Kickstarter Enamel Pin Designs #1 (Patreon)

So I'm working on the enamel pins which will be on offer in the Volume 1 Kickstarter.  The main pin will be Nellie Nelson, Nick's doggo!! It's gonna come with attached to a nice bit of card too (but haven't designed that yet).

Firstly, a bit of context! These are the first four merch tiers that will be on offer at the moment:

Tier A - PDF of the book
Tier B - BOOK
Tier C - MERCH SET. Book, enamel pin, signed bookmark
Tier D - MEGA MERCH SET. Book, 3 x enamel pins, 3 x prints, sticker sheet, signed bookmark.

Hope that makes sense! Could change of course, but that's the plan at the mo. That also gives you an idea of the merch I will be designing and sharing with y'all on Patreon over the next week or two. 

So, I have two questions for you!

1. Which one of these designs do you prefer! Note that 1 would not have any sort of shiny metal - the metal parts would just be black.

2. I need to design two more enamel pins, to be on offer in Tier D. If you have any ideas for this, let me know! Would you like to see another set of Nick and Charlie pin designs? Or perhaps a shoe each? Or something else entirely? Let me know! So in total there will be 3 different pins on offer in the Kickstarter :)

Hope that all makes sense. No need to comment if you're not particularly bothered, but if you have any thoughts do let me know :) I just like sharing these things with you at the design stage and hearing your opinions!