release their game there and releasing unfinished versions is another stupid thing to do. I am just not agreeing with you on the complete demonization of a certain site.

Matt Gorman

In some cases it's the dev that puts it there.

JEH

Thanks for the update, and for the teasers.👍❤️

meiwow

The second to last screenshot is fire.

Cpt.America45

Katie’s the best…that is all! 😂

Impracticality

Thanks for the update, I found the behind-the-scenes stuff quite interesting. I can't say I'm keen on adding anti-piracy features in the new update. I certainly understand the frustration when people take your game without paying even a small amount for it, but in my experience DRM usually adds more pain for paying customers than it does inconvenience for pirates. Hopefully that won't be the case here. As far as reposting these updates elsewhere, I'm not going to leak anything but I'll admit I'm torn on the topic. I think it's bad policy to restrict all news of a game's development to the people already paying for it, but also I think it's entirely reasonable to restrict in-depth details or sneak peaks for the loyal customers. The question is where to draw the line, and I don't know that I have a good answer for that.

Skypanic

For an interesting way to check the piracy. Director I follow Freddie Wong out of his new movie and then posted the 4K version on to torrent sites. But downloading that version starts the movie with him saying hope they enjoy and see it as it meant to be, but that it convinced them to support. Thought process being some people will always pirate but you convince the rest by having a good way to post fit it or exposing them to your product cause you know it’s quality and that alone will be enough for them to support you.

DSTommie

Always like to read more about game development and your thoughts on the project. Thanks for the share.

CG_Gaming

Yeah, I know what you mean. And I only meant copying / pasting every single update verbatim, including all teaser images. I have no problem with folks adding a summary or a "Release date has been pushed to November", etc. or just a general discussion about stuff I post. Hope it didn't come across as too tyrannical. Sometimes I just get frustrated, because I'd love to keep doing this full-time for the next few years (and maybe expand the team), but at the moment, I have enough savings, etc. to ensure I can finish WTHI (including the re-do, etc.), but not enough financial security to go beyond the next year or two. So that's why every now and then I get pissed off about piracy. Literally, for every patron, there is hundreds of non-patrons who play the game.