Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Content

LOTS of interesting discussion in the comments yesterday!!! 

What I'm going for with this scene is the idea that while Harry truly is sorry for his behaviour, Nick and Charlie - especially Charlie - owe him nothing, not even forgiveness. They have both, but particularly Charlie, been hurt by Harry's actions, and Charlie has been hurt repeatedly by homophobes like Harry, and no apology is going to take back any of the horrible bullying Charlie has suffered by people like Harry, and it's definitely not going to negate any of the residual trauma that is following Charlie through his life because of it.

I want this scene to show victims of any sort of bullying that just because a bully has changed or is sorry, that doesn't mean you need to have anything to do with them. They can change and find redemption in their own lives, and that's great! But you truly owe them nothing. You don't have to forgive them - one apology doesn't make up for all the hurt they caused. I hope that makes sense!!

Files

Previews only

Comments

Anonymous

I'm so proud of Charlie!!! ❤️ :')

Anonymous

👏👏👏 That's my boy! You're 100% justified to feel like that Charlie

Anonymous

Spot on ❤️ I am glad Charlie thinks this way ❤️ from the very first page we saw what the bullying and shitty “boyfriend” did to him. Precious boy should have never went through it. It’s trauma for life and horrible effects of it. From the intrusive thoughts, worrying, thinking the worst, the low self esteem, being scared, through constantly apologising, to self harm, depression, eating disorder and everything else. It’s there from the beginning. Ben basically sexually assaulted him. Those bullies made him terrified to come to school. How many tears and terrible lonely days and hurting himself and being scared and hurt. Charlie is still so very young and too much happened to him already and he suffers from it. It’s still haunting him and he struggles to deal with it. He needs help, not to help others. He does not owe them anything, nothing will take away what he suffered and will suffer, the effects of it for the rest of his life, and I’m glad everybody heard that. It’s just a sorry for Harry, but Charlie will be dealing with effects for the rest of his life, people don’t realise the trauma and how big this is. The wounds are still fresh too. He shouldn’t have ever suffered all that. Baby 🥺 And things will only get worse mentally so I am glad Charlie is putting his foot down. And yay for Nick really getting it! He always felt bad and saw a lot, that sweetheart is smart and loves Charlie, but I wanted him to really understand it and the impact of it. Eg with self harm he let it go quite quickly. Hopefully now he will be even smarter. Charlie always hides his pain and takes all the blame so for once people are getting told. It will be good for Nick and Charlie, because Nick will be able to help more now. He has the needed insight. The understanding. I hope he will use it. ❤️ maybe he will use uncle google to get a little bit more knowledge too. I think it’s also Nick not only realising the impact everything had on Charlie but adding one to one - problems with eating especially when Charlie is stressing about something, the self harm, the general low moods. It will break his heart. He was always full of love and had amazing reactions but this will make Nick even smarter. And others more aware. It’s unfair really, a bully will just move on, Charlie won’t. Yet he’s expected to just accept the apology to make Harry feel good? Nope! And I’m glad Charlie knows that. He doesn’t owe anybody anything. He does not need to forgive what they did. It’s his right. Especially so soon, so quick, when Harry is clearly only just learning what he and people like him did. I hope Nick will wrap those warm arms around him after this. And I hope Charlie’s words will give everyone something to think about. None of them, apart from Tao, were there.

Anonymous

I was in the exact same situation yesterday omg I should have said that lmao

Finn

heck YES!! charlie speakin the truth right here, he deserves to feel angry and he doesnt have to forgive if hes not ready for it. harry needs to continue showing how he has changed to eventually Earn charlies forgiveness. a quick sorry is not enough after years of torment

Anonymous

This is fantastic!

Anonymous

Yes! This is so true! 🖤

lifeless1

Perfect Charlie, perfect. Alice’s description of Charlie’s thought process is everything I always wanted to say.

Anonymous

I think the panel showing Nick’s expression too is so important. Nick most definitely had an idea and knew of the pain Charlie was in and still is from last year but I don’t think he quite understood how much it still affects him and always will in a way, I believe this expression we see is both shock but almost realisation? This may well give him another insight into Charlie’s feelings and his trauma. (Could just be my interpretation tho!) Also YES CHARLIE! I am so so proud of this boy!! 💓✨

Forester

Beautifully portrayed! <3

Anonymous

I am so ridiculously proud of Charlie, I just cannot even right now 💖

Exillior

This is a truly interesting scene and it's raised a lot of different thoughts and perspectives. I'm sure all of us (unfortunately) have known bullies, and some of us have probably hurt others too. I love that you are showing us that there are two separate components to this scene: 1. Harry's journey towards becoming a better person and 2. Charlie's journey through how he was bullied. Up until now I had been sceptical about the first bit, that Harry has changed; I thought he just wanted attention. But that's unfair of me and I am super glad to see that actually he has realised his behaviour was bad. And as somebody pointed out above, seeing that Charlie remains hurt may help Harry further appreciate that some actions are too hurtful for an apology to solve everything. With the second part to this scene, about Charlie's choice to not "absolve" Harry - I honestly am glad to see this because it shows that when you've been hurt, forgiveness should happen in your good time: when you have had time to process the events, trauma and feelings, and are ready to move on. Not when the person who bullied you feels it's time you forgave them.

Lily

That's my son ❤❤❤

Anonymous

Go, Charlie! This is a great lesson for anyone who has been abused. Forgiveness should be given when the abused is ready, not when it's demanded by the abuser. Thank you for this scene, Alice!

Anonymous

I fully agree with everything Charlie just said

Anonymous

i want nick to hold his hand!! or hug him!! in front of everyone! right now!!

Anonymous

Honestly my heart just breaks for Charlie. Nobody should suffer like that. Especially someone as good hearted and sweet as him. It’s not just mean comments and now everything is fine. It was horrible bullying and it really harmed him mentally and he will need to deal with it always, unlike Harry and others. It’s not ok. And they should know it. I’m glad he said it. That sorry won’t erase what they did to him. Just imagining what that kid was going through, every day, before, during and after school, is just terrible. All the tears and lonely times and breakdowns. And knowing how sick he became because of it and that the worst didn’t happen yet.😓 look at his dad’s face when he went to see Nick’s friends and Tao’s worry for him and it explains how bad it had to be, if the fact that he developed illnesses isn’t enough to show it.

Anonymous

👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻

Anonymous

... also Charlie is such a selfless good hearted precious kiddo unfairly blaming himself and expecting so little that any moment he actually puts his foot down is so important and I’m so proud of him 💕 Thank god he has Nick who’s so good hearted and sweet, they deserve each other ❤️ Nick, help our darling Charlie 🥺❤️ And right now I’m worrying because it’s Nick’s last year at high school. Sixth formers scared the bullies away from Charlie so there is a sixthform in their current school, so I hope he stays. Or at least somewhere close. Sigh 😒. Also, Nick surely feels even worse now that he didn’t help Charlie when that hell was happening. I’m glad he’s getting all this insight. He will be smarter and put more attention - although I have to say he is super attentive already ❤️ but now it will make more sense.

Jessica Sloan

This is so important ❤️❤️❤️❤️

Mat

I'm so proud of Charlie, after everything he went through, it's nice to see him stand up for himself and I feel like those are words many need to hear. I trust that Harry does want to change but I hope this will help him realize that he's gonna have to work for it.

Anonymous

I’m so SO happy with how this is being handled. Children always seem to be told to accept apologies even if they’ve been coerced, and it’s wrong! You should apologise if you’ve done wrong, without expecting a biscuit for doing the absolute minimum.

TheLastDreamer

I’m so proud of him. Like really, I’m tearing up